דרך הישרה להתנהג בגלות -הכנעה (כמו שיעקב אע"ה התנהג לעשו)
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע וישלח no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 6 תשל"ג (1972–73) Yiddish 1 hr 3 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains why, before the time of tikkun, the right way for Jews in exile is Yaakov's way of submission, prayer and gifts toward Esav, and how to recognize Esav even when he appears as a talmid chacham.
The Mashgiach opens with a contradiction: the Midrash criticizes Yaakov for submitting to Esav, while the Ramban says Chazal learned from him how to deal with Esav. The Chiddushei HaRim answers that the Midrash speaks by drash and the Zohar by sod; before the tikkun, since Adam's sin, the layers of Torah can seem to clash. Following Rabbeinu Bachya, in exile the way is prayer and gifts, not war. The Mashgiach applies this to the dispute over Soviet Jewry, Mordechai and Haman, and the Maharal on Rachel's plea. He warns that before Moshiach the erev rav, Esav disguised as a talmid chacham, will seem vindicated by signs, and that the test is following the earlier generations, as the Chasam Sofer taught. He closes with the gift to Esav, Esav's descendants, the alufim of Esav, and when war is warranted.
Topics: Yitzchak, Yaakov and Esav · Yisroel and the Nations · Hiskashrus to Tzaddikim and Emunas Chachamim
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Midrash and Zohar on Yaakov's submission listed in the guide
The Mashgiach presents the contradiction between the Midrash, which criticizes Yaakov for submitting to Esav, and the lesson Chazal drew from him, and brings the Chiddushei HaRim's answer: the Midrash speaks by drash, the Zohar by sod, and before the tikkun the layers of Torah can clash.
-
6:14 Prayer and gifts, not war, in exile listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Yaakov saw the layers of Torah and chose submission, since the kings of Edom had to reign first; the Tannaim followed him before Rome. He brings the Ramban that Yaakov prepared gifts, prayer and war, and Rabbeinu Bachya that in exile only gifts and prayer remain, because of the oath in the Gemara.
-
10:08 A test of emunas chachamim: Russia and Mordechai listed in the guide
The Mashgiach describes the recent dispute over Soviet Jewry: the gedolim favored shtadlanus and Tehillim, the militants favored confrontation, and the militants seemed to succeed. He compares it to Mordechai, whose refusal to bow brought Haman's decree, and says that before the tikkun such contradictions leave room to criticize the gedolim, a test of the time before Moshiach.
-
15:05 The Maharal on Rachel's plea listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Maharal in Netzach Yisrael on the Midrash of Rachel's plea: she was not jealous of Leah and gave her the signs, so why is Hashem jealous of the idols? The Maharal explains that Rachel understood it was not yet the time of tikkun, that contradictions must be smoothed out through exile, and that Jews' sins come from the state of the world, not their essence.
-
21:13 Causing sin is worse than killing listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says one must think carefully and go in the straight path: Russia lets Jews out, but many have left Yiddishkeit, and causing someone to sin is worse than killing him. He tells how the Baal HaTanya prayed for Russia's victory over Napoleon, preferring hardship for Jews over spiritual decline, and says Heaven measures by other standards.
-
25:05 False prophets with true signs listed in the guide
The Mashgiach speaks of the battle in Eretz Yisrael led by erev rav leaders, and of a tradition that before Moshiach the fire will descend on the altar of Baal, reversing Eliyahu at Carmel. With the Chiddushei HaRim on the passuk of the prophet who gives a sign, he says false ideas will seem confirmed from Heaven, and a Jew must cover his eyes, say Shema and hold to emunah.
-
28:58 Esav's angel disguised as a talmid chacham listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the man who wrestled with Yaakov appeared to him as a talmid chacham, and that Esav's angel can disguise himself as one. The worst exile will be that of the erev rav, and the Midrash says that when Esav sits among the tzaddikim in a tallis, only Hashem Himself will cast him down.
-
32:59 The exile of the erev rav today listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says the erev rav will join Gog and Magog against Moshiach, and points to events in Jerusalem against the Jews of Meah Shearim. The exile of the erev rav is harder because they are our brothers; Yaakov prayed to be saved from his brother, the talmid chacham Esav, and the question is how to tell who is who.
-
36:35 Follow the earlier shepherds; the sense of smell listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings Shir HaShirim as Chazal read it: in the confusion of exile, follow the tracks of the flock, the ways of earlier generations. The test is whether one introduces nothing new; he brings the Chasam Sofer's battle against Mendelssohn's innovations, R' Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld's opposition to the new Chief Rabbinate, and explains that the tzaddikim had a sense of smell like the one Havdalah needs.
-
42:29 Where the Torah shows who Esav is listed in the guide
The Mashgiach notes that a reader of the plain pesukim could think Esav was not so bad; a cheder boy knows he was a rasha only from his rebbe. But at the end of this parsha, as Rashi brings from Chazal, the Torah shows openly the mamzerus among Esav's descendants, and there one can recognize who Esav is.
-
47:48 Yaakov's gift and the captured souls listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Midrash that Yaakov was pained at sending a gift to Esav, since his animals had Jewish souls; before the tikkun many Jewish souls are captured by Esav. He compares Eliyahu's bull at Carmel, and brings the Midrash of an am ha'aretz who read 'minchah yashivu' as the return of Yaakov's gifts, explaining that his soul's root was among those gifts.
-
53:42 Shechem: milah without becoming a Jew listed in the guide
The Mashgiach turns to the episode of Shechem: a milah that is not done to become a Jew is no milah. From the Mishnah in Nedarim he explains that orlah is only an outer klipah on a Jew, while a non-Jew remains an arel even after cutting; a ger means becoming a proper Jew.
-
57:02 The alufim of Esav and when to fight listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that saying the names of the alufim of Esav returns Esav to his root, where he has no existence, which is a preparation for Chanukah. He sets the rule that one fights only when Yiddishkeit is at stake, as the Chashmonaim did, and closes by urging his listeners to hold on to the parsha, connect to the tzaddikim, and stand firm in emunah against the erev rav.
The shiur, written up
Midrash and Zohar on Yaakov's submission
The Mashgiach opens with an apparent contradiction. The Midrash criticizes Yaakov for submitting to Esav: because he called Esav 'my master' eight times, eight kings reigned in Edom before Israel had a king. Yet the Ramban writes that the Sages always learned from this parsha how to conduct themselves with Esav, namely by submitting. a,b
The Chiddushei HaRim answers that the Torah has four layers, pshat, remez, drash and sod, all true and fitting over one another like garments. By drash, the level of the Midrash, Yaakov need not have submitted; by sod, the level of the Zohar, he had to. Only since the sin of Adam HaRishon, before the world's tikkun, can the layers clash, and when Moshiach comes they will be smoothed out. d,c
Prayer and gifts, not war, in exile
Yaakov saw these layers and understood that his submission would bring more benefit than harm, since the kings of Edom had to reign first. So the Tannaim, as the Ramban brings, submitted when they went to plead before the Roman rulers. The Ramban notes that Yaakov prepared a gift, prayer and war; Rabbeinu Bachya adds that in exile only gift and prayer remain, since the Gemara in Kesubos speaks of an oath not to wage war against the nations. b,e,f
A test of emunas chachamim
The Mashgiach applies this to the recent dispute over Russia's oppression of its Jews. The gedolim held one should submit, through shtadlanus, tefillah and Tehillim; others, whom he likens to those who opposed R' Yochanan ben Zakkai, chose confrontation, and they seemed to succeed when Russia let Jews leave. He calls this a test of emunas chachamim, citing 'they believed in Hashem and in Moshe His servant'. g
The Maharal on Rachel's plea
The Mashgiach traces this to the Maharal in Netzach Yisrael, who brings the Midrash: when Hashem said He exiled the Jews for idolatry, Rachel pleaded that she, flesh and blood, had not been jealous of her sister Leah and had given her the signs Yaakov gave her; why then is Hashem jealous of idols? Hashem answered that she should hold back her weeping, for the children will return. i,j,k
The Maharal asks what her argument achieved, and answers that Rachel understood it was not yet the time of tikkun. Had Yaakov married her first, Yosef would have been the firstborn and the exile avoided, but she knew the contradictions must first be smoothed out through exile and the conflict between Yehudah and Yosef. The Jews' idolatry came not from their essence but from the state of the world. i
Causing sin is worse than killing
One must therefore reflect carefully and walk a straight line, the Mashgiach says. Russia lets Jews out, yet many have left Yiddishkeit, and causing sin is worse than killing. When Napoleon promised freedom, the Baal HaTanya worked for Russia's victory, preferring that Jews suffer under the Czar rather than decline spiritually. Who was right will be known only when Moshiach comes, for Heaven measures by that rule.
False prophets with true signs
The Mashgiach speaks of the war of faith in Eretz Yisrael; as the Chofetz Chaim said, the masses cannot be blamed, for they are dragged by erev rav leaders. Before Moshiach, he cites, Eliyahu's scene at Carmel will be reversed and fire will descend on Baal's altar. The Chiddushei HaRim reads the passuk of a prophet whose sign comes true this way: false prophets of foreign ideas will show signs, and a Jew must cover his eyes, say Shema and hold to emunah. d,l
Esav's angel as a talmid chacham
The man who wrestled with Yaakov, as Rashi brings, appeared to him as a talmid chacham; this was Esav's angel, who can pose as one. The Tikkunim say the hardest exile will be that of the erev rav, carrying Amalek's power. The Midrash says Esav will sit among the tzaddikim wrapped in a tallis, and no one will remove him until Hashem Himself casts him down, as the passuk in Ovadiah says. m,n,o
The exile of the erev rav today
Before Moshiach, the Mashgiach says, the erev rav will join Gog and Magog against him. He points to threats in Jerusalem against the Jews of Meah Shearim, and says this exile is harder because they are our brothers. So Yaakov prayed to be saved from his brother Esav, the talmid chacham. How then can one tell who is genuine?
Follow the earlier shepherds
Shlomo HaMelech already gave guidance. In Shir HaShirim, as Chazal explain, Knesses Yisrael asks how to live in exile, and Hashem answers: if you do not know, follow the tracks of the flock, the ways of earlier generations. The test is whether a person introduces nothing new. The Chasam Sofer set the rule that anything new is forbidden by the Torah against the reformers of his day, among them Mendelssohn, who looked traditional but led many astray. p
The great tzaddikim had a sense of smell, which the Gemara links to Moshiach. R' Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, of whom the Sanzer Rav foretold he would be king of Jerusalem, fought the new Chief Rabbinate. One need not be a great scholar, the Mashgiach says, only know that the new is forbidden; and Havdalah, separating holy from mundane, requires smell. q
Where the Torah shows who Esav is
One might think Esav was not so bad, the Mashgiach says; reading the pesukim of the sold birthright alone, a critic finds no explicit condemnation, and a cheder boy knows Esav was a rasha only because his rebbe told him. But at the end of this parsha, as Rashi brings from Chazal, the Torah openly shows the immorality and mamzerus among Esav's descendants. There one can recognize clearly who Esav is. r,s
Yaakov's gift and the captured souls
On the passuk 'the gift passed before him', the Midrash says Yaakov was pained at sending a gift to Esav. His animals had Jewish souls, and before the tikkun many Jewish souls are captured by Esav, like children from Tehran and Teiman, until they return. The Mashgiach compares the bull assigned to Baal at Carmel, which refused until Eliyahu persuaded it. t,u
He then brings the Midrash of an am ha'aretz who taught that the kings of Tarshish 'will return a gift' means they will return Yaakov's gifts, and the Sage said he would expound it publicly. Every Jew innovates Torah from his soul's root, the Mashgiach explains, and this am ha'aretz's soul came from those sent to Esav, only temporarily in Esav's camp. v
Shechem: milah without becoming a Jew
The alufim of Esav and when to fight
The parsha ends with the alufim of Esav. The Mashgiach cites a Chassidic sefer that saying their names nullifies Esav's power, and explains that everything exists only through its root in the Torah, where Esav has no existence; reading the names returns him there. This is a preparation for Chanukah.
He sets the rule: one fights when Yiddishkeit is threatened, as the Chashmonaim fought the Hellenizers, not against the nations. He closes by urging his listeners to hold on to this parsha, connect to the earlier tzaddikim and to today's people of mesiras nefesh, and stand firm in emunah while the erev rav judges who is a Jew.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 2:36 The Midrash's criticism of Yaakov and the Ramban's lesson from him are both true: one speaks by drash, the other by sod.
- 4:40 Since the sin of Adam HaRishon, before the world of tikkun, the parts of Torah can seem to contradict each other; with Moshiach the contradictions will be smoothed out.
- 9:36 In the time of exile the way toward the nations is prayer and gifts, not war, because of the oath not to rebel against them.
- 27:55 Before Moshiach the erev rav will appear as talmidei chachamim and even show signs, and a Jew must hold fast to emunah regardless.
- 37:53 The test of who is genuine is whether he follows the ways of the earlier generations, as the Chasam Sofer taught that anything new is forbidden by the Torah.
- 58:41 War is warranted only when Yiddishkeit itself is at stake, as the Chashmonaim fought the Hellenizers, not when it concerns the nations.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:22 How can the Midrash criticize Yaakov for submitting to Esav when Chazal learned from him how to deal with Esav?
Answer: 2:36 The Midrash speaks by drash, by which he need not have submitted; by sod he had to, and Yaakov saw that this would bring more benefit than harm.
-
Question: 17:43 Why did Hashem accept Rachel's plea when the exile came because of idolatry?
Answer: 17:58 Rachel understood that it was not yet the time of tikkun, that contradictions must be smoothed out through exile, and that the sins came from the state of the world, not from the Jews' essence.
-
Question: 11:48 If the militants' methods with Russia seemed to succeed, were the gedolim wrong?
Answer: 21:50 Many who left Russia left Yiddishkeit, and causing sin is worse than killing; Heaven measures by other standards, and only when Moshiach comes will it be known who was right.
-
Question: 36:29 How can one tell whether a talmid chacham is from the side of holiness or from the erev rav?
Answer: 36:35 Shlomo HaMelech's guidance: follow the tracks of the flock; whoever introduces nothing new and conducts himself as the earlier generations did is genuine.
-
Question: 52:11 Why could an am ha'aretz produce such a deep chiddush on 'minchah yashivu'?
Answer: 52:20 Every Jew innovates Torah according to his soul's root, and this am ha'aretz's soul came from the souls Yaakov sent to Esav as a gift.
-
Question: 58:37 When is war warranted and when not?
Answer: 58:41 When it is against Yiddishkeit and the soul, one must fight, as the Chashmonaim did against the Hellenizers; when it concerns the nations, one must not, because of the oath.
Stories
-
22:39 The Baal HaTanya and Napoleon
During Napoleon's war, many hoped he would win, since he promised freedom and Jews suffered under the Russian yoke. The Baal HaTanya, however, prayed and worked with great effort for Russia to win, with mesiras nefesh. He said that if Napoleon won it would be good for Jews materially but bring a great spiritual decline, and he preferred that Jews suffer under the Czar while their spiritual level did not fall.
In the story: Napoleon, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi)
-
40:55 R' Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld and the Sanzer Rav
R' Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld waged a great battle against the new Chief Rabbinate in Jerusalem and did not recognize it, although the world considered its head a fine Jew. As a bochur in Sanz, the Sanzer Rav said of him that he would be king of Jerusalem, and later he became the Rav of Jerusalem. The Mashgiach says that had his way been followed, Jerusalem would have stayed holy as it should be.
In the story: Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz)
Insights
- 3:33 The Midrash's criticism of Yaakov and Chazal's lesson from him are not a contradiction but two layers of Torah, drash and sod, worn like garments one over another; they clash only because the world has not yet reached its tikkun since Adam's sin.
- 18:01 Rachel's merit before Hashem was not only that she gave Leah the signs, but that she understood exile and its contradictions are needed before the tikkun, and that the Jews' sins come from the state of the world rather than from their essence.
- 29:39 Esav's angel appeared to Yaakov as a talmid chacham, and so the final exile is that of the erev rav, who can bring proofs no one can refute; only Hashem Himself can unmask him.
- 52:29 The am ha'aretz could innovate the reading of 'minchah yashivu' because his own soul came from the souls sent to Esav in Yaakov's gift, and he was only temporarily in Esav's camp.
- 39:17 Havdalah, the separation between holy and mundane, requires a sense of smell; so too the tzaddikim who could tell holy from unholy were those with a 'chush rei'ach', a sign associated with Moshiach.
- 57:34 Reading the names of the alufim of Esav brings Esav back to his root in the Torah, where he has no existence of his own, and so nullifies his power; this is a preparation for Chanukah.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 9:36 The Mashgiach says that in exile the way to deal with the nations is prayer and gifts, not war.
- 28:11 The Mashgiach says that even when signs seem to favor false ideas, a Jew must cover his eyes, say Shema, and hold to emunah.
- 41:50 The Mashgiach says one need not be a great talmid chacham; one need only know that anything new is forbidden by the Torah and not be swayed by the problems in the air.
- 58:49 The Mashgiach says one should fight only when Yiddishkeit is at stake, not over matters concerning the nations.
- 1:00:48 The Mashgiach urges holding on to the parsha, drawing strength from it, and connecting oneself to the tzaddikim of earlier generations and those with mesiras nefesh today.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Eliyahu HaNavi, Esav, Haman, Leah Imeinu, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moses Mendelssohn, Napoleon, Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai, Rabbeinu Bachya, Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld, Rachel Imeinu, Shlomo HaMelech, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Chasam Sofer, the Chiddushei HaRim, the Chofetz Chaim, the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz), the Maharal of Prague, the Ramban, Yaakov Avinu
Terms אמונת חכמים, הכנעה, חוש הריח, עולם התיקון, עקבתא דמשיחא, ערב רב, עשו, פרד"ס