אמונה - יסוד של כל המצוות
Catalog entry: אמונה א' no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 39 Yiddish 23 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains why emunah, the first mitzvah of the heart, is not just one mitzvah among the 613 but the foundation on which all of them stand.
The Mashgiach opens with the order of the Sefer Chareidim, which arranges the mitzvos by the limbs of the body and begins with the heart; its first mitzvah is emunah, from the verse 'Anochi Hashem Elokecha'. The 613 mitzvos build the body with which a person will rise at techiyas hameisim, so one who lacks emunah, a mitzvah of the heart, cannot rise at all. Yaakov's request for bread and a garment hints at Torah as the soul's food and mitzvos as its garments in the next world. He discusses gilgul and how learning about a mitzvah one cannot keep counts for it. He brings the Gemara in Makkos that Chavakuk based all the mitzvos on emunah, then the dispute whether emunah is counted among the 613: the Ramban compares it to a building's basement. Every mitzvah is a command, but 'Anochi' is a statement, and it names the exodus from Egypt, which the whole people saw.
Topics: Foundations of Emunah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Sefer Chareidim: the heart and the first mitzvah
The Mashgiach explains that the Sefer Chareidim orders the mitzvos by the limbs, starting with the heart, whose first mitzvah is emunah. He explains that the 613 mitzvos build the body for techiyas hameisim, so a person without emunah cannot rise, and mentions the garment made of the mitzvos.
-
4:58 Bread and garment: Torah and mitzvos
The Mashgiach asks why Yaakov, in danger, asked only for bread and a garment, and answers that in the next world Torah is the soul's food and mitzvos its garments. He discusses gilgul for a mitzvah not yet kept, the mitzvos that cannot be kept in galus, and how learning about a mitzvah counts for it.
-
10:25 Why learn emunah; Chavakuk's one mitzvah listed in the guide
Returning to emunah, the Mashgiach says that without it a Jew has no connection to the World to Come, and explains why the shiurim came to focus on this one mitzvah. He brings the Gemara in Makkos that Chavakuk based all the mitzvos on 'tzaddik be'emunaso yichyeh', and explains it means concentrating on one mitzvah through which all are kept.
-
13:59 Is emunah one of the 613? The basement listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the Gemara does not list the 613, so the Rishonim counted them and disagree on some, emunah among them. The Rambam counts it; the Ramban does not, because it is the foundation of the mitzvos, like a basement that is not counted as a room yet holds the whole building. He adds that every mitzvah in the Torah is worded as a command.
-
18:01 A command to love; 'Anochi' and the exodus listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that even love and fear of Hashem are commanded, since every Jew already loves Hashem and must only reveal it, whereas 'Anochi' is a statement, not a command. He asks why it mentions the exodus rather than creation, and answers that our emunah rests on the exodus, which the whole people saw.
The shiur, written up
Sefer Chareidim: the heart and the first mitzvah
The Mashgiach explains that the Sefer Chareidim orders the mitzvos by the limbs of the body, beginning with the heart, and its first mitzvah of the heart is emunah, from 'Anochi Hashem Elokecha'. At techiyas hameisim each limb rises through the mitzvah connected to it. One who missed a finger's mitzvah rises without that finger, but a Jew without emunah, a mitzvah of the heart, cannot rise at all. a,b
Bread and garment: Torah and mitzvos
The Mashgiach asks why Yaakov, fleeing into danger, asked only for bread and a garment, citing the verse about Hashem giving the convert bread and clothing and the Midrash Rashi brings there. He answers that the soul in Gan Eden also needs food and clothing: Torah is its food and the mitzvos its garments, and just as clothes cost more than food, mitzvos cost money while anyone can learn. c,d,e
A mitzvah never kept brings a person back in a gilgul. In galus, the Mashgiach notes, many mitzvos cannot be kept, as the Chofetz Chaim hints; learning about such a mitzvah counts, as with a man whose firstborn is a girl and who learns about pidyon haben.
Why learn emunah
Without emunah, the Mashgiach says, a Jew has no connection to the World to Come, which is why these shiurim stayed with this one mitzvah. He brings the Gemara in Makkos that Chavakuk based all the mitzvos on 'tzaddik be'emunaso yichyeh'. This does not mean keeping only one mitzvah; one concentrates on emunah and through it keeps them all. f,g
Is emunah one of the 613?
Since the Gemara does not list the 613, the Rishonim counted them and disagree on some, emunah among them. The Rambam counts it; the Ramban does not, because it is the foundation of the mitzvos. The Mashgiach compares it to a house's basement: it is not counted as a room, yet it holds the furnace and boiler that make the building livable. h
A command to love; 'Anochi' and the exodus
Even the mitzvos of the heart are commands. One cannot order a man to love spinach, but one can command a Jew to love Hashem, because every Jew loves Him inwardly and needs only to reveal it; fear of Hashem is likewise a command. Emunah, by the Rambam's count, is the exception: 'Anochi' is a statement, not a command. k,l,h,b
Sources
Torah
- b Shemos 20:2 text index In the write-up: 1:01, 18:06, 20:18
- c Bereishis 28:20 text index In the write-up: 5:00
- d Devarim 10:18 text index In the write-up: 5:00
- j Shemos 20:8 text index In the write-up: 16:55
- k Devarim 6:5 text index In the write-up: 18:06
- l apparently Devarim 6:13 index In the write-up: 18:06
Nevi'im
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- e Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 5:00
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
Key points
- 1:01 The Sefer Chareidim orders the mitzvos by the limbs, beginning with the heart, and the first mitzvah of the heart is emunah.
- 3:33 Each limb is built for techiyas hameisim by the mitzvah connected to it, and without emunah, a mitzvah of the heart, a person cannot rise at all.
- 6:23 Torah is the soul's food in Gan Eden and the mitzvos are its garments.
- 14:42 The Rishonim dispute whether emunah is counted among the 613; the Ramban holds it is not, because it is their foundation, like the basement of a building.
- 17:51 Every mitzvah, even those of the heart, is given as a command, but 'Anochi Hashem Elokecha' is worded as a statement.
- 20:40 Jewish emunah is based on the exodus from Egypt, where the whole people saw that Hashem controls nature.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 5:51 Why did Yaakov, fleeing into danger, ask only for bread to eat and a garment to wear?
Answer: 6:10 He meant the soul's needs in the next world: Torah is its food and mitzvos are its garments.
-
Question: 13:24 Does Chavakuk's basing everything on one mitzvah mean a Jew need keep only one?
Answer: 13:30 No; a Jew must keep all of them, but by concentrating on the one central mitzvah, emunah, he will come to keep them all.
-
Question: 14:46 Why does the Ramban not count emunah among the 613 mitzvos?
Answer: 14:59 Because it is the foundation of all the mitzvos, like a basement, which is not counted as a room but holds up and serves the whole building.
-
Question: 18:33 How can the Torah command a person to love Hashem, when love cannot be ordered?
Answer: 18:49 Every Jew already loves Hashem inwardly; the command is to bring that hidden love out into the open.
-
Question: 20:18 Why does 'Anochi Hashem Elokecha' mention the exodus from Egypt rather than creation?
Answer: 20:40 Because our emunah is built on the exodus: we did not see creation, but the whole Jewish people saw at the exodus that Hashem controls nature.
Insights
- 4:05 Because emunah belongs to the heart, and the heart and mind are life itself, a person who lacks emunah does not merely lack one limb at techiyas hameisim but cannot rise at all.
- 5:51 Yaakov, fleeing danger, asked only for bread and a garment because he meant the soul's needs in the next world: Torah as its food and mitzvos as its garments.
- 6:51 Just as clothing costs more than food, mitzvos cost more than Torah: anyone can learn, but a mezuzah or tefillin costs money.
- 13:24 Chavakuk basing all the mitzvos on emunah does not free anyone from the others; it means concentrating on one mitzvah through which all the others are kept.
- 15:18 Emunah is like a building's basement: no one counts it as a room, yet it holds the furnace and boiler that make the whole building livable.
- 18:38 Love of Hashem can be commanded, unlike loving a food, because every Jew already loves Hashem inwardly; the mitzvah is to bring it out into the open.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People Chavakuk, Dovid HaMelech, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rashi, the Chofetz Chaim, the Rambam, the Ramban, Yaakov Avinu
Terms אמונה, גלגול, טבע, יציאת מצרים, מחשבה דיבור ומעשה, רמ"ח אברים, תחיית המתים, תרי"ג מצוות