bachurim vayishlach
Catalog entry: Y 05 Current וישלח no. 6 תשע"ג (2012–13) Yiddish 42 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
Through a chain of stories about Chassidic and Lithuanian gedolim, the Mashgiach shows how far tzaddikim went to guard another Jew's honor and never to shame him.
The Mashgiach opens by recalling that this year's talks to the bachurim have dealt with kavod chaveirim, honoring one's fellow, a weak point in the generation before Moshiach, when the Gemara says chutzpah will increase. Instead of direct mussar he tells stories of tzaddikim, since tzaddikim said such stories strengthen emunah. He then tells a series of maasios: the Chiddushei HaRim refusing to count in a minyan a man who had slapped another Jew, and warning against calling someone by a nickname; the Divrei Chaim making his son-in-law pay for a whole wedding after shaming a poor man; Rabbi Yitzchak Elchanan keeping a poor man's secret; the Dukla Rav eating a pot of kerosene-tainted cholent to protect a maid; the refinement of Kelm; Rabbi Shmuel Salant's answer to a simple woman and his rebuke of a proud baal tokea; how Rabbi Yisrael Salanter's concern for a wagon driver won over the future founder of Novardok; and the Chofetz Chaim expelling a chutzpadik bachur while keeping a thief, based on the Mishnah in Avos.
Topics: Bein Adam LaChaveiro · Stories of Tzaddikim · Chazal and Gedolei Yisroel
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Honoring others and stories of tzaddikim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says this year's talks deal with kavod chaveirim, since chutzpah is a great test before Moshiach. He explains why he tells stories of tzaddikim instead of direct mussar: tzaddikim said such stories strengthen emunah, which will be very weak before Moshiach.
-
4:23 The Chiddushei HaRim's minyan and the nickname Story
On his yahrzeit the Chiddushei HaRim wanted a small minyan; when a man forced his way in by slapping another Jew, the Rebbe refused to count him, citing Choshen Mishpat. He also warns a man who called a rav by a nickname, answering that Gehinom has room for everyone.
-
8:31 The Divrei Chaim and Rabbi Yitzchak Elchanan Story
The Divrei Chaim makes his son-in-law, who shamed a poor man collecting for his daughter's wedding, raise money for the whole wedding. Rabbi Yitzchak Elchanan refuses to reveal the name of a ruined rich man even for a large donation, and the wealthy donor then reveals that he too is secretly poor.
-
15:14 The Dukla Rav's cholent and the refinement of Kelm Story
Rabbi Avigdor Halberstam eats an entire pot of cholent tainted with kerosene so the host will not be angry at the maid. In Kelm, as Rabbi Yaakov Kamenetsky told, a forgotten yarmulke lay untouched for months, and the havdalah candle was put out outdoors so its smell would bother no one.
-
21:48 Rabbi Shmuel Salant: the cat and the shofar Story
Rabbi Shmuel Salant answers a simple woman's foolish question about a cat with full seriousness so she will not be shamed. Then a young substitute baal tokea fails in the middle of the tekios, and Rabbi Shmuel tells him it was because he thought himself better than the old baal tokea.
-
28:56 Rabbi Yisrael Salanter and the Novardoker Story
Rabbi Yosef Yoizel, a wealthy merchant, sees Rabbi Yisrael Salanter break off a mussar talk so a wagon driver would not be distressed, and leaves business to become his talmid and found the Novardok yeshivos. Later Rabbi Yoizel rebukes a man who shamed another and claimed it was worth losing Olam Haba.
-
34:49 Rabbi Elya Lopian and the Chofetz Chaim's ruling
Rabbi Elya Lopian's wife is healed by a stranger he understood to be Eliyahu HaNavi, and the Sfas Emes knew of it. Rabbi Elya then relates, from the Chofetz Chaim's son-in-law, that the Chofetz Chaim kept a thief in yeshiva but expelled a bachur who spoke with chutzpah, explaining it from the Mishnah 'az panim l'Gehinom'.
The shiur, written up
Honoring others and stories of tzaddikim
The Mashgiach recalls that this year's talks to the bachurim began with kavod chaveirim, honoring one's fellow, because, as the Gemara says, chutzpah grows in the time before Moshiach and has become a great test. Lately, instead of direct mussar, he has been telling stories of tzaddikim, Chassidish, Lithuanian and Sephardi, since stories make a greater impression. a
He adds a second reason: before Moshiach emunah is weak, and tzaddikim said that gathering to tell stories of tzaddikim will preserve it. Even talking about a tzaddik already brings emunah.
The Chiddushei HaRim's minyan and the nickname
The Divrei Chaim and Rabbi Yitzchak Elchanan
A poor man received money from the Divrei Chaim for a tallis and shtreimel for his chassan. The Divrei Chaim's son-in-law said he had seen him buy them the day before, and the man stood there ashamed. The Divrei Chaim told the son-in-law to ask forgiveness, since the man might need clothing for his wife, and told the man not to forgive until the son-in-law paid for the whole wedding, which he had to collect around town.
Rabbi Yitzchak Elchanan collected for a ruined rich man. One wealthy man offered up to a hundred rubles to learn the name, but the Mashgiach refused so the man would not be shamed. The donor then called him back and confessed that he too secretly had nothing; he had been testing whether the Mashgiach keeps secrets. The Mashgiach concludes how careful one must be not to come even into a doubt of shaming a Jew.
The Dukla Rav's cholent and the refinement of Kelm
Rabbi Avigdor Halberstam, the Divrei Chaim's brother, was honored by his Shabbos host with serving the cholent. He tasted it and ate the whole pot. He later explained that the maid had poured in kerosene instead of oil, and he ate it, even at risk to his health, so the host would not be angry at her.
In Kelm they learned not to touch what belongs to another or cause anyone discomfort. Rabbi Yaakov Kamenetsky told that a forgotten yarmulke still lay on a windowsill months later. The havdalah candle was put out outdoors so its smell would bother no one. The Mashgiach says working on kavod habriyos refines a person in such details.
Rabbi Shmuel Salant: the cat and the shofar
During a shiur, a simple woman asked Rabbi Shmuel Salant, the rav of Jerusalem, what the din is with a cat that ate her unsalted meat. He silenced his laughing students with a look, consulted a sefer, and said the cat is treif and she should keep meat out of its reach. Afterwards he explained that if laughed at, she would be afraid to ask again.
When his old baal tokea grew weak, a young substitute was prepared rather than shame him. The old man could not blow; the young man blew well, then got stuck, and the tekios were finished with difficulty. Rabbi Shmuel told him it was because he had thought he could blow while the old man could not, and he admitted it.
Rabbi Yisrael Salanter and the Novardoker
Rabbi Yosef Yoizel, a talmid chacham turned wealthy merchant, was moved by Rabbi Yisrael Salanter's mussar. On a second visit Rabbi Yisrael interrupted their conversation to send him to his waiting wagon driver, lest the driver be distressed and lose another customer. Seeing how much another's distress mattered, he left business, became his talmid, and built the Novardok yeshivos.
Rabbi Elya Lopian and the Chofetz Chaim's ruling
Rabbi Elya Lopian's wife was gravely ill when a stranger showed him a plant to cook for her; the stranger vanished and she recovered, and he understood it was Eliyahu HaNavi. Later the Sfas Emes, though no one knew the story, asked why someone who had such a revelation needed his brachah.
Rabbi Elya also told, from the Chofetz Chaim's son-in-law, that the Chofetz Chaim kept a bachur caught stealing, who later became a rav in America, but expelled one who spoke to a woman with chutzpah. He explained with the Mishnah in Avos, 'az panim l'Gehinom': any sinner can do teshuvah, but a brazen person is presumed not to. e
Sources
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 1:37 The Mashgiach explains that in the time before Moshiach emunah is weak, and tzaddikim said that telling stories of tzaddikim strengthens it; therefore he tells stories rather than direct mussar.
- 10:38 Tzaddikim took extreme care not to come even into a doubt of shaming another Jew, as in the stories of Rabbi Yitzchak Elchanan and the Divrei Chaim.
- 19:57 Working on mussar and kavod habriyos refines a person until he notices even fine points, like the smell of an extinguished havdalah candle bothering someone.
- 24:30 Rabbi Shmuel Salant taught that one may not embarrass anyone, especially someone who asks a foolish question, lest she be afraid to ask again.
- 30:47 Rabbi Yisrael Salanter interrupted an important mussar conversation so that a wagon driver would not be distressed, and seeing this made Rabbi Yosef Yoizel leave his business and become his talmid.
- 39:36 The Chofetz Chaim kept a bachur who stole but expelled one who spoke with chutzpah, because an az panim is presumed not to do teshuvah.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 27:59 Why was the young baal tokea unable to finish blowing properly?
Answer: 28:11 Rabbi Shmuel Salant said it was because he had thought he could blow while the old man could not.
-
Question: 20:15 Why did Kelm extinguish the havdalah candle outdoors rather than in the beis medrash?
Answer: 20:20 Because extinguishing it gives off an unpleasant smell, and outside the air carries the smoke away so no one is bothered.
-
Question: 40:47 Why does the Mishnah single out the az panim for Gehinom, when any sinner deserves Gehinom?
Answer: 41:06 Any sinner can do teshuvah, but an az panim has a presumption that he will not do teshuvah.
Stories
-
5:18 The slap that cost a place in the minyan
The Chiddushei HaRim usually davened alone, and on his yahrzeit he asked the gabbai to arrange a small minyan of about ten. A chassid who was not invited insisted on coming in, slapped the man in his way, and entered. When the Rebbe asked where the minyan was, the gabbai said there were ten; the Rebbe answered that Choshen Mishpat says one who slaps another Jew is in cherem and is not counted for a minyan.
-
8:37 The Divrei Chaim and the tallis and shtreimel
A poor man asked the Divrei Chaim for money for a tallis and shtreimel for his daughter's chassan, and received it. The Divrei Chaim's son-in-law said he had seen the man buy a tallis and shtreimel the day before, and the man stood there ashamed. The Divrei Chaim told his son-in-law to ask forgiveness, saying the man may still need money for his wife's clothing for the chuppah, and told the man not to forgive until the son-in-law gave money for the whole wedding. The son-in-law had to go around town collecting for the whole wedding.
-
11:12 Rabbi Yitzchak Elchanan keeps a secret
Rabbi Yitzchak Elchanan went with an askan to the wealthy men of the city to raise several hundred rubles each for a once-rich man who had lost everything and needed to restart his business. One wealthy man offered twenty-five, then fifty, then a hundred rubles if only he were told who it was; Rabbi Yitzchak Elchanan refused, so the man would not be shamed. As they left, the wealthy man called him back privately and confessed that people think he is rich but he has nothing; he had wanted to be sure the Mashgiach would not reveal secrets before telling his own and asking for help.
-
15:16 The Dukla Rav and the kerosene cholent
Rabbi Avigdor Halberstam, the Dukla Rav and the Divrei Chaim's brother, spent a Shabbos at a wealthy man's home, where the custom was for the head of the house to serve the cholent. To honor him, the host set the pot before the Dukla Rav, who tasted it and ate the entire pot, leaving none for anyone. When his gabbai asked why, he said it smelled of kerosene: the maid had mistakenly poured kerosene instead of oil, and he ate it all so the householder would not be angry at her, even though it could harm his health.
-
18:41 The yarmulke on the windowsill in Kelm
Rabbi Yaakov Kamenetsky, a talmid in Kelm, told that a yarmulke someone forgot was found on a windowsill. He left the yeshiva for a rabbinical post, and when he came back a few months later to visit the rosh yeshiva, the yarmulke still lay there: no one had touched what belonged to another.
-
22:38 Rabbi Shmuel Salant and the cat
While Rabbi Shmuel Salant was giving a shiur, a simple woman came in: a cat had eaten meat she had left to salt, and she asked what the din was with the cat. The students wanted to laugh, but he silenced them with a stern look, took a sefer from the bookcase, looked into it, and ruled that the cat is treif, warning her not to leave meat where a cat can reach it. Afterwards he told his talmidim that one may not embarrass anyone, especially someone asking a foolish question, for if laughed at she would be afraid to ask again.
-
25:34 The baal tokea who thought he was better
In Rabbi Shmuel Salant's beis medrash an old baal tokea grew weak, but rather than tell him to stop, they prepared a young substitute. The old man made the brachah and could not blow, so the young man took over and blew well, until he too got stuck in the middle; with great difficulty they finished the tekios. After davening Rabbi Shmuel told him that while blowing he had thought that he could blow and the old man could not, and that was why his tekios were spoiled; the young man admitted it was true.
-
29:40 Rabbi Yisrael Salanter and the wagon driver
Rabbi Yosef Yoizel, a talmid chacham who had become a wealthy merchant, visited Rabbi Yisrael Salanter and was moved by his mussar. On a second visit, in the middle of a warm conversation, Rabbi Yisrael asked him to stay a few days; when he said a wagon driver was already waiting for him, Rabbi Yisrael told him to run, lest the driver look for him, be distressed, and lose another customer. Seeing that another's distress mattered so much to Rabbi Yisrael even in the middle of such a conversation, he left his business, became his talmid, and later built the Novardok yeshivos.
-
35:47 Rabbi Elya Lopian and Eliyahu HaNavi
When Rabbi Elya Lopian was a young man his wife fell gravely ill and the doctor said there was no hope. Broken, he went outside, where a Jew asked what was wrong, came in, said it was nothing, and showed him a plant whose leaves should be cooked and given to her to drink. When he gave her the drink the Jew vanished, and she opened her eyes, asked for water and recovered fully; he understood it was Eliyahu HaNavi. Later, passing near Ger, he went to the Sfas Emes for a brachah, and the Sfas Emes asked why a Jew who had a revelation of Eliyahu needs his brachah, though no one knew the story; he then blessed him.
-
39:05 The Chofetz Chaim, the thief and the chutzpadik bachur
Rabbi Elya Lopian heard from Rabbi Hirsch Levinson, the Chofetz Chaim's son-in-law and the administrator of the Radin yeshiva, that a bachur was caught stealing. Asked whether to expel him, the Chofetz Chaim said to let him stay, as he would yet become a rav, and he later became a rav in America. A few weeks later a woman complained that a bachur had spoken to her with chutzpah, and the Chofetz Chaim ordered him expelled; asked why, he explained from the Mishnah 'az panim l'Gehinom' that a sinner can do teshuvah, but a brazen person is presumed not to.
Insights
- 2:58 The Mashgiach presents stories of tzaddikim as a remedy for the weak emunah of the generation before Moshiach, citing tzaddikim who said that simply talking about a tzaddik already brings emunah.
- 14:18 In Rabbi Yitzchak Elchanan's story, his refusal to reveal one poor man's name is what allowed a second, hidden poor man to trust him and ask for help.
- 27:59 Rabbi Shmuel Salant traced the young baal tokea's failure to a single proud thought that he could blow while the old man could not.
- 31:50 Rabbi Yosef Yoizel was won over not by Rabbi Yisrael Salanter's mussar talk itself but by seeing him interrupt it for a wagon driver's feelings.
- 33:54 Rabbi Yoizel argued that a man who claims he would give up Olam Haba to shame someone, but would not give up any Olam Hazeh, shows only how little Olam Haba is worth to him.
- 41:06 The Chofetz Chaim read 'az panim l'Gehinom' as a statement about teshuvah: every sinner can repent, but brazenness creates a presumption that he will not.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People Eliyahu HaNavi, Rabbi Avigdor Halberstam, Rabbi Hirsch Levinson, Rabbi Shmuel Salant, Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), Rabbi Yisrael Salanter, Rabbi Yitzchak Elchanan Spektor, Rabbi Yosef Yoizel Hurwitz (the Alter of Novardok), Rav Elya Lopian, Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky, the Chiddushei HaRim, the Chofetz Chaim, the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz), the Sfas Emes
Terms אליהו הנביא, בין אדם לחבירו, כבוד הבריות