הנסיונות הגדולות של יעקב בפרשה זו - כנגד הנסיונות הגדולות של סוף הגלות
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע וישלח no. 4 Pocket Guide p. 7 תשמ"א (1980–81) Yiddish 1 hr 21 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains how Yaakov, having stayed pure in the house of Lavan, could repair the angels who had fallen in Sodom and face Esav, and draws from this the great trials of emunah at the end of the exile.
The Mashgiach opens with the Yismach Moshe: Yaakov met two camps of angels, those created by his mitzvos and those Hashem sent in his honor, and sent the second to Esav. He then brings the Targum Yonasan that the angels of Sodom were expelled from their place for saying 'we are destroying', and asks how angels could forget their Sender. Following the Arizal on Egypt, he answers that Sodom's impurity damaged even Gavriel and Rafael, and only a tzaddik free of that flaw could repair them. Yaakov, prepared in the yeshivah of Shem and Ever and unharmed by Lavan, did so, and sent those angels to Esav as witnesses. Since the deeds of the Avos are a sign for their children, the end of the exile brings the same trials, above all in emunah. He explains the two Kabbalas Shabbos psalms as a redemption of din or of chesed, ties Moshiach on a donkey to toil in prayer, and ends with the angel who must concede Yaakov's blessings.
Topics: Yitzchak, Yaakov and Esav · Avodah of the Last Generation · Doubts in Emunah and Amalek
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Two camps of angels
The Mashgiach brings the Yismach Moshe: angels are created by a person's mitzvos, and Yaakov met a second camp sent by Hashem in his honor. He sent that camp, not the angels of his mitzvos, to Esav.
-
3:14 The angels expelled after Sodom
The Mashgiach brings the Targum Yonasan that the angels Yaakov saw at the ladder had been expelled from their place for saying in Sodom 'we are destroying', and now went back up. He asks how angels could err, why they were forgiven now, and how they forgot their Sender.
-
8:03 Why the angels were harmed in Sodom
From the Arizal on 'I and not an angel' in the Haggadah, that Egypt was so impure that an angel would have been harmed there, the Mashgiach explains that Sodom was the same, so even Gavriel and Rafael were damaged. He speaks of the power of bad company and says the damaged angels could not return until repaired.
-
12:00 Only one free of the flaw can repair it listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells how souls came to tzaddikim such as the Arizal, the Ba'al Shem Tov and the Kozhnitzer Maggid for a tikkun, and explains that one can repair a flaw only if one is free of it. Yaakov first spent fourteen years in the yeshivah of Shem and Ever, filling himself with kedushah, so he could enter Lavan's house unharmed and repair the angels, which Avraham and Yitzchak could not.
-
17:01 Lavan's impurity and the reversed 'vayifge'u' listed in the guide
The Mashgiach describes Lavan as the greatest impurity, identified with Bilam, and Yaakov as the one who could stay with him and grow in kedushah. From the Zohar on 'vayifga' he explains that going to Charan Yaakov was surprised by the angels, while coming back the angels were the ones who had the joy of meeting him.
-
20:18 The repaired angels sent to Esav listed in the guide
With a story of the Chernobyler, the Mashgiach explains that a tzaddik is bound to help one who serves him, so Yaakov repaired the angels sent to escort him. He then sent them to Esav, since they, who had fallen in an impure place, could testify firsthand that he lived with Lavan and kept the mitzvos, and he did not fear the four hundred men.
-
25:15 Yaakov's return as a sign for the ingathering listed in the guide
Using the Ramban's rule that the deeds of the Avos are a sign for their children, the Mashgiach explains that Yaakov's joyous return to Eretz Yisrael with all the future Jewish souls is a sign of the return from exile. To know what the last struggle with Esav and Lavan will look like, he says, one must study the end of last week's parsha and the beginning of this one.
-
28:22 The trial of emunah before Moshiach listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the end of Daniel, the last chapter of Malachi and the Gemara that before Moshiach the wicked will succeed and one who turns from evil will be mocked. From the Arizal and the Ohr HaChaim he explains that at the end Jews will fall even into the fiftieth gate, heresy, and says that today even observance is often mere tradition; we are now in the house of Lavan and facing Esav.
-
34:00 Guarding emunah, and Chavakuk's one principle listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says every Jew must make a cheshbon hanefesh whether he could say 'I lived with Lavan and kept the mitzvos'. He teaches that emunah depends on guarding the bris, which includes guarding speech from lashon hara and mockery, and brings the Gemara that Chavakuk based all the mitzvos on one: 'the tzaddik lives by his emunah'.
-
39:25 Two psalms: redemption in Nissan or Tishrei listed in the guide
Explaining Chavakuk's name as embracing emunah, the Mashgiach turns to two Kabbalas Shabbos psalms that end almost alike, one with 'ki va' twice and 'be'emunaso', the other with 'ki va' once and 'bemeisharim'. He prefaces the Gemara's dispute whether the redemption comes in Nissan or Tishrei, which the Satmar Rav read as a redemption of chesed or of din.
-
43:46 A generation of disappointments that still believes listed in the guide
The Mashgiach describes how Jews waited for the redemption through many promised dates and disappointments, and how from such small generations nothing can be expected but emunah. With 'shomrim laboker' and 'hinei Elokeinu zeh kivinu lo' he explains that after each disappointment they hope again.
-
49:02 The psalms explained, and Esav's kiss listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the psalm with one 'ki va' and 'bemeisharim' describes a redemption of din, preceded by the shofar of Tishrei, while the psalm with 'ki va, ki va' and 'be'emunaso', preceded by the joy of Nissan, describes a redemption earned by renewed hope and emunah. So it was when Yaakov met Esav: Esav had no power to bite and his bite became a kiss.
-
52:18 'Shor vachamor': the sparks Yaakov drew out listed in the guide
On 'vayehi li shor vachamor' the Mashgiach brings the Midrash that these allude to the two Moshiachs, and asks why Yaakov tells Esav this. He explains with the Midrash that Lavan's sheep were Jewish souls held by the forces of evil, which Yaakov repaired and drew out; so he warns Esav that he too will be made to give up the holy sparks in him, such as the souls of Rabbi Akiva and Rabbi Meir.
-
57:50 Moshiach rides on the toil of prayer listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says that in the final war of good and evil a Jew must cry to Hashem 'save me from the hand of my brother, from the hand of Esav'. He explains that the greater one's spark of Moshiach, the harder his davening, and Moshiach 'riding on a donkey' means he comes through the groaning prayers of simple, physical Jews and through toil like Yissachar's.
-
1:03:01 The angel must concede the blessings listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why Yaakov needed the angel of Esav to concede his blessings, and answers with the Gemara of the two angels who accompany a Jew home on Friday night: when the house is ready the bad angel must answer amen, and that is the completeness of the redemption. Each Jew must prepare by a week of avodah, so that when the great Shabbos comes the angels meet him as they met Yaakov.
The shiur, written up
Two camps of angels
The Mashgiach opens with the Yismach Moshe. Every mitzvah a person does creates a good angel that goes with him. When Yaakov returned to Eretz Yisrael, Hashem also sent angels to receive him in his honor, so he saw 'two camps': the angels of his own mitzvos and the angels sent from Heaven. When he sent angels to Esav, he sent the second camp, because he did not want to use his mitzvos in this world. a,b,c
The angels expelled after Sodom
Going back to last week's parsha, the Mashgiach brings the Targum Yonasan on the angels Yaakov saw going up and down the ladder. The angels sent to Sodom had said 'we are destroying this place', as if by their own power, and so they were expelled from their place and remained below. When Yaakov came, their time arrived and they were allowed back up. d,e,f
He asks several questions. How can angels be expelled at all, and do they have free choice? Who decided that their exile should end exactly now? Above all, how could angels forget who sent them, when every part of creation, even the worst of the klipos, does Hashem's will?
Why the angels were harmed in Sodom
To answer, the Mashgiach brings the Arizal on 'I and not an angel' in the Haggadah. Egypt was so full of impurity that even a holy angel sent there would have been damaged, so Hashem went down Himself. The same, he says, was true of Sodom, the place of the worst sins. g
Even Gavriel and Rafael were harmed there and forgot their Sender. From this the Mashgiach shows the power of bad company and a bad atmosphere, and of choosing whom one connects with. Like a damaged soul that cannot enter Gan Eden until cleansed, the angels could not return to Heaven.
Only one free of the flaw can repair it
Souls that needed a tikkun came to tzaddikim. Rabbi Chaim Vital tells such stories of the Arizal; the Ba'al Shem Tov was known for it; and the soul of the man who threw the first stone at the prophet Zecharyah wandered without a tikkun until it came to the Kozhnitzer Maggid.
To repair someone's flaw, the Mashgiach explains, one must be free of it; only one who is above a thing can help another with it. So no one could help Gavriel and Rafael until Yaakov came, who had to go to Lavan's house.
Lavan's impurity and the reversed 'vayifge'u'
The repaired angels sent to Esav
A tzaddik is bound to help one who serves him. The Mashgiach tells that the Chernobyler's horses once stopped on the road; he threw a coin back, and they went on. A great rasha had once given him a coin; seeing he could not repair him, he returned it so as to owe him nothing.
So too, the angels sent to escort Yaakov, whom Rashi calls the angels of Eretz Yisrael, served him, and he repaired them. He then sent them to Esav to say 'I lived with Lavan', since they had fallen in an impure place themselves and could testify firsthand that he withstood it. With this he did not fear Esav's four hundred men. l,m,n
Yaakov's return as a sign for the ingathering
The Mashgiach cites the Ramban's rule that whatever happened to the Avos is a sign for their children. Yaakov leaving chutz la'aretz for Eretz Yisrael with all the Jewish souls, while angels danced, is a sign of the return from exile, when the shofar sounds and Jews come back to Zion. To know what the last struggle with Esav and Lavan will look like, one must study the end of last week's parsha and the start of this one. o,p
The trial of emunah before Moshiach
The sefarim and the prophets, at the end of Daniel and Malachi, describe the great trials before Moshiach, the main one in emunah. The wicked and those who join false leaders and heretics will succeed, while honest Jews are mocked; the Mashgiach brings the Gemara in Sanhedrin that one who turns from evil will be taken for a madman. Malachi's chapter, read before Pesach, also promises that Hashem values the few who fear Him. q,r,s
The Arizal says the Jews in Egypt sank to the forty-ninth gate of impurity; the Ohr HaChaim adds that before Moshiach they will fall even into the fiftieth, yet with the power of Torah can withstand it. Tzaddikim called that gate heresy. Today, the Mashgiach says, even among those who daven and keep Shabbos it is often mere tradition. We are all in Lavan's house now and wrestling with Esav. t
Guarding emunah, and Chavakuk's one principle
When the shofar of Moshiach comes, the Mashgiach says, each Jew must be equipped to say 'I lived with Lavan and kept the mitzvos', and must make a cheshbon hanefesh now. The Midrash says Jews leaving exile will come to a mountain called emunah, and those with emunah will be redeemed. u
Emunah depends on guarding the bris, which also means guarding the tongue: no lashon hara, mockery or stinging words. The Mashgiach says one who guards his bris will never speak ill of Jews.
Two psalms: redemption in Nissan or Tishrei
Chavakuk's name comes from Elisha's words 'you will embrace a son': one must embrace emunah, since weak generations cannot concentrate on everything. The Mashgiach then compares two psalms of Kabbalas Shabbos with nearly the same last verse. One says 'ki va' twice and ends 'be'emunaso'; the other says 'ki va' once and ends 'bemeisharim'. y,z,aa
A generation of disappointments that still believes
What decides between them? Jews have waited so long, the Mashgiach says, through dates foretold in sefarim that passed, persecutions and promises that came to nothing, yet they keep believing. Generations keep shrinking, and from one like ours nothing more can be expected than a little emunah. Earlier, greater generations could have been asked for full avodah.
The Mashgiach brings 'more than watchmen for the morning', which Rashi explains as hope repeated. After the First World War Jews expected Moshiach, and nothing came, yet they waited for the next morning. So too 'behold our G-d, we hoped for Him'. A small generation can still give one thing: emunah, as Chavakuk taught. x,ad,ae,af
The psalms explained, and Esav's kiss
With this the Mashgiach explains the psalms. A single 'ki va' with 'bemeisharim' is a redemption of din: the nations are judged and the Jews by their mitzvos, and it is preceded by the trumpets and shofar of Tishrei. The double 'ki va' describes a generation whose hope was disappointed and who still hope again; it ends 'be'emunaso' and is preceded by 'let the heavens rejoice', the joy of Nissan. z,aa,ag,ah
'Shor vachamor': the sparks Yaakov drew out
Yaakov told Esav 'I have an ox and a donkey', which the Midrash reads as the two Moshiachs, the donkey being Moshiach who comes 'poor and riding on a donkey'. Why tell this to Esav? The Mashgiach explains with the Midrash Rabbah that Yaakov's flock numbered six hundred thousand, the root souls of Israel. aj,ak,al,am
Lavan, an embodiment of the forces of evil, held those souls captive like animals, and Yaakov repaired them and drew them out. So Yaakov warns Esav: you think you will swallow me, but you will have to give back the holy sparks in you, as Lavan did. Through his struggle Yaakov drew from Esav souls such as Rabbi Akiva and Rabbi Meir.
Moshiach rides on the toil of prayer
This is the war of good and evil before Moshiach, the Mashgiach says, and a Jew must cry out to Hashem 'save me from the hand of my brother, from the hand of Esav'. Great souls in this time find many faults in themselves, yet the greater one is, the greater his yetzer, and with great toil they can rise higher. an,ao
Every Jew who davens carries a spark of Moshiach, and the larger it is, the harder his davening. Moshiach 'rides on a donkey': he comes through the groans and prayers of simple, physical Jews who toil, as Yaakov did in Lavan's house, and like Yissachar, 'a strong donkey' who bent his shoulder to the yoke, a soldier for Hashem. al,ap
The angel must concede the blessings
After wrestling with the angel of Esav, Yaakov would not let him go until he blessed him, meaning until he conceded the blessings. The Mashgiach asks why Yaakov needed this: was it not enough that Hashem and Yitzchak had blessed him? He answers that this is the completeness, and it happens whenever an exile ends. aq
The six weekdays hint at the exile and Shabbos at the day that is all Shabbos. The Gemara says two angels, a good one and a bad one, accompany a Jew home on Friday night. When the candles burn, the wine is ready and the challos are covered, the good angel blesses and the bad angel must answer amen. This, the Mashgiach says, is the completeness of the redemption. ar
Lavan's 'come, blessed of Hashem' to Eliezer was a sign of this as well: the blessing counts most when the other side concedes it. The Mashgiach says this is earned by the avodah of the whole week, the days of toil. as
In the last moments of ikvesa d'meshicha, the Mashgiach says, every Jew must prepare as for such a Shabbos, through the week, the twenty years with Lavan and the struggle with Esav. Then, when Hashem sanctifies the world with the great Shabbos, angels will meet him as they met Yaakov entering Eretz Yisrael, all conceding the blessings, and the bad angel too will answer amen.
Sources
Torah
- b Bereishis 32:2-3 text index In the write-up: 0:27
- c Bereishis 32:4 text index In the write-up: 0:27
- d Bereishis 28:12 text index In the write-up: 3:40
- f Bereishis 19:13 text index In the write-up: 3:40
- m Bereishis 32:5 (with Rashi) text index In the write-up: 21:32
- n Bereishis 32:7 text index In the write-up: 21:32
- p Bereishis 35:3 text index In the write-up: 25:15
- ai Bereishis 33:4 text index In the write-up: 51:56
- aj Bereishis 32:6 text index In the write-up: 52:18
- an Bereishis 32:12 text index In the write-up: 57:50
- ap Bereishis 49:14-15 text index In the write-up: 59:50
- aq Bereishis 32:27 text index In the write-up: 1:03:05
- as Bereishis 24:31 text index In the write-up: 1:05:26
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
- q apparently Daniel ch. 12 index In the write-up: 28:28
- v apparently Tehillim 55:21 37:01 index
- z Tehillim 96:13 text index In the write-up: 39:29, 49:10
- aa Tehillim 98:9 text index In the write-up: 39:29, 49:10
- ad Tehillim 130:6-7 text index In the write-up: 45:42
- ag Tehillim 98:6 text index In the write-up: 49:10
- ah Tehillim 96:11 text index In the write-up: 49:10
Targum
Talmud Bavli
- j Gemara Sanhedrin (place not identified) 17:26 index
- r Sanhedrin 97a text index In the write-up: 28:28
- w Makkos 24a text index In the write-up: 38:08
- ab Rosh Hashanah 11a text index In the write-up: 41:04
- ao apparently Sukkah 52a index In the write-up: 57:50
- ar Shabbos 119b text index In the write-up: 1:03:55
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 1:30 Yaakov met two camps of angels, those created by his own mitzvos and those Hashem sent in his honor; he sent the second camp to Esav, not wanting to use his mitzvos in this world.
- 8:29 The angels of Sodom were harmed by its impure atmosphere, just as the Arizal says Hashem did not send an angel into Egypt lest it be harmed there.
- 13:24 Only a tzaddik who is himself free of a flaw can repair it, so the fallen angels had to wait for Yaakov, who stayed untouched in the house of Lavan.
- 25:15 Following the Ramban's rule that the deeds of the Avos are a sign for their children, Yaakov's return from Lavan and his struggle with Esav foreshadow the last trials before the redemption.
- 28:38 The main trial of the end of the exile is emunah, and the Mashgiach says one must guard it, including in speech, since with emunah alone the Jews will leave the exile.
- 44:20 A small generation that has lived through many disappointments can be asked only for emunah, and so the redemption must come in the way of Nissan, of chesed, and not of Tishrei, of din.
- 1:05:15 The completeness of the redemption is that even the side of evil must concede the blessings, as the bad angel must answer amen on a Friday night prepared by a week of avodah.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 6:03 How could angels, who are only messengers, forget their Sender and say 'we are destroying'?
Answer: 8:44 Sodom was as impure as Egypt, where the Arizal says an angel would have been damaged; even Gavriel and Rafael were harmed there and forgot.
-
Question: 6:38 Why were the expelled angels restored only when Yaakov came?
Answer: 13:24 Only one free of a flaw can repair it; Yaakov, prepared in Shem and Ever and unharmed by Lavan, was the first tzaddik able to do so.
-
Question: 23:13 Why did Yaakov send these particular angels to Esav?
Answer: 23:28 They had fallen in an impure place and been repaired by one who withstood it, so they could testify firsthand that he lived with Lavan unharmed.
-
Question: 40:40 Why do the two Kabbalas Shabbos psalms differ in 'ki va' and in 'be'emunaso' versus 'bemeisharim'?
Answer: 49:37 One describes a redemption of din in the way of Tishrei, the other a redemption of chesed in the way of Nissan, which a generation of repeated hope earns with emunah.
-
Question: 1:03:25 Why did Yaakov need the angel of Esav to concede the blessings, when Hashem and Yitzchak had already blessed him?
Answer: 1:04:34 That is the completeness of the redemption, like the bad angel who must answer amen when the Shabbos home is ready.
Stories
-
12:35 The soul that came to the Kozhnitzer Maggid
The Mashgiach mentions, among the stories of souls that came to tzaddikim for a tikkun, the soul of the one who threw the first stone at the prophet Zecharyah. It had wandered for a very long time without a tikkun until it came to Rabbi Yisrael of Kozhnitz.
In the story: the Kozhnitzer Maggid (Rabbi Yisrael of Kozhnitz), Zechariah HaNavi
-
20:30 The Chernobyler and the coin
The Chernobyler was once traveling when the horses stopped and could not go on. He took a coin and threw it back onto the road, and the horses went on. He explained that a great rasha had once given him a coin, and so had attached himself to him; but seeing he could not repair him, he gave the coin back, so that he received nothing from him and was not bound to help him.
In the story: Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl (the Me'or Einayim)
Insights
- 8:44 The Mashgiach reads the angels' error in Sodom through the Arizal on Egypt: a place of extreme impurity can damage even Gavriel and Rafael, and from this he shows the power of a bad environment and bad company.
- 14:05 The angels expelled after Sodom waited for a tzaddik who could enter a place of impurity unharmed; this explains why they were restored only when Yaakov came, after Shem and Ever and Lavan.
- 18:21 'Vayifga' is reversed: on the way to Charan Yaakov had the surprise of meeting the angels, but on the way back it was the angels' joy to meet Yaakov, who had redeemed them.
- 23:39 Yaakov sent to Esav precisely the angels who had once fallen in an impure place, because only they could testify from experience that he had lived with Lavan without being harmed.
- 49:37 The two nearly identical Kabbalas Shabbos psalms describe two kinds of redemption: one of din, in the way of Tishrei, judged 'bemeisharim', and one of chesed, in the way of Nissan, earned by a generation that keeps hoping 'ki va, ki va' with emunah.
- 1:00:11 The 'chamor' on which Moshiach rides is the physical, toiling Jew whose davening is hard; the greater his spark of Moshiach, the harder his prayer, and Moshiach comes through such groaning prayers.
- 1:03:25 Yaakov's demand that the angel of Esav concede the blessings is the same as the bad angel answering amen on Friday night: the completeness of the redemption is when even the side of evil must acknowledge the good.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 34:27 The Mashgiach says every Jew must make a cheshbon hanefesh whether he is equipped to say, when the last trials come, 'I lived with Lavan and kept the mitzvos'.
- 36:26 He says one must hold fast to emunah and guard against what damages it: lashon hara, mocking other Jews, and reading books and literature that can harm it.
- 58:01 He says a Jew must cry and pray 'save me from the hand of Esav' in the last moments before the redemption.
- 1:07:30 He says one must prepare through the avodah of the whole week so that on Shabbos even the bad angel answers amen.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Bilaam, Chavakuk, Eliezer, servant of Avraham, Elisha HaNavi, Esav, Lavan, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Chaim Vital, Rabbi Eliezer (ben Hurkenos), Rabbi Meir, Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl (the Me'or Einayim), Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya, the angel Gavriel, the angel Refael, the Arizal, the Baal Shem Tov, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Chofetz Chaim, the Kozhnitzer Maggid (Rabbi Yisrael of Kozhnitz), the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, the Rambam, the Ramban, the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum), the Yismach Moshe, Yaakov Avinu, Yissachar, Yitzchak Avinu, Zechariah HaNavi
Terms אמונה, ישיבת שם ועבר, מדת הדין, מדת החסד, מלאכי השרת, מעשה אבות סימן לבנים, ניצוצות, סמאל, עקבתא דמשיחא, פגם, פגם הברית, קליפה, שער החמישים, תיקון