Toldos
Catalog entry: Y 05 Current תולדות no. 6 תשס"ט (2008–09) Yiddish 42 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that a Jew's emunah is a feeling of the heart inherited from the mother, so that even a Jewish apikorus believes deep down and only invents excuses, like the fox with his 'sour grapes'.
The Mashgiach opens by contrasting a goy, who can grasp emunah through logic, with a Jew, who senses it by instinct. He illustrates instinct with the Chasam Sofer on a father who breaks into his son's home unaware: the son may not kill him, since the father's heart knows. Jews are Hashem's children and feel Him with the heart. The three matzos and four cups at the Seder stand for the Avos and the Imahos, mind and heart. A disciple feels his Rebbe, as the Lechovitcher felt the passing of Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin. Jewishness follows the mother because emunah, a feeling, comes from her, which the Mashgiach also reads in the word emunah itself. Using Ben Sira's fable of the fox and the sour grapes, he shows how gaavah drives a person to justify himself: Esav blamed his wives, and the Jewish apikorus, who truly believes, denies only to follow his desires.
Topics: The Pintele Yid: The Inner Point of Every Jew · Foundations of Emunah · Simple Emunah, Above Reason
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 A Jew's emunah is instinct
The Mashgiach contrasts a goy, who understands emunah through logic, with a Jew, who senses it by instinct. He brings the Chasam Sofer on a father who breaks into his son's home unaware that it is his son's: the son may not kill him, since the father's heart knows. The same feeling exists in animals, and Jews, as Hashem's children, feel Him with the heart.
-
5:47 Matzos and cups: mind and heart
The Mashgiach explains that the three matzos are the Avos and the four cups the Imahos, chochmah and binah. Facts of the mind are the same for everyone, while the heart leans by a person's nature, as with Beis Hillel. He brings that women were given extra binah, that grain gives understanding while wine stirs feeling, and ties this to the two shins of the tefillin and to the emunah in the heart inherited from Avraham.
-
12:16 The feeling of a wife and a disciple
The Mashgiach explains why one witness suffices to let a woman remarry: she feels whether her husband is alive. So too a disciple feels his bond to his Rebbe, and he tells how the Lechovitcher cried out that he no longer felt his Rebbe until he was told that Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin had passed away.
-
15:39 Why Jewishness follows the mother
The Mashgiach asks why a child's Jewishness is set by the mother when tribe and inheritance follow the father, and answers that emunah is a feeling, which comes from the mother. He then shows it in loshon hakodesh: when a verb ending in nun becomes a noun, the last nun falls away, as chanun becomes chen, shanun becomes shen and ganun becomes gan; so amun becomes em, mother.
-
23:57 Ben Sira's fable of the sour grapes
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara's discussion of Ben Sira, who wrote fables of foxes that the nations later took over. He tells the fable of the fox who struggled for three days to climb a fence to reach grapes and then declared them sour, and explains that a person, out of gaavah, would rather blame the grapes than admit his own weakness.
-
28:18 Esav blames his wives listed in the guide
The Mashgiach relates that the Chazon Ish told a melamed who wanted to study psychology that everything can be learned from Chumash and Rashi. He then shows the same trait in the parsha: Esav saw that he lost the brachos and that Yaakov was sent to take a proper wife, concluded that his wives were to blame, and married the daughter of Yishmael, rather than admitting his own fault.
-
32:06 Rationalization and the Jewish apikorus
The Mashgiach gives examples of blaming others: the bachur who hits his finger and blames the hammer, the bachur who does not learn and blames the Rebbe and the classroom. This rationalization comes from gaavah, and it is why a Jewish apikorus, a child of the Avos, says he does not believe: he wants to follow his desires. He adds a joke about a man falling down the stairs and a philosopher's essay that there was never a true atheist.
-
36:22 The Six Day War and the letter about the beach
The Mashgiach recalls the danger before the Six Day War and the open miracles in it, such as a burning house whose fire was put out when a second bomb burst the water tank on the roof. He tells of a woman who wrote to a newspaper asking it to stop writing about the miracles, because they disturbed her driving to the beach on Shabbos; this, he concludes, is the Jewish apikorus, who believes but says 'sour grapes'.
The shiur, written up
A Jew's emunah is instinct
The Mashgiach recalls that a goy can grasp emunah through logic, while a Jew senses it by instinct. To show what instinct means, he brings the law of the thief who breaks in, who may be killed because he is ready to kill the owner who resists. A son, however, may not kill his father who comes to steal, and the Chasam Sofer adds that this holds even when the father does not know the house is his son's, since a father's heart knows. a,b
Matzos and cups: mind and heart
At the Seder, the Mashgiach explains, the three matzos are the Avos and the four cups the Imahos: chochmah, knowledge of fact, and binah, the feeling of the heart. Facts like two and two are four are the same for everyone, but where a matter can be argued either way, the heart decides by the root of the soul: one inclined to chesed rules leniently, like Beis Hillel, and 'according to Abaye' means according to Abaye's heart.
Hashem built Chavah, and the Gemara reads this as extra binah given to women, who feel more than men. Grain, the Gemara says, brings understanding; wine weakens the mind but strengthens feeling. So the matzos match the shin with three heads on the tefillin and the cups the shin with four, and Jews feel with the heart that they are Hashem's children, the inheritance of Avraham Avinu. d,e,f
The feeling of a wife and a disciple
A single witness suffices to let a woman remarry, and the Mashgiach cites the Avnei Nezer that a wife feels whether her husband is alive. So a disciple feels his bond to his Rebbe: when Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin was killed and no one told the Lechovitcher, he cried that he no longer felt his Rebbe, and calmed only once told of the passing. h
Why Jewishness follows the mother
The Mashgiach asks why the child of a Jewish mother is Jewish and the child of a non-Jewish mother is not, when the tribe and inheritance follow the father, as the passuk says 'by their families, by their fathers' house'. He answers that emunah is a feeling, believing what one does not understand; women have more emunah, so whether a child is a Jew is set by the mother. i,j
He shows this from loshon hakodesh, using Rashi's terms po'al (verb) and shem (noun). When a three-letter verb ending in nun becomes a noun, the last nun falls away: chanun, to grant favor, becomes chen; shanun, to sharpen, as in 'veshinantam', becomes shen, a tooth; ganun, to protect, becomes gan, a fenced garden. k,l,m,n
Ben Sira's fable of the sour grapes
The Gemara discusses outside books, among them Ben Sira, who wrote fables of foxes that the nations later took over. In one, a fox struggled three days and nights to climb the fence of a vineyard and could not, then turned away saying the grapes were sour. p
The lesson, the Mashgiach explains, is that a person who has not worked on himself is a ba'al gaavah who must always be right. Rather than admit he was too weak, the fox says the grapes are no good.
Esav blames his wives
When a melamed asked the Chazon Ish about studying psychology to understand children, he answered that everything is learned from Chumash and Rashi. The Mashgiach shows this trait in the parsha. Esav's idolatrous wives were bitter to Yitzchak and Rivkah, and Rivkah urged that Yaakov not marry such a woman. q,r
Rationalization and the Jewish apikorus
A bachur building a sukkah hits his finger and blames the hammer; a bachur who will not learn blames the boring Rebbe and the stuffy classroom. Psychology calls this rationalization or denial: a person talks himself into thinking he is fine, and it stems from gaavah.
So the Jewish apikorus, a child of Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov, says he does not believe because he wants to follow desires the Torah forbids. The Mashgiach adds a philosopher's essay that there was never a true atheist: deep in his heart he knows there is a Ribono shel Olam.
The Six Day War and the letter
The Mashgiach recalls the danger before the Six Day War, when a small Jewish army faced Arab armies vowing to drive the Jews into the sea and newspapers wrote of the end of Israel. Instead there were open miracles: a fire bomb set a house ablaze, and a second bomb burst the water tank on the roof and put out the fire.
For months the papers wrote of miracles, until a woman wrote asking them to stop, since it disturbed her driving to the beach on Shabbos. This, the Mashgiach concludes, is the Jewish apikorus: he believes, but his desire makes him say 'sour grapes'.
Sources
Torah
- a apparently Shemos 22:1 index In the write-up: 0:36
- c apparently Devarim 14:1 index In the write-up: 4:26
- d apparently Bereishis 2:22 index In the write-up: 9:09
- j apparently Bamidbar 1:2 index In the write-up: 16:04
- m apparently Devarim 6:7 index In the write-up: 18:44
- o apparently Bereishis 15:6 index In the write-up: 22:27
- q apparently Bereishis 26:34-35 index In the write-up: 28:29
- r apparently Bereishis 27:46 index In the write-up: 28:29
- s apparently Bereishis 28:6-9 index In the write-up: 30:13
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
- b apparently Sanhedrin 72b index In the write-up: 0:36
- e apparently Niddah 45b index In the write-up: 9:09
- f apparently Berachos 40a index In the write-up: 9:09
- g Gemara Yevamos (place not identified) 12:36 index
- i Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 16:04
- n apparently Kiddushin 30a index In the write-up: 18:44
- p apparently Sanhedrin 100b index In the write-up: 24:00
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 0:25 A goy can understand emunah through logic, but a Jew senses it by instinct, with his heart.
- 3:55 Just as a father's heart senses his son even when he does not know it is him, Jews, as Hashem's children, feel a bond with Him that goes beyond what the mind dictates.
- 5:47 The three matzos and four cups correspond to the Avos and Imahos: chochmah, the mind, and binah, the feeling of the heart, in which women are greater.
- 16:21 A child's Jewishness follows the mother because emunah is a feeling, and feeling comes from the mother.
- 27:03 Out of gaavah a person refuses to admit his own failure and blames something else, as the fox called the grapes sour.
- 34:18 A Jewish apikorus truly believes deep in his heart; he denies only because he wants to follow his desires.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 3:06 Why may a son not kill his father who breaks in, when the father does not know that it is his son's home?
Answer: 3:44 Because even without knowing, the father's heart senses his son, so he would not kill him.
-
Question: 16:25 Why does a child's Jewishness follow the mother, when tribe and inheritance follow the father?
Answer: 17:07 Because emunah is a feeling, and feeling comes from the mother.
-
Question: 12:16 Why does a woman's word, supported by one witness, suffice to let her remarry?
Answer: 12:55 Because a wife feels whether her husband is alive; if she believes the witness, it is a sign that she feels he is gone.
-
Question: 30:37 Why did Esav go and take the daughter of Yishmael?
Answer: 31:12 He saw that he lost the brachos and that Yaakov was sent to take a proper wife, and concluded that his wives were to blame rather than himself.
-
Question: 34:15 Why does a Jewish apikorus, a child of the Avos, say that he does not believe?
Answer: 34:24 Because he is a ba'al taavah who wants to follow his desires, and the Torah forbids them, so he justifies himself.
Stories
-
13:30 The Lechovitcher feels his Rebbe's passing
Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin had great disciples, among them Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch, Rabbi Asher of Stolin and the Rebbe of Strelisk. When Rabbi Shlomo was killed by a goy, people were afraid and did not tell the Lechovitcher. He began crying out that he no longer felt his Rebbe and that he must have been cut off from him. Only when they had to tell him that the Rebbe had passed away did he calm down, understanding that the Rebbe was no longer there.
-
25:01 The fox and the sour grapes
A fox came to a vineyard and saw beautiful grapes that he wanted to eat, but a high fence stood in the way. For three days and three nights he struggled to climb over it and could not. At the end he turned away and said that the grapes were sour. The Mashgiach brings it as one of Ben Sira's fables, later known among the nations as Aesop's fables.
-
28:19 The melamed and the Chazon Ish
A successful melamed came to the Chazon Ish and asked whether to study books of psychology, so that he would understand a child's way of thinking and be a better melamed. The Chazon Ish told him it was not needed: one who learns Chumash and Rashi properly can learn everything from the Torah.
-
38:57 The bomb and the water tank
During the Six Day War a fire bomb fell on a Jewish house, the house caught fire and the people could not get out. Seconds later a second bomb fell and burst the large water tank on the roof, and the water put out the fire. The Mashgiach says many such miracles happened, and every Jew had his own miracles to tell.
-
40:20 The letter about the beach on Shabbos
After the war the newspapers wrote about the miracles for months. A woman wrote a letter to a newspaper asking it to stop, because on Shabbos she drives to the beach to swim, and while the papers write about miracles she cannot do it. The Mashgiach says she did not want to hear of the miracles because of her desire to go to the beach.
Insights
- 3:44 The Chasam Sofer's ruling that a son may not kill his unaware father shows that the bond of feeling works even without knowledge, and the Mashgiach reads the Jew's bond to Hashem the same way.
- 7:01 Matters of fact are the same for every mind, but in matters open to opinion the heart decides according to the root of a person's soul; thus a ruling 'according to Abaye's heart' reflects his nature.
- 10:03 Grain builds the intellect while wine weakens it but strengthens feeling; so the Seder pairs three matzos with the Avos and four cups with the Imahos, and the tefillin carry a three-headed shin and a four-headed shin.
- 19:04 The word emunah itself shows that faith comes from the mother: a verb ending in nun loses that nun when it becomes a noun, so amun becomes em.
- 31:12 Esav married Yishmael's daughter because he concluded from the brachos he lost that his wives were at fault, the same 'sour grapes' self-justification born of gaavah.
- 34:24 There is no true Jewish apikorus: his denial is a rationalization to permit his desires, as shown by the woman who asked a newspaper to stop reporting miracles so she could go to the beach on Shabbos.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 28:47 Citing the Chazon Ish, the Mashgiach says that one who learns Chumash and Rashi properly can learn everything from the Torah, including how to understand a child.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Abaye, Avraham Avinu, Beis Hillel, Ben Sira, Esav, Rabbi Asher of Stolin, Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch, Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin, Rabbi Uri of Strelisk (the Strelisker), Rivka Imeinu, the Avnei Nezer of Sochatchov, the Chasam Sofer, the Chazon Ish, Yaakov Avinu, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms אמונה, אפיקורס, גאוה, הרגש, התקשרות, חב"ד, רבונו של עולם, שורש הנשמה, תאוה