bachurim Chaya Sarah
Catalog entry: Y 05 Current חיי שרה no. 3 תשע"ג (2012–13) Yiddish 36 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
Through Yosef and his brothers, Tamar and Potifar's wife, a story of the Sanzer Rav and the Midrash on Amalek, the Mashgiach teaches that one must never shame or ruin another Jew, since even a deed meant for the sake of Heaven is wicked without good middos.
The Mashgiach opens with Yosef sending everyone out before revealing himself, so as not to shame his brothers. He explains that the shevatim, each bound to a combination of Hashem's Name, judged Yosef in beis din as a rodef, and brings the Midrash Tanchuma that some events, like Adam's sin, Moshe's failure at Mei Merivah and the sale of Yosef, had to happen. Yosef therefore risked his life to spare his brothers shame. Rashi says Tamar and Potifar's wife both meant it for the sake of Heaven, yet Potifar's wife is called wicked: Tamar risked her life not to shame Yehuda, while the other had bad middos and libeled Yosef. The Mashgiach applies this to shaming someone who talks during davening, tells of the Sanzer Rav and a business competitor, and explains through a Midrash mashal why Hashem blames Amalek rather than Israel's doubt. He closes with kavod habriyos, love of a Jew as love of Hashem, and a story of the Belzer Rav.
Topics: Bein Adam LaChaveiro · Yosef and His Brothers · Middos Tovos
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Yosef spares his brothers shame
The Mashgiach brings Rashi that Yosef sent everyone out so his brothers would not be shamed, and explains that the shevatim, each bound to a combination of Hashem's Name, judged Yosef in beis din as a rodef.
-
4:24 Events Hashem decrees, and Yosef's risk
From the Midrash Tanchuma the Mashgiach explains that Adam's sin, Moshe's failure at Mei Merivah and the sale of Yosef had to happen. He then brings the Midrash that Yosef risked being killed by sending everyone out, rather than shame his brothers.
-
10:15 Tamar and Potifar's wife: middos decide
The Mashgiach brings Rashi that Tamar and Potifar's wife both acted for the sake of Heaven, and asks why the latter is called a rasha. He answers that Tamar had good middos and would not shame Yehuda, while Potifar's wife libeled Yosef, and applies this to shaming someone who talks during davening.
-
16:05 The Sanzer Rav and the competitor Story
The Mashgiach tells of a man in Sanz who claimed it was a mitzvah to ruin a competitor who was not a proper Jew, and of the Sanzer Rav's proof from the darkness in Egypt that it is no mitzvah. He concludes that rebuke must be given pleasantly.
-
19:46 Amalek and the king's dog
The Mashgiach asks why Hashem says 'remember what Amalek did' rather than reminding Israel of their doubt 'is Hashem among us'. He brings the Midrash's mashal of a king whose thieving friend was bitten by the guard dogs, and who blamed the dog so as not to shame his friend.
-
24:52 Kavod habriyos and love of a Jew
The Mashgiach shows the weight of kavod habriyos from the laws of interrupting kerias shema, and brings the remez that the verses of love of Hashem and love of one's fellow are equal in gematria. He mentions the yahrzeit of Rabbi Yissachar Dov of Belz.
-
29:21 The Belzer Rav's cry on Rosh Hashana Story
The Mashgiach tells of a boy who had strayed and stood outside chatting on Rosh Hashana in Belz, and became a baal teshuvah when he heard the Belzer Rav read 'al er'eh b'mos hayeled' with a cry. He concludes that a word of a tzaddik can break the heart, and one must guard oneself from hearing words against emunah.
-
32:35 L'chaim and singing (Singing)
The shiur, written up
Yosef spares his brothers shame
Before revealing himself, Yosef had everyone sent out, and Rashi explains that he did not want to shame his brothers, who had sold him. The Mashgiach notes that selling him may have been worse than killing, as the Gemara says captivity is worse than death. a,b,c
Yet the shevatim, each bound to a month and to one of the twelve combinations of Hashem's Name, did not act wantonly. They held a beis din and ruled that Yosef was a rodef, since his reports to their father could bring a curse upon them.
Events Hashem decrees, and Yosef's risk
The Mashgiach explains that, rarely, Hashem takes away a person's choice because He wants something to happen. The Midrash Tanchuma lists such events: Adam had to eat from the Etz haDaas so that a yetzer hara and free choice would exist; Moshe had to fail at Mei Merivah, since his entering Eretz Yisroel would have made galus impossible; and the brothers had no choice in selling Yosef. e
Tamar and Potifar's wife: middos decide
Rashi explains that the parsha of Yehuda and Tamar stands beside that of Yosef and Potifar's wife because both women meant it for the sake of Heaven: Tamar knew Moshiach would come from Yehuda, and Potifar's wife foresaw children from Yosef, though it was really her daughter Osnas. The Mashgiach asks why, then, she is called a rasha. j
He answers that Tamar had good middos and gave herself over rather than shame Yehuda, while Potifar's wife libeled Yosef into prison for twelve years. One can intend Heaven and still be a great rasha. So, the Mashgiach says, one may not shame a person for talking during davening, but should speak to him privately.
The Sanzer Rav and the competitor
In Sanz, a man claimed before the Sanzer Rav that it was a mitzvah to ruin a competitor who was not a proper Jew. The Sanzer Rav answered that the Jews in Egypt, lacking mitzvos, were given the blood of the Pesach and of milah; had ruining such a Jew been a mitzvah, they had plenty, burying those who died in the darkness. The Mashgiach concludes that rebuke must be pleasant, never ruinous.
Amalek and the king's dog
When Israel doubted, asking 'is Hashem among us', Amalek came. The Mashgiach asks why Hashem then says to remember what Amalek did, and not their doubt. m,o
The Midrash answers with a mashal: a king's dear friend who loved to steal took fruit from the king's garden and was mauled by the guard dogs. Later, passing the dogs, the king exclaimed at the dog's chutzpah rather than say his friend stole. So too Hashem did not say that Israel sinned, but they were meant to understand. p
Kavod habriyos and love of a Jew
To show the weight of kavod habriyos, the Mashgiach notes that kerias shema may not be interrupted even by a hint, yet one may answer the greeting of a respected person. He brings a remez: 've'ahavta es Hashem' and 've'ahavta l'reiacha kamocha ani Hashem' are equal in gematria, so loving a Jew is loving Hashem, and hating one is a sign of the opposite. He then mentions the yahrzeit of Rabbi Yissachar Dov of Belz. q,r
The Belzer Rav's cry on Rosh Hashana
A boy who had strayed stood outside chatting on Rosh Hashana in Belz when he heard the Belzer Rav read, with a cry, Hagar's words that she would not see the child die. The cry entered his heart, and he became a baal teshuvah and a talmid chacham. The Mashgiach says a tzaddik's word can break the heart, and one must guard against hearing words against emunah. s
Sources
Torah
- a Bereishis 45:1 text index In the write-up: 0:25
- i apparently Bereishis 39:12 12:03 index
- m Shemos 17:7 text index In the write-up: 19:53
- n apparently Shemos 17:8 20:15 index
- o apparently Devarim 25:17 index In the write-up: 19:53
- q apparently Devarim 6:5 index In the write-up: 25:16
- r apparently Vayikra 19:18 index In the write-up: 25:16
- s apparently Bereishis 21:16 index In the write-up: 30:18
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 0:13 Yosef sent everyone out before revealing himself so as not to shame his brothers, even though he thereby put his own life in danger.
- 1:34 The brothers did not act wantonly: they held a beis din and ruled that Yosef had the status of a rodef.
- 4:53 According to the Midrash, certain events were decreed by Hashem and those involved had no real choice, among them the sale of Yosef.
- 14:14 One can act for the sake of Heaven and still be a great rasha if one lacks good middos; the difference between Tamar and Potifar's wife was that Tamar refused to shame Yehuda.
- 19:15 It is no mitzvah to ruin a Jew who is not a tzaddik; rebuke must be given pleasantly and in a friendly way.
- 27:16 Love of a fellow Jew is bound up with love of Hashem, as hinted by the equal gematria of the two verses of 've'ahavta'.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 12:29 Why does the Torah place the parsha of Yehuda and Tamar next to that of Yosef and Potifar's wife?
Answer: 12:32 Rashi says both women meant it for the sake of Heaven: Tamar knew Moshiach would come from Yehuda, and Potifar's wife saw that offspring would come from her with Yosef, though in truth it was her daughter Osnas.
-
Question: 13:42 If Potifar's wife meant it for the sake of Heaven like Tamar, why does Rashi call her a rasha?
Answer: 14:14 Tamar had good middos and was ready to give her life rather than shame Yehuda; Potifar's wife had bad middos and libeled Yosef into prison for twelve years.
-
Question: 20:57 Why does Hashem tell Israel to remember what Amalek did, and not remind them that Amalek came because they asked 'is Hashem among us'?
Answer: 23:01 Like the king in the Midrash's mashal who blamed the dog rather than tell his friend he stole, Hashem did not want to say that Israel sinned, but they were meant to understand it.
Stories
-
16:24 The Sanzer Rav and the business competitor
In Sanz a Jew had a business, and another Jew opened the very same business across the street. The first went to the Sanzer Rav, the Divrei Chaim, who called the competitor to a din Torah. The competitor claimed the first man was not a proper Jew and that it was a mitzvah to ruin him. The Sanzer Rav answered that when the Jews in Egypt lacked mitzvos Hashem gave them the blood of the Pesach and of the milah; had ruining such a Jew been a mitzvah, they would have had many mitzvos, since they buried those who died in the days of darkness. So it is no mitzvah to ruin a Jew, even one who is not a great tzaddik.
-
30:18 The boy outside the Belzer Rav's window
A boy in Belz had strayed from the Jewish path and wanted neither to learn nor to daven. His father once took him to Belz for Rosh Hashana, and while everyone davened inside he stood outside with a few rough friends, chatting and laughing. Passing the window, he heard the Belzer Rav read the Rosh Hashana Torah reading with a cry, at Hagar's words that she did not want to see the child die. The cry entered his heart; from that moment he became a baal teshuvah, and later a great ehrlicher Jew and talmid chacham. The story was told by someone who knew the man, who had heard it from him.
Insights
- 1:58 The Mashgiach explains that the shevatim, each corresponding to one of the months and to one of the twelve combinations of Hashem's Name, could not have acted wantonly; they ruled in beis din that Yosef was a rodef.
- 5:42 Following the Midrash, the Mashgiach explains that Adam had to eat from the Etz haDaas so that a yetzer hara and free choice would exist, and Moshe had to fail at Mei Merivah because had he entered Eretz Yisroel no galus would have been possible.
- 9:14 Since the brothers held Yosef liable to death, by sending everyone out and standing alone with them Yosef risked his life, choosing danger over shaming them.
- 13:42 Intending the sake of Heaven is not enough: Potifar's wife also meant it for Heaven's sake, yet she is a rasha because of her bad middos, while Tamar's willingness to die rather than shame Yehuda made the difference.
- 17:42 The Sanzer Rav's proof: when the Jews in Egypt lacked mitzvos they were given the blood of the Pesach and of the milah; had ruining an unworthy Jew been a mitzvah, they would have had plenty, burying those who died in the darkness.
- 20:57 Hashem's command to remember what Amalek did, rather than Israel's doubt, is like the king who blames the biting dog so as not to tell his friend he stole; Israel was meant to understand the hint by themselves.
- 27:37 The Mashgiach brings a remez that 've'ahavta es Hashem' and 've'ahavta l'reiacha kamocha ani Hashem' are equal in gematria: loving a Jew is loving Hashem, and hating a Jew is a sign that one does not love Hashem.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 9:57 The Mashgiach says a person should let himself be put in danger of death rather than shame another.
- 15:27 The Mashgiach says one may not shame someone who talks during davening; one should speak to him privately, where no one sees.
- 19:25 The Mashgiach says one must rebuke a Jew in a pleasant, friendly way, and never ruin him.
- 32:12 The Mashgiach says one must guard oneself from hearing words against emunah, and want to hear only good.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Boaz, Hagar, Moshe Rabbeinu, Osnas, Peretz, Potiphar's wife, Rabbi Yissachar Dov of Belz, Rashi, Rus, Tamar, the Belzer Rav (unspecified), the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz), Yehudah (son of Yaakov), Yishmael, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms אהבת ישראל, בחירה, בעלי תשובה, יצר הרע, כבוד הבריות, לשם שמים, מי מריבה, מסירות נפש, עץ הדעת, צירופי שם הוי"ה, קריאת שמע, שבטים