Cell Phones
כינוס התעוררות בענין: חומר סכנת Cell Phones בלי הכשר
Catalog entry: שונות no. 20 Pocket Guide p. 36 תשס"ח (2007–08) Yiddish 50 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach warns the young men of his shul against cellphones without a hechsher, from the leitzanus of text messages to the danger of immorality, and insists that the ruling of the Gedolim must be obeyed.
Speaking in the days of Selichos to the young men raised in his shul, the Mashgiach addresses a report that some have become absorbed in their cellphones. Text messages, he explains, remove the natural shame of face-to-face speech and breed a constant traffic of jokes and leitzanus, even during learning and davening. He brings a story of someone who left a meal rather than sit in a moshav leitzim, and the passuk that one cannot sit among scoffers and desire Hashem's Torah at once. New tools are new forms of the yetzer hara. Far worse, a phone with open features exposes a person to immorality. Using the Gemara in Bava Basra and the Rashbam, he explains that only someone who truly needs it for his livelihood may use one, and compares this to a heter given only for a pressing case. Ignoring the Gedolim's ban, he argues from zaken mamrei, Rabbeinu Yonah and the fall of American Jewry, cuts a person off from Hashem. He ends with practical guidance and a call to tefillah.
Topics: Technology and the Internet · Hiskashrus to Tzaddikim and Emunas Chachamim · Shmiras Einayim
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Text messages and the loss of shame listed in the guide
The Mashgiach addresses the young men raised in his shul, says it is a time of seeking Hashem, and relates the report that some are absorbed all day in their cellphones. He explains that text messages remove the shame of face-to-face speech, breed leitzanus, and distract bochurim even during the shiur and davening.
-
6:32 Leaving a moshav leitzim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells of a man who got up and left a family meal when a joke was made, because it was a moshav leitzim, and contrasts this with devoting a whole day to leitzanus by text. He tells the young men they are too choshuv to fall to such lowness.
-
10:07 Learning is Shabbos; new yetzer haras listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says that during learning one treats the phone as on Shabbos, and that even a kosher phone does not belong in the beis medrash. One cannot both sit among scoffers and desire Hashem's Torah. He then speaks of new forms of the yetzer hara, such as movies and radio, that keep appearing.
-
14:59 A trembling world and the Mississippi drasha listed in the guide
The Mashgiach describes a time when the world is in turmoil and dangers loom, and tells how the Chofetz Chaim gathered people for a drasha on teshuvah because the Mississippi had flooded in America. When Hashem shakes the world, he says, the message is for Jews; mocking such things by text is laughable, and the phone holds something worse than leitzanus.
-
19:28 The danger of zenus and the one who closes his eyes listed in the guide
The Mashgiach warns that a phone with open features exposes a person to immorality, citing the passuk not to approach the door of her house. Rabbanim allowed it only for business; he brings the Gemara in Bava Basra and the Rashbam that one who walks a road of temptation without need is a rasha even if he shuts his eyes, while one with no other way becomes a ba'al bechirah who must guard himself.
-
24:55 A heter for one is treif for another listed in the guide
The Gedolim forbade such phones and permitted them only for business. Through a mashal of two shailos on meat, one before Shabbos when the Mashgiach relies on the Rema's leniency for a pressing case and one on Sunday, the Mashgiach shows that what is permitted for one is forbidden for another. He adds that a single look can harm a person for life, and that zenus belongs to the sins of yehareg ve'al ya'avor.
-
29:50 Zaken mamrei and the yud of yarbeh listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says disobeying the rabbanim is worse still: the Rambam calls the parsha of zaken mamrei the foundation of the Torah. He tells of Shlomo HaMelech, who relied on his own wisdom to take more wives, and asks why it was the yud of 'yarbeh' that complained; the yud stands for bitul, as Moshe added a yud to Yehoshua's name for his humility.
-
33:55 The Gedolim's ruling and Rabbeinu Yonah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach stresses that the Gedolim of America and Eretz Yisroel forbade phones without a hechsher except for a business need, and one who disobeys is like a zaken mamrei. He brings the Gemara in Berachos and Rabbeinu Yonah, who explains the death penalty for disregarding the rabbanim, and the passuk of the judge 'in those days'; cleaving to talmidei chachamim is how one cleaves to Hashem.
-
39:20 Decide now; why American Jewry fell listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says the gadol hador has the status of one's main rebbe, and calls on whoever has such a phone without a business need to decide now to give it up despite the cost. He explains that American Jews fell away because they did not listen to the rabbanim about kashrus, and that the word 'zadon' marks undermining the foundation of Yiddishkeit.
-
43:12 Who may use it, and how listed in the guide
The Mashgiach praises the young men and says one must daven daily to be saved from the yetzer hara. He gives the example of a mechanech who must reach doctors and psychologists for his students: such a person may use it, but only during business hours, like chametz that is kosher all year and becomes treif. Doubts should go to a moreh hora'ah, and the principle of 'once permitted for a need' does not apply here.
-
46:52 No half-measures; tefillah and a brachah listed in the guide
Blocking text service by calling the company is no real solution, since it can be restored with one call; the only solution is not to have it, and the main one is to ask Hashem for help. The tests of this generation come because it is being prepared for Moshiach, and the talk ends with blessings for the new year.
The shiur, written up
Text messages and the loss of shame
The Mashgiach addresses the young men who grew up in his shul, whom he has watched rise in Torah, tefillah and middos, and says this is a time to seek Hashem. He was told something he could hardly believe: some have become absorbed all day in their cellphones, especially in text messages full of jokes.
He explains why. Face to face, a person's natural shame restrains him from coarse speech; a text removes that restraint, and jokes fly back and forth. This is leitzanus, and teachers report that bochurim turn their attention from the rebbi to their texts in the middle of a shiur, davening and even chazaras hashatz.
Leaving a moshav leitzim
The Mashgiach tells of a man who, at the meal of his child's wedding, stood up and left when a joke was made, because he could not sit in a moshav leitzim. Yet here people devote a whole day to it. Everyone stumbles at times, he says, but these are choshuve young men and such lowness does not suit them.
Learning is Shabbos; new yetzer haras
During learning, the Mashgiach says, it is Shabbos: one does not pick up the phone even if it rings, and even a kosher phone does not belong in the beis medrash. Tehillim's 'in the seat of scoffers he does not sit' and 'his desire is in Hashem's Torah' are two sides; one cannot have both. a,b
In these days of Selichos he adds that from Adam HaRishon until about a century ago the yetzer hara stayed the same; since then new ones keep appearing, movies, radio and more.
A trembling world and the Mississippi drasha
The world is in turmoil, the Mashgiach says, with dangers from Iran, Russia and terror never seen before. He tells how the Chofetz Chaim once gathered people for a drasha on teshuvah because the Mississippi had flooded in America, a word the Jews of Radin had never heard. When Hashem shakes the nations, He means the Jews, as the passuk in Tzefaniah says. To mock such things by text is laughable. d
The danger of zenus
A heter for one is treif for another
The Gedolim forbade such phones except for business. The Mashgiach gives a mashal: the Rema permits relying on a leniency in a pressing case. A rav permits Chatzkel's shailah an hour before Shabbos, and in Heaven it is written as oneg Shabbos; Pinchas relies on it on Sunday and it is written that he ate treif.
Zaken mamrei and the yud of yarbeh
Disobeying the rabbanim is still worse: the Rambam calls zaken mamrei the foundation of the Torah. Shlomo HaMelech, sure his heart would not turn, took more wives than the passuk allows, and the yud of 'yarbeh' went up to complain. The Mashgiach asks why the yud, and answers that it is bitul, as the Targum Yonasan says Moshe gave Yehoshua a yud for his humility. Even when right, one submits to the Torah. i,k,l
The Gedolim's ruling and Rabbeinu Yonah
All the Gedolim of America and Eretz Yisroel forbade a phone without a hechsher except for business, and one who disobeys is like a zaken mamrei. The Gemara in Berachos calls one who eats before Maariv liable to death, and Rabbeinu Yonah explains that he disregards the rabbanim. Zaken mamrei, he holds, is not only before the Sanhedrin. m,n
Decide now; why American Jewry fell
Whoever has such a phone without a business need, the Mashgiach says, should decide now to give it up, even at a loss. American Jews fell away because they ignored the rabbanim who cried that kashrus was not in order. The word 'zadon' appears also with the false prophet: it means undermining the foundation of Yiddishkeit. r
Who may use it, and how
The Mashgiach says one must daven daily to be saved from the yetzer hara. A mechanech who must reach doctors and psychologists for his students may use it, but only during business hours; like chametz, kosher all year, at other times it is treif. Doubts go to a moreh hora'ah, and 'once permitted for a need' does not apply. s
No half-measures; tefillah and a brachah
Blocking text service is no solution, since one call restores it; the only solution is not to have it, and the main one is asking Hashem for help. These tests come because this generation is being prepared for Moshiach. The talk ends with blessings for a year of Torah, tefillah, refuah and peace.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Targum
Talmud Bavli
- f apparently Bava Basra 57b index In the write-up: 22:14
- h apparently Sanhedrin 75a index In the write-up: 28:31
- m apparently Berachos 4b index In the write-up: 34:54
- p apparently Rosh Hashanah 25b index In the write-up: 38:05
- q apparently Kesubos 111b index In the write-up: 38:05
- s apparently Beitzah 12a index In the write-up: 43:14
Rishonim
Other
Key points
- 3:48 Text messages remove the shame of speaking face to face, so they become a channel for constant jokes and leitzanus.
- 11:32 A person cannot both sit among scoffers and truly desire Hashem's Torah; it is one or the other.
- 19:20 A cellphone with open features exposes its owner to the danger of immorality, which is far graver than leitzanus.
- 23:32 Only someone who must have such a phone for his livelihood may use it, and then he must guard himself; one who does not need it and takes it anyway is called a rasha.
- 34:54 Disobeying the Gedolei Yisrael who forbade such phones is akin to the sin of the zaken mamrei and cuts a person off from Hashem.
- 39:52 The Mashgiach calls on those without a business need to decide now to get rid of such a phone, and on everyone to daven daily for protection from the yetzer hara.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 22:55 The Gemara asks about one who shuts his eyes passing women at the river: if he has another road he is a rasha, and if not he is compelled, so whom does the passuk praise?
Answer: 23:10 Following the Rashbam, the Mashgiach explains that one with no other way becomes a ba'al bechirah who must restrain himself, while one who chooses the road without need is a rasha even with his eyes shut.
-
Question: 31:57 Why was it the yud of 'yarbeh' that complained about Shlomo HaMelech?
Answer: 32:12 The rest of the word knew Shlomo was right, but the yud is the letter of bitul, as Moshe gave Yehoshua a yud for his humility, and bitul demands submitting to the Torah even when one is right.
-
Question: 35:43 Rabbeinu Yonah asks why one who eats before Maariv is liable to death; what is so severe?
Answer: 35:56 Because he disregards the rabbanim's enactment; he is not submitting to them, which is akin to a zaken mamrei.
-
Question: 40:56 Why did so many American Jews fall away from Yiddishkeit?
Answer: 41:04 Because during the immigration they did not listen to the rabbanim, who cried out that the kashrus was not in order.
Stories
-
6:40 Leaving the table because of a joke
The Mashgiach tells of a man who made a wedding for his child. At the meal the mechutan greeted him with some joke, and he stood up and left, because he could not sit at a table that had become a moshav leitzim. The Mashgiach contrasts leaving after hearing one joke with spending a whole day on leitzanus.
-
15:31 The Chofetz Chaim and the Mississippi flood
The Mashgiach relates, through someone who was present as a bochur, that the Chofetz Chaim once gathered people to say a drasha calling for teshuvah because the Mississippi river had flooded in America. The Jews of Radin had never even heard a word as long as 'Mississippi', and it was thousands of miles away. The lesson the Mashgiach draws is that when Hashem brings upheaval on the world, He means the Jews.
In the story: the Chofetz Chaim, Rabbi Avraham Kalmanowitz, Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky
-
30:43 Shlomo HaMelech and the yud of yarbeh
Shlomo HaMelech took more wives than the Torah allows a king, reasoning that he knew himself and his heart would not be turned, and that he wished to bring them under the wings of the Shechinah. The yud of the word 'yarbeh' went up before the Kisei HaKavod to complain, and Shlomo HaMelech indeed stumbled.
In the story: Shlomo HaMelech, the Arizal
Insights
- 3:18 The Mashgiach explains the pull of texting psychologically: a person's built-in shame and self-restraint work face to face, and the screen removes them, so jokes flow that he would never say aloud.
- 11:41 Reading the opening of Tehillim, the Mashgiach says 'moshav leitzim' and 'Toras Hashem cheftzo' are two sides of a divide: a person must stand on one side, he cannot have both.
- 23:10 From the Rashbam on one who shuts his eyes while passing women at the river, the Mashgiach derives that need is what turns a dangerous road into a legitimate test: with no other way, a person becomes a ba'al bechirah; without need, closing his eyes does not save him from being a rasha.
- 32:06 The Mashgiach asks why the yud of 'yarbeh', and not another letter, complained about Shlomo HaMelech, and answers that the small yud is the letter of bitul: even if Shlomo was right, one must submit to the Torah.
- 45:01 A heter given for business, the Mashgiach says, is like chametz, kosher all year and forbidden at its time: the phone is permitted only during the hours it is needed, and the rule that what was permitted for a need is permitted without need does not apply.
- 49:09 The Mashgiach sees the new tests of this generation as a sign that it is being prepared for Moshiach and for the greatest greatness.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 10:27 The Mashgiach says that during learning one should treat the phone as on Shabbos and not pick it up, and that it should not be brought into the beis medrash at all.
- 39:52 The Mashgiach calls on anyone with a phone without a hechsher who does not need it for business to decide now to get rid of it.
- 44:38 One who needs it for business should use it only during business hours and not carry it otherwise, and in a doubt should ask a recognized moreh hora'ah.
- 43:14 The Mashgiach says one should daven every day to be saved from the yetzer hara and ask Hashem for help in these matters.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbeinu Ephraim, Rabbeinu Yonah, Shlomo HaMelech, the Chazon Ish, the Chofetz Chaim, the Rambam, the Rashbam, the Rema, Yehoshua bin Nun
Terms בושה, בחירה, ביטול, זקן ממרא, יהרג ואל יעבור, יצר הרע, ליצנות