עומק ישרות דיני תורה' להזהר במעשינו לפי מדריגותינו

Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע משפטים no. ⁨5⁩ Pocket Guide p. 10 תשס"ג (2002–03) Yiddish 42 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 42 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach shows that the judgments of the Torah are just in a depth that spans gilgulim, and that the higher a Jew's level, the stricter the 'din' that applies to him.

The Mashgiach opens with a story of the Ba'al Shem Tov: his talmidim watched an innocent man beaten over a lost wallet, and the Ba'al Shem Tov revealed that it settled a wrong ruling from an earlier gilgul. From this he asks how a beis din, where the Shechinah rests, can ever rule against the truth, and answers with the Zohar that 've'eleh hamishpatim' speaks of gilgulim: 'mishpetei Hashem emes tzadku yachdav', all generations taken together are just, as in the mashal of the gabbai who gives aliyos over many Shabbosim. He then asks why the Zohar and the Gemara say 'as if' or 'liable to death' for things the Shulchan Aruch treats lightly, and answers that souls stand at different levels, so more is demanded of a higher Jew. He illustrates this with kohanim, levels of tumah, shechitah, wine and a stained shirt, and with Rabbah bar bar Chanah, for whom acting beyond the letter of the law was the din. He applies it to Shabbos, to pride in avodah, and to the days of Adar.

Topics: Gilgulim and Tikkun HaNeshamos · Levels and Root of the Soul · Mishpatim

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 The Ba'al Shem Tov and the lost wallet Story

    The Mashgiach tells how the Ba'al Shem Tov had his talmidim watch silently as an innocent man was beaten over a lost wallet, and then revealed that this settled a wrong din Torah from an earlier gilgul.

  2. 6:05 How can a beis din rule falsely? listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach asks how a beis din, where the Shechinah stands with the dayanim, can rule against a man who knows he is right, and answers from the Zohar on 've'eleh hamishpatim' that it repays an earlier gilgul: 'mishpetei Hashem emes tzadku yachdav'.

  3. 10:09 The mashal of the gabbai and the aliyos listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings a mashal of a guest who complains that the gabbai gives aliyos without order, until the gabbai explains that he reckons many Shabbosim together, and applies it to a person who sees only his own seventy or eighty years.

  4. 13:30 The puzzle of 'as if' in Chazal listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach raises the many places where Chazal and the Zohar speak of 'as if' or 'liable to death', such as walking four amos without netilas yadayim, and asks why such things are not treated that way in practice.

  5. 17:35 Levels of souls, levels of Torah listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach answers that souls come from Asiyah, Yetzirah, Briah and Atzilus, matching pshat, remez, drush and sod; the Shulchan Aruch is for every Jew, but from a refined Jew who works on himself more is demanded, and for him the Zohar's words apply.

  6. 21:17 The higher, the more sensitive listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach shows the principle in halachah: a kohen and a kohen gadol in marriage, bread of chullin, terumah and kodesh in tumah, a potato, a bird and an animal in shechitah, and wine; then a mashal of an inked potato sack against a chassan's fine shirt with a tiny stain.

  7. 27:44 Rabbah bar bar Chanah and the porters Story listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach tells the Gemara of porters who broke Rabbah bar bar Chanah's barrel of wine, and Rav who told him to forgo and even pay them, saying this is the din; he explains that for a man of his stature, going beyond the letter of the law is the din.

  8. 31:35 A shirt, not a potato: Shabbos and avodah listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach applies the principle: a refined Jew is a shirt, not a potato, so his Shabbos must differ from that of one who waits for three stars to buy pizza, as 'beini u'vein bnei Yisrael' shows. He reads the end of Yisro, 'lo sa'aleh vema'alos al mizbechi', as a warning against pride in avodah, and links it to 've'eleh hamishpatim': for such a Jew, chassidus becomes din.

  9. 37:20 The days of Adar and Shabbos Mevorchim

    The Mashgiach describes the world boiling like a lit firecracker before Moshiach, notes that Hashem prepares the cure before the blow as with Esther, brings the Gemara that a Jew's mazal is strong in Adar, and urges making Shabbos Mevorchim a whole Shabbos, closing with a brachah.

The shiur, written up

The Ba'al Shem Tov and the lost wallet

1:04

The Mashgiach opens with a story of the Ba'al Shem Tov, who told his talmidim to hide on a hill, watch what happens, and say nothing. A man lay down to sleep in a field and his wallet fell out; another man came, found it and took it. Then a third man lay down in the same place, and the owner came back, accused him and beat him. The talmidim wanted to cry out that he was innocent, but they had been told to keep silent.

4:15

Afterwards the Ba'al Shem Tov explained that in an earlier gilgul these men had a din Torah before a dayan who did not look into it enough and ruled wrongly. Now the one who had lost found exactly that sum, and the dayan received the blows.

How can a beis din rule falsely?

6:08

From here the Mashgiach asks: sometimes a lender has no witnesses, the beis din rules by Choshen Mishpat, and the one who knows he is right loses his money. How can this be, when from 've'eleh hamishpatim asher tasim lifneihem' it is learned that the Shechinah stands with dayanim who judge l'shem Shamayim, as Rashi brings? a,b

8:49

He answers that in an earlier gilgul this man took the money unjustly and now must return it. This, he says, is the Zohar's meaning of 've'eleh hamishpatim': they are the secret of gilgul. 'Mishpetei Hashem emes tzadku yachdav': only when everything is taken together is it seen to be just. d,c

The mashal of the gabbai

10:17

The Mashgiach brings a mashal on this passuk. A guest in shul sees the gabbai give aliyos seemingly without order and complains. The gabbai explains that he reckons many Shabbosim together: whoever missed an aliyah before receives it now. c

12:35

So too, a person comes to the world for seventy or eighty years and thinks he understands everything. Looking at earlier gilgulim, one would see why one suffers and another prospers, and that all is just.

The puzzle of 'as if'

13:34

The Mashgiach turns to a matter found often in the Gemara and the sefarim: things said to be 'as if' something grave. The sefarim bring from the Zohar that one who walks four amos in the morning without netilas yadayim is liable to death, and the Gemara has many such statements. Yet they are not treated this way in halachah, and the Mashgiach asks why. e,f

Levels of souls, levels of Torah

17:45

He answers that souls come from Asiyah, Yetzirah, Briah and Atzilus, and the higher the soul, the more is demanded of it. Corresponding to these are pshat, remez, drush and sod. A simple Jew needs the pshat of the Gemara and the Shulchan Aruch, which is for every Jew; a finer one must act by remez, and the greatest by sod.

20:14

For refined Jews who work on themselves, pshat is not enough. The Zohar's words speak of such a Jew: for him, walking without netilas yadayim is truly liable. e

The higher, the more sensitive

21:17

The Mashgiach shows this throughout halachah. A simple Jew may marry a divorcee or a widow; a kohen may not marry a divorcee, and a kohen gadol not even a widow. Bread of chullin is not made tamei by a sheni; terumah is, and kodesh even by a shlishi.

23:30

A potato needs no knife at all, a bird needs one siman, and an animal two. Wine, the most refined drink, is used for kiddush and every brachah, and the touch of a goy already makes it nesech.

26:06

He adds a mashal: a farmer who finds an ink spot on a potato sack gets no refund, but a chassan whose fine shirt has a tiny ink stain returns it at once. The more precious something is, the more it is affected.

Rabbah bar bar Chanah and the porters

27:50

The Mashgiach brings the Gemara: porters broke Rabbah bar bar Chanah's barrel of wine, and he brought them to Rav to pay. Rav told him to forgo, 'lema'an telech bederech tovim'. When they pleaded that they were poor and had worked all day, Rav told him to pay their wages too, and said this is the din. g,h

30:51

The Mashgiach explains: for a simple Jew the din is to pay for the barrel. For Rabbah bar bar Chanah, who stood higher, acting beyond the letter of the law was itself the din.

A shirt, not a potato

31:35

The Mashgiach applies this: refined Jews must hold themselves to more, and some chassidishe ways are binding on them. Such a Jew is a shirt, not a potato; a stain on him is a stain.

32:45

So with Shabbos: one man keeps Shabbos, watches for three stars and runs to buy pizza. A higher Jew's Shabbos must be different, as 'beini u'vein bnei Yisrael os hi' shows that Shabbos is a sign of a higher bond. i

35:37

He reads the end of Yisro, 'lo sa'aleh vema'alos al mizbechi', as a warning against pride: the siddur and the Gemara are a mizbeach, and one who davened well should not go about proud. This is a level of chassidus, but next to 've'eleh hamishpatim' it becomes din for one who has reached it. j

The days of Adar

37:20

The Mashgiach says these are great days. The world is boiling, like someone sitting on a firecracker whose wick is lit, yet one need not be frightened. Hashem prepares the cure before the blow, as Esther became queen before Haman's decree.

39:17

He brings the Gemara that a Jew's mazal is strong in Adar, and urges taking hold of the Shabbosim and the month, making Shabbos Mevorchim a whole Shabbos, not half. He closes with a brachah. k

Sources

Torah

  1. a Shemos 21:1 text index In the write-up: 6:08
  2. i Shemos 31:16-17 text index In the write-up: 32:45
  3. j Shemos 20:23 text index In the write-up: 35:37

Kesuvim

  1. c Tehillim 19:10 text index In the write-up: 8:49, 10:17
  2. h apparently Mishlei 2:20 index In the write-up: 27:50

Talmud Bavli

  1. f Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 13:34
  2. g Bava Metzia 83a text index In the write-up: 27:50
  3. k apparently Taanis 29b index In the write-up: 39:17

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. d apparently Zohar, Parshas Mishpatim index In the write-up: 8:49
  2. e Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 13:34, 20:14

Rishonim

  1. b Rashi (place not identified) index In the write-up: 6:08

Key points

  1. 7:05 When a Jewish beis din rules against the truth, the Mashgiach explains, it is settling an account from an earlier gilgul.
  2. 9:48 'Mishpetei Hashem emes tzadku yachdav': Hashem's judgments are seen to be just only when all generations are taken together.
  3. 17:41 Souls are of different levels, Asiyah, Yetzirah, Briah and Atzilus, and the higher the soul, the more is demanded of it.
  4. 21:31 The more refined and precious something is, the more sensitive it becomes, as seen in the kohen, in levels of tumah, in shechitah and in wine.
  5. 31:09 For a great person like Rabbah bar bar Chanah, acting beyond the letter of the law is itself the din.
  6. 31:35 A Jew who works on himself must keep Shabbos and his avodah on a higher plane, and guard against pride when he davens well.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 7:05 How can a beis din, where the Shechinah stands with the dayanim, rule against a man who knows he is right?

    Answer: 8:07 In an earlier gilgul he took that money unjustly, and now he must return it.

  2. Question: 15:45 Why does the Zohar call walking four amos without netilas yadayim a sin liable to death, when the Shulchan Aruch, written for all Jews, does not?

    Answer: 17:41 Souls differ in level; the Zohar speaks of a refined Jew from whom more is demanded.

  3. Question: 30:30 How could Rav call paying the porters 'the din', when the porters were liable?

    Answer: 30:51 For a simple Jew the din is that they pay, but for one on Rabbah bar bar Chanah's level, beyond the letter of the law is the din.

Stories

  1. 1:04 The Ba'al Shem Tov and the lost wallet

    The Ba'al Shem Tov told his talmidim to hide on a hill, watch what happens, and say nothing. A man lay down in a field, his wallet fell out as he slept, and another man came, found it and took it. Then a third man came and lay down there; the owner returned, accused him and beat him, while the talmidim wanted to cry out that he was innocent. The Ba'al Shem Tov then explained that in an earlier gilgul these men had a din Torah before a dayan who did not look into it enough and ruled wrongly; now the one who had lost found exactly that sum, and the dayan received the blows.

    In the story: the Baal Shem Tov, the Maggid of Mezritch

    told in 2 other shiurim →

  2. 27:50 Rabbah bar bar Chanah and the porters

    Porters carrying a barrel of wine for Rabbah bar bar Chanah stumbled and broke it, and all the wine spilled. He brought them to Rav to make them pay, but Rav told him to forgo, citing 'lema'an telech bederech tovim'. The workers then said they were poor, had worked all day and needed bread for their families, and Rav told him to pay them too. When he asked whether that is the din, Rav answered that it is.

    In the story: Rabbah bar bar Chanah, Rav (the Amora)

    told in 4 other shiurim →

Insights

  1. 8:36 A ruling that seems false is not a failure of the Shechinah's presence in the beis din: it is how an account from an earlier gilgul is repaid.
  2. 9:55 The Mashgiach reads 'tzadku yachdav' as 'just when taken together': across many lifetimes, as a gabbai balances aliyos over many Shabbosim.
  3. 18:06 The severe 'as if' and 'liable to death' of Chazal and the Zohar are the din for a higher soul, while the Shulchan Aruch speaks to every Jew.
  4. 30:30 When Rav told Rabbah bar bar Chanah 'this is the din', he meant that for him, beyond the letter of the law is the law itself.
  5. 36:32 The juxtaposition of the end of Yisro with 've'eleh hamishpatim' teaches that what is a level of chassidus for others becomes din for one who has reached it.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 32:45 The Mashgiach says a Jew who works on himself must make his Shabbos different and higher than the Shabbos of one who only waits for it to end.
  2. 35:37 The Mashgiach says one who davened well should not go about proud of it, for the siddur and the Gemara are a mizbeach.
  3. 40:05 The Mashgiach urges taking hold of the Shabbosim and the month of Adar, and making Shabbos Mevorchim a whole Shabbos, not half a Shabbos.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Rabbah bar bar Chanah, Rav (the Amora), the Baal Shem Tov

Terms גאוה, גלגול, יין נסך, לפנים משורת הדין, מזבח, נטילת ידים, פרד"ס, שבת מברכים, שכינה

Report an error on this page