טבע נשמות ישראל להיות בטל להקב"ה לגמרי י"ט כדי להתאחד באור אין סוף ב"ה וב"ש.

Catalog entry: TANYA ENGLISH no. ⁨38⁩ Pocket Guide p. 77 English 56 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 56 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains Tanya chapter 18: because Hashem is clothed in the Chochmah of every Jewish soul, even the simplest Jew has an instinctive emunah, above reason, that makes him ready to give his life rather than deny Hashem's unity.

The Mashgiach opens by recalling the levels of the previous chapter and asks how the verse 'it is very close to you' applies to a Jew who cannot even intellectually grasp Hashem's greatness. The answer begins with the Avos, whose qualities their children inherit. He then explains Chochmah as the fountain of intellect: the sudden spark, above the mind, that Binah develops, compared to the tefillin above the brain. Since no thought can grasp Hashem, emunah is above reason, like a child's knowledge of his parents. He brings the Chasam Sofer's ruling that a son may not kill his father who breaks in, because a father's bond to his son is instinctive. With 'a simple one believes everything', 'I was like a beast with You' and 'an ox knows its owner', he shows that this emunah is instinct. Hence even the lowest Jews gave their lives, unlike drilled soldiers, and nearly all keep milah and avoid chametz.

Topics: Ahavah Mesuteres (Tanya ch. 18-25) · Simple Emunah, Above Reason · Mesiras Nefesh

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 The third level and the legacy of the Avos listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach reviews the levels of the previous chapter and asks how the verse 'it is very close to you' applies to a Jew who cannot even intellectually grasp Hashem's greatness. He explains that the Avos were a merkavah, and their children inherit their qualities, revealed or hidden.

  2. 5:44 Chochmah, the fountain of intellect listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that Chochmah is not wisdom but the source of the sudden spark of insight that Binah develops. He compares it to tefillin, which sit above the brain, brings Pasach Eliyahu, and reads Chochmah as 'koach mah', a power we cannot grasp.

  3. 14:46 Pure logic and emunah above reason listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach says no thought can grasp Hashem, discusses the Gemara that women have extra Binah yet rarely pure logic, and adds that most men's thinking is also biased by desire. Emunah is above reason, like a child who knows his parents without understanding why.

  4. 20:45 The Chasam Sofer on a father and son listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the Chasam Sofer's ruling that a son may not kill his father who breaks in, even if the father does not recognize him, because a father instinctively will not kill his son. With Reb Chaim Brisker's remark on the Rosh, he explains that a ruling without proof comes from a mind molded by Torah.

  5. 28:01 The simple one, the beast and the ox listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach reads 'a simple one believes everything' and says the greatest wisdom in emunah is simplicity. He explains 'I was like a beast with You' and 'an ox knows its owner': an animal knows its master by instinct, and so does a Jew.

  6. 34:45 Self-sacrifice by instinct, not by thought listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that even the lowest Jews endure torture rather than deny Hashem without thinking it through, like a mother animal defending its young. He contrasts this with soldiers who were trained to give their lives for the king.

  7. 38:11 The chassid and the flogged soldier Story

    The Mashgiach tells of a chassid who came to the Ba'al HaTanya after years away; he had seen a soldier flogged for coming back from guard duty with frozen ears, and that stirred his davening for years. He explains that today there is no fear of the king, and describes how soldiers were drilled until they would die for the king.

  8. 42:27 Undrilled Jews who gave their lives listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach notes that no Jew would blow himself up for a political leader, yet history shows sinful Jews who let themselves be killed in the Crusades rather than convert. He adds that one who says Shema with intent and readies himself for mesirus nefesh, as the Zohar says, has worked himself up to it.

  9. 45:56 Exceptions, and milah and chametz listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the Tzemach Tzedek that sins connected with gentiles, such as chalav akum, yayin nesech or chametz on Pesach, deaden the feeling for mesirus nefesh. He mentions a survey in Eretz Yisrael that nearly everyone keeps milah and avoids chametz, and explains that Hashem Echad lights up the whole soul through Chochmah.

  10. 50:52 Milah above reason; idolatry as suicide of the soul listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the dispute of Yishmael and Yitzchak over milah and explains that milah is above daas, in a Jew's blood. Idolatry is suicide for the neshamah, so a Jew instinctively sacrifices the body for it, like a hand shielding the eye; he closes with a remark on Greek culture.

The shiur, written up

The third level and the legacy of the Avos

0:34

The Mashgiach recalls the levels of the previous chapter: the higher beinoni whose Chochmah and Binah give birth to real love and fear of Hashem, and one whose soul is still hidden, who has only intellectual love and fear. Now the Tanya speaks of a third level, one who cannot grasp Hashem's greatness even with his mind. Since every verse applies to every Jew, the Mashgiach asks how 'it is very close to you' applies to him. a,b

4:56

The answer begins with the Avos, who were a merkavah, cleaving to Hashem. Their children are an extension of them and carry their qualities, revealed or hidden, which is why simple parents can give birth to a lofty neshamah.

Chochmah, the fountain of intellect

5:44

On the Tanya's words that Chochmah is the source of intellect, the Mashgiach explains that Chochmah here does not mean wisdom. A learner stuck on a contradiction in a Rambam suddenly gets a spark from above; developing it into a structure of ideas is Binah, from 'binyan'. Chochmah is the father, Binah the mother. a

7:53

As Hashem created the world with ten sefiros, He placed ten powers in the soul, and the one corresponding to Chochmah is the source of that spark. The mind receives it but cannot grasp it, as a watch cannot understand its watchmaker. The Mashgiach compares it to tefillin, the Keser, part of a person yet above the brain, which hold 'Hashem Echad'; he cites Pasach Eliyahu, which places the sefiros on the limbs of man. d,o

13:33

He reads Chochmah as 'koach mah', a power that is a question mark, and mentions the Targum Yonasan that the world was created with Chochmah. Only when it filters down to Binah does one understand. e

Pure logic and emunah above reason

15:21

No thought, the Mashgiach says, can grasp Hashem. He brings the Gemara learned from 'Vayiven Hashem' that women have more Binah, an intuition between logic and emotion, which is why a girl becomes bas mitzvah first; yet they do not produce pure logic. Most men also do not, since desire bends their thinking, and certainly not the unlearned. f,g

19:40

Still they believe, for emunah is above understanding, and in emunah all are fools. A child does not understand why these are his parents, but he knows.

The Chasam Sofer on a father and son

20:45

The Mashgiach brings the Chasam Sofer at the beginning of Pesachim. A burglar may be killed in self-defense, since he is ready to kill the resisting owner; but a son may not kill his father who breaks in, because a father will not kill his son. The Chasam Sofer rules this even when the father does not know it is his son's home, since instinct stops him, and brings no proof. h

23:39

The Mashgiach explains with Reb Chaim Brisker's remark that when the Rosh rules without proof the ruling is firmer, since its proof is all of Shas that shaped his mind. So the Chasam Sofer, who learned Tanya, knew that the bond of father and son cannot be disturbed, and this is what the Ba'al HaTanya says here. a

The simple one, the beast and the ox

28:01

Such Jews, the Tanya says, believe as 'a simple one believes everything'. As a child knows his parents without reason, a Jew knows Hashem by intuition. In emunah, the Mashgiach says, the one who reasons whether to believe is the greatest fool and simple faith is the greatest wisdom, while the cunning one believes only what he understands. i,a

31:10

Since no thought grasps Hashem, he reads Dovid HaMelech's 'I was like a beast with You': a beast knows its master. As Yeshayah says, an ox knows its owner, for kinyan is in the Torah, the blueprint of creation; even the donkey knows its master's trough. Therefore, 'I am always with You.' j,k,l

Self-sacrifice by instinct, not by thought

35:00

So even the lowest Jews suffer torture rather than deny Hashem, though they know little of His greatness and never thought about it. The Mashgiach compares this to a mother animal risking itself for its young, by instinct rather than thought, unlike a person talked into being a devoted soldier of the king.

The chassid and the flogged soldier

38:11

The Mashgiach tells of a chassid who came to the Ba'al HaTanya after years away. At army barracks he had seen a soldier flogged for returning from winter guard duty with frozen ears, since a servant of the king should burn with devotion; it stirred his davening for six years. Today, the Mashgiach says, there is no fear of the king, so fear of Heaven is lacking; soldiers were once drilled daily until ready to die for the king.

Undrilled Jews who gave their lives

42:33

No Jew, the Mashgiach notes, would blow himself up for a political leader. Yet in the Crusades whole communities of Jews who sinned freely let themselves be drowned or burned rather than convert. One who says Shema with intent ready for mesirus nefesh, as the Zohar says, has trained himself like the soldier, but most did it without that. m

Exceptions, and milah and chametz

45:59

The exceptions are explained by the Tzemach Tzedek: sins connected with gentiles, such as chalav akum, yayin nesech or chametz on Pesach, deaden the feeling of emunah. The Mashgiach mentions a recent survey in Eretz Yisrael that almost everyone, even the irreligious, keeps milah and avoids chametz. They do it by instinct, without reasoning, because Hashem Echad lights up the whole soul through its Chochmah.

Milah above reason; idolatry as suicide of the soul

50:55

The Mashgiach contrasts Yishmael, who claimed greatness for undergoing milah at thirteen, with Yitzchak, and explains that milah is above daas; he cites 'Who will go up for us to heaven', whose initials spell milah. It is in a Jew's blood, not worked up. n

53:09

A normal person cannot commit suicide, and idolatry is suicide of the neshamah, so a Jew gives up the body to save the soul, as one reflexively sacrifices a hand to shield the eye.

Sources

Torah

  1. b apparently Devarim 30:14 index In the write-up: 0:34
  2. g Bereishis 2:22 text index In the write-up: 15:21
  3. n Devarim 30:12 text index In the write-up: 50:55
  4. o Devarim 6:4 text index In the write-up: 7:53

Nevi'im

  1. l Yeshayah 1:3 text index In the write-up: 31:10

Kesuvim

  1. i Mishlei 14:15 text index In the write-up: 28:01
  2. k Tehillim 73:22-23 text index In the write-up: 31:10

Targum

  1. e apparently Targum Yonasan, Bereishis 1:1 index In the write-up: 13:33

Talmud Bavli

  1. c Gemara Berachos (place not identified) 4:40 index
  2. f apparently Niddah 45b index In the write-up: 15:21

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. d apparently Tikkunei Zohar, Introduction (Pasach Eliyahu) index In the write-up: 7:53
  2. j apparently Tikkunei Zohar, Introduction 17a index In the write-up: 31:10
  3. m Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 42:33

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a Tanya ch. 18 text index In the write-up: 0:34, 5:44, 23:39, 28:01
  2. h apparently Chiddushei Chasam Sofer, beginning of Pesachim index In the write-up: 20:45

Key points

  1. 6:17 Chochmah is the source of intellect: a spark from above that the mind receives but cannot grasp, which Binah then develops into understanding.
  2. 19:40 Emunah is above reason; in emunah everyone is like a simple fool, and the greatest wisdom in emunah is simple faith.
  3. 20:00 A Jew knows Hashem by intuition, the way a child knows his father and mother without being able to explain why.
  4. 35:19 Even the lowest Jews gave their lives rather than deny Hashem's unity, not out of thought or drilling, but by an instinct like a mother animal protecting its young.
  5. 53:14 Idolatry is like suicide for the neshamah, so a Jew instinctively gives up his body to save it, as a hand reflexively shields the eye.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 3:48 How does the verse 'it is very close to you' apply to a Jew who cannot even intellectually grasp Hashem's greatness?

    Answer: 4:56 Every Jew inherits the Avos' bond with Hashem, and Hashem is clothed in the Chochmah of every soul, giving an emunah above reason.

  2. Question: 7:45 If Chochmah is above the mind, where does the spark of insight come from?

    Answer: 8:53 From a power Hashem placed in man corresponding to the sefirah of Chochmah, a source the mind receives but cannot understand.

  3. Question: 22:14 Why may a son not kill his father who breaks in, though anyone else breaking in may be killed?

    Answer: 22:24 Because a father will not kill his son, so there is no self-defense; the Chasam Sofer says this holds even if the father does not recognize him, since it is instinct.

  4. Question: 45:56 Why are there Jews who would not give their lives?

    Answer: 46:04 The Tzemach Tzedek says sins connected with gentiles, like chalav akum, yayin nesech or chametz on Pesach, deaden the feeling of emunah.

Stories

  1. 38:11 The chassid and the soldier with frozen ears

    A chassid came to the Ba'al HaTanya after not having been there for some years and asked for something to stir his fear and love of Hashem in davening. The Rebbe asked what had kept him going until then. He said that he did business with the Russian government and once, visiting the barracks, saw a soldier being flogged for coming back from night guard duty in the cold Russian winter with frozen ears: a servant of the king should be so devoted that his blood boils within him. That sight had inspired his davening for six years, and now it was used up, so he came for more.

    In the story: the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi)

    told in 3 other shiurim →

Insights

  1. 12:24 Chochmah is read as 'koach mah', a power that is a question mark: we receive its flashes but cannot know where they come from, as a watch cannot understand the watchmaker.
  2. 9:57 Tefillin are the person's Keser: part of him yet above the brain, the source from which the mind receives its flashes.
  3. 29:06 In emunah the roles flip: the 'wise man' who reasons whether to believe is the greatest fool, and the one who believes with simple faith has the greatest wisdom.
  4. 23:39 Reb Chaim Brisker's remark that a Rosh ruling without proof is firmer than one with proof, since its source is the whole of Shas that shaped his mind, explains why the Chasam Sofer could rule on the father's instinct with no proof.
  5. 32:29 Because ownership (kinyan) is in the Torah, the blueprint of creation, it is built into creation itself, so an ox knows its owner.
  6. 51:11 Yishmael's claim to greatness for undergoing milah at thirteen shows the opposite: milah is above daas, so a milah done by choice as an adult misses its point.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Dovid HaMelech, Eliyahu HaNavi, Rabbi Chaim Soloveitchik (Reb Chaim Brisker), the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Chasam Sofer, the Rosh, the Tzemach Tzedek, Yeshayahu HaNavi, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu

Terms בינה, חכמה, חלב עכו"ם, יין נסך, כח מה, כתר, מסירות נפש, מרכבה, ספירה, עם הארץ, קל שבקלים, רבונו של עולם

Report an error on this page