התבוננות בנפלאות הבריאה
Catalog entry: אמונה א' no. 7 Pocket Guide p. 39 Yiddish 22 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that in our time, when open miracles are not seen, the mitzvah is to believe, yet one who contemplates his surroundings can still see wonders, such as the striking number of Kohanim and Levi'im among the great teachers of halachah.
The Mashgiach opens by noting that today we see no great revelations or miracles, while our grandparents told reliable stories of tzaddikim. He tells one such story, recorded by the Maharsham's son: the Maharsham, a great masmid as a young man, fell gravely ill; a messenger was sent to Reb Ayzikl of Zidichov, and at that very hour the Maharsham saw his heavenly judgment, where a dark angel blew his Torah off the scale until a young black-bearded dayan defended Torah learned even not purely for Heaven's sake. Later he recognized that dayan as Reb Ayzikl, who told him to always be lenient for Jews. The Mashgiach then explains that today the mitzvah is to believe, and believing is greater than seeing, as the Kotzker Rebbe answered. Still, contemplating our surroundings shows wonders: Moshe Rabbeinu's blessing that Levi would teach Torah to Israel is visible in how many Kohanim and Levi'im are among the commentators on Shulchan Aruch, the later poskim, the Brisk line and even the roshei yeshiva in the beis medrash.
Topics: Simple Emunah, Above Reason · Stories of Tzaddikim · Kavod HaTorah and Talmidei Chachamim
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Stories of tzaddikim and the Maharsham's diligence
The Mashgiach notes that today no great miracles are seen, while our grandparents told reliable stories of tzaddikim. He introduces the Maharsham, a great posek known for leniency, asks where this came from, and describes how the Minchas Chinuch told him at his semichah to learn constantly, even in spare minutes on Shabbos.
-
3:53 The Maharsham's illness and heavenly judgment Story
The Mashgiach tells how the young Maharsham fell gravely ill, a messenger was sent to Reb Ayzikl of Zidichov, and at the crisis he saw his judgment in Heaven: a dark angel blew his Torah off the scale until a black-bearded young dayan defended Torah learned even not for its own sake. Later he recognized Reb Ayzikl as that dayan and was told to always be lenient for Jews, which the Mashgiach says explains the Maharsham's leniency.
-
12:42 Believing is greater than seeing listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that today the mitzvah is to believe, and tells how the Kotzker Rebbe answered a tzaddik who claimed to see the ushpizin with his eyes: he believes they come, and believing is greater than seeing. Yet contemplating our surroundings reveals wonders, and he begins his example: Moshe Rabbeinu's blessing that Levi will teach Torah, and the Chemdas Shlomo's observation that almost all the commentators on Shulchan Aruch are from Levi.
-
15:57 Kohanim and Levi'im as Israel's teachers listed in the guide
The Mashgiach goes through the Shulchan Aruch and its commentators, the later poskim and the Brisk line of roshei yeshiva, showing how many are Kohanim or Levi'im, far beyond their share of the people, and notes that Chassidic Rebbes come from the house of David. He counts the roshei yeshiva sitting at the mizrach wall, finds seven Kohanim and Levi'im against four Yisraelim, and concludes that one sees here the truth of the Torah, three and a half thousand years after Moshe Rabbeinu's blessing.
The shiur, written up
Stories of tzaddikim and the Maharsham's diligence
The Mashgiach observes that today no great miracles are seen, while our grandparents told stories of tzaddikim, some known to be true. He tells one about the Maharsham, a leading posek who used his great Torah strength to rule leniently, and asks where this came from. As a young man the Maharsham was a great masmid; at his semichah the Minchas Chinuch told him to learn constantly, even in spare minutes on Shabbos.
The Maharsham's heavenly judgment
The story, the Mashgiach notes, is reliable, unlike many embellished tales: the Maharsham told it himself and his son wrote it in his sefer. The young Maharsham fell gravely ill, and his wife sent a messenger to Reb Ayzikl of Zidichov, who promised a complete recovery.
At the crisis he began to sweat and later told that he had stood before the heavenly court. His Torah outweighed his sins, but a dark angel blew it off the scale, saying it was not learned for Heaven's sake. A young black-bearded dayan demanded a new weighing and cried out that in so bitter an exile a young man learning Torah, even not for its own sake, is precious above, and he was sent back to life.
It happened at the very hour the messenger was with Reb Ayzikl. When the Maharsham went to thank him, he recognized the dayan, and Reb Ayzikl told him always to be lenient for Jews. This, the Mashgiach says, is why his rulings are lenient.
Believing is greater than seeing
Today, the Mashgiach explains, the mitzvah is to believe. A tzaddik sent word to the Kotzker Rebbe that he sees the ushpizin enter his sukkah; the Kotzker answered that he believes they come, and believing is greater than seeing.
Kohanim and Levi'im as Israel's teachers
Going through the Shulchan Aruch, the Mashgiach shows that its main commentators, such as the Taz, a Levi, and the Shach, a Kohen, are mostly Kohanim and Levi'im, far beyond their small share of the people. Among later poskim the Mishnah Berurah's author was a Kohen and the Aruch HaShulchan a Levi; the Shulchan Aruch HaRav survived only in part. Chassidic Rebbes, by contrast, descend from the house of David. c,d,e
The Brisk line was Levi'im, and Rav Chaim's main students were Kohanim. Counting the roshei yeshiva at the mizrach wall, he finds seven Kohanim and Levi'im against four Yisraelim, and concludes that here, three and a half thousand years after Moshe Rabbeinu's blessing, one sees the truth of the Torah. a
Sources
Torah
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
Key points
- 12:38 Today there are no open miracles because the mitzvah of our time is emunah, and believing is greater than seeing.
- 4:27 Not every story of tzaddikim is reliable, since many were embellished or invented, but some were recorded by trustworthy people and can be relied on.
- 8:32 In the Maharsham's story, the Torah he had learned saved him in the heavenly judgment, because even Torah not learned purely for Heaven's sake is precious above in a time of deep exile.
- 14:10 One who contemplates his surroundings can see wonders today as well, which show that there is a Ribono shel Olam.
- 14:48 Moshe Rabbeinu's blessing that the tribe of Levi will teach Torah to Israel is fulfilled to this day in the disproportionate number of Kohanim and Levi'im among the great poskim and teachers of Torah.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:55 Where did the Maharsham's practice of ruling leniently come from?
Answer: 12:02 From the story of his illness: Reb Ayzikl of Zidichov, who saved him, told him he would become a great posek and should always strive to be lenient for Jews.
-
Question: 12:38 Why are such miracles not seen today?
Answer: 12:42 Because today the mitzvah is emunah, to believe, and believing is greater than seeing.
Stories
-
6:27 The Maharsham's heavenly judgment
As a young man devoted to learning, the Maharsham fell gravely ill, and when the illness reached its crisis his wife sent a messenger to Reb Ayzikl of Zidichov, who said he would have a complete recovery. At the crisis the Maharsham began to sweat, opened his eyes and told that he had been brought before the heavenly court, where good angels piled his Torah on the scale until it outweighed his sins, but a dark angel blew the Torah off, saying it was not learned for Heaven's sake. A new young dayan with a black beard insisted on weighing again and, when the dark angel blew again, cried out that in such a bitter exile a young man learning Torah is very precious above even if not purely for its own sake, and he was sent back to live. The messenger's report showed it happened at exactly that hour; when the Maharsham later traveled to Zidichov to thank Reb Ayzikl, he recognized him as the black-bearded dayan, and Reb Ayzikl told him to always be lenient for Jews.
In the story: the Maharsham, Rabbi Yitzchak Eizik of Zidichov
-
12:50 The Kotzker Rebbe and the ushpizin
The Kotzker Rebbe had a new path in serving Hashem that another great tzaddik disagreed with. That tzaddik sent a messenger asking why the Kotzker quarreled with him, since on Sukkos he sees with his own eyes the seven ushpizin coming into his sukkah. The Kotzker sent back that on Sukkos he believes with complete faith that the seven ushpizin come into his sukkah, for believing is greater than seeing.
In the story: the Kotzker Rebbe (Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk), Rabbi Meir of Apta (the Ohr LaShamayim), the Apter Rav (the Ohev Yisrael)
Insights
- 1:55 The Mashgiach traces the Maharsham's well-known leniency in psak to the instruction he received from Reb Ayzikl of Zidichov after being saved, that making things hard for Jews is no skill and one must make things easy.
- 10:06 In the story, the defense that saves the Maharsham is that in a bitter exile with so much hiding of Hashem's face, a young man sitting and learning Torah is very precious above, even if not purely for Heaven's sake.
- 13:44 The Mashgiach reads the Kotzker Rebbe's reply as a deep point: though he is sure the Kotzker also saw the ushpizin, he chose to say that he believes, because believing is greater than seeing.
- 17:32 The Mashgiach presents the concentration of Kohanim and Levi'im among halachic authorities, from the Shulchan Aruch's commentators to the roshei yeshiva of his own beis medrash, as a visible, present-day proof of the truth of Moshe Rabbeinu's blessing.
- 19:11 The Mashgiach contrasts the Chassidic Rebbes, among whom one does not find this pattern of Kohanim and Levi'im, but rather descent from the royal house of David.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 14:10 The Mashgiach says that by contemplating our surroundings one can see wonders even today that show there is a Ribono shel Olam in the world.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin, Rabbi Chaim Soloveitchik (Reb Chaim Brisker), Rabbi Naftali Trop, Rabbi Yitzchak Eizik of Zidichov, the Aruch HaShulchan, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Beis HaLevi (Rabbi Yosef Dov Soloveitchik of Brisk), the Chofetz Chaim, the Kotzker Rebbe (Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk), the Maharsham, the Minchas Chinuch, the Vilna Gaon
Terms אושפיזין, הסתר פנים, התמדה, רבונו של עולם, שלא לשמה