שיטת פרעה "אני עשיתיני" - Evolution
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע וארא no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 8 תשל"ז (1976–77) Yiddish 1 hr 8 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains Pharaoh's claim 'I made myself' as the evolutionism of his day, a refusal to acknowledge a Creator that no logic could break, only the makos, and applies it to the Pharaoh within every person and to the hester panim of our generation.
The Mashgiach opens with the theme of Vaera: Hashem reveals Himself. The Avos saw Him even within hester panim, but Moshe protested the concealment out of mesiras nefesh for Klal Yisrael, and was told he would not enter Eretz Yisrael, which in turn saved the generation of the desert; this links to Avraham giving water through a messenger and to the unfulfilled fifth expression of redemption. He then turns to Pharaoh, a great sage who said of himself 'I made myself' (Yechezkel), and explains him as the evolutionist of his time, who denied a first cause because he did not want obligations. Logic could not move him, only makos, because a klipah clouds emunah. The Midrash on 'kaved lev Pharaoh', the Satmar Rav's explanation, and examples of design in nature follow. He concludes that every person has a Pharaoh to strike during Shovavim through effort in avodah, and that our generation, living in great hester panim, must believe without seeing.
Topics: Galus Mitzrayim and the Makkos · Foundations of Emunah · Hester Panim and Suffering
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Vaera: Hashem reveals Himself
The Mashgiach explains that the parsha answers Moshe's complaint about hester panim: the Avos saw Hashem even in concealment, through nature. Moshe protested out of mesiras nefesh for Klal Yisrael, and Rashi says he was told he would not lead the war against the thirty-one kings.
-
6:02 Water through a messenger, and the fifth cup
The Mashgiach asks why Avraham, the great man of chesed, gave water to his guests through a messenger, and answers that he hated their avodah zarah and did not want to show it. Measure for measure, water in the desert came through Moshe, and his not entering Eretz Yisrael saved the generation; the fifth expression of redemption, 'veheveisi', remains for the time of Eliyahu.
-
15:15 Pharaoh says: I made myself listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the revelation of Vaera is directed at Pharaoh, whose name means uncovering. He brings the haftarah in Yechezkel where Pharaoh says 'my river is mine and I made myself', and asks how a great sage, king of the center of civilization, could say such a thing; Rashi says he deified himself at the Nile.
-
21:08 Pharaoh, the evolutionist of his time listed in the guide
Since history repeats itself, the Mashgiach explains Pharaoh as the evolutionist of his day: he denied a first cause for the same reason as today's evolutionists, because admitting a Creator obliges one to accept the Torah. Every falsehood needs a point of truth, and the Torah itself describes the world developing from water to plants, fish and man.
-
26:55 Not logic, only makos listed in the guide
Pharaoh's whole system rested on the Nile as the beginning of everything, which even a child sees is madness. The Mashgiach explains that such people do not want to hear the truth so as not to keep mitzvos, so one cannot explain it to them with logic, only with makos; he compares Korach's followers, who sinned 'against their own souls'.
-
30:31 The klipah of ervas ha'aretz
The purpose of every makah was that Pharaoh should acknowledge 'that I am Hashem in the midst of the land', yet he saw and suffered and still did not believe. The Mashgiach explains that a klipah held him back: Egypt was ervas ha'aretz, a place of pgam habris, which clouds emunah so that no logic helps.
-
34:18 The barad and the fifty-fifty chance listed in the guide
Before the barad Moshe gave the Egyptians practical advice to bring their animals inside, yet some left them in the field. The Mashgiach asks how, after six makos all foretold exactly, anyone could ignore this, and compares drinking from one of two bottles when one is poison; the answer is the klipah, which would not lift until the full process of ten makos.
-
39:07 Kaved lev Pharaoh: a heart that is not a heart
The Mashgiach brings the Midrash that reads 'kaved lev Pharaoh' as 'Pharaoh's heart is a liver', with its parable of the lion, the donkey at the toll bridge and the fox who ate its heart. He explains it with what he heard in the name of the Satmar Rav: every heart fears Hashem, and a heart without fear of Hashem is not a heart at all.
-
44:00 The deaf moth and the wonders of creation listed in the guide
The Mashgiach cites a sefer of one of the gedolei Yisrael about a night-flying moth that is deaf to everything except the sound of the bat that hunts it, and whose wings bear the image of a bird's eye. He adds the heart beating harder when running, fever, the body's repair system and involuntary muscles, all in harmony, and asks how people who say all this happened by chance would not take the chance with their animals; the answer is again the klipah.
-
49:38 The Pharaoh within, and Shovavim
The Torah tells this for all generations because every person has a Pharaoh within him. The Mashgiach explains that the six weeks of Shovavim, from Shemos to Mishpatim, are the time to repair the pgam of ervas ha'aretz before Terumah, when a Mishkan can be built in the heart; once this was done with fasts, and today the makos are effort in tefillah, Torah, chesed and breaking one's desires.
-
53:42 Mitzvos, 'veheveisi' and the generation of the desert
The Mashgiach says the true way to emunah is through mitzvos, as the Jews in Egypt were given Pesach and milah. He asks how the promise 'veheveisi' was made to a generation that never entered the land, and answers that those souls return in the generation of Moshiach. With Dovid Hamelech's words he explains that the generation of the desert lacked emunah despite seeing miracles, because emunah comes from a clean heart, not from seeing wonders.
-
57:20 Our generation: believing without seeing
The Mashgiach explains that our generation is the reverse of the desert generation: it lives in the greatest hester panim, after millions of Jews were killed, and its task is to believe without seeing. Those who complain why the Jews let themselves be led away do so not out of mesiras nefesh but because they do not want the truth, which is written in Ha'azinu: 'how could one pursue a thousand' unless Hashem had handed them over.
-
1:03:24 The first exile as a sign for ours
The Mashgiach brings Rabbeinu Bachya at the end of Parshas Shemos, that the exile of Egypt hints at our exile: we wait 'shomrim laboker' for a morning that passes, and the end of the exile is harder than all of it. He points to growing hatred of Jews and to 'good friends' among the nations who turned out otherwise, concluding that one can rely only on Hashem.
The shiur, written up
Vaera: Hashem reveals Himself
The Mashgiach opens with the end of Parshas Shemos, where Moshe complains about the hester panim, and explains that Vaera is Hashem's answer: He shows Himself. Rashi brings that the Avos went through great concealment, as when Avraham had to buy a burial place in the land promised to him, yet they did not question; they found Hashem even in nature, in Kel Shakai. a,b,c
Water through a messenger, and the fifth cup
To explain this, the Mashgiach brings Chazal that what Avraham did himself for his guests Hashem repaid directly, but the water he gave through a messenger was repaid through a messenger, Moshe. He asks why Avraham, the master of chesed, used a messenger. He answers that Avraham hated avodah zarah, whose tractate in his day had four hundred chapters, and his guests worshipped the dust on their feet; so as not to show irritation, he had someone else wash them. e,f
Measure for measure, this saved Klal Yisrael. Because Moshe struck the rock, he stayed with the dor hamidbar, and they too will enter the land; and since he did not build the Beis Hamikdash, Hashem could pour His wrath on wood and stones. So Moshe's mesiras nefesh was granted.
Pharaoh says: I made myself
The Mashgiach explains that the revelation of Vaera is aimed at Pharaoh, whose name means uncovering: even Pharaoh must acknowledge that there is a Ribono shel Olam. The haftarah in Yechezkel has Pharaoh say of himself that the river is his and he made himself. j
He asks how Pharaoh could say this. He was no madman but a great sage, king of the center of civilization whose achievements are not understood to this day, and the navi would not record a madman's words for all generations. His whole claim was tied to the Nile, and Rashi says that is where he deified himself. k
Pharaoh, the evolutionist of his time
Since history repeats itself, the Mashgiach says, Pharaoh was the evolutionist of his time. He denied a first cause, which would answer every question, for the same reason as today's evolutionists: admitting a Creator obliges one to look further into the Torah and its mitzvos. Their shifting theories are rationalization, burying the head in the sand.
At bottom the claim is always that the world made itself, so the creature is its own creator, which was Pharaoh's klipah. Yet every falsehood needs a point of truth, as Chazal say of the letters of sheker, and the Torah too shows the world developing from water to plants, fish and finally man. l
Not logic, only makos
Pharaoh's system held that everything began from the Nile, which even a small child sees is madness. Such people do not want to hear, so as not to keep mitzvos or fight their yetzer hara, and the Mashgiach says it cannot be explained with logic, only with makos. Korach's followers likewise sinned 'against their own souls', against their own understanding. m
The klipah of ervas ha'aretz
Each makah was meant to make Pharaoh acknowledge 'that I am Hashem in the midst of the land', yet he saw and suffered and did not believe. The Mashgiach explains that a klipah held him back: Egypt was ervas ha'aretz, a place of pgam habris, which clouds emunah and breeds questions that no logic or suffering answers. Six makos had passed without effect, because the pgam was not yet wiped away. n
The barad and the fifty-fifty chance
Before the barad Moshe offered practical advice to bring the animals indoors, yet some left them in the field. The Mashgiach asks how, after six makos foretold in every detail, anyone could risk it; even calling it chance, no one drinks from one of two bottles when one is poison. o
He answers that a klipah of ervas ha'aretz clouded their emunah, and it would not clear until the whole process of ten makos, seven in Vaera and three in Bo.
Kaved lev Pharaoh: a heart that is not a heart
A Midrash reads 'kaved lev Pharaoh' as 'Pharaoh's heart is a liver'. It tells of the lion who tore apart the donkey for demanding a toll from the king; the fox ate the heart and explained that the donkey had none, or it would not have had such chutzpah. p,q
The Mashgiach explains it as he heard in the name of the Satmar Rav: every heart fears Hashem. The limbs of a holy person become a vessel for their counterparts above, so an eye or heart without fear of Hashem is merely an organ, and Pharaoh's heart was no heart.
The deaf moth and the wonders of creation
The Mashgiach cites a sefer of one of the gedolei Yisrael about a night moth that is deaf to every sound except that of the bat that hunts it, and whose wings bear the eye of a large bird that frightens away smaller birds. Such coincidences, he says, are everywhere: the heart beats harder when running, fever kills bacteria, the body repairs itself, and the heart and lungs work by themselves, all in harmony.
Why then did those who say all this came by chance not fear for their animals? It is not logic but a klipah on the heart, which six makos could not remove.
The Pharaoh within, and Shovavim
The Torah records this for all generations, the Mashgiach says, because every person has a Pharaoh within him. The six weeks of Shovavim, from Shemos to Mishpatim, are the time to repair the pgam of ervas ha'aretz before Terumah, when a Mishkan can be built in the heart. Once fasts served as these makos; today they are effort in tefillah and Torah, doing good for another Jew, and breaking one's desires.
Mitzvos, 'veheveisi' and the generation of the desert
The true way to emunah is through mitzvos, like the Pesach and milah given in Egypt. Since 'veheveisi' was promised to a generation that never entered the land, the Mashgiach suggests those souls return before Moshiach. Dovid Hamelech says they did not believe despite the miracles, for emunah comes from a heart cleansed of sin, not from seeing wonders. h,s
Our generation: believing without seeing
Our generation, the Mashgiach says, is the reverse of the desert generation: we live in hester panim, and our task is to believe without seeing. Ours saw greater concealment than Egypt, with millions of Jews killed, and without the leaders who strengthened Jews there.
The first exile as a sign for ours
The Mashgiach concludes with Rabbeinu Bachya at the end of Parshas Shemos: the exile of Egypt hints at ours. We are 'shomrim laboker', waiting for a morning that passes, and the end of the exile is harder than all of it, as our times show. v,w
Hatred of Jews grows across the world, and the 'good friends' among the nations proved otherwise. He recalls a prime minister calling France a good friend, and says one can rely only on Hashem.
Sources
Torah
- a Shemos 5:22-23 text index In the write-up: 0:44
- c Shemos 6:3 text index In the write-up: 0:44
- h Shemos 6:8 text index In the write-up: 12:27, 53:42
- m apparently Bamidbar 17:3 index In the write-up: 27:26
- n apparently Shemos 8:18 index In the write-up: 31:01
- o Shemos 9:20-21 text index In the write-up: 34:49
- p Shemos 7:14 text index In the write-up: 39:19
- t Devarim 32:29-30 text index In the write-up: 59:45
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Targum
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- q Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 39:19
Rishonim
- b apparently Rashi on Shemos 6:9 index In the write-up: 0:44
- d apparently Rashi on Shemos 6:1 index In the write-up: 4:22
- g apparently Ba'al HaTurim on Shemos 6:6 index In the write-up: 12:27
- k apparently Rashi on Shemos 7:15 index In the write-up: 17:47
- u Ramban (place not identified) index In the write-up: 59:45
- v apparently Rabbeinu Bachya on Shemos, end of Parshas Shemos index In the write-up: 1:03:43
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 1:24 The Avos found Hashem within every state of concealment, while Moshe protested the hester panim out of mesiras nefesh for Klal Yisrael.
- 19:21 Pharaoh's claim 'I made myself' was not madness but the position of an evolutionist: denying a first cause and claiming that the world, and he himself, came about on their own.
- 23:41 The denial comes from not wanting to accept obligation, not from logic, so it cannot be answered with logic but only with makos.
- 32:02 A klipah born of ervas ha'aretz clouds a person's emunah, so neither suffering nor statistics helped the Egyptians until all ten makos had passed.
- 50:34 Every person has a Pharaoh within him, and the weeks of Shovavim are the time to strike it, today through effort in tefillah, Torah, chesed and breaking one's desires, and through mitzvos.
- 56:33 The generation of the desert did not believe though it saw miracles; our generation lives in great hester panim and its task is to believe without seeing.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 6:50 Why did Avraham, the great man of chesed, give his guests water through a messenger?
Answer: 8:21 Because he hated their avodah zarah and did not want them to feel his irritation when they came with dust they worshipped on their feet.
-
Question: 17:47 How could Pharaoh, a great sage and king of the center of civilization, say 'I made myself'?
Answer: 21:31 He was the evolutionist of his time, denying a first cause and claiming that he and the world came about on their own.
-
Question: 29:40 Why did Korach's followers rebel after seeing all of Moshe's wonders?
Answer: 30:08 They sinned 'against their own souls': not out of logic, since they understood it was forbidden, but because they had sold themselves to falsehood.
-
Question: 35:30 How could Egyptians who had seen six makos foretold exactly leave their animals in the field before the barad?
Answer: 38:12 It is not a question of logic: a klipah of ervas ha'aretz clouded their emunah, and it would not lift until the full process of ten makos.
-
Question: 54:51 How could 'veheveisi' be promised to the generation of Egypt, who never entered the land?
Answer: 55:10 Those souls are reincarnated in the generation of Moshiach, and through them it will be fulfilled.
-
Question: 1:00:16 How could the Jews, a people with a history of courage, let themselves be led away to be killed?
Answer: 1:01:09 The Torah answers it in Ha'azinu: one could pursue a thousand only because Hashem had handed them over, and no one can stand against His will.
Stories
-
39:42 The lion, the donkey and the fox
The Midrash tells that the lion, king of the animals, was walking with his attendants and came to a bridge where the donkey collected the toll. The donkey demanded that the king pay, and the lion, insisting that all the tolls belong to him, tore the donkey to pieces and continued on his walk, leaving the fox to prepare it as a meal. When the lion returned he found the heart missing, because the fox had eaten it, and the fox answered that the donkey had no heart: had it had one, it would not have dared such chutzpah to the king.
In the story: Pharaoh
Insights
- 10:21 Moshe not entering Eretz Yisrael was itself the reward for his mesiras nefesh: because he would not lead the war, the generation of the desert and later Klal Yisrael were saved, since Hashem poured His wrath on wood and stones.
- 8:11 Avraham gave water through a messenger out of chesed: hating avodah zarah intensely, he let someone else wash the guests' feet so they would not feel his irritation, and measure for measure Klal Yisrael received water in the desert through Moshe, which spared them.
- 24:56 Pharaoh's 'I made myself' and the claim that the world made itself are one position: the source of creation lies within the creature itself, so that the creation and the creator are the same.
- 50:02 The greatest wonder of the Exodus was that the Egyptians, after all the wonders, still denied; the Torah records this because the same Pharaoh lives in every person.
- 42:28 Following the Satmar Rav, the limbs of a holy person become a vessel for their counterparts above, so an eye or heart without fear of Hashem is only an organ, not truly an eye or a heart; this is the meaning of the Midrash that Pharaoh had no heart.
- 55:10 The souls of the generation of Mitzrayim, to whom 'veheveisi' was promised but not fulfilled, return in the generation before Moshiach: they did not believe when they saw, and now they believe without seeing.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 52:47 The Mashgiach says that during Shovavim the makos to strike one's inner Pharaoh are, today, effort in tefillah, in Torah, in doing good for another Jew, and breaking one's desires, not fasts that weaken.
- 53:42 The Mashgiach says the true way for Jews to reach emunah is through mitzvos, which remove the klipah from the heart.
- 57:25 The Mashgiach says that in our time of hester panim our task is to believe even in what we do not see, and that one can rely only on Hashem.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Aharon HaKohen, Amram, Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Eliyahu HaNavi, Korach, Moshe Rabbeinu, Pharaoh, Pinchas, Rabbeinu Bachya, Rashi, Rav Shlomo Wolbe, the Baal HaTurim, the Ramban, the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum), Yechezkel HaNavi
Terms הסתר פנים, מדת הדין, מסירות נפש, עבודה זרה, ערות הארץ, פגם הברית, קליפה, רבונו של עולם, שובבים