הכרה של אמונה ע"י נפלאות הבריאה
Catalog entry: אמונה א' no. 6 Pocket Guide p. 39 Yiddish 25 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach shows from the wonders and the precise balance of nature, the human body and history that the world cannot have come about by itself, and that people who claim it did are rationalizing so as not to see the Ribono shel Olam.
Continuing from his earlier talk on the wonders of the human body, the Mashgiach widens the view to all of nature: plants and animals depend on each other for oxygen and carbon dioxide, and the planets are held in a balance that a small shift would destroy. He brings the parable of the Chovos HaLevavos about a magnificent picture that someone claimed came from spilled ink, and calls the belief that the world made itself an even greater madness, a rationalization. He illustrates this with a story from Telz: a member of a club of maskilim stopped coming after a halacha about burying a dead man's blood revealed the Ribono shel Olam, because it took away his peace of mind. The Mashgiach then brings more wonders: the fixed 21 percent of oxygen in the air, cells that renew themselves except those of the brain, blood clotting, and water that expands as it freezes so that ice floats. He closes with Hashem's guidance seen in history and in the protection of every small child.
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The interdependence of all of nature listed in the guide
The Mashgiach recalls that he spoke about the wonders of the body, and widens it to nature: animals and plants cannot exist without each other, exchanging oxygen and carbon dioxide, and the planets are held in a balance that would collapse if one left its orbit.
-
3:14 The Chovos HaLevavos's parable of the ink listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Chovos HaLevavos's parable of a magnificent picture that someone claimed was made by ink bottles spilled by the wind, and says that believing the world made itself is a greater madness. He calls it a rationalization and begins to recount how, during a war in Eretz Yisroel, even secular newspapers reported the miracles.
-
6:27 The club house in Telz Story
The Mashgiach tells a story from a sefer about Telz: after a member of a club of maskilim took his own life, plaster kept falling from the ceiling until the Rosh Yeshiva's halacha about burying a dead man's blood was followed. One member then stopped coming, because seeing the Ribono shel Olam took away his peace of mind; the Mashgiach says one need not go to such a club house to see Him.
-
11:44 Oxygen, cells and blood clotting listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the air holds exactly 21 percent oxygen, enough to breathe and not so much that one match would set the world on fire. He then describes how the body's cells die and are replaced within seven years, except the brain cells that hold memory, and how a substance in the blood makes it clot so that a cut does not bleed a person to death.
-
17:02 Why ice floats listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that every substance expands with heat and contracts with cold, as in a thermometer, but water near freezing reverses and expands, which is why a frozen bottle bursts. Because of this, ice stays on top of a river as a blanket and the fish below survive; were it otherwise the river would fill with ice from the bottom and all life in it would die.
-
21:49 Hashem in history and in raising children listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks whether, with millions of such wonders, one can say the world made itself, mentions sleep as another wonder, and says that just as Hashem is seen in physics He is seen in history, especially Jewish history, and in daily events. He ends with the protection Hashem gives every small child through countless dangers, so that the boys before him grew up healthy.
The shiur, written up
The interdependence of all of nature
Having spoken about the wonders of the human body, the Mashgiach turns to all of nature. As no system of the body exists without the others, animals cannot live without plants: plants give off the oxygen animals breathe and live from what animals give off. Even the planets are held in a balance that would end in collision if one left its orbit.
The Chovos HaLevavos's parable of the ink
The club house in Telz
To show this, the Mashgiach tells a story from a sefer about Telz. A member of a club of young maskilim took his own life and bled to death. Afterwards plaster kept falling from the ceiling below, however often it was repaired. The Rosh Yeshiva said he knew no hidden matters, only the halacha that a dead man's blood, even soaked into boards, must be buried. Once the boards were buried, nothing more fell.
One member then stopped coming: he now saw there is a Ribono shel Olam, and that took away his peace of mind, since he could no longer do as he pleased. The Mashgiach says such people make themselves blind, yet one needs no club house to see Hashem; nature shows Him.
Oxygen, cells and blood clotting
The air holds a constant 21 percent oxygen, the Mashgiach explains: enough to breathe, yet if it were all oxygen one match would burn the whole world. The body's cells die and are replaced within seven years, except the brain cells, which hold memory; that is why a person still remembers the aleph-beis learned in childhood.
Likewise a substance in the blood makes it clot, so a cut does not drain the body. The Mashgiach notes that people lacking it are ill and must warn their dentist, and calls clotting one of the wonders of the Ribono shel Olam.
Why ice floats
Every substance expands when heated and contracts when cooled, as in a thermometer, and water does too, until it nears freezing; then it reverses and expands, which is why a frozen bottle of soda bursts. So ice stays on a river's surface like a blanket and the fish below keep swimming. Were ice heavier than water, the Mashgiach explains, it would sink layer after layer and all life in the river would die.
Hashem in history and in raising children
With millions of such wonders, the Mashgiach asks, can one say the world made itself? Just as Hashem is seen in physics, He is seen in history, especially Jewish history, and in daily events. A toddler crawling toward windows and streets cannot be watched every moment even by his mother; Hashem guards him, and so the boys before the Mashgiach grew up healthy.
Sources
Rishonim
Key points
- 1:13 All parts of nature depend on each other, like the systems of the body: plants give off oxygen for animals and live from what animals give off, and the planets are held in a delicate balance.
- 3:14 Saying the world came about by itself is a greater madness than saying a masterpiece came from spilled ink; it is a rationalization.
- 10:48 People avoid seeing the Ribono shel Olam because recognizing Him would take away their freedom to do as they please.
- 13:13 The exact makeup of the air, the renewal of cells, blood clotting and the unusual behavior of water as it freezes are all wonders of the Ribono shel Olam that keep life possible.
- 22:37 Just as Hashem is seen in physics, He is seen in history, especially Jewish history, in current events and in the protection of every child.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 3:09 Can one say that a world full of such harmony and wonders came about by itself?
Answer: 4:32 No more than one could say a priceless picture came from ink spilled by the wind; that would be madness, and this is greater madness still.
-
Question: 5:27 Why do people insist that the world made itself?
Answer: 5:31 It is a rationalization: seeing the Ribono shel Olam would stop them from doing what they want, so they make themselves blind.
Stories
-
7:09 The club house in Telz and the buried blood
In Telz, a club of young maskilim and Zionists had a club house with rooms where they slept. One of them took his own life by cutting his wrists and bled to death. Afterwards plaster kept falling from the ceiling of the bar below, and no matter how often it was repaired it fell again, so they went to the Rosh Yeshiva. He said he did not know of hidden matters, but knew the halacha that the blood of a dead person must be buried, even boards it soaked into; they tore up the boards, buried them in the cemetery, replastered, and nothing more happened. One member then stopped coming to the club house, because he now saw there is a Ribono shel Olam and it took away his peace of mind.
In the story: Rabbi Yosef Leib Bloch (Telzer Rosh Yeshiva)
Insights
- 1:26 The Mashgiach compares the world to the body: just as no system of the body can exist without the others, no part of nature, from plants to planets, can exist without the rest.
- 5:31 Denying a Creator is not an intellectual conclusion but a rationalization: people make themselves blind because recognizing the Ribono shel Olam would put the brakes on their desires.
- 14:42 The brain cells that never get replaced are what make memory possible, so that a person still remembers the aleph-beis he learned as a small child.
- 21:09 Water behaves like every other substance until it nears freezing, and only then reverses, precisely so that ice floats and life in rivers survives the winter.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
Terms טבע, נפלאות, רבונו של עולם