Shir Hashirim
Catalog entry: Shir Hashirim no. 7 Yiddish 41 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the file name.
Listen
About this shiur
On 'I am black but beautiful', the Mashgiach explains that a Jew's sins are only an outer stain while his essence stays good, and that on Shabbos he returns to that essence and feels it.
The Mashgiach explains Shir HaShirim 1:5-6: Klal Yisroel tells the nations that its blackness is only a sunburn, not its nature. Through the Midrash brought by Rashi, black in its own deeds but beautiful in the deeds of the Avos, he explains that a Jew is good in essence and his sins are incidental, which is why teshuvah helps him; he brings Malachi, that Hashem loves Yaakov and hates Esav even when their deeds look alike. A second Midrash reads the verse as black on weekdays and beautiful on Shabbos. The Mashgiach describes Shabbos as the Jew's soul, digresses on Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch and reads his English essay on Shabbos, and then says a Jew must work all week to taste Shabbos, which is a day of love, a taste of Olam Haba and a return to the soul's source where sin does not reach. He ends with the Ba'al Shem Tov's custom of saying Hodu before Shabbos and with teshuvah on Erev Shabbos.
Topics: Shir HaShirim · Kedushas Shabbos · The Pintele Yid: The Inner Point of Every Jew · Teshuvah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Black but beautiful: only a sunburn listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the verses: Klal Yisroel tells the nations, the 'daughters of Jerusalem', that it is black like the tents of Kedar but beautiful like the curtains of Shlomo, and that its blackness is only a sunburn. He adds that in the future Jerusalem will be the metropolis to which the other nations submit.
-
4:12 Good in essence, sinful only incidentally listed in the guide
From the Midrash in Rashi, black in my deeds and beautiful in my fathers' deeds, the Mashgiach explains that like begets like: a Jew coming from the Avos is good in essence, so teshuvah helps him, unlike a gentile. He brings Malachi, that Hashem loves Yaakov and hates Esav even when their deeds look alike.
-
9:21 Black on weekdays, beautiful on Shabbos listed in the guide
A second Midrash reads the verse as black during the week and beautiful on Shabbos. The Mashgiach compares Shabbos to an oasis after the desert, calls it the soul of the Jew, and brings the Midrash that Shabbos had no partner until Klal Yisroel was given to it.
-
14:11 Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch and the Haskalah
Before reading Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch's essay on Shabbos, the Mashgiach describes the destruction the Haskalah caused in Germany, how Rabbi Hirsch brought German Jews back, and why he wrote in German, ending with his answer to a maskil who criticized him for it.
-
20:40 Reading Rabbi Hirsch's essay on Shabbos
The Mashgiach reads in English from Rabbi Hirsch's essay: taking Shabbos from a Jew robs him of his richest jewel, and Shabbos, given to children, stays with them when all else fails. He comments that it is still pale, but a very good attempt to describe what Shabbos means to a Jew.
-
25:18 A gift from the treasury: tasting Shabbos
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that Hashem told Moshe He has a good gift in His treasury called Shabbos and to let the Jews know it, and Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin's word that one who keeps Shabbos without toiling for it will sit in Gan Eden like a block. He describes a Shabbos table of Torah and zemiros, and uses his own upset stomach, when good apple juice tasted bitter, to show why one must prepare all week.
-
29:46 Shabbos: day of love and return to the source listed in the guide
Shabbos is the root of all pleasure and the source of Olam Haba; the Ramban explains there is no sin-offering on Shabbos because it is a day of love, which covers all sins. The Mashgiach explains that the soul is hewn from the Kisei HaKavod and on Shabbos returns there, to the world of Klal Yisroel that sin does not reach, which ties the two Midrashim together.
-
35:13 Hodu before Shabbos and teshuvah on Erev Shabbos listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the Ba'al Shem Tov's institution of saying Hodu before Shabbos: the four who must thank Hashem are like a Jew leaving the prison, sickness, desert and stormy sea of the weekdays. He closes with the Gemara on checking one's garments on Erev Shabbos, read as checking one's betrayals, and with teshuvah and mikveh before Shabbos.
The shiur, written up
Black but beautiful: only a sunburn
The Mashgiach explains Shir HaShirim 1:5: Klal Yisroel speaks to the nations, called 'daughters of Jerusalem' as small towns are the daughters of a city. It is black like the tents of Kedar, but beautiful like the curtains of Shlomo. The next verse explains that the sun burned it: the blackness is external and temporary, not its nature. a,b
Good in essence, sinful only incidentally
Rashi brings the Midrash: black in my own deeds, beautiful in my fathers' deeds. The Mashgiach explains that like begets like; a Jew comes from the Avos and is good in essence, his sins only incidental, like mud washed off. Teshuvah means returning to one's roots, so it helps a Jew, who has good roots, unlike a gentile. c
Black on weekdays, beautiful on Shabbos
Another Midrash reads the verse as black on weekdays and beautiful on Shabbos. The Mashgiach compares Shabbos to an oasis after the desert, where one rests and gathers strength. Shabbos is the Jew's soul and makes him a Jew, as the Midrash relates that Shabbos complained it had no partner and was given Klal Yisroel. g,h
Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch and the Haskalah
To introduce an essay on Shabbos, the Mashgiach describes Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch. The Haskalah began in Germany and caused a terrible destruction; Chassidus saved the Jews of Poland, Galicia and Russia. The Haflaah thanked Hashem for being Rav in Frankfurt, a city of talmidei chachamim, yet some thirty years later Rabbi Hirsch found only thirteen families there keeping Shabbos. i
Knowing they could not be changed at once, he led them to learn Torah while remaining educated professionals, and brought German Jewry back. When a maskil criticized him for writing in German, he answered that his German writings would last while the other's would be lost.
Reading Rabbi Hirsch's essay on Shabbos
The Mashgiach reads from Rabbi Hirsch's English essay, written to urge German Jews to keep Shabbos: taking Shabbos from a Jew robs him of his richest jewel, and it heals wounds and makes the poor rich. Shabbos given to children stays with them when wealth and friends fail. The Mashgiach comments that it is still pale, but a very good attempt.
A gift from the treasury
The Gemara says Hashem told Moshe He has a good gift called Shabbos and to let the Jews know it. Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin said one who keeps Shabbos without toiling to feel it will sit in Gan Eden like a block. One must strive, at a table of divrei Torah and zemiros, not magazines. k
With an upset stomach, the Mashgiach relates, good apple juice tasted bitter to him; a spiritually upset stomach likewise cannot taste Shabbos.
A day of love and return to the source
Hodu before Shabbos and teshuvah
The Ba'al Shem Tov instituted saying Hodu before Shabbos. Tehillim 107 lists those who must thank Hashem: one lost in the desert, the prisoner, the sick and the seafarer. A Jew should feel he is leaving the prison, sickness, desert and stormy sea of the weekdays, and coming to his Father on Shabbos. p
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 1:34 Klal Yisroel's blackness is like a sunburn: external and temporary, not its true nature.
- 5:11 A Jew is good in essence because he comes from the Avos; his sins are incidental, so teshuvah, a return to his roots, helps him.
- 11:19 Shabbos is the soul and life-spirit of a Jew; it is what makes him a Jew.
- 25:50 Hashem gave Shabbos as a gift and wanted the Jews to know what it is; a Jew must work during the week to feel its taste.
- 29:57 Shabbos is a day of love between Hashem and Klal Yisroel, a taste of Olam Haba, and a return to the place the soul was hewn from.
- 35:13 On Shabbos a Jew should feel like one freed from prison, sickness, the desert and the sea, which is why Hodu is said before Shabbos.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 8:19 If Esav is Yaakov's brother and at times their deeds look alike, why does Hashem love Yaakov and hate Esav?
Answer: 9:00 Because Esav is bad in essence and Yaakov good in essence; Yaakov's bad is only incidental and temporary and can be washed off.
-
Question: 30:24 Why is there no sin-offering among the Shabbos offerings, unlike every Yom Tov?
Answer: 30:50 Because Shabbos is a day of mutual love between Hashem and Klal Yisroel, and love covers all sins.
Stories
-
15:55 Frankfurt before and after the Haskalah
The Mashgiach relates that the Haflaah, Rabbi Pinchas Horowitz, wrote in his introduction that he thanked Hashem for becoming Rav in Frankfurt, a city full of talmidei chachamim and a yeshivah. Some thirty years after the Haskalah began to rage, Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch came to Frankfurt and found only thirteen families keeping Shabbos. He brought German Jewry back to emunah.
In the story: the Haflaah (Rabbi Pinchas Horowitz), Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch
-
19:10 Rabbi Hirsch answers a maskil
The maskilim wrote their heretical books in Hebrew, and one of them criticized Rabbi Hirsch for writing his works in German rather than in the eternal language. Rabbi Hirsch answered that his writings in German would remain forever, while the other's writings in the eternal language would be lost. The Mashgiach adds that so it indeed was.
In the story: Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch
-
28:34 The bitter apple juice
The Mashgiach relates that the previous week he had an upset stomach, and was given a glass of apple juice. It tasted bitter to him and he thought it was spoiled, but he was told it was good apple juice. Once his stomach recovered, the same apple juice tasted wonderful. So too, one with a spiritually upset stomach does not know what Shabbos is.
Insights
- 5:14 The proof that a Jew is good in essence is that like begets like: since he comes from the Avos, he is essentially as they were, and his sins are only incidental.
- 6:20 Teshuvah means returning to one's roots; a Jew has good roots to return to, while for a gentile, whose sin is essential, it does not help in the same way.
- 8:40 Hashem's answer to 'is not Esav a brother to Yaakov' is that even when their deeds look alike, Esav is bad in essence and Yaakov good in essence.
- 29:57 Shabbos is not only a taste of Olam Haba: following Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin, it is the fountain from which Olam Haba itself draws.
- 33:00 The word 'Shabbos' means return: on Shabbos the soul goes back to the Kisei HaKavod it was hewn from, where no sin reaches, which unites the two Midrashim on 'black but beautiful'.
- 37:13 Weekdays ('chol') are like sickness ('choleh'), prison, desert and sea; Shabbos is the release for which the four who must give thanks in Hodu thank Hashem.
- 40:05 Checking one's garments ('begadim') on Erev Shabbos is read, in the Slonimer Rebbes' Chassidic interpretation, as checking one's betrayals ('bgidos') against Hashem and doing teshuvah.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 27:14 The Mashgiach says a Jew must toil and try with all his strength to feel what Shabbos is: a Shabbos table with divrei Torah and zemiros, not magazines.
- 29:37 He says one prepares for Shabbos all week, by learning, davening and guarding oneself properly, and then tastes Olam Haba on Shabbos.
- 37:10 He says that when Shabbos comes a Jew should feel freed from the troubles of the week, like one of those who give thanks in Hodu.
- 40:20 He says one must do teshuvah on Erev Shabbos and not enter Shabbos unprepared; the mikveh on Erev Shabbos is a form of teshuvah.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Esav, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Aharon of Karlin (Rabbi Aharon HaGadol), Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch, Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin, Rabbi Yisrael Salanter, Rashi, Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, Rebbe Elimelech of Lizhensk (the Noam Elimelech), the Baal Shem Tov, the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz), the Haflaah (Rabbi Pinchas Horowitz), the Maharal of Prague, the Ramban, the Slonimer Rebbe, Yaakov Avinu
Terms השכלה, זיווג, כסא הכבוד, מעין עולם הבא, מקרה, שבעים אומות