אגרת התניא אודות תפילה; מלוה מלכה

Catalog entry: שיעורים לבחורים no. ⁨6⁩ Pocket Guide p. 52 Yiddish 28 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 28 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach learns the Ba'al HaTanya's letter protesting against those who push away a long davener, tells a true story of a dybbuk driven out by the Shinava Rav, and explains why Yehuda was sent ahead to Goshen and how the Melave Malka inaugurates the new week.

The Mashgiach opens with a letter of the Ba'al HaTanya in Iggeres HaKodesh, written when he heard that people would not let a man who davens at length lead the prayers. Chazal say that prolonging one's tefillah prolongs life, so the Mashgiach calls the claim of having no time a false calculation. The letter explains that in earlier generations Torah was the main avodah, but in the time before Moshiach it is tefillah, which needs contemplation of each word, and it asks for orderly, unhurried davening together. The Mashgiach then sets out the two conditions of a proper story, a known source and a lesson, and tells, through Rabbi Elazar Brizel, how the Shinava Rav freed a girl from a dybbuk, linking it to the Chofetz Chaim's words about our test of emunah. Finally he explains that Yehuda, the root of hodaah, inaugurated Goshen, just as the Melave Malka of Dovid HaMelech inaugurates the week.

Topics: Kavanah in Davening

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 The Ba'al HaTanya's letter on long davening listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach introduces the Iggeres HaKodesh, letters the Ba'al HaTanya sent his chassidim, and reads one written when he heard that a man who davens at length was kept from leading the prayers. He explains the letter's argument from Chazal that prolonging tefillah prolongs life, calls the claim of 'no time' a false calculation, and explains how the chazan's repetition covers one who must leave.

  2. 3:46 Tefillah as the avodah before Moshiach listed in the guide

    Answering the complaint that the chassidim invented a new stringency, the letter explains that the early generations served mainly through Torah while in the time before Moshiach the main avodah is tefillah, requiring slow contemplation in Pesukei DeZimra and the blessings of Shema. The Mashgiach adds that the early great souls could daven briefly because their minds were open and unclouded by sin, and he reads the letter's request for orderly davening together and its rules for choosing chazanim.

  3. 10:01 What makes a true story; dybbukim and emunah

    The Mashgiach sets out two conditions for telling a story, a known source and a lesson, and presents the source of his story, Rabbi Elazar Brizel, who heard it from his father. He describes what was once seen of sinful souls fleeing the angels of destruction into a living person as a dybbuk, and brings the Chofetz Chaim's statement that there would be no more dybbukim because our generation's test is emunah amid hiddenness.

  4. 16:47 The Shinava Rav and the dybbuk Story

    The Mashgiach tells how a girl possessed by a dybbuk was brought to the Shinava Rav's shalosh seudos, where the dybbuk cried out at his holy words, and after Havdalah the gabbai was sent to a certain grave and the girl was healed. He then applies it: many of us carry inner 'dybbukim', forces born of sins that keep us from learning and davening properly, which must be uprooted before Moshiach comes.

  5. 21:12 Yehuda sent to Goshen and the Melave Malka listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach asks why Yaakov sent Yehuda, and not Yissachar or Levi, ahead to Goshen, and explains it through the custom of chanukas habayis: a place is inaugurated with praise of Hashem, and Yehuda is the root of hodaah and of Dovid HaMelech. So too the Melave Malka, the seudah of Dovid HaMelech, inaugurates the coming week, and he closes with blessings that the coming days of darkness in Teves turn to joy.

The shiur, written up

The Ba'al HaTanya's letter on long davening

0:35

The Mashgiach introduces the Iggeres HaKodesh, letters the Ba'al HaTanya sent his chassidim, and reads one written when he heard that a man who davens at length was kept from leading the prayers. Since Chazal say that one who prolongs his tefillah has his days prolonged, the Mashgiach calls the excuse of having no time a false calculation: the one short of time is the one who should daven longer. a,b

Tefillah as the avodah before Moshiach

3:46

To the complaint that the chassidim invent new stringencies, the letter answers that in the early generations Torah was the main avodah, but in the time before Moshiach the main avodah is tefillah. Saying the words, even with their meaning, is not yet davening; it means contemplating each word, which takes time, to awaken the hidden love in every Jew's heart before Shema. a

6:45

The early generations could daven briefly, the Mashgiach explains, because their minds were open, not clouded by sins. The letter then asks that all daven together word by word without idle talk, and that chazanim be chosen from those who daven at a measured pace. a

What makes a true story; dybbukim and emunah

10:25

Before his story, the Mashgiach lays down two conditions for telling one: a known source, since many invented stories circulate, and a lesson to take away. His source is Rabbi Elazar Brizel of Yerushalayim, a gadol in Torah and Chassidus, who heard it from his father, who was present.

14:09

In earlier times, the Mashgiach explains, sinful souls fleeing the angels of destruction entered living people as dybbukim and spoke from them. When such a case occurred in the Chofetz Chaim's time, he said there would be no more dybbukim: seeing such things makes belief easy, while our generation's test is emunah when nothing is seen.

The Shinava Rav and the dybbuk

16:57

A girl possessed by a dybbuk was brought to the Shinava Rav's shalosh seudos. When he began the zemiros, the dybbuk cried out that it burned; after Havdalah the Mashgiach sent the gabbai to a certain grave, and the girl was healed. Later the Shinava Rav said he had driven out no dybbuk.

19:58

The Mashgiach adds that many of us carry inner dybbukim, forces born of sins that keep one from learning and davening properly, and they must be uprooted before Moshiach comes.

Yehuda sent to Goshen and the Melave Malka

21:36

The Mashgiach asks why Yaakov sent Yehuda ahead to Goshen, and not Yissachar or Levi, who are closer to Torah. A new house is inaugurated, some with seven days of learning, as Rabbi Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz once arranged, others with a seudah and songs of praise. Mitzrayim needed such inauguration, and Yehuda, named for Leah's thanks to Hashem, inaugurates with praise, which drives out harmful forces. d,e

25:44

From Yehuda comes Dovid HaMelech, author of Tehillim, so the Melave Malka, the seudah of Dovid, inaugurates the week. This week, with the days of darkness in Teves, especially needs it, and the Mashgiach blesses that the fast become joy for the house of Yehuda, as the passuk in Zechariah says. g

Sources

Torah

  1. d Bereishis 46:28 text index In the write-up: 21:36
  2. e Bereishis 29:35 text index In the write-up: 21:36

Nevi'im

  1. g Zechariah 8:19 text index In the write-up: 25:44

Talmud Bavli

  1. b apparently Berachos 54b index In the write-up: 0:35
  2. c apparently Rosh Hashanah 35a 3:09 index
  3. f apparently Berachos 7b 25:04 index

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a apparently Tanya, Iggeres HaKodesh 1 index In the write-up: 0:35, 3:46, 6:45

Key points

  1. 1:03 The Ba'al HaTanya was deeply pained to hear that a man who davens at length was kept from leading the prayers, since Chazal say that prolonging tefillah prolongs life.
  2. 4:02 In earlier generations Torah was the main avodah; in the time before Moshiach the main avodah is tefillah.
  3. 5:28 Davening means contemplating each word, which can only be done slowly, so as to awaken the hidden love in every Jew's heart before Shema.
  4. 10:25 A story worth telling needs two things: a known source, so one knows it is true, and a lesson one can take away.
  5. 15:34 The Chofetz Chaim said there would be no more dybbukim, since the test of the last generation before Moshiach is to believe without seeing.
  6. 23:24 Yehuda, named for thanking Hashem, was sent to inaugurate Goshen, and the Melave Malka, the seudah of Dovid HaMelech, likewise inaugurates the new week with songs of praise.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 1:21 Why was the Ba'al HaTanya so pained that a long davener was kept from leading the prayers?

    Answer: 1:33 Because Chazal say that prolonging tefillah prolongs life, so cutting short another's davening cuts short his life.

  2. Question: 3:46 Why do the chassidim daven at length, if the early generations did not make it their main avodah?

    Answer: 4:02 In earlier generations Torah was the main avodah, but in the time before Moshiach the main avodah is tefillah.

  3. Question: 15:34 Why did the Chofetz Chaim say there would be no more dybbukim?

    Answer: 15:49 Seeing such things makes belief easy, while the test of the generation before Moshiach is to believe when nothing is seen.

  4. Question: 23:43 Why did Yaakov send Yehuda to Goshen, and not Yissachar or Levi, who are more connected to Torah?

    Answer: 24:00 Because a place is inaugurated by praising Hashem with songs, and Yehuda is named for hodaah.

Stories

  1. 16:50 The Shinava Rav and the dybbuk at shalosh seudos

    Rabbi Elazar Brizel's father was in Shinava for a Shabbos when a woman came with a daughter possessed by a dybbuk that spoke from her and made her suffer. She was told to bring her to the Shinava Rav's shalosh seudos, a time of great favor; Rabbi Brizel's father arrived late, found no seat in the dark, and sat on a window sill by the women's section. When the Shinava Rav began the zemiros, the dybbuk cried out that it burned and hurt, unable to bear his holy words. After Havdalah the Shinava Rav sent the gabbai with directions to a certain grave in the cemetery; there was such a scream that Rabbi Brizel's father fell from the window, and the girl became well. When another Rav later said he had heard the Shinava Rav drove out a dybbuk, the Shinava Rav answered that he had driven out no dybbuk, perhaps the gabbai had.

    In the story: Rabbi Elazar Brizel, Rabbi Yechezkel of Shinova (the Divrei Yechezkel)

Insights

  1. 2:02 The Mashgiach calls 'I have no time, so I daven quickly' a false calculation: since prolonging tefillah prolongs life, the one short of time is precisely the one who should daven at length.
  2. 6:31 What allowed early generations to daven briefly was not the size of their minds but their openness: a mind not clouded by sins can daven in a moment.
  3. 16:00 The end of dybbukim in the Chofetz Chaim's time fits the generation's task: when such things are seen, believing is easy, while the mitzvah of our generation is emunah amid hiddenness.
  4. 19:56 Though outward dybbukim ceased, the Mashgiach says many people carry inner ones: forces created by sins that block learning, davening and good middos.
  5. 23:47 Yehuda rather than Yissachar or Levi was sent to prepare Goshen because a place is inaugurated with praise of Hashem, which drives out the opposing forces, and Yehuda's name comes from hodaah.
  6. 25:51 The Melave Malka is the chanukas habayis of the week: as the seudah of Dovid HaMelech, a descendant of Yehuda, its songs of praise drive out the accusers of the weekday.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 10:25 The Mashgiach says a story should be told only when its source is known and one can take a lesson from it for one's own level.
  2. 20:50 The Mashgiach says one must strengthen oneself and uproot the inner 'dybbukim' so as not to greet Moshiach in shame.
  3. 26:17 The Mashgiach says the new week should begin with the Melave Malka, with Torah, thanks and songs of praise to Hashem.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Dovid HaMelech, Leah Imeinu, Rabbi Elazar Brizel, Rabbi Elchonon Wasserman, Rabbi Yechezkel of Shinova (the Divrei Yechezkel), Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Chofetz Chaim, the Stoliner Rebbe, Yaakov Avinu, Yehudah (son of Yaakov)

Terms אהבה מסותרת, דיבוק, הודאה, המאריך בתפילתו, הסתר פנים, התבוננות, חנוכת הבית, מלאכי חבלה, מלוה מלכה, עקבתא דמשיחא, עשרה בטבת, פסוקי דזמרה, שליח ציבור, שלש סעודות

Report an error on this page