הנצחיות של המנורה ושל התורה ושל משה רבינו. (שייכות לפורים קטן)
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע תצוה no. 2 Pocket Guide p. 10 תשל"ו (1975–76) Yiddish 1 hr 21 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that the menorah, as Torah, belongs to no place or time and burns even in galus, that Moshe Rabbeinu's soul is the hidden light that returns in every generation, and that Purim Katan teaches a Jew to see Hashem even in hiddenness.
The Mashgiach opens with the repetition of the menorah parsha in Tetzaveh and in Emor and asks several questions on the wording. Building on the Chasam Sofer, he explains that the menorah is both a part of the whole Mishkan and a mitzvah of its own; as such it stands for Torah, above all the oral Torah, which unlike avodah does not depend on the Mikdash and burns even at night, in galus. The ner maaravi, the pure menorah and the 'kasis' allusion to the destroyed Batei Mikdash all show that Torah is eternal. Moshe's name is absent from Tetzaveh not as a punishment but because his soul is the hidden light, preserved and returning in every generation, as Mordechai, who fights Amalek. The Mashgiach then ties Moshe's wish to intercalate the year to the flaw of the moon, Knesses Yisrael, and explains Purim Katan and why the Jews did not accept Purim as a yom tov.
Topics: Moshe Rabbeinu · The Mishkan and the Kohanim · The Power and Greatness of Torah · Purim Katan and the Leap Year
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Questions on the repeated menorah parsha listed in the guide
The Mashgiach notes that the opening of Tetzaveh on the menorah is repeated in Emor and brings Rashi that Tetzaveh speaks of the building of the Mishkan and Emor of the order of lighting. He asks why it is repeated, why its place is given negatively as 'outside the paroches', why the order of the words is reversed, and why the Baal HaTurim's allusion in 'kasis' to the years of the two Batei Mikdash uses a word of crushing.
-
6:52 The menorah as a mitzvah of its own listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why the extra words 'the pure menorah', explained in Menachos as coming from a place of purity, appear only in Emor, and suggests that the menorah had to be made first, before the Mishkan. He brings the Chasam Sofer's Chanukah drashos: the menorah is both a part of the whole building and a separate mitzvah, so the Chashmona'im lit it in the courtyard before the Mikdash was fit, and the miracle was publicized.
-
14:20 Torah does not depend on the Mikdash listed in the guide
On this basis the Mashgiach explains the two parshiyos: Tetzaveh speaks of the menorah as part of the building, Emor of its own mitzvah. He contrasts Torah and avodah in Sefer Shemos: avodah is bound to the Mikdash, while Torah is eternal and even flourished after the churban; the luchos and the menorah allude to the written and the oral Torah, and Torah is the soul of Moshe, who is netzach.
-
20:45 The menorah, the oral Torah and the ner maaravi listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the menorah's ornaments are chiddushei Torah, the pilpul given to Moshe, so the menorah has an identity not bound to place and time, and 'outside the paroches' says it belongs even outside. He brings the Gemara that the ner maaravi is testimony that the Shechinah rests in Israel, alluding that Torah burns even after the churban, and notes that avodah was invalid at night.
-
26:33 A light in the night of galus listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the menorah burned through the night, alluding to the chiddushei Torah created in galus, and that after the egel it was commanded at once. The ner maaravi's miracle comes from the hidden light, which is Moshe's soul; Emor adds 'the pure menorah' because Torah does not receive tumah even in galus, 'kasis' hints that the light remains though the Batei Mikdash were destroyed, and the ner maaravi is like the Kosel Maaravi, a place never destroyed.
-
34:05 Why Moshe's name is hidden in Tetzaveh listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Baal HaTurim that Moshe's name is absent from Tetzaveh because he said 'erase me from Your book', and argues that it is rather his honor: Moshe's soul is the hidden light, and hiding something means preserving it, a reward for his readiness to be lost for Israel. He adds that in every generation a tzaddik carries Moshe's soul, sometimes hidden, and one can connect to him even without knowing who he is.
-
40:35 Mordechai, Amalek and the month of Adar listed in the guide
The Mashgiach notes that Tetzaveh falls before Purim and brings the Midrash comparing Mordechai to Moshe: Moshe returns in each generation under other names. Amalek, who wants to erase Israel, is Moshe's opposite, and Moshe, who offered to be erased for Israel, is present in every war with Amalek. He brings the Bnei Yissaschar on the angel appointed over Adar and its blessing, the month in which Moshe blessed Israel before his passing.
-
47:25 Blessing without conditions; Moshe in every generation listed in the guide
From the Baal HaTurim, that a sage's curse comes true even on a condition, the Mashgiach derives that a sage's blessing comes even without one, so in Adar Jews are blessed without being judged, and on Purim the hidden light within every Jew shows beneath the masks. He brings that Moshe's soul was earlier Noach and Shes, hinted in the last word of Terumah and the first of Tetzaveh, and that before one tzaddik's sun sets another's rises.
-
52:48 How to recognize the true leader listed in the guide
On 'an eternal statute for your generations' in Emor, the Mashgiach says that every generation has its Moshe, but there are also impostors, leaders of the erev rav who dress in Moshe's garb. The sign, from 'go out in the footsteps of the sheep', is that the true leader guides Israel in the ways of the earlier tzaddikim and does not bend with the times.
-
56:21 Moshe's prayer and the flaw of the moon listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Megaleh Amukos, one of whose explanations of Moshe's plea to enter Eretz Yisrael is that he wanted to intercalate the year. He explains the kiddush levana prayer to fill the moon's flaw: the moon is Knesses Yisrael, which receives from the sun; it was diminished because of future sins and falls further behind the sun each year, so the end of the year in Adar is a time of hester panim, the time of Esther.
-
1:01:59 David and the completion of the moon listed in the guide
At kiddush levana one asks that the moon become whole; the Mashgiach explains that David is the aspect of the moon, as in 'and David their king' and 'until David grew great'. Moshe wanted to intercalate the year, which means equalizing the lunar year with the solar year, so that Knesses Yisrael would be equal to the sun and the small light would become great.
-
1:05:26 Purim Katan: comforting the moon, seeing Hashem's name listed in the guide
In a leap year the first Adar brings a double hiddenness and disappointment, and Jews comfort the moon with a seudah on Purim Katan; the Mashgiach brings the Rema on this and 'a good heart is a constant feast', tied to 'I place Hashem before me constantly'. Just as Hashem's name does not appear in the Megillah yet a brachah is made on it, a Jew must see Hashem's name in history, in the news and in everything that happens to him.
-
1:12:10 Why the Jews did not accept Purim as a yom tov listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that Esther wanted Purim to be a yom tov but the Jews did not accept it, and asks why. He explains that a yom tov, like Shabbos, is a day on which nothing is lacking and there are no poor, while matanos l'evyonim awaken the sun to give to the moon; the Jews wanted a day that draws blessing even in galus and hiddenness, and this is the true meaning of Purim Katan.
The shiur, written up
Questions on the repeated menorah parsha
The Mashgiach opens with a repetition: the oil and lighting of the menorah at the start of Tetzaveh appear again, almost word for word, in parshas Emor. Rashi explains that Tetzaveh speaks of the order of building the Mishkan and Emor of the order of lighting. Yet no other part of the Mishkan is repeated, so why this one? a
He adds further questions. The Torah places the menorah 'outside the paroches' (Shemos 27:21), saying where it is not rather than where it is, and in Emor the order of these words is reversed (Vayikra 24:3). And the Baal HaTurim and Rabbeinu Bachya read 'kasis', crushed, as an allusion to the years the two Batei Mikdash stood. Why allude to them with a word of destruction? b,c,d,e
The menorah as a mitzvah of its own
Emor adds the words 'the pure menorah' (Vayikra 24:4), which the Gemara in Menachos explains as a menorah whose making came down from a place of purity, since Moshe was shown it from Heaven. Why is this said only in Emor? The Mashgiach suggests that the mitzvah was to make the menorah first, even simply, before the long work of the Mishkan. g,h
He then brings the Chasam Sofer's Chanukah drashos, which ask how the Chashmona'im could light the menorah in the courtyard when it must stand in its place in the Heichal. Building on the Rambam, who allows the lamps to be prepared outside, the answer is that the menorah has two aspects: it is part of the whole building, without which the Mikdash is incomplete, and it is a mitzvah of its own. So while the Mikdash was being restored they lit it outside, and all the Jews saw the miracle. i,j
Torah does not depend on the Mikdash
This explains the two parshiyos. Tetzaveh treats the menorah as part of the building, so its place comes first; Emor treats the lighting as a mitzvah of its own, so its place is secondary and is mentioned later.
Why must the menorah not wait for the building? The Mashgiach explains that Sefer Shemos speaks first of Torah and then of avodah. Avodah exists only in the Mikdash, but Torah is eternal and, as the Midrash says, flourished even more after the churban, from Rabbi Akiva on. In the Mikdash two things are Torah: the luchos, the written Torah, and the menorah, the oral Torah. Torah is the soul of Moshe, who is netzach, and every talmid chacham who learns lishmah has a share in it. k
The menorah, the oral Torah and the ner maaravi
The menorah, the Mashgiach says, is Moshe Rabbeinu: its knobs and flowers are chiddushei Torah, the pilpul which Chazal say was given to Moshe and passed on by him to Israel. So the menorah has an identity of its own, bound to no place or time, and 'outside the paroches' is not negative: it says the menorah belongs even outside. l,b
A light in the night of galus
Yet the menorah burned through the night, because its light is meant for darkness: the Jews created their chiddushei Torah mainly in galus. So after the egel, when darkness came down, the menorah was commanded at once, before the building was complete.
The ner maaravi's miracle comes from the hidden light, which is Moshe's soul; when he was born, the Gemara in Sotah says, the house filled with light. Emor adds 'the pure menorah' because, as the Gemara in Berachos says, words of Torah do not receive tumah, like fire, so even in galus Torah stays pure. And the Baal HaTurim's 'kasis' says that though both Batei Mikdash were crushed, the light remains forever. r,g,n,d
The ner maaravi is like the Kosel Maaravi: where the sun of Israel sets, there remains a place that is never destroyed and a light that never goes out.
Why Moshe's name is hidden in Tetzaveh
The Baal HaTurim, following the Zohar, says Moshe's name is absent from Tetzaveh because he said 'erase me from Your book' (Shemos 32:32). The Mashgiach finds this hard: a good deed, giving himself for Israel, cannot bring about something bad. o,p,q
Rather, it is his honor. Moshe's soul is the hidden light, which the Ba'al Shem Tov says was hidden in the Torah, and Tetzaveh opens with the menorah, the parsha of that light. One hides what one wants to keep; since Moshe was ready to be lost for Israel, he was rewarded by being hidden and preserved.
As the Arizal writes, in every generation there is a tzaddik with Moshe's soul, sometimes hidden, and one can connect to him even without knowing who he is.
Mordechai, Amalek and the month of Adar
Tetzaveh comes before Purim, and the Midrash on 'a Jewish man in Shushan' teaches that Mordechai was like Moshe. Moshe, the Mashgiach says, returns in every generation under another name, sometimes Moshe, sometimes Mordechai, according to the generation. t
Blessing without conditions; Moshe in every generation
How to recognize the true leader
On 'an eternal statute for your generations' (Vayikra 24:3), the Mashgiach says every generation has its Moshe, but also Hamans who dress as Moshe, leaders of the erev rav. The sign, from 'follow the footsteps of the sheep' (Shir HaShirim 1:8), is a leader who follows the earlier tzaddikim and does not say that today is different. c,aa
Moshe's prayer and the flaw of the moon
When Moshe pleaded 'let me cross over' (Devarim 3:25), one of the Megaleh Amukos's explanations is that he wished to intercalate the year, which is done only in Eretz Yisrael. ab,ac
The Mashgiach explains the kiddush levana prayer to fill the moon's flaw. The moon is Knesses Yisrael, which receives from the sun; it was diminished at creation because of sins that would come later, and the lunar year falls eleven days behind the sun. By Adar the distance is greatest: hester panim, the time of Esther, until the Megillah reveals what was hidden. ad
David and the completion of the moon
At kiddush levana one asks that the moon become whole and mentions David, who is the aspect of the moon, as in 'until David grew great' (Shmuel I 20:41). Moshe's wish to intercalate the year meant equalizing the lunar year with the solar year, so that Knesses Yisrael would be equal to the sun. ad,af
Purim Katan: comforting the moon, seeing Hashem's name
In a leap year the first Adar arrives and the hoped-for Purim does not come: a double hiding. Still, Jews comfort the moon with a meal on Purim Katan. The Mashgiach brings the Rema: though one does not hold a full feast, one adds somewhat to the meal, since 'a good heart is a constant feast', which the Pischei Teshuvah links to 'I place Hashem before me constantly' at the opening of the Shulchan Aruch. aj,ak,am,al
Hashem's name does not appear in the Megillah, yet a brachah is made on it with His name. So a Jew must know that Hashem's name is in history, in the newspaper, in his breakfast and in his daf Gemara; 'the King' in the Megillah means Hashem.
Why the Jews did not accept Purim as a yom tov
The Gemara in Megillah says Esther wanted Purim to be a yom tov, but the Jews did not accept it: the first verse says 'and yom tov' (Esther 9:19), the second only feasting, joy and gifts to the poor (Esther 9:22). The Mashgiach asks why anyone would refuse another yom tov. an,ao,ap
A yom tov is like Shabbos, when a Jew should feel that all his work is done and nothing is lacking; on Shabbos everyone is rich, so there is no place for matanos l'evyonim. Giving tzedakah during the week awakens the sun to give to the moon, Knesses Yisrael, which in galus is like the poor. For the same reason, the Mashgiach brings from the poskim, citing Kabbalah, that the moon is not sanctified on Shabbos.
The Jews wanted a day whose mitzvah draws Hashem's blessing even in galus and hiddenness, so they chose matanos l'evyonim over yom tov. This, the Mashgiach concludes, is the true meaning of Purim Katan: receiving from above even when no comfort is seen, rising above time, and, with 'a good heart is a constant feast', seeing Hashem in everything, which brings hope for the geulah. ak
Sources
Torah
- b Shemos 27:21 text index In the write-up: 3:09, 20:52
- c Vayikra 24:3 text index In the write-up: 3:09, 53:15
- f Vayikra 16:3 6:05 text index
- g Vayikra 24:4 text index In the write-up: 7:02, 29:16
- q Shemos 32:32 text index In the write-up: 34:07
- u Devarim 25:19 text index In the write-up: 43:14
- w Devarim 33:1 47:09 text index
- ab Devarim 3:25 text index In the write-up: 56:31
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
- h apparently Menachos 29a index In the write-up: 7:02
- l apparently Nedarim 38a index In the write-up: 20:52
- m Shabbos 22b text index In the write-up: 24:34
- n Berachos 22a text index In the write-up: 29:16
- r apparently Sotah 12a index In the write-up: 29:16
- s apparently Shabbos 101b 20:10 index
- y apparently Kiddushin 38a index In the write-up: 50:05
- z apparently Kiddushin 72b 52:00 index
- ah apparently Sanhedrin 96a 59:24 index
- ai apparently Chullin 139b 1:01:25 index
- an apparently Megillah 5b index In the write-up: 1:12:21
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
- a apparently Rashi on Vayikra 24:2 index In the write-up: 0:35
- d apparently Baal HaTurim on Shemos 27:20 index In the write-up: 3:09, 29:16
- e apparently Rabbeinu Bachya on Shemos 27:20 index In the write-up: 3:09
- j Mishneh Torah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 10:13
- o apparently Baal HaTurim on Shemos 27:20 index In the write-up: 34:07, 47:32
- aq apparently Rashi on Shemos 20:9 1:14:05 index
Acharonim and Chassidus
- i Derashos Chasam Sofer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 10:13
- v Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 45:57
- x Yalkut Reuveni (place not identified) 49:41 index
- ac Megaleh Amukos (place not identified) index In the write-up: 56:31
- aj Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 697:1 text index In the write-up: 1:06:43
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 14:44 The menorah appears in two parshiyos because it has two aspects: in Tetzaveh it is part of the whole building of the Mishkan, in Emor it is a mitzvah of its own.
- 17:44 The menorah stands for Torah, especially the oral Torah and its chiddushim, which is not bound to the Mikdash and continues even after the churban and in galus.
- 35:57 Moshe Rabbeinu's name is missing from Tetzaveh because his soul is the hidden light, and what is hidden is preserved from loss.
- 39:49 In every generation Moshe's soul is present in a tzaddik, in Mordechai's time as Mordechai, and he stands against Amalek in every generation.
- 54:05 The true leader of a generation is recognized by following the footsteps of the earlier tzaddikim, not by claiming that today is different.
- 1:07:22 Purim teaches that Hashem is with the Jews even in hiddenness; Purim Katan, the double hiddenness of the first Adar, teaches a Jew to see Hashem's name in everything.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 2:17 Why is the menorah parsha of Tetzaveh repeated in Emor?
Answer: 14:44 Tetzaveh speaks of the menorah as part of the building of the Mishkan, Emor of the menorah as a separate mitzvah, which is Torah.
-
Question: 3:09 Why does the Torah give the menorah's place negatively, 'outside the paroches'?
Answer: 23:13 It is not negative: it says that the menorah belongs even outside, even when the building is not there.
-
Question: 5:44 Why would the Torah allude to the years of the two Batei Mikdash with 'kasis', a word of crushing?
Answer: 32:30 To say that even when the Batei Mikdash are crushed, the light remains a ner tamid, because Torah is eternal.
-
Question: 6:52 Why do the words 'the pure menorah' appear only in Emor?
Answer: 30:18 Emor speaks of the menorah in galus; it comes from a place of purity, and Torah, like fire, does not receive tumah even among the impurity of galus.
-
Question: 34:12 Why is Moshe Rabbeinu's name not mentioned in Tetzaveh?
Answer: 35:57 His soul is the hidden light, and the menorah parsha is the parsha of the hidden light; the hiding is his honor and his preservation.
-
Question: 1:12:54 Why did the Jews not accept Purim as a yom tov?
Answer: 1:14:13 A yom tov, like Shabbos, lacks nothing and has no poor; the Jews wanted a day of matanos l'evyonim that draws blessing even in galus.
Insights
- 11:41 The two menorah parshiyos reflect two aspects of the menorah: as one vessel of the Mishkan it belongs to the whole building, but as Torah it is a mitzvah of its own that functions even where the building is not complete or no longer stands.
- 23:10 'Outside the paroches' is not a negative instruction where not to place the menorah, but a statement that the menorah belongs even outside, even when the Mikdash is destroyed.
- 33:05 The ner maaravi parallels the Kosel Maaravi: precisely in the west, where the sun of Israel sets, there remains a light that is never extinguished, the essence of Torah.
- 35:11 Moshe's name being hidden in Tetzaveh is his reward, not his punishment: one hides what one wants to preserve, so the man who offered to be lost for Israel is preserved as the hidden light.
- 43:05 Moshe's 'erase me' stands against Amalek's erasure: because he was ready to be erased so that Israel would exist, he is present in every war against Amalek until Moshiach.
- 56:49 Moshe's plea to enter Eretz Yisrael was, in one explanation, a wish to intercalate the year, which means making the lunar year equal to the solar year, so that Knesses Yisrael, the moon, would be equal to the sun.
- 1:14:13 The Jews declined to make Purim a yom tov because a yom tov, like Shabbos, has no poor and lacks nothing, while they wanted a day of matanos l'evyonim, which draws Hashem's blessing to Knesses Yisrael even in galus.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 40:03 The Mashgiach says one can connect oneself to the tzaddik of the generation even without knowing who he is, and that this connection is a Jew's main success.
- 54:24 The Mashgiach says to recognize a true leader by whether he follows the ways of the earlier tzaddikim, and that one who says today is different and more progressive is certainly not the true one.
- 1:08:43 The Mashgiach says that on Purim Katan one should rejoice and add somewhat to the meal with friends, as 'a good heart is a constant feast'.
- 1:10:27 The Mashgiach says a Jew must learn to see Hashem's name in everything: in history, in the newspaper, and in every event of his day.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Aharon HaKohen, Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Noach, Rabbeinu Bachya, Rabbi Akiva, Rashi, Shaul HaMelech, Shes, the Arizal, the Baal HaTurim, the Baal Shem Tov, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Chasam Sofer, the Chashmonaim, the Megaleh Amukos, the Rambam, the Rema, Yeravam ben Nevat, Yonasan ben Shaul
Terms אור הגנוז, הסתר פנים, מיעוט הירח, מתנות לאביונים, נצח, נר המערבי, ערב רב, פורים קטן, שנה מעוברת, תורה שבעל פה