גודל כח סעודת מרעים
מקבלים השפעות גדולות מציל ממים הזידונים של גלות
Catalog entry: שונות no. 19 Pocket Guide p. 36 תשל"ח (1977–78) Yiddish 46 min
Listen
About this shiur
At a melave malka held as a farewell seudah for a friend, the Mashgiach explains that Jews who eat together are bound into one group that receives a higher flow of life, and that this bond is a teivah that saves them from the waters of the present exile.
The Mashgiach opens with melave malka as a seudah that escorts Shabbos and traces the farewell seudah to Shemini Atzeres. He tells a story from the Midrash, cited in teshuvos of the Divrei Chaim and the Chiddushei HaRim, of a couple who parted with a seudah and were then blessed with children. He then explains that Hashem sends greater hashpa'ah to a tzibbur, which becomes a new collective soul, and that eating together forms a zimun the same way; 'yachdav' means bound, not merely together. The Midrash reads the four 'vayigberu' of the Mabul as the four exiles, and the present Mabul of heresy is escaped through the teivah: Torah, tefillah and joining with friends. Finally he links the thirty letters of a line in a Sefer Torah to the chaburos of the korban Pesach, and applies all this to the seudah for their friend Menachem.
Topics: Ahavas Yisroel and Achdus · Melave Malka
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Melave malka and the farewell seudah
The Mashgiach describes melave malka as a small seudah escorting Shabbos as it leaves and traces the farewell seudah to Shemini Atzeres. He begins a teshuvah of the Divrei Chaim about a talmid chacham married ten years without children.
-
3:18 The couple who parted with a seudah Story
The Mashgiach relates that the same question was sent to the Chiddushei HaRim, who ended with the Midrash of the childless couple who came to Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai to divorce, parted with a seudah, and were blessed with children through his tefillah. He adds what a Sanzer descendant told him about the family's tradition.
-
7:10 Hashpa'ah to a tzibbur and through eating listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Hashem sends each soul hashpa'ah through Torah, tefillah and eating, measured to what it can hold, and that ten Jews joined as a tzibbur become a new entity that receives more. Eating as a Jew should eat draws a holier kind of life, and several eating together form a zimun, which already brings the Shechinah with three.
-
12:07 Zimun comes from eating; 'yachdav' means bound listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Chiddushei HaRim's reason why chassidim eat together after davening, and shows that the bond of zimun comes from eating together, not from benching together. From the passuk of zimun and the laws of shaatnez he proves that 'yachdav' means bound, not merely side by side.
-
16:24 Eating creates friendship; Ammon and Moav listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says eating together creates lasting friendship and connection. Using the principle that not believing in techiyas hameisim is a sign rather than a punishment, he explains that Ammon and Moav's failure to bring bread and water showed they have no connection to the Jewish people.
-
19:51 The Mabul of today and the teivah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Midrash that the four times 'vayigberu' are the four exiles, so the Mabul repeats itself in galus, and today's Mabul is one of heresy and immorality. Citing the Ba'al Shem Tov that a teivah is a word of Torah and tefillah, he says a Jew must flee into it, as Noach did, and those who bind themselves to the tzaddikim will remain.
-
24:18 The four exiles: breadth, height and time listed in the guide
The Mashgiach describes each exile: Bavel scattered the Jews in breadth, Madai brought Haman's decree, Yavan fought in height against the Shechinah, matching the fifteen amos the waters rose, and Edom contains them all and adds the dimension of time, an exile without a set end, matching the hundred and fifty days. The answer remains to flee into the teivah of Torah and tefillah.
-
30:05 Joining with friends as a teivah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says binding with friends is part of the teivah, bringing the Ruzhiner Rebbe's advice that Jews should gather and strengthen each other, and the command to Noach to take food into the teivah. He cites Malachi that in the final hester panim those who fear Hashem speak to one another, and tells of a talmid who complained that people come to sit with him, and was told that this itself is a great strength.
-
35:06 Thirty letters in a line and the korban Pesach listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that a line in a Sefer Torah holds thirty letters, 'lemishpechoseichem' three times, and asks why it is learned from the korban Pesach and not from the earlier 'lemishpechoseihem' by Noach. He explains that souls come down in groups, that the korban Pesach was eaten in chaburos and slaughtered in three groups of thirty, and that leaving the teivah broke the group while the Pesach gathered it.
-
42:15 This seudah and the parting from Menachem listed in the guide
The Mashgiach applies the ideas to the gathering: they are eating a melave malka bound to Shabbos and parting from their friend Menachem, and eating together binds them. He contrasts a passuk, which cannot be split, with a flexible line, and closes that everything written about the Mabul is a lesson for galus, noting the first passuk of Zichronos about Noach.
The shiur, written up
Melave malka and the farewell seudah
The Mashgiach opens by describing melave malka as a small seudah that escorts Shabbos as it departs. He traces the farewell seudah to Shemini Atzeres, when Hashem asks for a small seudah together before parting. He then begins a teshuvah of the Divrei Chaim about a talmid chacham, married ten years without children, whose wife did not want a divorce. a,b
The couple who parted with a seudah
Later the Mashgiach found the same question, in the same words, in the teshuvos of the Chiddushei HaRim, who ends with the Midrash of a childless couple who came to Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai to divorce. He told them to part with a seudah as they had married with one. The wife gave her husband wine, and he told her to take the dearest thing to her father's house; she carried him there, told him he was the dearest, and through Rabbi Shimon's tefillah they had children. c,d
A Sanzer grandson in Williamsburg later told the Mashgiach that his family knows an ancestor followed this advice and was helped.
Hashpa'ah to a tzibbur and through eating
To explain why a farewell seudah matters, the Mashgiach says Hashem renews creation constantly and sends each soul hashpa'ah through Torah, tefillah and eating, only as much as it can hold. Ten Jews joined as a tzibbur become one new entity with a collective soul, and can receive what even the greatest tzaddik alone cannot, such as Kedushah and the reading of the Torah.
Eating, too, is receiving life. When a Jew eats as he should, with washing, a beracha and benching, he receives a holier life, and several who eat together form a zimun that receives still more, with the Shechinah present already among three.
Zimun comes from eating; 'yachdav' means bound
The Mashgiach brings the Chiddushei HaRim's reason why chassidim eat together after davening: closeness that the davening did not achieve may come through eating together. He shows that the bond of zimun comes from the eating, since three who ate separately cannot bench with a zimun.
Eating creates friendship; Ammon and Moav
Eating together, the Mashgiach says, builds a lasting friendship. He notes that Chazal's statement about one who denies techiyas hameisim is not a punishment but a sign that he has no share in it. Likewise, Ammon and Moav not bringing bread and water showed they have no connection to Klal Yisrael and the eating that binds Jewish souls. g,h
The Mabul of today and the teivah
The four exiles: breadth, height and time
The Shechinah goes with the Jews into exile, but the waters seek to extinguish the spark burning in every Jew. Bavel scattered the Jews in breadth, and Madai brought Haman's decree. Yavan came in height, warring against the Shechinah while Jews were still in Eretz Yisrael, matching the fifteen amos the waters rose, which the Mashgiach links to the hei of Hashem's Name. l
Joining with friends as a teivah
Part of the teivah, the Mashgiach says, is binding with friends. The Ruzhiner advised that Jews gather and strengthen one another in emunah, and Noach was told to bring food into the teivah. Eating with sincere friends saves from the waters, as Malachi says that in the last hester panim those who fear Hashem speak to one another. o,p
He tells of a talmid who complained that townspeople keep coming to sit with him. He was told this is the main thing: sitting together apart from the outside world is a great strength for emunah in galus.
Thirty letters in a line and the korban Pesach
The Gemara says a line in a Sefer Torah holds thirty letters, 'lemishpechoseichem' three times, a word from the korban Pesach. The Mashgiach asks why it is not learned from the earlier 'lemishpechoseihem' when Noach's families left the teivah. q,r,s
Citing a Midrash, he explains that souls come down in groups, so people bound together on earth are bound above. The korban Pesach was eaten as a chaburah, each by his eaters, and slaughtered in three groups: kahal, edah and Yisrael, ten each, thirty in all. Each letter is a soul, so a line is such a chaburah. t,u,v,w
This answers his question: leaving the teivah broke the group apart, while at the Pesach it gathers into one.
Sources
Torah
- f apparently Devarim 22:11 index In the write-up: 14:12
- h Devarim 23:5 text index In the write-up: 17:41
- j Bereishis 6:9 text index In the write-up: 22:03
- k Bereishis 7:23 text index In the write-up: 22:03
- l Bereishis 7:20 text index In the write-up: 24:44
- m Bereishis 7:24 text index In the write-up: 27:44
- o apparently Bereishis 6:21 index In the write-up: 30:12
- r apparently Shemos 12:21 index In the write-up: 35:16
- s apparently Bereishis 8:19 index In the write-up: 35:16
- u apparently Shemos 12:4 index In the write-up: 36:55
- w apparently Shemos 12:6 index In the write-up: 36:55
- y apparently Bereishis 8:1 index In the write-up: 45:04
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 8:38 A tzibbur of ten becomes a new entity with a collective soul and can receive a hashpa'ah that even the greatest individual tzaddik cannot.
- 11:36 Eating is a receiving of life, and when several Jews eat together they form a zimun that receives a higher kind of life; the bond of zimun comes from the eating, not from the benching.
- 20:23 The Midrash teaches that the four times 'vayigberu' appears by the Mabul are the four exiles, so the Mabul is a living lesson for galus.
- 29:52 The way to be saved from today's Mabul is to run into the teivah: Torah, tefillah, Tehillim, and binding oneself with friends.
- 39:29 A line of thirty letters in a Sefer Torah corresponds to the three groups of ten in which the korban Pesach was slaughtered and eaten.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 13:12 Why must three who want to bench with a zimun have eaten together?
Answer: 13:28 Because the bond of zimun comes from the eating, which unites the souls, not from the benching.
-
Question: 12:07 Why do chassidim eat together after davening?
Answer: 12:20 According to the Chiddushei HaRim, if the davening did not bring the closeness to Hashem one wanted, eating together may bring it.
-
Question: 17:51 Why were Ammon and Moav excluded for not bringing bread and water?
Answer: 19:05 It is not a punishment but a sign: eating binds Jewish souls, and their not offering food showed they have no connection to Klal Yisrael.
-
Question: 35:16 Why does the Gemara learn the thirty-letter line from 'lemishpechoseichem' by the Pesach and not from the earlier 'lemishpechoseihem' by Noach?
Answer: 41:45 By Noach they were leaving the teivah and the group was breaking up; at the korban Pesach the group gathers as one chaburah.
-
Question: 40:43 Why must a line in a Sefer Torah hold thirty letters?
Answer: 39:46 Each letter is like a soul, and thirty is the chaburah of the korban Pesach, slaughtered in three groups of kahal, edah and Yisrael.
Stories
-
4:29 Parting with a seudah
A couple without children for ten years came to Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai to divorce. He told them that just as they married with a seudah, they should part with a seudah. The wife gave her husband good wine, and he told her to take the dearest thing from the house to her father's house; she carried him there. When he woke she told him he was the dearest thing, and Rabbi Shimon davened for them and they were blessed with children.
In the story: Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai
-
6:30 A Sanzer grandson's family tradition
The Mashgiach met a friend, a grandson of Sanz living in Williamsburg, and asked whether he knew of this teshuvah. The friend said he did: his family has a tradition that an ancestor followed the advice of the Chiddushei HaRim and was helped.
-
33:14 The talmid whose house was full of visitors
A talmid of a great tzaddik complained to his Rebbe that the people of his town keep coming in to talk with him. He was told that this is the main thing: when Jews sit together, even without words of Torah, simply because they set themselves apart from the outside world, it is a great strength for emunah and for holding on in galus.
Insights
- 8:38 Ten Jews joined as a tzibbur are not ten individuals but a new entity with a collective soul, which is why a tzibbur can say Kedushah and read the Torah, something no single tzaddik can do.
- 13:05 The bond that makes a zimun is created by eating together: three who ate separately and then meet cannot bench with a zimun.
- 14:25 'Yachdav' means bound, not merely together: as with shaatnez, wool and linen lying loosely one on the other are not 'yachdav'.
- 18:13 Not believing in techiyas hameisim is not punished by losing it but is a symptom of having no share in it; likewise Ammon and Moav's not bringing bread and water was a sign that they have no connection to Klal Yisrael.
- 25:32 Each exile struck in another dimension: Bavel in breadth, Yavan in height against the Shechinah (the fifteen amos), and Edom also in time, an exile without an end (the hundred and fifty days).
- 35:38 The thirty letters of a line in a Sefer Torah are learned from the korban Pesach and not from Noach's families leaving the teivah, because there the group was breaking up while at the Pesach it was gathering into one chaburah.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People Haman, Noach, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), the Baal Shem Tov, the Chiddushei HaRim, the Divrei Chaim (Rabbi Chaim of Sanz), Yaakov Avinu
Terms הסתר פנים, השפעה, מבול, מלוה מלכה, קרבן פסח, שעטנז, תחיית המתים, תיבה