ביאור נפלא על מעשה זמרי וקנאת פנחס
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע פנחס no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 12 תשל"ג (1972–73) Yiddish 53 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that Zimri meant to bring the nations under the wings of the Shechinah but erred, while Pinchas was zealous for the indestructible point of Jewishness, the 'small yud', which is also the Kosel Maaravi that was never destroyed.
The Mashgiach opens with a difficulty: Zimri was a prince of his tribe and a tzaddik, and Chazal say the angels sided with him against Pinchas. Drawing on the Megaleh Amukos, that Rabbi Akiva was Zimri's reincarnation and the wife of Turnus Rufus was Cozbi, and on the Arizal's explanation of Shlomo HaMelech's marriages to daughters of kings, he explains that Zimri wanted to bring the nations under the Shechinah. His flaw was a conversion not yet complete, and doing it before all of Israel, where the public would misunderstand. Pinchas was zealous for the point of Jewishness that can never be blemished but can be cut off through intermarriage, and was rewarded measure for measure. That point is the small yud of Pinchas and, in place, the Kosel Maaravi. Some truths, as Rav Ketina and Rabbi Yaakov Emden show, must be withheld from the public. He closes with the comfort of the Three Weeks.
Topics: Balak, Bilam and Pinchas · The Pintele Yid: The Inner Point of Every Jew
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Zimri's greatness and the angels' stand listed in the guide
The Mashgiach describes Zimri as the prince of the tribe of Shimon, appointed by Hashem and much older than Moshe and Aharon, and brings Chazal that the angels wanted to push Pinchas away. He asks what really happened there.
-
3:56 Rabbi Akiva, Turnus Rufus's wife and Shlomo HaMelech listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that Rabbi Akiva married the wife of Turnus Rufus, and the Megaleh Amukos that he was Zimri's reincarnation and she was Cozbi. He then brings the Arizal that Shlomo HaMelech married daughters of kings to bring the whole world to Hashem, and the Midrash that on the day he married Pharaoh's daughter the land of Rome began to form.
-
9:34 Pinchas's rewards and the point that cannot be soiled listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Targum Yonasan that Pinchas became an angel who lives forever and will herald the redemption as Eliyahu, and the promise of eternal kehunah, and asks why his zealotry earned these. He explains that every Jew has a point of G-dliness that no sin can soil, citing the Shir HaYichud and the Midrash that Israel is like a nut.
-
15:25 Where the seed of Israel can be lost listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that one place the seed of Avraham can be cut off is a union with a gentile woman, since no Jewish soul joins that body. He connects this to the end of the zuhama at Sinai, and explains that Pinchas, who guarded the Jewish body from foreign seed, was rewarded measure for measure with eternal life in the body and with entry into the Holy of Holies.
-
20:25 Zimri's holy intention listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Zimri's intention was the same as Shlomo HaMelech's: to convert a king's daughter of Midian and through her bring the whole nation under the wings of the Shechinah. He reads 'vayakrev el echav' as bringing her to his brothers, and explains that this is why the angels sided with Zimri.
-
23:56 The hair of idolatry and the tikkun through Rabbi Akiva listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains Zimri's flaw: in his eagerness he did not see that Cozbi's conversion was complete, and the hair of her forelock showed idolatry still on her. Because he meant it for Heaven, he was reincarnated as Rabbi Akiva, himself a son of converts, and repaired it when the wife of Turnus Rufus converted properly.
-
27:54 The small yud and 'before all the congregation' listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Pinchas saw the time had not come and was zealous for the point of Jewishness, which the small yud in his name represents. He then points to a second flaw from the passuk: Zimri acted 'before the eyes of all the congregation', where the masses would not understand his intention and others would copy him with base intentions.
-
32:57 The Kosel Maaravi as the point of Eretz Yisrael listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Eretz Yisrael has a soul and a point no defilement can touch: the Even Shesiyah, which extends to the Kosel Maaravi, just as Avraham Avinu is the foundation stone of Israel. He brings the Midrash that Hashem did not let Titus destroy the Kosel, and notes that the masses cannot always be told such things.
-
37:20 Rav Ketina and the necromancer Story
The Mashgiach tells the Gemara in Berachos: a necromancer explained an earthquake as Hashem's tears over the Beis HaMikdash, and Rav Ketina called him a liar. The Gemara says the necromancer was right, but Rav Ketina spoke so that people would not be drawn after him, and the Mashgiach learns that one must sometimes say such people are wrong.
-
40:42 Rabbi Yaakov Emden, the Zohar and the Shabbatean sect
The Mashgiach explains why Rabbi Yaakov Emden, fighting the sect of Shabsai Tzvi which built on Kabbalah, cast doubt on the Zohar's authenticity although all of Israel and the poskim accepted it and he himself cites it. He brings the Yam Shel Shlomo on giving one's life rather than deny even one halacha, and explains that to save Klal Yisrael one may have to deny a truth.
-
46:21 Nadav and Avihu, fire from heaven and the comfort listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Yismach Moshe that the Beis HaMikdash was built for the sake of what remains after its destruction, the Kosel Maaravi, and the Zohar that the souls of Nadav and Avihu entered Pinchas. Their strange fire tried to hasten what must come as fire from heaven, and Pinchas repaired it. He closes that in the Three Weeks, the parsha of Eliyahu gives comfort: the Kosel and the point in every Jewish heart are never destroyed, and there one can pour out one's heart.
The shiur, written up
Zimri's greatness and the angels' stand
The Mashgiach begins by stressing who Zimri was: the prince of the tribe of Shimon, appointed by Hashem, one of the seventy souls who went down to Egypt, far older than Moshe and Aharon, a tzaddik respected by all. Yet Chazal say that when Pinchas went to act, the angels wanted to push him away, and only Hashem stood by Pinchas. So the Mashgiach asks what really happened there. a
Rabbi Akiva, Turnus Rufus's wife and Shlomo HaMelech
To answer, he brings the Gemara in Avodah Zarah that Rabbi Akiva foresaw that the wife of Turnus Rufus, the Roman ruler over Eretz Yisrael, would convert, and later married her. The Megaleh Amukos adds that Rabbi Akiva was Zimri's reincarnation and she was Cozbi, whom Zimri, as the Midrash says, brought by her forelock to Moshe's beis din. b,c,d
Pinchas's rewards and the point that cannot be soiled
Pinchas received two rewards. The Targum Yonasan explains the 'covenant of peace' as making him an angel who lives forever and will herald the redemption as Eliyahu, and the next passuk gives his descendants the kehunah gedolah. The Mashgiach asks why his zealotry earned exactly these. g,h,i
He explains that a Jew's free choice is limited: sins can damage his whole being, but there is a point, the pintele yid, where he cannot be a rasha. The Shir HaYichud says no filth can soil Hashem, and the soul is part of Him. The Midrash compares Israel to a nut: fallen into filth, it is washed and the fruit inside is clean. j,k
Where the seed of Israel can be lost
Yet the seed of Avraham can be cut off: a Jew's child from a gentile woman is a gentile, because no Jewish soul joins that body. At Sinai the zuhama of the serpent ceased; Pinchas was zealous that Jewish seed not mix with it again. Measure for measure, his own body was purified, so he lives in the body like an angel and may enter the Holy of Holies. l
Zimri's holy intention
The hair of idolatry and the tikkun
His flaw was eagerness: he did not ensure a complete conversion. A convert must first separate from idolatry, as the passuk of mourning her father and mother shows, and Cozbi's forelock was a remnant of idolatry; that one hair is the difference between Jew and gentile. Because he meant it for Heaven, he returned as Rabbi Akiva, a son of converts, and the wife of Turnus Rufus converted properly. p
The small yud and 'before all the congregation'
The Kosel Maaravi as the point of Eretz Yisrael
The same point exists in place. Eretz Yisrael has a soul, and its point is the Even Shesiyah, from which the world was founded, as Avraham is the foundation of Israel; it extends to the Kosel Maaravi. The Midrash says Hashem made Titus's general leave the Kosel standing, so it was never destroyed and the Shechinah never leaves it. He adds that the masses cannot be told everything. q
Rav Ketina and the necromancer
The Gemara in Berachos, on the Mishnah of earthquakes, tells that a necromancer told Rav Ketina the rumbling was Hashem's tears over the Beis HaMikdash falling into the sea. Rav Ketina called him a liar. The Gemara says he was right, but Rav Ketina spoke so people would not be drawn after him; sometimes one must call such people wrong. r,s
Rabbi Yaakov Emden and the Zohar
Nadav and Avihu, fire from heaven and the comfort
The Yismach Moshe writes that the whole Beis HaMikdash was built for what remains after the destruction, the Kosel Maaravi, where the Shechinah rests, the point of Klal Yisrael. Such knowledge, the Mashgiach says, must not be spread, since it can be misused. v
The Zohar says the souls of Nadav and Avihu entered Pinchas. Every soul seeks its tikkun where it erred: they brought strange fire instead of waiting for fire from heaven, and Pinchas stopped Zimri's attempt to hasten the redemption. As Rashi on Sukkah says, the Beis HaMikdash will descend in fire. w,x
He closes that this parsha of Eliyahu, read in the Three Weeks, brings comfort: the Kosel and the point in every Jewish heart are never destroyed, and one can reach them now and pour out one's heart there that the whole Beis HaMikdash be rebuilt.
Sources
Torah
- f apparently Bamidbar 9:15 9:12 index
- h Bamidbar 25:12 text index In the write-up: 9:57
- i Bamidbar 25:13 text index In the write-up: 9:57
- n Bamidbar 25:6 text index In the write-up: 21:08, 30:30
- o apparently Bamidbar 25:11 index In the write-up: 28:01
- p Devarim 21:13 text index In the write-up: 24:16
Kesuvim
Targum
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 21:08 Zimri was a great man and his act was meant for the sake of Heaven: like Shlomo HaMelech, he wanted to bring the nations under the wings of the Shechinah through a king's daughter.
- 24:27 Zimri's flaw was that Cozbi's conversion was not yet complete, a single hair of idolatry still on her, and that hair is the whole difference between a Jew and a gentile.
- 12:40 Every Jew has a point of G-dliness that no sin can blemish, but through a union with a gentile woman the seed of Israel can be cut off from its root, and for that point Pinchas was zealous.
- 18:59 Pinchas's rewards, living forever in his body and the kehunah gedolah, came measure for measure for guarding the Jewish body from mixing with foreign seed.
- 32:23 Some things, even when true and proper in themselves, may not be done or said before the masses, since others will misunderstand and be drawn after them.
- 35:15 The Kosel Maaravi is in place what the point of Jewishness is in the soul: it was never destroyed and the Shechinah never leaves it.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 3:22 Zimri was a prince and a tzaddik, and the angels sided with him; what really happened?
Answer: 21:08 He meant to bring the nations under the Shechinah through a king's daughter, as Shlomo HaMelech did, but the conversion was not complete and he did it before all of Israel.
-
Question: 11:17 Why did Pinchas's zealotry earn him eternal life and the kehunah gedolah?
Answer: 18:59 Measure for measure: he guarded the Jewish body from being cut off through foreign seed, so his body was purified, lives forever and may enter the Holy of Holies.
-
Question: 39:10 How could Rav Ketina call the necromancer a liar if he was right?
Answer: 39:23 So that people would not be drawn after him; sometimes one must say such people are wrong even where they are right.
-
Question: 43:34 How could Rabbi Yaakov Emden doubt the Zohar, which all of Israel and the poskim accepted?
Answer: 45:24 To separate Klal Yisrael from the Shabbatean sect, which built on the Zohar; for the good of the community one may have to deny even a truth.
-
Question: 49:07 Why did the souls of Nadav and Avihu enter Pinchas?
Answer: 49:10 Every soul seeks its tikkun in the very thing it damaged: they brought strange fire instead of waiting for fire from heaven, and Pinchas stopped an attempt to hasten what must come from heaven.
Stories
-
37:35 Rav Ketina and the necromancer
Rav Ketina passed by a necromancer when the earth shook with a loud noise, and asked him the reason. The necromancer said that when Hashem remembers the destroyed Beis HaMikdash He lets two tears fall into the sea, and that is the noise. Rav Ketina called him a liar. The Gemara concludes that the necromancer was right, and Rav Ketina said it so that people would not be drawn after him.
In the story: Rav Ketina
-
40:42 Rabbi Yaakov Emden's stand on the Zohar
In Rabbi Yaakov Emden's time there was a great war against the sect of Shabsai Tzvi, which built itself on Kabbalah, and the leaders feared people would again be drawn after it through mystical matters. Rabbi Yaakov Emden wrote that he was not sure the whole Zohar was authentic. The Mashgiach notes that he himself cites the Zohar, and explains that he did so to cut Klal Yisrael off from the sect.
In the story: Rabbi Yaakov Emden (the Yaavetz), Shabsai Tzvi
Insights
- 20:39 The Mashgiach reads Zimri's act through the Arizal on Shlomo HaMelech: taking a king's daughter was an attempt to draw her whole nation under the Shechinah, which is why the angels, awaiting the end of days, sided with Zimri.
- 26:27 Zimri's error is repaired in reverse in Rabbi Akiva: Zimri risked turning Jewish seed into gentile seed, and Rabbi Akiva came into the world from converts, gentile seed that became Jewish, and married the wife of Turnus Rufus after a proper conversion.
- 18:27 Pinchas's reward fits his act exactly: because he guarded the Jewish body from mixing with the seed of the serpent, his own body was purified as at Sinai, so he lives on in the body and may enter the Holy of Holies.
- 29:06 The small yud in Pinchas's name stands for the smallest point of Jewishness, which even the lowest Jew carries and which will one day flare into a great flame.
- 34:05 The Kosel Maaravi corresponds to the point of Avraham Avinu in every Jew: the Even Shesiyah extends to it, so in a time of destruction it is the place one can still reach, as the point in the heart is.
- 48:40 Nadav and Avihu's strange fire was an attempt to hasten what must come as fire from heaven; their souls entered Pinchas so that he would repair it, and like Eliyahu he must wait for the Beis HaMikdash to descend in fire.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 32:23 The Mashgiach says that some things, even proper in themselves, may not be done or revealed before the masses, who will not understand and may be led astray.
- 52:58 The Mashgiach says that even in a time of destruction, in the Three Weeks, one should reach the point in the heart, like the Kosel Maaravi, and pour out one's heart there that the whole Beis HaMikdash be rebuilt.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Aharon HaKohen, Avihu, Avraham Avinu, Eliyahu HaNavi, Kozbi bas Tzur, Nadav, Pinchas, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Yaakov Emden (the Yaavetz), Rav Ketina, Shabsai Tzvi, Shlomo HaMelech, the Arizal, Titus, Turnus Rufus, Zimri ben Salu
Terms אבן שתיה, אש זרה, בין המצרים, גלגול, זוהמא, כותל המערבי, תחת כנפי השכינה