אמונה של כלל ישראל תלוי במעמד הר סיני
Catalog entry: אמונה א' no. 10 Pocket Guide p. 39 Yiddish 26 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that the mitzvah of emunah rests on the mesorah of Maamad Har Sinai, where Hashem spoke to an entire nation, unlike every other faith that rests on one individual.
The Mashgiach asks what the halachos of the mitzvah of emunah are: just as a sukkah must be built according to its halachos, emunah, which the Rambam counts among the 613 mitzvos, has its own laws. The instinct of faith, contemplating nature and philosophical inquiry were discussed earlier; now he turns to the Rambam in Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah. First he gives the gist: something one individual reports can be doubted, but an event witnessed by multitudes cannot be denied, as with George Washington or Julius Caesar. Other religions rest on one man and his charisma or wonders, while the Torah was given before millions at Sinai and handed down by the whole people. He then learns the Rambam: Moshe was not believed because of his signs, which he performed for practical needs, but because of Sinai, where Hashem spoke face to face with the nation. A later navi is believed only because Moshe commanded it, as witnesses are believed by Hashem's command.
Topics: Torah Min HaShamayim and the Mesorah · Matan Torah at Har Sinai · Foundations of Emunah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The halachos of the mitzvah of emunah
After a question on Rashi about the first mitzvah, the Mashgiach asks what the halachos of emunah are, comparing it to a sukkah that must follow its halachos. He reviews the ways to emunah discussed earlier and turns to the Rambam, noting that in the Yad the Rambam speaks as halacha, unlike the Moreh Nevuchim.
-
5:33 A public event cannot be denied listed in the guide
The Mashgiach states that the Jewish emunah comes from Sinai and cannot be questioned, and sets out the rule: an individual's report may be doubted, but a public event may not. He illustrates with George Washington and Julius Caesar, whose existence and deeds no sane person denies even if many stories about them are false.
-
10:55 Other faiths rest on one man; Sinai on a nation listed in the guide
The Mashgiach contrasts Christianity and Islam, each founded on one individual who swayed people with charisma or wonders, with the Torah, given before millions at Har Sinai who all heard Hashem and passed it down. Even other religions accept the Torah because they cannot deny it, claiming only that it was later replaced.
-
17:06 The Rambam: not signs but Sinai listed in the guide
The Mashgiach learns the Rambam in Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah chapter 8: belief based on signs leaves a doubt, and Moshe's wonders were done for practical needs. Belief in Moshe comes from Sinai, where the people saw with their own eyes and Hashem spoke 'face to face' with all of them, and no lie can be handed to later generations without protest.
-
22:26 Believing a navi, like believing witnesses listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that a later navi is believed not for his wonders but because Moshe commanded it, just as beis din believes two witnesses although they might lie, as in the case of Navos. He concludes that the other ways to emunah only support it, while the mitzvah itself is the mesorah, and says the Rambam will be continued next week.
The shiur, written up
The halachos of the mitzvah of emunah
The Mashgiach asks what the halachos of emunah are. A sukkah may be built by a contractor with every comfort, but it must still follow the halachos of sukkah; emunah, which the Rambam counts among the 613 mitzvos, must likewise have its laws.
A public event cannot be denied
The Jewish emunah comes from Sinai, the Mashgiach says, and no question can touch it. What one person reports may be doubted; what happened before multitudes must be believed, and denying it is madness.
Whoever claimed George Washington never existed would be called mad, since he led an army and a country among hundreds of thousands. Many stories about Julius Caesar are probably false, yet his rule over Rome was handed down by a whole continent and cannot be denied.
Other faiths rest on one man; Sinai on a nation
The Rambam: not signs but Sinai
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Rishonim
Key points
- 2:15 Emunah is one of the 613 mitzvos, so like every mitzvah it has halachos, and the Rambam sets them out in Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah.
- 6:26 What one individual claims can be believed or doubted, but an event that happened before multitudes cannot be denied by any reasonable person.
- 11:08 Other religions rest on a single founder who swayed people with his character or wonders, while the Jewish people believe in no individual.
- 14:39 At Sinai Hashem revealed Himself to millions, who all heard Him directly and passed it down to their children; this mesorah of a whole people is unique.
- 17:12 According to the Rambam, Moshe Rabbeinu was not believed because of his signs, which he performed out of need, but because of Maamad Har Sinai.
- 23:05 A later navi, like witnesses in beis din, is believed not because of his wonders but because the Torah commands it; the mitzvah of emunah itself is the mesorah.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:33 If emunah is a mitzvah, what are its halachos?
Answer: 3:53 The Rambam in Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah defines it as the mesorah of Maamad Har Sinai.
-
Question: 14:11 Why do the Jewish people believe in the Torah?
Answer: 14:15 Not because one person persuaded them, but because millions stood at Har Sinai and heard Hashem themselves.
-
Question: 18:37 Why did the Jews believe in Moshe Rabbeinu if not because of his signs?
Answer: 18:43 Because of Maamad Har Sinai, where their own eyes saw and Hashem spoke to them face to face.
-
Question: 23:28 Why do we believe a navi, or witnesses, when they might be lying?
Answer: 23:54 Because the Torah commands it; beis din need not worry, since Hashem stands among the judges.
Insights
- 1:49 Emunah, being a mitzvah, has halachos like a sukkah: the instinctive, natural and philosophical paths to faith are not its halachic definition.
- 4:27 The Rambam in the Yad speaks of emunah as halacha, differently from his philosophical approach in the Moreh Nevuchim.
- 15:55 Even other religions accept the Torah because a public revelation cannot be denied; they can only claim it was later replaced.
- 17:46 Moshe's wonders, such as the splitting of the sea and the mann, were done because they were needed, not as proofs that he was right.
- 23:18 Belief in a navi works like belief in witnesses: not certainty about the person, but trust in Hashem's command, for Hashem stands among the judges.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achav, George Washington, Julius Caesar, Moshe Rabbeinu, Navos HaYizre'eli, Rashi, the Avos, the Rambam
Terms אמונה, מסורה, מעמד הר סיני, נס, רבונו של עולם