כל התיקון תלוי בהמתנה
Catalog entry: אמונה א' no. 17 Pocket Guide p. 39 Yiddish 30 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach teaches that the whole tikkun of the world depends on waiting, and that our generation, in the footsteps of Moshiach, is living through the last test, the test of the Akeidah, where Hashem feels distant and the answers are hidden.
The Mashgiach opens with the idea that the test of our generation is emunah, and that a Jew must wait for Moshiach even if it takes long. The sin of Adam HaRishon was not waiting: the Tree of Knowledge was a vine whose wine he was meant to use for Kiddush on Friday night, and he ate before Shabbos. The sin of the Golden Calf was the same failure to wait, and the mitzvah of orlah teaches the same lesson. The Malbim's parable of the cookie shows that the maskilim 'know better' only because they need not wait. A letter of Rav Hillman and the two kinds of keitz lead to the call to keep believing. The Mashgiach then explains that a nisayon is meant to raise a person, and asks why the Akeidah, Avraham's tenth test, was harder than Ur Kasdim. His answer: at the Akeidah Avraham saw Hashem 'from afar', in a state of katnus, full of questions. By the Ramban's rule that the deeds of the Avos are a sign for their children, our generation faces that same last test.
Topics: Awaiting Moshiach · Akeidas Yitzchak · Avodah of the Last Generation
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The tikkun of the world depends on waiting listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says the test of our generation is emunah and that a Jew must wait for Moshiach. He explains that Adam's sin was eating from the Tree of Knowledge on Erev Shabbos instead of waiting to make Kiddush with its wine, that the Golden Calf was the same failure to wait, and he brings orlah as a lesson in waiting.
-
7:01 The Malbim: the maskilim need not wait Story listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells of the Malbim's battles with the maskilim and his surprising remark that they 'know better' than him, explained with a parable of a cookie he may not eat on waking until he washes, davens and makes a brachah. A Jew must wait; that is all of Yiddishkeit.
-
10:15 Rav Hillman's letter and the two kitzin listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells of a short letter from Rav Hillman to Rav Pinchas Scheinberg, explaining that he had no time to write because he had to prepare for Moshiach. He says that even if an awaited time passes, Jews will keep believing, and he explains the two kitzin, 'b'itah' and 'achishenah'.
-
13:45 A nisayon is meant to raise listed in the guide
The Mashgiach turns to the Akeidah, which is said daily and recalled in Selichos. From the two meanings of the root of 'nisah', to test and to raise up, he explains that every test is a promotion, so Avraham's ten tests grew harder; and he asks why the Akeidah should be the hardest, when any Jew would obey a direct prophecy.
-
18:51 Ur Kasdim versus the Akeidah: seeing Hashem from afar listed in the guide
The Mashgiach contrasts Ur Kasdim, where Avraham gave his life for a G-d he had never seen, with the Akeidah. He answers that at the Akeidah Avraham saw Hashem 'from afar': he was in katnus, without his usual feeling, and had questions on Hashem's promise about Yitzchak. The simple answer the angel later gave did not occur to him, because not knowing the answer is part of the test.
-
25:44 Our generation lives the test of the Akeidah listed in the guide
Bringing the Ramban's rule that the deeds of the Avos are a sign for their children, the Mashgiach concludes that the Jewish people's last test mirrors the Akeidah: Hashem feels remote and there are questions, as in the books written after the Holocaust. The answer is simple and will be understood when Moshiach comes.
The shiur, written up
The tikkun of the world depends on waiting
The Mashgiach opens by recalling that every generation has its test, and the test of ours is emunah. He brings the Zohar's praise of whoever holds fast to emunah in the last generation, and says a Jew must wait and hope for Moshiach even if it takes long, because waiting repairs the world. a
All the troubles of the world stem from Adam's sin. Citing the Ohr HaChaim, the Mashgiach explains that the Tree of Knowledge was a good vine: Adam was meant to press its grapes for Kiddush on Friday night, beginning an eternal Shabbos, but he ate on Erev Shabbos and did not wait. At Sinai the chance to repair this came again, as the verse in Tehillim implies, but the Golden Calf ruined it; as Rashi explains, the people miscounted Moshe's return by a day and did not wait. Orlah teaches the same: one waits three years, then eats the fruit in Yerushalayim in holiness. b,c,d,e
The Malbim: the maskilim need not wait
The Malbim always defeated the maskilim in debate, yet once said they know better than him. He explained: on waking he wants a cookie but must first wash, daven and make a brachah; they can eat at once. A Jew must wait, the Mashgiach says, and that is all of Yiddishkeit.
Rav Hillman's letter and the two kitzin
Rav Hillman, asked by his son-in-law Rav Pinchas Scheinberg why he did not write, answered that the years left were not enough to prepare for Moshiach. Even if an awaited time passes, the Mashgiach says, Jews will keep singing Ani Maamin. He explains the two kitzin of 'b'itah' and 'achishenah': Moshiach can come any day, but the true end was hidden even when Yaakov wished to reveal it to his sons. f,g
A nisayon is meant to raise
Seeing Hashem from afar
At Ur Kasdim Avraham reasoned his way to one Creator of light and darkness and let himself be thrown into fire for a G-d he had never seen. That seems far harder. l
The answer lies in 'he saw the place from afar': he saw Hashem from a distance. Every Jew passes through gadlus, with tears and closeness in davening, and katnus, when every holy word is like pulling a tooth. Avraham, the man of chesed and love, was then in katnus, and a person facing something hard begins asking questions. Hashem had promised that through Yitzchak he would have descendants and does not go back on His word; how could He now say to offer Yitzchak? m,n,o,p,q
Our generation lives the test of the Akeidah
By the Ramban's rule that the deeds of the Avos are signs for their children, the Jewish people too face ten tests, and the last, before Moshiach, is the Akeidah's: Hashem seems remote and there are questions, as in the books after the Holocaust asking where He was. Klal Yisroel does not know the answer, but it is simple and will be understood when Moshiach comes. The Mashgiach ends with the angel's praise of Avraham. s,t
Sources
Torah
- e apparently Vayikra 19:23 index In the write-up: 2:13
- i Bereishis 22:1 text index In the write-up: 14:11
- m apparently Bereishis 22:4 index In the write-up: 21:03
- o Bereishis 21:12 text index In the write-up: 21:03
- p apparently Bereishis 22:2 index In the write-up: 21:03
- q Bamidbar 23:19 text index In the write-up: 21:03
- t apparently Bereishis 22:16 index In the write-up: 26:36
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
- d apparently Rashi on Shemos 32:1 index In the write-up: 2:13
- g apparently Rashi on Bereishis 49:1 index In the write-up: 10:32
- j Rashi (place not identified) index In the write-up: 14:11
- r apparently Rashi on Bereishis 22:12 index In the write-up: 24:40
- s apparently Ramban on Bereishis 12:6 index In the write-up: 26:36
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 0:11 The Mashgiach says the test of our generation is emunah, and a Jew must wait and hope for Moshiach even if it takes a long time.
- 3:03 Adam HaRishon's sin was that he did not wait to use the Tree of Knowledge in holiness on Shabbos, and the sin of the Golden Calf was likewise a failure to wait.
- 16:01 The Mashgiach explains that a nisayon is meant to raise a person up, like a test that leads to promotion, so Avraham's ten tests grew harder until the Akeidah.
- 21:03 The Akeidah was the hardest test because Avraham then saw Hashem 'from afar', in a state of katnus, and had questions he could not answer.
- 26:41 By the Ramban's rule that the deeds of the Avos are a sign for their children, the Jewish people's last test, in the footsteps of Moshiach, is the test of the Akeidah: Hashem feels distant and the answer is not known until Moshiach comes.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:20 Why was eating from the Tree of Knowledge a sin, if it was created for a purpose?
Answer: 2:33 The tree was good, but it had to be used in holiness at the right time, for Kiddush on Friday night; Adam's sin was that he did not wait.
-
Question: 8:26 How could the Malbim say the maskilim know better than him?
Answer: 8:59 They can eat at once, while he must wait to wash, daven and make a brachah.
-
Question: 18:17 Why was the Akeidah the hardest of the ten tests, when Ur Kasdim, giving his life for a G-d he had never seen, seems much harder?
Answer: 21:03 At the Akeidah Avraham saw Hashem 'from afar': he was in katnus, without his feeling of closeness, and had questions.
-
Question: 25:00 Why did Avraham not see the simple answer about Hashem's promise that a child learning Chumash knows?
Answer: 25:18 Because it was a test, and part of a test is that the answer does not occur to the one being tested.
Stories
-
7:01 The Malbim and the cookie
The Malbim, a master of all wisdoms, waged a constant war with the maskilim in Germany and always defeated them in debate. Once he surprised people by saying that the maskilim know better than he does. He explained: when he opens his eyes in the morning he is hungry and wants a cookie, but he cannot eat it; he must wash his hands, daven, and make the proper brachah. The maskilim can eat it as soon as they wake; they need not wait.
In the story: the Malbim
-
10:22 Rav Hillman's letter to Rav Scheinberg
Rabbi Yaakov Weisburg told the Mashgiach he has a photostat of a short letter from Rav Hillman to Rav Pinchas Scheinberg. Rav Scheinberg had complained that his father-in-law, who had gone to Eretz Yisroel, did not write to him. Rav Hillman answered that a mekubal had told him only twenty-eight years remain, that twenty-eight years are not enough for him to prepare for Moshiach, and asked whether he should still find time to write.
In the story: Rabbi Yaakov Weisburg, Rav Hillman, Rabbi Chaim Pinchas Scheinberg
Insights
- 2:33 The Tree of Knowledge was good: it was a vine whose grapes Adam was meant to press for Kiddush on Friday night, which would have begun an eternal Shabbos; his sin was only that he did not wait.
- 8:55 The Malbim's remark that the maskilim 'know better' than him means only that they may eat on waking, while a Jew must wait: wash, daven and make a brachah first.
- 16:01 Since in loshon hakodesh one root carries both meanings, 'nisayon' as test and 'nes' as raising up reveal each other: the purpose of every test is to lift a person higher.
- 22:57 Avraham's difficulty at the Akeidah was not the deed itself but that he was in katnus: when a person must do something hard, a defense mechanism makes him ask questions.
- 24:59 Not knowing a simple answer is itself part of the test: Avraham, the great sage, did not think of what a child learning Chumash sees, until after the test.
- 26:44 By the Ramban's rule, Avraham's ten tests foreshadow ten tests for the Jewish people, so the last test before Moshiach is the Akeidah's: Hashem seems remote and there are questions without answers.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Avraham Avinu, Moshe Rabbeinu, Pharaoh, Rabbi Chaim Pinchas Scheinberg, Rabbi Yaakov Weisburg, Rashi, Rav Hillman, Sarah Imeinu, the Malbim, the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, the Ramban, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms אור כשדים, בעתה אחישנה, חטא העגל, מעשה אבות סימן לבנים, נסיון, עץ הדעת, עקבתא דמשיחא, עקידה, ערלה, קטנות