פרקי אבות
פרק קנין תורה: גדלות הצדיקים' ביאור ענין תורה לשמה וגודל גן עדן של לומד תורה לשמה
Catalog entry: שונות no. 2 Pocket Guide p. 34 תשל"ו (1975–76) Yiddish 56 min
Listen
About this shiur
On the opening Mishnah of Avos, the Mashgiach traces the chain of the Torah from Moshe at Sinai to the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah and on to our own weak generation of 'broken luchos', explaining what each link teaches and how the Torah is held today.
The Mashgiach opens with Avos 1:1 and explains why the Oral Torah could not be written: it is inscribed on the heart and mouth of the Jew, a private code of Hashem and His people. With the Bartenura he explains why Avos begins at Sinai, and reads 'from Sinai' as the lesson of humility of the lowest mountain, which made Moshe, and after him Yehoshua, the vessel for the Torah. He then follows the chain to the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah, who restored the praise 'the great, mighty and awesome' because they spoke for the Jewish people, the kallah, while the prophets spoke for Hashem. He describes our era after the recent churban as a time of silence and of 'broken luchos', with hidden leaders whom one finds by following the old footsteps, and ends with the three directives of the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah as the answer to the weakening of the generations.
Topics: Pirkei Avos · Torah Min HaShamayim and the Mesorah · Anavah and Bittul
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Why the Oral Torah cannot be written
The Mashgiach opens with 'Moshe received the Torah from Sinai' and brings that Moshe wanted the Oral Torah written, but the nations would then claim to be Israel. He explains that the Oral Torah is written on the heart and mouth of the Jew, a secret code only a Jewish heart understands, so even in translation it is not theirs.
-
5:12 Received 'from Sinai': the lesson of humility
With the Bartenura the Mashgiach explains why Avos, which deals with middos, opens with Sinai. He reads 'from Sinai' as 'because of Sinai': Hashem chose the lowest mountain, and Moshe reasoned that as the humblest man he must receive the Torah. The name Chorev teaches that one who lives a life of luxury cannot be a vessel for Torah.
-
9:48 Why Yehoshua received the Torah
The Mashgiach explains that Yehoshua was not Moshe's greatest student, yet he merited to succeed him through humility, as Moshe saw when he renamed him. He links this to the days of Sefirah as days of humility before Kabbalas HaTorah, and describes how Yehoshua served Moshe and prepared the beis medrash, like the moon that has no light of its own.
-
14:05 Restoring 'the great, mighty and awesome'
The Mashgiach describes the eras of the Zekeinim, the Neviim and the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah, who 'restored the crown': prophets had dropped 'mighty' and 'awesome' when they saw the churban, and the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah put them back, since a lamb surviving among seventy wolves is itself Hashem's might. He adds that praise of Hashem must fit the time and the situation.
-
20:58 The Anshei Knesses HaGedolah speak for the kallah
The Mashgiach asks why they are called the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah and explains that with them the written Torah ended and the era of the Oral Torah began, Torah that flows from Jewish hearts. The prophets speak for Hashem, the chassan; the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah speak for Knesses Yisroel, the kallah, as in the Berditchever's reading of Pesach and Chag HaMatzos. So in galus they could proclaim the praise that the prophets had left out.
-
29:15 From 'received' to an era of silence
The Mashgiach explains why the Mishnah says Moshe 'received' and not that Hashem 'gave over' the Torah: no human can take over the infinite Torah, but Moshe gave over all of it to Yehoshua. He continues the chain through Tannaim, Amoraim, Geonim, Rishonim and Acharonim, and calls our time a new era of poverty and silence after a churban greater than earlier ones, a time to preserve rather than create.
-
36:02 The generation of broken luchos
The Mashgiach explains that the last words of the Torah allude to the broken luchos, and these are the last generations before Moshiach. Yet broken luchos also lie in the aron, and the chain from teacher to student cannot stop; hidden, small leaders are found by following, as Shir HaShirim says, the footsteps of the flock, those who keep the old ways, and not those who invent new ones.
-
41:43 Leaders chosen by people, and our deafness
The Mashgiach says that today's leaders are not luchos from heaven but are appointed by people, and gives the sign for the true ones: 'the words that were on the first luchos', no new paths. He recalls that in the Chofetz Chaim's time all of Klal Yisroel knew who its leaders were, and says that today the weakness is ours: we have become deaf and do not hear.
-
47:35 Holding the thread: today's might of Hashem
The Mashgiach compares the mesorah to pearls on a thread: today no pearls are seen, only the thread, and holding it is the lifeline. A Jew who still davens and learns while the wolves of the yetzer hara tear at his words is the 'might and awe' of Hashem today. He suggests that the number 120 of the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah reflects the twelve tribes, all of Klal Yisroel.
-
50:57 Three directives for weakening generations
The Mashgiach explains that from the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah on, each generation only 'receives' and grows weaker, so they gave three directives. Be deliberate in judgment, because the special siyata diShmaya of earlier poskim, seen in stories of the Chasam Sofer and Rabbi Akiva Eiger, is gone; raise many students because fewer learn; and make a fence because yiras Shamayim has weakened.
The shiur, written up
Why the Oral Torah cannot be written
The Mashgiach opens with the Mishnah 'Moshe received the Torah from Sinai' and brings the Midrash that Moshe wanted Hashem to write down the Oral Torah too. It was not written, because the nations would translate it and claim, as they do today, that they are Israel. a,b
The Mashgiach explains that the Oral Torah is in fact written, but on the heart and mouth of the Jew who learns as Torah should be learned; it flows from a well in every Jewish heart. Only a Jewish heart understands it, so even where its words are available to the nations, for them it is not Oral Torah. It is a private code between Hashem and His people.
Received 'from Sinai': the lesson of humility
Following the Bartenura, the Mashgiach explains that Avos, which deals with middos, opens with Sinai so that no one thinks refined people invented them. He then reads 'from Sinai' as 'because of Sinai': the mountains ran to receive the Torah, yet Hashem chose Sinai, the lowest. Moshe reasoned that he, who saw himself as the smallest man, must therefore receive it. c,d
Why Yehoshua received the Torah
Restoring 'the great, mighty and awesome'
The Mashgiach traces how the Torah passed through the eras of the Zekeinim and the Neviim to the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah in the time of the second Beis HaMikdash. The Gemara says they 'restored the crown': after Moshe said 'the great, mighty and awesome', prophets who saw the nations ruling and the Beis HaMikdash in ruins left out 'awesome' and 'mighty'. The Anshei Knesses HaGedolah put them back, because one lamb surviving among seventy wolves is itself Hashem's might and awe. i
The Anshei Knesses HaGedolah speak for the kallah
Why are they called the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah? The Maharal says their number, 120, holds a wondrous secret without explaining it, so the Mashgiach seeks the meaning. With them the prophets, and with them the written Torah, ended, and the era of the Oral Torah began, which the Midrash links to galus. The Oral Torah comes from Jewish hearts, and the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah were the mouth of all of Knesses Yisroel. l
The prophets speak in the name of Hashem, the chassan; the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah speak for the kallah. The Berditchever explains this way why the Torah calls the Yom Tov Chag HaMatzos, Hashem's praise of Israel, while we call it Pesach, our praise of Him. So in galus, among seventy wolves, the prophets omitted the praise, but Knesses Yisroel's spokesmen restored it. m
From 'received' to an era of silence
The Mashgiach notes that the Mishnah says 'from Sinai' for Hashem's honor, and 'Moshe received' rather than that Hashem gave over, since no human can take over the infinite Torah; but Moshe gave over all of it to Yehoshua. a
Continuing, the chain would run through Tannaim, Amoraim, Geonim, Rishonim and Acharonim; today is a new era of poverty and waiting. After a churban far greater than earlier ones, for which Rabbeinu Gershom's generation had composed kinos, no kinos or fasts are made; the response is silence. Our task is to preserve the little received, not to create new things.
The generation of broken luchos
The last words of the Torah, 'before the eyes of all Israel', allude to the broken luchos, and the Mashgiach says these are the last generations before Moshiach, lacking the gedolim of old. Yet broken luchos also lie in the aron, and the Torah must pass from mashpia to mekabel, so there must still be Jews to cling to. n,o
Leaders chosen by people, and our deafness
Our leaders are not heavenly luchos but people appointed by others, like the second luchos Moshe had to hew himself. The sign of true ones is 'the words that were on the first luchos': no new paths, continuing what was good before. q
The Mashgiach recalls being a small child when the Chofetz Chaim passed away; all knew who led Klal Yisroel, and even Ben Gurion knew whom to approach. Today communication is weak: the leaders are not deaf, we are, and cannot hear.
Holding the thread
The mesorah is a thread of pearls: Moshe, Yehoshua, the Zekeinim, the Neviim. Today no pearls are seen, only the thread, and holding it is our lifeline. A Jew who still davens and learns while the wolves of the yetzer hara tear at his mouth is today's 'might and awe'. The 120 may reflect the twelve tribes, the unity in Hashem's tefillin. r
Three directives for weakening generations
From the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah on, generations only 'receive' and grow weaker in knowledge, numbers and yiras Shamayim, so they said: be deliberate in judgment, raise many students, make a fence. a,s
Earlier poskim had siyata diShmaya: the Chasam Sofer said the halachah remains true even if his proofs fall, and Rabbi Akiva Eiger wrote that his son-in-law answered what was not asked, and the witnesses proved related. Today one must deliberate; and fences, like the Gemara's secondary arayos, guard weakened yiras Shamayim. t
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Targum
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
- e apparently Shabbos 89a-b index In the write-up: 8:47
- h apparently Bava Basra 75a index In the write-up: 12:22
- i apparently Yoma 69b index In the write-up: 14:27
- j apparently Berachos 33b index In the write-up: 19:03
- k apparently Shabbos 118b index In the write-up: 19:03
- o apparently Berachos 8b index In the write-up: 36:28
- r apparently Berachos 6a index In the write-up: 47:35
- t apparently Yevamos 21a index In the write-up: 52:58
Midrash
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
Key points
- 2:36 The Oral Torah is written on the heart and mouth of the Jew who learns properly, so it cannot be put in writing or truly reached by the nations.
- 6:53 'Moshe received the Torah from Sinai' means through the humility of Sinai, the lowest mountain; Yehoshua merited to succeed Moshe for the same humility and devotion.
- 23:12 The Anshei Knesses HaGedolah spoke for Knesses Yisroel and opened the era of the Oral Torah, which flows from Jewish hearts; therefore they could restore praises of Hashem that the prophets had left out.
- 35:10 Our era is one of silence and of 'broken luchos': the task is to preserve what was received, not to create new things, and to hold on to the thread of the mesorah.
- 51:57 The three directives of the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah answer three ways the generations weaken: in Torah knowledge, in the number of learners, and in yiras Shamayim.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:59 Why could the Oral Torah not be written down?
Answer: 2:36 Because it is written on the heart and mouth of the Jew and flows from a Jewish heart; only a Jewish heart understands it, so the nations cannot claim it.
-
Question: 5:14 Why does Avos open with 'Moshe received the Torah from Sinai'?
Answer: 5:17 Since Avos deals with middos, one might think they were devised by refined people; the opening teaches that all of it is from Sinai.
-
Question: 6:16 What does 'from Sinai' add?
Answer: 6:53 It means 'because of Sinai': Moshe learned from Hashem's choice of the lowest mountain that he, the humblest man, must receive the Torah.
-
Question: 9:54 Why was the Torah given over to Yehoshua, who was not Moshe's greatest student?
Answer: 13:28 Because of his humility and self-nullification toward his rebbe, the same trait through which Moshe received the Torah.
-
Question: 18:03 How could the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah restore 'mighty' and 'awesome', which the prophets before them had left out?
Answer: 25:47 The prophets spoke for Hashem and praised only what was seen; the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah spoke for Knesses Yisroel and saw in the lamb's survival among the wolves an even greater might.
-
Question: 20:58 Why are they called the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah?
Answer: 24:40 Because they represent Knesses Yisroel, the whole Jewish people, and reveal the Torah that grows in Jewish hearts.
Stories
-
12:22 Yehoshua prepares the beis medrash
According to the Midrash the Mashgiach brings, Yehoshua's fellows called him a fool who could not learn. Wanting a share in Torah, he served Moshe: he spread a mat where Moshe sat and arranged the benches and seforim in the beis medrash so that the students would not lose time. Because of this service he was the one chosen to carry the Torah after Moshe.
In the story: Yehoshua bin Nun, Moshe Rabbeinu
-
44:09 When the Chofetz Chaim passed away
The Mashgiach recalls that he was a small child when the Chofetz Chaim passed away, and that in his father's chassidish shtiebel too everyone knew who the leaders of Klal Yisroel were: the Chofetz Chaim, the Gerrer Rebbe, and later others. All of Klal Yisroel accepted them, and even Ben Gurion, when he wanted the Torah world's agreement on drafting women, knew whom to approach.
In the story: the Chofetz Chaim, the Gerrer Rebbe, David Ben-Gurion
-
52:34 The Chasam Sofer's quick teshuvah
The Chasam Sofer once received a very difficult question and wrote the teshuvah quickly, during his meal. His son, the Ksav Sofer, asked how he could answer such a complicated matter without thinking it through. He answered that in every generation there is one through whom Hashem's halachah is decided, and even if someone later refutes his proofs, the halachah stays true.
In the story: the Chasam Sofer, the Ksav Sofer
-
54:05 Rabbi Akiva Eiger and the related witnesses
In a case involving certain witnesses, the Chasam Sofer, without being asked, wrote that one must also check that the witnesses are not relatives. Rabbi Akiva Eiger wrote in his teshuvah that his son-in-law Reb Moshe had answered something they had not asked, and when they investigated they found the witnesses were indeed relatives. The Mashgiach brings this as the siyata diShmaya earlier generations had in their psak.
In the story: Rabbi Akiva Eiger, the Chasam Sofer
Insights
- 2:36 The Oral Torah is 'written' on the heart and mouth of the Jew who learns properly, a private code between Hashem and His people; therefore even when its words are available in translation, it is not truly Oral Torah for the nations.
- 7:41 'From Sinai' means 'because of Sinai': as Hashem chose the lowest mountain, Moshe reasoned that he, who saw himself as the lowest man, was the one obligated to receive the Torah.
- 25:43 The prophets speak for Hashem, the chassan, so they could not praise Him with what was not seen; the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah speak for Knesses Yisroel, the kallah, who sees the survival of the lamb among the wolves as His might, and so they restored the praise.
- 30:18 The Mishnah says Moshe 'received' rather than that Hashem 'gave over', because no human can take over the infinite Torah entirely; but Moshe did give all of it over to Yehoshua.
- 36:17 The last words of the Torah allude to the broken luchos, and the last generations before Moshiach are those broken luchos; yet broken luchos were also kept in the aron.
- 48:58 Today's 'might and awe' of Hashem is the Jew who still manages to say words of tefillah and Torah while the wolves of the yetzer hara tear at his mouth.
- 51:57 The three directives of the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah answer three ways the Torah weakens over the generations: deliberation in judgment for lost knowledge and siyata diShmaya, many students for fewer learners, and a fence for weakened yiras Shamayim.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 9:09 The Mashgiach says one who wants to learn Torah cannot do so against a background of a life of luxury; he must be humble and ready for every hardship.
- 11:00 The Mashgiach says that in the days of Sefirah, the preparation for Kabbalas HaTorah, one should hold oneself more in humility and find one's own lowliness.
- 35:41 According to the Mashgiach, our time is not one for creating new things but for preserving the little that was received.
- 40:53 The Mashgiach says to follow those who keep the old ways, guidance and customs of the earlier gedolim, and not those who come with new paths.
- 47:42 The Mashgiach says that even when no pearls are seen, one must hold on to the thread of the mesorah, which is our lifeline.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Chaggai, Daniel, David Ben-Gurion, Dovid HaMelech, Malachi, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbeinu Gershom Me'or HaGolah, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Akiva Eiger, Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, Shimon HaTzaddik, the Bartenura, the Chasam Sofer, the Chofetz Chaim, the Gerrer Rebbe, the Ksav Sofer, the Maharal of Prague, Yehoshua bin Nun, Yirmiyahu HaNavi, Zechariah HaNavi
Terms אנשי כנסת הגדולה, כנסת ישראל, מסורה, סייעתא דשמיא, ספירת העומר, ענוה, שבירת הלוחות, תורה שבכתב, תורה שבעל פה