Bachurim Noach
Catalog entry: Y 05 Current נח no. 3 תש"ע (2009–10) Yiddish 39 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
Starting from the Ba'al Shem Tov's reading of 'make a light for the teivah' as making the word of prayer shine, the Mashgiach teaches the bachurim that tefillah, said slowly, aloud and with the whole heart, is the ark that saves a Jew from the flood of this world.
The Mashgiach opens with the Ba'al Shem Tov on Parshas Noach: the teivah is the word of prayer, which one must fill with light and enter with one's whole being. Through his rebbe he ties this to the plain meaning: the world is a flood of desires, and as Noach was saved by the ark, a Jew is saved by davening, above all a long morning davening. He tells how a camp minyan of bachurim who davened slowly grew into the shul's minyan, and explains with the Gemara why tefillah, though it stands at the height of the world, is mocked. He then reads the Ramban at the end of Parshas Bo: the world was created so that people gather in shuls and proclaim aloud that they are His creations, and loud davening overpowers the yetzer hara. From the Ba'al HaTanya's letters he shows the call for slow chazzanim and long davening, and closes that in the time before Moshiach the main avodah is tefillah with the whole heart, alongside learning.
Topics: Kavanah in Davening · Davening with the Tzibbur and the Beis HaKnesses
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The teivah is the word of prayer listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Ba'al Shem Tov's reading of 'make a light for the teivah' as filling the word of prayer with light and entering it with everything one has. He asks how this drush fits the plain meaning and answers with his rebbe's teaching that the world is a flood, and as Noach was saved by the ark a Jew is saved by davening, above all in the morning.
-
6:29 A bachurim minyan, and why prayer is mocked
The Mashgiach tells how, as rosh hamasmidim in camp, he organized young bachurim to daven slowly in the morning, and how their request to continue in the city became the minyan of the shul. He then asks why someone who learns well is honored while someone who davens well is mocked, and answers with the Gemara that tefillah is among the things that stand at the height of the world yet people treat lightly.
-
12:17 The Ramban: prayer is the purpose of creation
The Mashgiach explains that reading a holy sefer in the author's own words is as if the author stands before the reader, and then reads the Ramban at the end of Parshas Bo. The Ramban writes that the purpose of the mitzvos and of creation is that people recognize Hashem as their Creator, thank Him and turn to Him in prayer.
-
16:24 Davening aloud, in shul, against the yetzer hara
Continuing the Ramban, the Mashgiach explains that shuls and loud prayer exist so that people gather and proclaim before Hashem that they are His creations, and brings the Yerushalmi on the people of Nineveh that prayer needs a voice. He adds that loud davening overpowers the yetzer hara, who urges a quick davening, and brings Reb Aharon of Karlin that simple people must daven aloud, as is the custom in Stolin.
-
22:22 The Ba'al HaTanya's letter on the chazzan
The Mashgiach reads a letter of the Ba'al HaTanya asking that working men not lead the weekday davening, but melamdim and kollel yungeleit who can daven shacharis for at least an hour and a half, chosen by lot or by the majority, with the others surrounding the chazzan. He adds that in his shul the best places around the amud are given to the bachurim, who still have freshness in davening.
-
26:37 Don't drive away the long-davening chazzan
From a second letter, the Mashgiach explains why the Ba'al HaTanya was pained by people who push a slow chazzan from the amud: one who lengthens his prayer lengthens his days, and they drive away that life. He tells of the Chasam Sofer's answer to a friend about long davening, and concludes that a person who must hurry to work should rather leave, even without hearing kedushah, than rush the chazzan, applying this to his own yungeleit.
-
32:24 Prayer with the whole heart before Moshiach
The Mashgiach explains that fast davening without kavanah fulfills only the rabbinic mitzvah, not the Torah mitzvah of serving Hashem with all one's heart, and brings the Shulchan Aruch on kavanah in the first berachah. He returns to the Ba'al HaTanya: in the time before Moshiach the main avodah is tefillah, while bachurim must still learn, and in davening the hidden love of Hashem in every Jew comes out.
The shiur, written up
The teivah is the word of prayer
The Mashgiach opens with the Ba'al Shem Tov's teaching on Parshas Noach. 'Make a light for the teivah' means: bring light into the teivah, the word, of your davening. 'Come into the teivah with all your household' means: put everything you have, your whole inner self, into each word of prayer. a,b,c
Since a drush must connect to the plain meaning, he brings his rebbe's explanation. The world is a flood full of yetzer hara, and most people drown in its pursuits of pleasure and honor. As Noach was saved by the ark, a Jew is saved by davening, above all the long morning davening, which surrounds a person with kedushah for the whole day.
A bachurim minyan, and why prayer is mocked
The Mashgiach recalls that as rosh hamasmidim in camp he had young bachurim daven a slow, unhurried morning davening. They enjoyed it so much that after the season they asked for such a minyan in Boro Park, and from those bachurim came the shul they have today.
He then asks why a boy who learns well is praised while one who davens well is not, and is even mocked. He answers with the Gemara: tefillah stands at the height of the world, yet people treat it lightly. Prayer reaches very high, so especially before Moshiach one must put all one's strength into it. d
The Ramban: prayer is the purpose of creation
Before reading, the Mashgiach explains that one who learns a sefer in its author's words should see the author as standing before him. He then reads the Ramban at the end of Parshas Bo: the purpose of the mitzvos is that people believe in Hashem and thank Him for creating them. The world was created only so that people would turn to Hashem, praise Him, thank Him and ask of Him. f,g
Davening aloud, against the yetzer hara
The Ramban continues: the voice is raised in prayer, and shuls exist, so that people gather and proclaim before Hashem that they are His creations. The Mashgiach adds the Yerushalmi on the people of Nineveh, who called out mightily, that prayer needs a voice, like a public proclamation. g,h,i
Loud davening also defeats the yetzer hara, who argues for a quick twenty-minute davening; one must shout over him. Reb Aharon of Karlin said that some tzaddikim could daven quietly, but simple people must daven aloud, which remains the custom of Stolin.
The Ba'al HaTanya's letter on the chazzan
The Mashgiach reads a letter of the Ba'al HaTanya: on weekdays a working man in a hurry should not lead the davening, but melamdim or kollel yungeleit who have time to daven shacharis for at least an hour and a half, chosen by lot or by the majority, with such people standing around the chazzan. In the Mashgiach's shul, he notes, the best places by the amud go to the bachurim, who still daven with freshness. j
Don't drive away the long-davening chazzan
In a second letter the Ba'al HaTanya writes that he was deeply pained by people who push a slow chazzan from the amud. The Mashgiach explains why: the Gemara says one who lengthens his prayer lengthens his days, so such people drive away the long life of those who want to daven at length. k,l
He tells that when a friend boasted to the young Chasam Sofer of learning a siman of Shulchan Aruch during his long shemoneh esrei, the Chasam Sofer answered that long prayer would bring him the years to make it up. One who must rush to work should rather leave, even without kedushah, than pressure the chazzan, since the Gemara treats those unable to attend as covered by the chazzan's repetition. m
Prayer with the whole heart before Moshiach
The Mashgiach explains that one who davens fast without kavanah fulfills only the rabbinic mitzvah, not the Torah mitzvah of serving Hashem with all your heart, which the Rambam counts among the mitzvos. He brings the Shulchan Aruch on kavanah in the first berachah, where today one does not repeat, since the second time would also lack kavanah. n,o
Returning to the Ba'al HaTanya, he says that in earlier generations the main avodah was learning, while before Moshiach it is tefillah. Talmud Torah outweighing all applied to earlier generations, yet bachurim must still learn all day, as life begins with Torah. Through davening the hidden love of Hashem in every Jew comes out. q
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Talmud Yerushalmi
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
Key points
- 0:49 The Ba'al Shem Tov reads 'make a light for the teivah' as making each word of prayer shine, and 'come into the teivah with all your household' as putting one's whole self into the words.
- 3:27 The world is a flood of desires and pursuit of honor in which most people drown, and as Noach was saved by the ark, a Jew is saved by davening, especially a long morning davening.
- 15:29 According to the Ramban, Hashem created the world so that people gather in shuls and proclaim aloud that they are His creations, which is the purpose of raising the voice in prayer.
- 23:10 The Ba'al HaTanya asks that the weekday chazzan be someone with time, who can daven shacharis for at least an hour and a half, and he is pained by those who push a long-davening chazzan away from the amud.
- 32:30 Davening fast without kavanah fulfills only the rabbinic mitzvah of tefillah, not the Torah mitzvah of serving Hashem with all one's heart.
- 36:44 In the generations before Moshiach the main avodah is tefillah, though bachurim must still learn all day, since the start of a person's life, like the start of the world, belongs to Torah.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:38 A drush should connect to the plain meaning, so how does the Ba'al Shem Tov's teaching about the word of prayer relate to Noach entering the ark because of the flood?
Answer: 3:27 The world is a flood of desires in which most people drown, and just as Noach was saved through the ark, a Jew is saved from it through the 'ark' of davening.
-
Question: 8:42 Why is someone who learns well honored and held up as an example, while someone who davens well is not, and is even mocked?
Answer: 9:49 The Gemara says tefillah is among the things that stand at the height of the world, yet people treat them lightly; that it is belittled reflects how high it reaches.
-
Question: 16:24 Why do people raise their voices in prayer, and why do Jews have shuls?
Answer: 16:57 According to the Ramban, so that people gather and proclaim aloud before Hashem that they are His creations, which is the purpose for which the world was created.
-
Question: 27:11 Why was the Ba'al HaTanya so pained by people who push a slow chazzan from the amud?
Answer: 27:37 Because one who lengthens his prayer brings long life, so whoever drives away the long-davening chazzan drives away the life of those who want to daven at length.
Stories
-
7:01 The camp minyan that became the shul
The Mashgiach tells that he was rosh hamasmidim in Camp Torah Vodaath and organized young bachurim to daven in the morning a good, unhurried davening, and taught them how to daven slowly. They enjoyed it so much that when the camp season ended they asked him for such a minyan in the city, in Boro Park. A minyan was founded, it began with bachurim, and from those bachurim who wanted to daven well came the shul they have today.
-
28:23 The Chasam Sofer and the long shemoneh esrei
A story is told that when the Chasam Sofer was a young bachur he used to daven long. A friend told him that in the time he davened shemoneh esrei, the friend davened shemoneh esrei and also learned a whole siman of Shulchan Aruch. The Chasam Sofer answered that the Gemara says one who lengthens his prayer is granted long days, so Hashem would give him long years in which to make up the siman the friend had learned.
Insights
- 2:38 The Mashgiach's rebbe joins the Ba'al Shem Tov's drush to the plain meaning: the flood is the world itself, whose 'arks' of pleasure and honor swallow people, and the true ark of rescue is the word of prayer.
- 9:13 The Mashgiach reads the Gemara's 'things that stand at the height of the world, which people treat lightly' as the very sign of tefillah's greatness: that good davening is mocked while good learning is praised shows how high prayer reaches.
- 17:53 Loud davening is both a proclamation before Hashem that we are His creations, as the Ramban writes, and a weapon: shouting over the yetzer hara, who argues for a quick and easy davening.
- 27:37 Pushing a slow chazzan from the amud is not merely impatience: since lengthening prayer lengthens life, the hurried worshipper drives away the long life of those who want to daven at length.
- 37:00 The order of a person's life mirrors the order of history: just as a person begins with Torah and later turns to avodah, the early generations' main avodah was Torah, while in the time before Moshiach it is tefillah.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 11:52 The Mashgiach says one must put all one's strength into davening, especially in the generations before Moshiach.
- 20:17 The Mashgiach urges davening with a raised voice to overpower the yetzer hara, who argues for a short, quick davening.
- 30:04 The Mashgiach says that someone who must hurry to work should daven briefly and leave, even without hearing kedushah, rather than pressure the chazzan to daven faster.
- 31:38 The Mashgiach tells his yungeleit who must reach yeshiva or kollel on time to daven with the shul slowly, and to leave after shemoneh esrei, after kedushah if possible, rather than daven fast elsewhere.
- 37:06 The Mashgiach says that bachurim must still learn all day, since for them the main task is learning, even while they invest in tefillah.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Dovid HaMelech, Noach, Rabbi Aharon of Karlin (Rabbi Aharon HaGadol), Rabbi Chaim Vital, Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Chasam Sofer, the Ramban
Terms אהבה מסותרת, המאריך בתפילתו, חזרת הש"ץ, יצר הרע, מבול, עבודה שבלב, עקבתא דמשיחא, צהר תעשה לתיבה, שליח ציבור, תיבה