האדם צריך לעשות חשבון שהרי כדי שלא לעבוד ע"ז הי' מוסר נפשו' וכל עבירה הוי מרידה בהקב"ה והוי ממש כמו ע"ז.
Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH כ"ב no. 39 Pocket Guide p. 77 English 51 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains the Tanya's image of the soul as 'the candle of Hashem': like a flame that surges upward to its source even at the cost of its own existence, the Jewish soul by nature longs to be nullified in Hashem, the way of kedushah, while tumah clings to its own ego.
The Mashgiach opens by recalling the previous chapter: even simple Jews steeped in sin are ready to give their lives rather than serve idols, and the coming chapters explain why. He introduces the verse 'the soul of man is the candle of Hashem', and expands with a thought on Chanukah as a glimpse of the light of Moshiach, illustrated by a story of the Chozeh of Lublin. Returning to the Tanya, he describes how a flame surges upward to rejoin its root in the sphere of the moon, why it flickers from side to side, and why Jews sway when they learn. Unlike every other being, fire is ready to be extinguished to return to its source; the soul likewise longs to be nullified in Hashem. He explains that 'nature' means what reason cannot explain, then contrasts kedushah, rooted in Chochmah and bittul, with tumah, which is ego. This leads to true humility, the selfish 'giver' of kelipah called Kna'ani, and the tzaddik whose body alone holds his soul back.
Topics: Ahavah Mesuteres (Tanya ch. 18-25) · Anavah and Bittul · Kedushah and Kelipah · Mesiras Nefesh
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Why sinners give their lives; the candle of Hashem listed in the guide
The Mashgiach recalls that even sinners are ready for mesiras nefesh against idolatry and says the coming chapters explain why. He introduces 'the soul of man is the candle of Hashem' and brings the teaching that wicks and oils unfit for Shabbos are fit for Chanukah, applied to souls that Shabbos does not ignite but Chanukah does.
-
3:56 Chanukah, light of Moshiach, and the Chozeh's story
The Mashgiach explains that Chanukah's eight lights reach beyond Shabbos's seven into the light of Moshiach, so it can stir even distant souls; when a Jew lights below, Hashem lights his soul above. He tells the story of the Chozeh of Lublin, who would not curse an informer at the moment he was lighting Chanukah candles.
-
9:01 Why a flame surges upward
Back in the Tanya, the Mashgiach explains that a flame always stands upright because it wants to tear loose from the wick and rejoin the general element of fire, whose root is in the sphere of the moon. He describes the invisible spheres and the Rambam's statement that they are pure like clear glass, and the rule that every being yearns for its origin.
-
14:37 Bedikas chametz at night; why Jews sway
The Mashgiach uses the flame's root in the moon to explain why a candle works better at night, hence bedikas chametz at night. The flame shakes side to side like a tooth being pulled, and so Jews sway when they learn or daven; he tells of two babies mixed up at birth, where the one who swayed over Gemara was the Jew.
-
18:09 Fire and soul ready for self-nullification
The Mashgiach explains that the flame strives to free itself even though it would then be extinguished, against the rule that every being fights to preserve itself. The soul, including its lower levels of ruach and nefesh, acts likewise: it longs to cleave to Hashem, the source of all life, even if it would cease to exist as itself.
-
23:46 What 'nature' means: beyond explanation
The Mashgiach explains that the word 'nature' is a borrowed term for what has no reason. He brings the Rashab's point that a scientist can say a hard, sharp knife cuts soft challah but not why, and the example of a machine whose workings can be explained only down to a point; the soul's urge to cleave to Hashem is 'nature' in this sense.
-
28:40 Kedushah is bittul, tumah is ego; true humility
The Mashgiach explains that Chochmah is the potential that produces logic and is higher than it. In kedushah there is an urge to be nullified to Hashem, while tumah is ego, the 'capital I'. He then defines true humility as having no self apart from Hashem, shows how Dovid HaMelech could demand honor without ego, and says a true anav is always joyful.
-
35:21 Kelipah acts for itself; right over left
The Mashgiach explains that whoever draws from Chochmah is nullified and lacks nothing, while kelipah does everything for itself, even its mitzvos. He interprets Chochmah as 'koach mah', the power of nothingness, and lists the seven middos of kelipah, such as its self-praise. In kedushah the giving, right side of chesed dominates, as seen in tefillin, washing and dressing the right side first.
-
41:16 In kelipah the receiver rules: Kna'ani
The Mashgiach brings the Ohr HaChaim's account of his struggle with two dogs, male and female, where the female was far harder to overcome, because in the sitra achra the receiving side is stronger. He applies this to the nations' 'ladies first' and to Rashi's contrast of Yaakov and Esav, and explains that chesed of kelipah is called Kna'ani because its 'giver' really gives for himself.
-
46:16 The merchant, the tzaddik, and the word 'me'
The Mashgiach explains why a merchant is called Kna'ani, then contrasts the tzaddik who gives out of pure chesed and surges to Hashem, held back only by his body, the wick. He brings Nadav and Avihu and Sarah Imeinu as souls that flew out from closeness to Hashem, and closes with a story of a son who learned nothing if he can still say 'me'.
The shiur, written up
Why sinners give their lives; the candle of Hashem
The Mashgiach recalls the previous chapter: even the simplest Jews, steeped in sin and never thinking of the Ribono shel Olam, are ready for mesiras nefesh when faced with idolatry. Why does this stir them more than any other aveirah? The coming chapters, he says, explain it by examining what a Jewish soul is.
Chanukah and the light of Moshiach
Chanukah, the Mashgiach explains, is a temporary glimpse of the light of Moshiach in our homes. Shabbos reaches seven, this world; Chanukah's eight reaches beyond it, like the Gemara's eight-stringed harp of Moshiach. Since at Moshiach's coming even a rebel will run after him, Chanukah's preview can stir even the farthest souls, and when a Jew lights below, Hashem lights his soul above. c
He brings, through the Imrei Emes from the Chiddushei HaRim, that the Chozeh of Lublin refused to curse a dangerous informer because his soul was shining in all the worlds; the next day he cursed him. The man, he explained, had been lighting Chanukah candles at that moment.
Why a flame surges upward
Returning to the Tanya, the Mashgiach explains that while every object falls downward, a flame stands erect, always surging upward. It wants to tear loose from the wick and fuse with its root, the general element of fire under the sphere of the moon. a
He describes the ancient tradition, taught to the nations by Shlomo HaMelech, that each planet is mounted in an invisible turning sphere, which the Rambam says is too pure to see, like clear glass. Every being has a natural urge to rejoin its origin, so fire shoots upward.
Bedikas chametz at night; why Jews sway
From this the Mashgiach explains why bedikas chametz is at night: with the moon itself present, fire shines better. The flame also shakes side to side, like a dentist rocking a tooth, to free itself from the wick. So too a Jew sways when he learns or davens, as the fire in him wants to rise; the Mashgiach tells of two babies mixed up at birth, where the one who swayed over Gemara would be the Jew. d
Fire and soul ready for self-nullification
The flame strives to break free even though it would then be extinguished and no longer shine. This, the Mashgiach notes, defies a general rule Hashem set in nature: every animal and plant fights or flees to preserve its existence. Fire alone is ready to become nothing, losing its individual existence, as long as it returns to its root.
What 'nature' means
The Mashgiach explains that 'nature' is a borrowed term for what has no reason. He brings the Rashab: a scientist says a hard, sharp knife cuts soft challah, but why not the reverse? Only one who learns Chassidus can explain it.
Similarly, a machine can be explained step by step until one reaches a point that is simply 'its nature'. So the soul's urge to cleave to Hashem cannot be explained; it is higher than reason.
Kedushah is bittul, tumah is ego
Chochmah, the Mashgiach explains, is not logic but the potential that produces it, and so higher than logic. This is a rule of kedushah: it has an urge to be nullified to Hashem. Tumah is ego; that is why English writes 'I' capitalized, while the Torah has no enlarged aleph for 'ani'. Kedushah returns to its source even at the cost of its existence; tumah insists it is something.
Hence humility is not meekness but having no self apart from Hashem. Dovid HaMelech could demand honor as king without ego, since his role required it, like any mitzvah. One who is depressed about lacking wealth or wisdom is really proud; a true anav is always joyful, lacking nothing.
Kelipah acts for itself
One drawing from Chochmah, the Mashgiach says, is nullified and lacks nothing, while kelipah does everything, even mitzvos, for its own gain, the way of the Erev Rav. Chochmah is 'koach mah', the power of nothingness, as Moshe said 'what are we'. e
The seven middos of kelipah mirror those of kedushah; its tiferes praises itself, as Rashi explains a passuk in Tehillim. In kedushah the giving, right side of chesed dominates the receiving side, as in the Tikkunei Zohar, tefillin, washing and the Gemara's rule of dressing the right first. f,g,h
In kelipah the receiver rules: Kna'ani
In tumah it is the opposite, the Mashgiach says, bringing the Ohr HaChaim, who battled the sitra achra as two dogs: the male fell quickly, the female only after a terrible struggle. So the nations, led by their angels, put 'ladies first', and Rashi notes that Yaakov placed his sons before his wives, Esav the reverse. i,j
Chesed of kelipah is called Kna'ani, from 'hachna'ah', because its giver submits to the receiver: he gives for himself, like a donor who wants a plaque. A tzaddik said that a darshan who preaches for money is the receiver, his listeners the givers.
The tzaddik and the word 'me'
So a merchant is called Kna'ani: he provides, but for profit. The tzaddik gives from pure chesed and surges toward Hashem; only his body, the wick, holds back his soul until his time. Nadav and Avihu's souls flew out from closeness to Hashem, and some explain that Sarah Imeinu's did on hearing of the Akeidah. k
The Mashgiach closes with a tzaddik whose son, back from learning by a greater tzaddik, answered 'me' at the door; the father said he had learned nothing, since by a real tzaddik the 'me' does not exist.
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 10:00 The soul is 'the candle of Hashem': like a flame, which always surges upward to rejoin its root, the soul by nature longs to leave and cleave to its source, Hashem.
- 19:05 Fire is the exception in creation: every other being fights to preserve its existence, yet fire is ready to be extinguished as long as it returns to its root, and the soul is the same.
- 23:59 The word 'nature' is a borrowed term for whatever cannot be explained by reason; the soul's urge to cleave to Hashem is 'nature' in this sense, higher than logic, because it comes from Chochmah.
- 30:00 Kedushah means bittul, being ready to be nullified to Hashem, while tumah is ego: it insists on its own separate existence.
- 32:02 True humility is not feeling inferior but having no sense of self apart from Hashem; such an anav is always joyful, while one who is depressed over his shortcomings is really showing pride.
- 40:55 In kedushah the giving side is stronger than the receiving side; in the sitra achra the 'giver' really gives for himself, and that is why it is called Kna'ani, from the word for submitting.
- 47:51 The tzaddik surges toward Hashem without concern for his own existence; only his body, the 'wick', holds his soul back until his time comes.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:09 Why does mesiras nefesh against idolatry stir up even Jews steeped in sin, more than any other aveirah?
Answer: 22:38 Because the soul is the candle of Hashem: like a flame, it by nature longs to leave and be nullified in its source, even at the cost of its own existence.
-
Question: 8:14 Why did the Chozeh of Lublin refuse to curse the informer one night and curse him the next day?
Answer: 8:22 At that first moment the informer was lighting Chanukah candles, and his soul was shining in all the worlds.
-
Question: 14:41 Why is bedikas chametz done at night?
Answer: 15:13 Fire is rooted in the sphere of the moon, so a candle shines better at night when the moon itself is present.
-
Question: 24:52 Why does a knife cut challah and not the challah the knife?
Answer: 25:44 A scientist can only say that is its nature; 'nature' is a term for what reason cannot explain, which only one who learns Chassidus can understand.
-
Question: 32:44 How could Dovid HaMelech, the greatest anav, demand respect as king?
Answer: 33:12 His honor involved no ego; it was needed to fulfill his role as king, like any mitzvah done because it is required.
Stories
-
6:08 The Chozeh of Lublin and the informer
The Mashgiach brings, via the Imrei Emes from the Chiddushei HaRim, that an informer was causing great suffering to the Jews of a town by reporting them to the Czar's government. They brought a kvittel with his name to the Chozeh of Lublin, asking him to curse the man. The Chozeh looked at it and said this man's soul was now shining in all the worlds, and he could not curse him. The next day they gave the kvittel again, and this time he cursed him and the informer was removed. Asked why, the Chozeh explained that the night before, at that moment, the man had been lighting Chanukah candles.
In the story: the Chozeh of Lublin, the Imrei Emes (Rabbi Avraham Mordechai of Ger), the Chiddushei HaRim, the Sfas Emes, the Shem MiShmuel of Sochatchov, the Avnei Nezer of Sochatchov
-
17:23 Two babies mixed up at birth
The Mashgiach says he heard that two children, one Jewish and one not, were once mixed up at birth and no one could tell which was which. They asked a Rav, who said to teach both of them Torah until they began learning Gemara. The child who swayed while learning would be the Jew, and the one who sat rigidly would be the non-Jew.
-
41:18 The Ohr HaChaim and the two dogs
The Mashgiach brings that the Ohr HaChaim, on a passuk in Parshas Vayishlach, tells how he was confronted, somewhat like Yaakov Avinu, by the sitra achra in the form of two dogs, a male and a female. He overpowered the male quickly and threw him down, but with the female he had a terrible struggle and subdued her only partially. The Mashgiach explains this is because in the sitra achra the female, receiving side is stronger.
In the story: the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, Yaakov Avinu
-
49:18 The son who said 'me'
A great tzaddik sent his son to learn avodas Hashem by a greater tzaddik. After a year or two the son returned and knocked on the door. His father asked who it was, and the son answered 'me'. The father said that if he can still say 'me', he has learned nothing there, since by a real tzaddik the 'me' does not exist.
Insights
- 2:47 Wicks and oils unfit for Shabbos are fit for Chanukah: there are souls that even Shabbos does not ignite, but Chanukah, a glimpse of the light of Moshiach, can.
- 15:52 The flame's side-to-side flicker is its effort to tear loose from the wick, like a dentist rocking a tooth before pulling it, and the same fire in a Jew makes him sway when he learns and davens.
- 15:04 Because fire is rooted in the sphere of the moon, a candle burns better at night when the moon itself is present, which is why bedikas chametz is done at night.
- 34:09 A person who feels depressed about lacking wealth, wisdom or strength compared to others shows pride, not humility, since he feels he is something that deserves more.
- 30:16 In English the word 'I' is capitalized even mid-sentence, reflecting ego, whereas the Torah has no such enlarged letter for 'ani'.
- 43:41 Kelipah's chesed is called Kna'ani, from 'hachna'ah', submission: its giver submits to the receiving side because he really gives for himself, like a donor who wants a plaque or a darshan who speaks for pay.
- 47:55 In the tzaddik's case the wick is the body and the flame is the soul: the body alone holds him back from flying up to Hashem until his time comes.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avihu, Dovid HaMelech, Esav, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nadav, Rashi, Sarah Imeinu, Shlomo HaMelech, the Chiddushei HaRim, the Chozeh of Lublin, the Imrei Emes (Rabbi Avraham Mordechai of Ger), the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, the Rambam, the Rebbe Rashab (Rabbi Sholom Dovber of Lubavitch), Yaakov Avinu
Terms אורו של משיח, ביטול, דביקות, חכמה, טבע, יסוד, מסירות נפש, משפיע ומקבל, נר ה' נשמת אדם, סטרא אחרא, ענוה, ערב רב, רבונו של עולם