Behar
Catalog entry: Y 05 Current בהר no. 10 תשע"א (2010–11) Yiddish 38 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
Opening a new series for bachurim on tefillah, the Mashgiach explains why he speaks so much about prayer, tells how his beis medrash grew out of a group of bachurim who wanted to daven properly, and shows that the heart of tefillah is kavanah, the awareness of standing before the King.
The Mashgiach announces a new series on tefillah and explains why he speaks about prayer more than Torah: the bachurim hear about Torah all week in yeshiva, while tefillah, as the Gemara says, stands at the heights of the world yet people belittle it. He tells how a group of bachurim he led in a summer camp's masmidim division learned to daven slowly, then asked for a year-round minyan; despite mockery it grew into his beis medrash, whose foundation is tefillah. He brings the Gemara's dispute whether Torah or tefillah is greater and the Rambam's ruling. He then teaches that tefillah is the mitzvah of serving Hashem with the heart, that the Anshei Knesses Hagedolah fixed three daily tefillos, corresponding to the Avos or the korbanos, and that as thought can disqualify a korban, thought and kavanah are the core of tefillah. He closes on the first berachah, standing before the King, and kiddush levanah.
Topics: Kavanah in Davening · The Power of Tefilah · Bachurim in Yeshivah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Why the Mashgiach speaks about tefillah
After a short announcement about a new commentary on Pirkei Avos, the Mashgiach opens a new series on tefillah. He recalls the Satmar Rav's drashos, explains that bachurim hear about Torah all week, and brings the Gemara that tefillah stands at the heights of the world yet people belittle it.
-
6:21 How the chaburah and beis medrash began Story
The Mashgiach tells how, at the Skverer Rebbe's instruction, he became head of the masmidim in a summer camp, taught the bachurim to daven slowly, and how their request for a year-round minyan grew, despite mockery, into a beis medrash that expanded from place to place.
-
14:31 A beis medrash founded on tefillah
The Mashgiach describes the beis medrash today and why the early years' davening was better, then explains that it was built for tefillah. He brings the Gemara's dispute whether Torah or tefillah is greater and the Rambam's ruling, and announces the new series on tefillah.
-
19:57 Service of the heart and the Anshei Knesses Hagedolah
The Mashgiach explains that tefillah is the mitzvah of serving Hashem with the heart and shows where it appears in kriyas shema. He then describes the Anshei Knesses Hagedolah, who, when prophecy ended in the second Beis Hamikdash, strengthened Yiddishkeit with the rabbinic takanos.
-
27:03 Three tefillos and the power of thought
The Mashgiach brings the two views on whether the three tefillos correspond to the Avos or to the korbanos, and argues that since thought can invalidate a korban, thought is the core of tefillah. Without kavanah one fulfills only the rabbinic obligation, and one must ask Hashem for the kavanah itself.
-
32:21 Standing before the King; kiddush levanah
The Mashgiach discusses kavanah in the first berachah and why the Acharonim say not to repeat Shemoneh Esrei, asks why kavanah should not be needed in all the berachos, and explains that the whole tefillah prepares one to feel he stands before the King. He ends on kiddush levanah as greeting the Shechinah.
The shiur, written up
Why the Mashgiach speaks about tefillah
The Mashgiach opens a new series on tefillah and asks why he speaks about prayer rather than Torah. He recalls hearing the Satmar Rav's drashos, which dealt with particular matters rather than Torah, and says he now understands: a leader speaks about what his generation especially needs, while Torah is a general subject.
How the chaburah and beis medrash began
The Mashgiach tells how, at the Skverer Rebbe's instruction, he became head of the masmidim in a summer camp, where good bachurim learned all day. Every beis medrash he visited davened Shacharis in half an hour, so he taught the bachurim to daven slowly, taking about an hour and twenty minutes. They learned well and davened well, for when one davens well, he says, one learns well afterwards.
The bachurim then asked to daven this way all year. Fearing the scoffers, the Mashgiach was encouraged by the Skverer Rebbe to make a minyan, which began in a store near the tracks. People mocked them, but the bachurim ignored it. The minyan kept moving to larger places; to keep peace with a neighbor they gave up four extra feet, and later, when she sold them the building, that space became a mikveh.
A beis medrash founded on tefillah
The Mashgiach says the davening used to be better, because persecution brought better tefillos and the original group was the majority; still, the beis medrash is respected, and chassanim come to daven there. It was built only because bachurim who learned well wanted also to daven well, so its foundation is tefillah.
Service of the heart and the Anshei Knesses Hagedolah
The mitzvah of tefillah, the Mashgiach explains, is 'to serve Him with all your heart' (Devarim 11:13), which the Gemara in Taanis calls service of the heart. It is so great a mitzvah that it appears in kriyas shema: the first parsha, Shema Yisrael, is accepting the yoke of Heaven, and the second, accepting the mitzvos, gives tefillah as its example. d,e,f
He then turns to the Anshei Knesses Hagedolah. In the second Beis Hamikdash prophecy ceased and the miracles of the first were absent, so Yiddishkeit had to be strengthened. Their last member was Shimon HaTzaddik, with whom Pirkei Avos begins, and almost all rabbinic takanos come from them, as fences around the mitzvos. g
Three tefillos and the power of thought
The Anshei Knesses Hagedolah enacted three daily tefillos. The Gemara in Berachos gives two views: they correspond to the korbanos, or to the Avos, Yitzchak's mincha learned from 'to converse in the field' and Yaakov's maariv from 'when the sun set'. h,i,j
Since a mere thought of eating a korban out of its time makes it pigul, thought is central to tefillah too. Without kavanah one fulfills only the rabbinic enactment, not serving Hashem with the heart. Citing the Yerushalmi on the passuk in Tehillim, he says Hashem grants the kavanah, so one must pray for it. k,l
Standing before the King; kiddush levanah
Per the Gemara and Shulchan Aruch, one without kavanah in the first berachah must repeat, but the Acharonim say not to today, since he would likely lack kavanah again. The Mashgiach asks: he still missed the Torah mitzvah, and why should kavanah suffice in one berachah and not all eighteen? m
Everything before Shemoneh Esrei is preparation, to warm one up. Citing the Rambam, he says one must feel he stands before the King; quoting the Ba'al Shem Tov that a person is where his thoughts are, facing Yerushalayim places him before the Kodesh HaKodashim. He closes on kiddush levanah, greeting the Shechinah, after which Karlin said no tachanun. n,o
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Talmud Yerushalmi
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 3:55 The Mashgiach speaks constantly about tefillah because yeshivos speak about Torah all week, while tefillah, though it stands at the heights of the world, is belittled by people.
- 16:47 His beis medrash was built only because bachurim who learned well also wanted to daven well, so its foundation is tefillah.
- 19:58 Tefillah fulfills the mitzvah of serving Hashem with all one's heart, and therefore its core is the heart and the thought.
- 27:07 The Anshei Knesses Hagedolah fixed three daily tefillos, corresponding either to the Avos or to the korbanos.
- 29:10 Since thought alone can invalidate a korban, and tefillah corresponds to the korbanos, thought and kavanah are the essence of tefillah.
- 34:17 Everything before Shemoneh Esrei is preparation, so that a person can stand in prayer feeling that he stands before the King.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 3:27 Why does the Mashgiach speak so much about tefillah and not about Torah?
Answer: 3:55 The bachurim hear about Torah all week in yeshiva, while people belittle tefillah, which stands at the heights of the world; and his beis medrash was founded on tefillah.
-
Question: 14:53 Why did the davening in the beis medrash use to be better than today?
Answer: 15:05 Because they were persecuted then, which led to better tefillos, and because the original group was the majority, while today many newcomers, children and grandchildren fill it.
-
Question: 26:03 Why did the Anshei Knesses Hagedolah need to make so many takanos, when in the first Beis Hamikdash there were almost none?
Answer: 24:53 In the first Beis Hamikdash the people followed the prophets and saw open miracles; once prophecy ended in the second, Yiddishkeit had to be strengthened with fences and enactments.
-
Question: 29:10 Why is thought so central to tefillah?
Answer: 29:24 Because tefillah corresponds to the korbanos, and with a korban a mere thought of eating it out of its time or place disqualifies it.
Stories
-
6:28 Rosh hamasmidim in the summer camp
A summer camp had a regular division with sports and swimming and only an hour of learning morning and afternoon, and a masmidim division where good bachurim learned all day in a separate building. The Mashgiach was asked to become head of the masmidim and did not want to, but the Skverer Rebbe told him to accept, and he did. Looking for a place where one could daven properly, he went from beis medrash to beis medrash and found everywhere a hurried half-hour Shacharis, so he taught the bachurim to daven slowly; Shacharis took about an hour and twenty minutes, and they learned and davened with enjoyment for two or three summers.
-
11:04 The minyan that became a beis medrash
Afterwards the bachurim asked the Mashgiach to daven this way all year. He feared the mockery of scoffers, but the Skverer Rebbe encouraged him to make a minyan, and it began in a store near the tracks, every Shabbos. People mocked them and called them names, but the bachurim paid no attention. As it grew they moved to ever larger places; a woman living in the building objected to enlarging the room by four feet, and to keep peace with the neighbors they gave up the four feet. Later she sold the building to the chaburah, an apartment was built for the Mashgiach, and where the extra four feet were, a mikveh was made.
Insights
- 2:52 The Mashgiach explains, recalling the Satmar Rav's drashos, that a leader speaks about the matters his generation particularly needs, while Torah is a general subject; this is why he himself speaks about tefillah.
- 14:58 The davening in the beis medrash was better in its early years because the group was persecuted, which drove them to better tefillos, and because the original members were then the majority.
- 20:48 Tefillah is so great a mitzvah that it is included in kriyas shema itself: within the parsha of accepting the mitzvos, 'to serve Him with all your heart' stands as the example of a mitzvah.
- 29:10 Since pigul shows that a mere thought can disqualify a korban, and tefillah stands in place of the korbanos, the Mashgiach derives that thought is the decisive part of tefillah.
- 30:34 Saying the words without kavanah fulfills only the rabbinic enactment of three tefillos, not the Torah mitzvah of serving Hashem with the heart.
- 31:21 Kavanah itself is a gift from Hashem, as the passuk says that He prepares their heart and then listens, so one must daven to be able to daven with kavanah.
- 35:19 Citing the Ba'al Shem Tov that a person is where his thoughts are, the Mashgiach explains that one who faces Yerushalayim in prayer is truly there, before the Kodesh HaKodashim, standing before the King.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Chaggai, Dovid HaMelech, Malachi, Mordechai HaTzaddik, R' Leibush, Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi, Rabbi Yochanan, Shimon HaTzaddik, Shlomo HaMelech, the Baal Shem Tov, the Rambam, the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum), the Skverer Rebbe, Yaakov Avinu, Yeshayahu HaNavi, Yirmiyahu HaNavi, Yitzchak Avinu, Zechariah HaNavi
Terms אנשי כנסת הגדולה, כוונה, עבודה שבלב, פיגול, קידוש לבנה, שמונה עשרה, תחנון