אמונה - ירושה מאבותינו הקדושים
Catalog entry: אמונה א' no. 2 Pocket Guide p. 39 Yiddish 29 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that a Jew's emunah is an inheritance from Avraham Avinu, an inborn trait like an animal's instinct, so the mitzvah is not to acquire it but not to spoil it.
The Mashgiach opens with the dispute between the Rambam and the Ramban whether emunah is counted among the 613 mitzvos, and asks why the mitzvah of 'Anochi Hashem' is written as a statement and not as a command. To explain, he distinguishes acquired traits, such as knowledge and good habits, from hereditary ones, such as height and eye color, and shows from the instincts of spiders, beavers, birds and bees that even knowledge can be inherited. Emunah is such an inheritance: Jews are believers, sons of believers. A Jew who seems not to believe has a sick emunah, made ill mainly by forbidden foods and arayos, and must go to a tzaddik for a cure. Following Rav Tzadok HaKohen, the mitzvah is not to spoil this fact. He urges learning Chumash with Rashi and Ramban, and closes with the spark of Avraham in every Jew, guarded by Hashem as 'Magen Avraham'.
Topics: Foundations of Emunah · Simple Emunah, Above Reason · Avraham Avinu
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Is emunah a mitzvah? Acquired and inherited traits listed in the guide
The Mashgiach recalls the Rambam-Ramban dispute whether emunah is counted among the 613 mitzvos, and asks why 'Anochi Hashem' is written as a statement rather than a command. He begins his answer by distinguishing traits acquired from outside, like knowledge and trained habits, from hereditary ones, like height, eye color and hair color.
-
5:05 Inherited knowledge: instinct and emunah listed in the guide
Knowledge itself normally comes from outside, but the Mashgiach shows from the spider's web, the beaver's dam, birds' migration and the bees' honeycomb that some knowledge is inherited. So it is no wonder that a Jew's emunah comes by inheritance, and Jews who do not believe have made their emunah sick.
-
9:55 Believers, sons of believers; healing a sick emunah listed in the guide
From Moshe Rabbeinu's words 'they will not believe me' and Hashem's reply that they are believers, sons of believers, the Mashgiach shows that emunah, love and fear of Hashem are inherited from Avraham and Yitzchak. Where they are weak, the soul is sick, and as the Rambam says, it must be healed like the body: a man who ruined his appetite still has it and needs a doctor to restore it.
-
14:02 What sickens emunah, and the mitzvah not to spoil it listed in the guide
Every sin weakens emunah, but especially questionable food and arayos, which clog the soul like cholesterol clogs the heart; the cure is to go to the tzaddik for a prescription of learning, davening and tzedakah. The Mashgiach then answers his opening question, developing Rav Tzadok HaKohen: the mitzvah is written as a fact because a Jew is born believing, and the command is not to spoil that fact.
-
18:01 The parshiyos of the Avos as the foundation of emunah listed in the guide
Turning to the parshiyos about to be learned, beginning with Avraham's birth at the end of Noach, the Mashgiach says the stories of the Avos and Yetzias Mitzrayim are the foundation of emunah, and brings the Chasam Sofer that a Jew must regularly learn Chumash with Rashi and Ramban. Once emunah was absorbed at home and in the shtetl; today, when many shuls are social institutions, it must be drawn from the seforim.
-
21:45 The spark of Avraham in every Jew listed in the guide
Emunah is inherited from Avraham Avinu, the first to truly believe, and the first mention of emunah in the Torah is his. With the parable of a tree containing all the trees that grow from its seeds, the Mashgiach explains that every Jew was once part of Avraham and carries a piece of him, a spark or pilot light that no waters can extinguish. He brings the Chiddushei HaRim that in 'Magen Avraham' we thank Hashem for guarding this point.
The shiur, written up
Is emunah a mitzvah? Acquired and inherited traits
The Mashgiach recalls the dispute between the Rambam and the Ramban whether emunah is counted among the 613 mitzvos. The Rambam counts it from 'Anochi Hashem'; the other view holds it is the foundation of the mitzvos and cannot be counted. But the Rambam is difficult: every mitzvah is written as a command, while 'Anochi Hashem' is written as a statement. a,b
To explain this, he distinguishes two kinds of traits. Money, knowledge and good habits come from outside, and a child not trained will not have them. Height, eye color and hair color come by inheritance and need not be taught.
Inherited knowledge: instinct and emunah
Knowledge normally comes from outside; only the capacity to absorb it is inherited. Yet some knowledge is inherited: a spider that never saw its mother weaves exactly her web, birds migrate thousands of miles and return to the same tree, and bees build their honeycomb with an engineer's wisdom.
So, the Mashgiach says, it is no wonder that a Jew's emunah in Hashem comes by inheritance. Jews who seem not to believe have made their emunah sick, but it is still there.
Believers, sons of believers
When Moshe Rabbeinu said 'they will not believe me', Hashem was displeased and answered, as the Gemara brings, that they are believers, sons of believers. A Jew believes not because he was convinced but by inheritance: he loves Hashem as a child of Avraham and fears Him as a child of Yitzchak. c,d
What sickens emunah, and the mitzvah not to spoil it
Every sin sickens emunah, especially questionable food and arayos; Rashi in Shemini explains that forbidden food dulls the heart. They are the soul's cholesterol, and the cure is the tzaddik's prescription: learning, davening, tzedakah. f
Developing Rav Tzadok HaKohen, the Mashgiach answers his question: the mitzvah is written as a fact because a Jew is born believing, and the command is not to spoil it.
The parshiyos of the Avos as the foundation of emunah
Noach ends with Avraham's birth, and the Mashgiach says the parshiyos of the Avos and Yetzias Mitzrayim are the foundation of emunah. The Chasam Sofer says a Jew must regularly learn Chumash with Rashi and Ramban, especially on Shabbos.
Once emunah was absorbed in the shtetl, in shul and even in the market. Today many shuls are social institutions, so it must be drawn from the seforim.
The spark of Avraham in every Jew
Our emunah is inherited from Avraham Avinu, the first to truly believe. The Gemara teaches that a thing's first mention in the Torah is its foundation, and emunah is first mentioned with Avraham in Lech Lecha. g
As the first tree contained every tree that grows from its seeds, every Jew was once part of Avraham, and Yaakov held Avraham and Yitzchak within him. A trait usually thins over generations, but grows stronger when both sides carry it, so Jews are almost entirely Avraham.
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Key points
- 3:16 Some traits are acquired from outside, like knowledge and trained habits, while others pass by inheritance, like hair and eye color.
- 6:38 Animal instincts, like the spider's web and the bird's migration, show that even knowledge can be inherited.
- 9:20 A Jew's emunah in Hashem is an inheritance; Jews are 'believers, sons of believers'.
- 12:05 A Jew whose emunah is weak has made it sick, mainly through forbidden foods and arayos, and needs a tzaddik to heal him.
- 17:29 The mitzvah of emunah is written as a fact because Jews are born with it; the command is not to spoil it.
- 24:09 Every Jew carries a piece of Avraham Avinu within him, a spark that can never be extinguished.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 0:43 Why is the mitzvah of emunah, unlike other mitzvos, written as a statement and not as a command?
Answer: 17:29 Because a Jew is born believing; 'Anochi Hashem' states a fact, and the command is not to spoil it.
-
Question: 5:38 How can knowledge pass by inheritance, when knowledge comes from outside?
Answer: 6:38 Nature shows inherited knowledge in animals: the spider's web, the beaver's dam, birds' migration and the bees' honeycomb.
-
Question: 9:55 Why was Hashem displeased when Moshe Rabbeinu said the Jews would not believe him?
Answer: 10:22 Because they are believers, sons of believers; their emunah is an inheritance, not a matter of being convinced.
-
Question: 9:36 If emunah is inherited, why are there Jews who do not believe?
Answer: 9:41 They have made their emunah sick, chiefly through forbidden food and arayos; the emunah is there but ill.
Insights
- 6:55 The Mashgiach uses the inborn knowledge of animals, such as a spider that never saw its mother yet weaves her exact web, as a model for how emunah can be inherited by a Jew.
- 17:29 The mitzvah of 'Anochi Hashem' is phrased as a fact because the Jew already believes; the command within it is not to spoil what he was born with.
- 13:00 Weak emunah is not an absence but an illness: like a man who ruined his appetite with a bad breakfast, the desire is there and only needs treatment.
- 15:26 Forbidden food and arayos are the spiritual cholesterol of the soul, clogging the heart of emunah as cholesterol blocks the arteries.
- 24:46 As the first tree contained every tree that would grow from its seeds, every Jew was once actually part of Avraham, and Yaakov held within him Avraham and Yitzchak.
- 26:12 Although a trait usually thins out over generations, it grows stronger when both partners carry it; since Klal Yisrael all descends from Avraham, Jews are almost entirely Avraham.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 16:12 The Mashgiach says one whose emunah is sick must go to a chacham or tzaddik for a prescription of extra learning, davening, tzedakah and self-discipline.
- 18:58 Following the Chasam Sofer, the Mashgiach says one should set fixed time, especially on Shabbos, to learn Chumash with Rashi and Ramban.
- 20:32 Since emunah is no longer absorbed from the surroundings, the Mashgiach says one must strengthen it from the seforim that speak about it.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen of Lublin, Rashi, the Chasam Sofer, the Chiddushei HaRim, the Rambam, the Ramban, Yaakov Avinu, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms אמונה, אנכי ה' אלקיך, יראת שמים, ירושה, מאכלות אסורות, מאמינים בני מאמינים, מגן אברהם, עריות, רבונו של עולם, תרי"ג מצוות