חנוכה - שורש החקירה מהיונים
Catalog entry: אמונה א' no. 9 Pocket Guide p. 39 Yiddish 28 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach traces philosophy back to the Greeks, who denied the natural instinct of emunah and replaced it with the worship of physical strength and beauty, and presents Chanukah as the fight against that substitute.
The Mashgiach recalls that the great Torah thinkers wrote works of chakirah (philosophical inquiry) only because Jewish intellectuals in Arab lands were drawn after gentile philosophy, whose root is Greek wisdom; the Torah itself never sets out to prove that there is a Creator. Citing the Bnei Yissaschar, he explains that one who 'tests' both sides is, for that moment, a kofer, and that the siddur puts Ein k'Elokeinu before Mi k'Elokeinu for this reason. Philosophy, he says, is mental acrobatics: like a chess champion, any philosopher can be refuted by a bigger mind. The Greeks set up reason as the only thing to believe, to throw off the yoke. But Hashem created an instinct of emunah in every person, just as He created appetite, and an instinct must be satisfied. So the Greeks made idols of physical strength and beauty, the root of sport and fashion. Chanukah, whose gematria equals guf, fought this. He closes by urging bochurim to make a cheshbon hanefesh.
Topics: The Miracle of Chanukah and the Greeks · Simple Emunah, Above Reason
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Why Torah giants wrote works of chakirah
The Mashgiach recalls the earlier discussion of the Jewish philosophers led by the Rambam and the controversy over his books, notes that the Torah never tries to prove the Creator's existence, and explains that these works were needed because Jewish intellectuals in Arab lands were drawn after gentile philosophy rooted in Greek wisdom.
-
3:17 Testing both sides, and philosophy as mental acrobatics
The Mashgiach brings the Bnei Yissaschar that one who weighs, in the philosophical way, whether there is a Ribono shel Olam is a kofer at that moment, and explains why the siddur says Ein k'Elokeinu before Mi k'Elokeinu. He then calls philosophy mental acrobatics and compares it to chess champions: any proof can be overturned by a greater mind.
-
7:58 Greek philosophy and the instinct of emunah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach traces philosophy to Greece and explains that its axiom, to believe only what reason proves, was a way to throw off the yoke. Against this he shows that Hashem created an instinct of emunah in every person, just like appetite, without which buying milk or asking a stranger the time would be impossible; the Greeks, whom the Chashmona'im fought, tried to nullify it.
-
14:13 Idols of strength and beauty listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that every instinct must be gratified, illustrating with what a psychologist told him about feeding through a zipper in the stomach. Since the Greeks would not believe in G-d, who would bind them, they made idols of physical strength and beauty; from this came the Olympics and athletics, and the hero-worship of athletes today.
-
19:09 Chanukah against the worship of the body listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the Chashmona'im fought with mesirus nefesh against the two substitutes for emunah, beauty and strength of the body, the worship of beauty showing also in designer clothing. Just as Moshiach equals nachash in gematria, Chanukah equals guf; the haftarah's 'not by might nor by strength but by My spirit' is its message, and the Greeks' idols in the Beis HaMikdash were what the victory removed.
-
23:04 Kelipas Yavan today and a Chanukah cheshbon hanefesh
The Mashgiach laments that the Greek kelipah of sports heroes and designer fashion has entered the batei medrash, explains with the Gemara's 'today he says do this' how it leads step by step toward avodah zarah, contrasts an elder who kept his wedding Shabbos garment all his life, and calls on bochurim to make a cheshbon hanefesh on Chanukah.
The shiur, written up
Why Torah giants wrote works of chakirah
The Mashgiach recalls the Jewish philosophers, headed by the Rambam, and the fierce controversy over their books. The Torah and the Gemara never stop to prove that there is a Creator. These works were written because in the Arab lands Jewish intellectuals were drawn after gentile philosophy, whose root is Greek wisdom.
Testing both sides
Citing the Bnei Yissaschar, the Mashgiach explains that one who investigates in the philosophical way, weighing whether there is a Ribono shel Olam, must for that moment think there is none, and is then a kofer. For this reason, he says, the siddur puts Ein k'Elokeinu before Mi k'Elokeinu: the answer must come before the question. a,b
Philosophy, he says, is mental acrobatics. A chess champion of Bulgaria may meet a greater player in Russia; so too any philosopher's proofs can be overturned by a bigger mind, and absolute truth cannot be known this way.
Greek philosophy and the instinct of emunah
Philosophy began in Greece with Aristotle and his circle, who wanted to shake off the yoke and so set up the axiom that nothing is believed unless reason proves it. Reason became their king and their idol.
But Hashem built into man the drives he needs, like the desire to eat, without which chewing meal after meal would be unbearable. Likewise He created an instinct of emunah, which a person needs to reach the purpose of his creation. Even buying milk or asking a stranger the time rests on it, and without it there would be no friendship or family life. The Greeks, whom the Chashmona'im fought, tried to nullify it.
Idols of strength and beauty
Every instinct must be satisfied. A psychologist told the Mashgiach that a person fed through a zipper in his stomach would soon break down, because his craving for food was never gratified.
The Greeks too had to believe in something, but not in a G-d who would bind them, so they deified physical strength and beauty. From this came athletics and the Olympics, and the Mashgiach likens today's adulation of athletes, with their betting and collector cards, to that same idolatry.
Chanukah against the worship of the body
The worship of beauty, the Mashgiach says, also led to fashion, where people pay double for a designer's name. Against these two substitutes for emunah, beauty and strength of the body, the Chashmona'im fought with mesirus nefesh.
Kelipas Yavan today
The Mashgiach says one should dress respectably, but not to catch the eye or compete. He laments that kelipas Yavan has entered the batei medrash. As the Gemara says, the yetzer hara advances step by step; he has seen bochurim slide this way. f
By contrast, an elder still had at his passing the Shabbos garment bought for his wedding: worn, but clean. The Mashgiach calls on every bochur to make a cheshbon hanefesh on Chanukah.
Sources
Nevi'im
Talmud Bavli
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 1:21 The Torah never sets out to prove that there is a Creator; the Jewish works of chakirah were written only to counter gentile philosophy that attracted Jewish intellectuals.
- 6:20 Philosophy cannot reach absolute truth: whatever proofs one thinker brings, a greater mind can come and refute them.
- 10:31 Hashem created in every person an instinct of emunah, just as He created the appetite for food, because without trust neither personal nor social life could exist.
- 15:53 Having rejected emunah in G-d, the Greeks still had to satisfy that instinct, so they deified physical strength and beauty.
- 20:35 The Chashmona'im fought against these two substitutes for emunah, and the message of Chanukah is that victory comes not through might but through the spirit of Hashem.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:21 If the Torah never tries to prove the Creator's existence, why did the Torah giants write works of chakirah?
Answer: 1:52 Because in the Arab lands the gentiles wrote philosophy and many Jewish intellectuals were drawn after it, so Jewish works of chakirah were needed to stand against those books.
-
Question: 3:29 Why may one not investigate, in the philosophical way, whether there is a Ribono shel Olam?
Answer: 4:13 Because to weigh both sides he must, for that moment, entertain the thought that there is no Ribono shel Olam, and then he is a kofer.
-
Question: 4:59 Why does the siddur put Ein k'Elokeinu before Mi k'Elokeinu, when one would expect the question first?
Answer: 5:12 Because one may not ask without first knowing the answer; once the answer is stated, one can ask.
-
Question: 7:17 Why can philosophy not establish the absolute truth?
Answer: 7:24 Because it is only a contest of minds: however strong a philosopher's proofs, a greater mind can always come and refute them, as with chess champions.
-
Question: 15:53 Why did the Greeks, who denied G-d, make idols of strength and beauty?
Answer: 16:06 Because they too had the instinct of emunah, which must be satisfied, but they would not believe in something that binds them, so they chose physical strength and beauty instead.
Stories
-
25:19 The elder's wedding Shabbos garment
The Mashgiach describes an older Jew of the previous generation who had his Shabbos garment, a kapote. When he passed away he still had the original Shabbos garment he had bought for his wedding. It was worn and had lost the shine of a new garment, but it was clean, and that is what he was careful about.
Insights
- 10:28 The Mashgiach calls emunah a created instinct, parallel to the appetite for food: Hashem builds a desire into whatever a person needs, and a person needs emunah to reach the purpose of his creation.
- 8:27 He explains Greek rationalism as a means rather than an honest search: by declaring that only proven things are believed, the Greeks freed themselves from the yoke.
- 14:13 Because an instinct must be gratified, the Greeks who denied G-d did not stop believing; they redirected the instinct of emunah onto physical strength and beauty, which the Mashgiach sees as the root of sport and of fashion worship.
- 21:10 Like Moshiach, whose gematria equals nachash because he repairs what the snake spoiled, Chanukah has the gematria of guf, because it stands against the worship of the body.
- 5:05 The order Ein k'Elokeinu before Mi k'Elokeinu teaches that one may not ask the question about Hashem before first stating the answer.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 23:09 The Mashgiach says one should go in respectable, clean clothing, but not in clothes meant to catch the eye or to compete over who looks finer.
- 27:09 He says Chanukah is a time for every bochur to make a cheshbon hanefesh and see whether, knowingly or not, something of these Greek matters has crept into him.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Aristotle, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Chashmonaim, the Rambam
Terms אמונה, גבורה, גימטריא, חקירה, חשבון הנפש, חשמונאים, יוונים, רבונו של עולם