וואס זאל מען טוען אז עס דאווענט זיך נישט? לערנט זיך נישט?

Catalog entry: שיעורים לבחורים no. ⁨19⁩ Pocket Guide p. 52 Yiddish 31 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 31 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains that when learning or davening does not go, one must look for the cause, as a doctor does, and that purity, yiras shamayim and preparation are the vessel through which the light of Torah and tefillah comes.

The Mashgiach opens with the question: eating comes by itself and sleeping comes by itself, so why does learning and davening not come? He has spoken to the bachurim about negel vasser, mikvah and preparing for davening, and was asked why he does not speak more about learning. He answers that the rebbeim already speak about learning, and that a doctor treating a patient with no appetite looks for the cause rather than telling him to eat. Learning needs preparation and purity. He brings the Ramchal's Derech Hashem: the words of Torah are only a case for its inner light, which comes only to one who learns with yiras shamayim. Reb Aharon of Karlin said mikvah brings what no mitzvah brings, and the Ohr HaChaim teaches that a pure person keeps the mitzvos by nature. After stories of long, warm davening, he concludes that davening and learning depend on each other, and urges the bachurim to use their golden years.

Topics: Torah Lishmah and Hasmadah · Tumah, Taharah and Mikveh · Yiras Shamayim · The Power of Tefilah · Bachurim in Yeshivah

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Why doesn't learning come by itself? listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach asks why eating and sleeping come by themselves but learning and davening do not. He recalls his talks on negel vasser, mikvah and preparing for davening, and the question why he does not speak more about learning, since Talmud Torah outweighs everything; Torah is the mind and tefillah the heart, and both must be healthy.

  2. 4:02 The doctor looks for the cause listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach answers that the rebbeim and mashgichim already speak about learning, while these matters are rarely discussed. He compares a weak boy without appetite: the doctor does not tell him to eat but searches for the infection or the bad air causing it. So too, when learning does not go, prizes and honor are not the real answer.

  3. 8:04 Torah needs purity and preparation listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach speaks of washing the hands after touching covered places before learning, and says one who does not go to mikvah when he needs to will not merit true Torah. Torah is not an ordinary wisdom; Klal Yisroel had to prepare to receive it. He introduces the Ramchal's Derech Hashem with a mashal of an expensive watch and its case.

  4. 12:22 The Derech Hashem: conditions for learning listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach learns the Derech Hashem: the words of Torah, even a sugya like 'two holding a tallis', are a case for great lights that come down only when one learns with yiras shamayim; knowledge alone is like science. He contrasts a medical student reclining with his feet on the table with one who learns Gemara that way, and explains that learning without awe is like reading a letter, yet Torah itself still sanctifies a little over time.

  5. 19:09 Why the kallah runs away listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach asks why the Torah, the kallah, runs away from a person. He brings Reb Aharon of Karlin, that mikvah is not a mitzvah but what it brings no mitzvah can bring, and the Ohr HaChaim on 'lalleches bahem', that one who is pure and holy keeps the mitzvos by nature. The neshama wants to learn and daven; impurity, lashon hara and idle talk before davening are the barrier.

  6. 22:36 Preparation, and how Jews once davened listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach stresses that speaking of negel vasser, mikvah and a clean body is speaking about Torah itself. He regrets that many bachurim do not use the chance to daven with the shul on Shabbos, and tells of a stranger at Reb Aharon of Karlin's minyan and of the Karliner shtiebel on Orchard Street, where a two-hour weekday Shacharis still felt rushed.

  7. 27:13 Davening and learning together; using the golden years listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach returns to the doctor: if the neshama wants to daven and learn, one must ask what is contaminating the body. Davening and learning depend on each other, as the Mishnah Berurah brings, and a tzaddik compared asking which is more important to asking a child whom he loves more. He ends by urging the bachurim to use their precious years and to purify themselves to serve Hashem.

The shiur, written up

Why doesn't learning come by itself?

0:09

The Mashgiach opens with a question: eating comes by itself and sleeping comes by itself, so why do learning and davening not? He recalls his recent talks on negel vasser, mikvah and cleansing oneself before davening, and that he was asked why he does not speak more about learning, since Talmud Torah outweighs everything. On whether Torah or tefillah is greater, he says it is not our concern: Torah is the mind, tefillah the heart, and a person must be healthy in both. a

The doctor looks for the cause

4:29

He answers that the rebbeim and mashgichim already speak about learning, while these matters are hardly discussed. A boy who wastes away with no appetite is taken to a doctor, who will not tell him to eat meat and bread; he looks for the infection or the blocked chimney behind it. So too, when learning does not go, one must ask why. Yeshivos give tests, prizes and honor, but that is not truly learning.

Torah needs purity and preparation

9:19

One who scratches his head while thinking over a sugya, the Mashgiach says, must wash his hands, and one who needs mikvah and does not go will not merit Torah according to truth. Torah is not an ordinary wisdom; one cannot learn it without the preparations it needs, just as Klal Yisroel had to prepare to receive it. He introduces the Ramchal's Derech Hashem with a mashal: a costly watch comes in a gold case, yet the case does not show its worth, which lies in the works inside. b

The Derech Hashem: conditions for learning

12:28

The words of Tanach and Gemara, the Mashgiach explains from the Derech Hashem, are a case prepared to receive holy lights, and learning needs conditions: above all, yiras shamayim while learning, and being a proper Jew at all times. Even a sugya like two holding a tallis, with the claims of a thief, carries the lights of Torah. The knowledge alone is like science; it is only a vessel for the light. b,c

16:04

A medical student may study with his feet on the table and still become a great doctor, but one who learns Gemara that way will draw down nothing; he must sit with yiras shamayim. Without it, learning is like reading a letter. Still, the words of Torah sanctify somewhat on their own, so over a long time a little holiness enters; one who learns with awe is something else entirely. b

Why the kallah runs away

19:22

Why, the Mashgiach asks, does the Torah, the kallah, run away from a person? Reb Aharon of Karlin said mikvah is not a mitzvah, but what it brings no mitzvah can bring: when one purifies himself, holiness comes running and learning and davening go. The Ohr HaChaim on 'lalleches bahem' says one who is pure keeps the mitzvos by nature, for the neshama wants to learn and daven; impurity, lashon hara and idle talk before davening are the barrier. d,e

Preparation, and how Jews once davened

22:40

Speaking of negel vasser, mikvah and a clean body, the Mashgiach stresses, is speaking about Torah, since it is Torah's preparation. He regrets that many bachurim do not use the chance to daven with the shul on Shabbos, a davening visitors praise as warm and unhurried.

24:54

He tells of a stranger at Reb Aharon of Karlin's minyan who waited through Baruch She'amar, davened alone up to Shemoneh Esrei, and only then heard the chazzan finish the brachah. In the Karliner shtiebel on Orchard Street, weekday Shacharis lasted two hours, and Ephraim Tenenbaum still asked why they rushed, when every word is sweet as honey.

Davening and learning together

27:25

If the neshama wants to daven and learn, the Mashgiach says, one must go to the doctor and ask what is contaminating the body. Davening and learning depend on each other; as the Mishnah Berurah brings, as one davens in the morning so one learns all day. A tzaddik compared asking which matters more to asking a child whether he loves his father or mother more. f

30:40

He ends by urging the bachurim, free of parnassah, to use these precious years, and if learning and davening do not go, to repair and sanctify themselves.

Sources

Torah

  1. d Vayikra 18:4-5 text index In the write-up: 19:22
  2. h Devarim 30:14 29:04 text index

Mishnah

  1. a Peah 1:1 text index In the write-up: 0:09

Talmud Bavli

  1. c Bava Metzia 2a text index In the write-up: 12:28

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. b apparently Derech Hashem 4:2 index In the write-up: 9:19, 12:28, 16:04
  2. e apparently Ohr HaChaim on Vayikra 18:4 index In the write-up: 19:22
  3. f Mishnah Berurah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 27:25
  4. g Yaaros Devash (place not identified) 28:08 index

Key points

  1. 5:13 When learning or davening does not go, one must look for its cause, as a doctor looks for the cause of a lost appetite.
  2. 22:40 Purity, washing the hands, mikvah and preparing oneself are the preparation for Torah, not side matters.
  3. 12:28 According to the Derech Hashem, the words of Torah are a vessel for its holy light, which comes down only when one learns with yiras shamayim.
  4. 21:56 The neshama wants to learn and daven; only barriers such as impurity and forbidden speech hold it back.
  5. 27:51 Davening and learning depend on each other: as one davens in the morning, so one learns through the day.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 2:13 Since Talmud Torah outweighs everything, why does the Mashgiach not speak more to the bachurim about learning?

    Answer: 4:21 The rebbeim and mashgichim in yeshiva already speak about learning constantly, while purity and preparation are rarely discussed, and they are what make learning succeed.

  2. Question: 3:00 Which is greater, Torah or tefillah?

    Answer: 3:12 That is not our concern: Torah is the mind and tefillah the heart, and asking which matters more is like asking whether one should be healthy in the body or the heart.

  3. Question: 6:43 What should one do when learning does not go?

    Answer: 6:46 Look for the cause, as a doctor does: learning needs purity and preparation, and without them one will not merit true Torah.

  4. Question: 19:14 Why does the Torah, the kallah, run away from a person?

    Answer: 20:19 Because he is not purified; when one purifies himself holiness comes to him and then learning and davening go, as Reb Aharon of Karlin said of mikvah.

  5. Question: 27:29 If the neshama wants to daven and learn, why does it not happen?

    Answer: 29:44 Something is contaminating the body, such as forbidden speech or impure food, drink or places; one must find it and repair one's deeds.

Stories

  1. 24:54 The stranger at Reb Aharon of Karlin's minyan

    A stranger came to Reb Aharon of Karlin's minyan when they began Baruch She'amar. He waited for the chazzan to finish the brachah, but the chazzan did not. Thinking the chazzan was not heard, he davened on alone up to Shemoneh Esrei and was still waiting, until it suddenly grew quiet and the chazzan concluded the brachah, so long had Baruch She'amar taken.

    In the story: Rabbi Aharon of Karlin (Rabbi Aharon HaGadol)

  2. 26:00 The Karliner shtiebel on Orchard Street

    An older Jew the Mashgiach davened with used to tell about a Karliner shtiebel on Orchard Street on the East Side, fifty to seventy years earlier, where immigrants gathered to daven and the Rebbe would send them letters of chizuk. There they davened weekday Shacharis for about two hours, and after davening Ephraim Tenenbaum asked why they had rushed so today, since two hours was not enough when every word is sweet as honey.

    In the story: Ephraim Tenenbaum

  3. 28:28 Davening or learning: which is more important?

    Someone once asked a tzaddik what is more important, davening or learning. The tzaddik answered that if one asks a small child whom he loves more, his father or his mother, the child says he loves each one more. Both are needed: they are the heart and the mind.

Insights

  1. 5:32 A lack of desire to learn is like a lack of appetite: a symptom of a deeper cause, so incentives that only push a person to learn miss the point, just as a doctor would not simply tell such a patient to eat.
  2. 11:48 The words of Torah are like the gold case of a costly watch: the case does not show the value, which lies in the inner works; so too the knowledge of a sugya is only a vessel for the light within it.
  3. 13:36 Even a Gemara about a thief's claims carries the light of Torah, so the difference between Torah and science is not the subject matter but whether the light comes down through the learner.
  4. 20:15 Reb Aharon of Karlin's saying: mikvah is not a mitzvah, yet what it brings no mitzvah can bring, because when one purifies himself holiness comes running to him, and then learning and davening go.
  5. 22:40 Speaking about negel vasser, mikvah and a clean body is not speaking about side matters but about Torah itself, since they are its preparation.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 23:22 The Mashgiach says the first step is to wash negel vasser properly, then to purify oneself and learn before davening.
  2. 9:51 He says one who scratches his head or touches covered places while learning must wash his hands.
  3. 16:02 He says one must sit and learn with yiras shamayim, not lightheadedly or reclining.
  4. 30:40 He urges the bachurim to use their precious years, free of parnassah worries, for learning and davening.
  5. 31:02 When learning and davening do not go, he says one must look for the lack, repair one's deeds and sanctify oneself.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Ephraim Tenenbaum, Rabbi Aharon of Karlin (Rabbi Aharon HaGadol), the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, the Ramchal (Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto)

Terms ברוך שאמר, השפעה, חלק אלוק ממעל, טהרה, יראת שמים, נעגל וואסער, קלות ראש, רבונו של עולם, תלמוד תורה כנגד כולם

Report an error on this page