עשר כתרין דמסאבותא כנגד עשר ספירות דקדושה. ביאור טעם שהטומאה נקראת כתרין.

Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' ו no. ⁨17⁩ Pocket Guide p. 42 Yiddish 44 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 44 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

On Tanya chapter six, the Mashgiach explains that the ten powers of kedushah have a counterpart of ten 'crowns' of impurity, why impurity is called crowns and sitra achra, and how a Jew elevates kelipas noga by doing even permitted things for the sake of Heaven.

The Mashgiach opens with the principle 'zeh l'umas zeh asah ha'Elokim': Hashem keeps kedushah and impurity in balance, and only one who takes Hashem with him tips the scale. He illustrates this with the Gemara about Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya, a Midrash about the Satan at the births of the Avos, and the great sorcerers of earlier times. He then reads Tanya chapter six: just as the G-dly soul has ten holy sefiros, the Jew's animal soul from kelipas noga has ten powers of impurity. Using a walnut's four shells, the laws of orlah, milah and periah, and the Masorah's siman for Parshas Kedoshim, he shows that only a Jew can elevate noga. He explains why impurity is called 'crowns' rather than sefiros, how intellect shapes the middos, why there is no neutral reshus, and, with a vort of the Kotzker Rebbe, why impurity is called the 'other side'.

Topics: Kedushah and Kelipah · The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8) · The Sefiros

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Zeh l'umas zeh: kedushah and impurity in balance

    The Mashgiach recalls the previous perek on the union with Hashem through Torah and mitzvos, then opens chapter six with 'zeh l'umas zeh asah ha'Elokim'. He brings the Gemara about Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya and the minim, and concludes that kedushah and impurity are balanced, and Hashem tips the scale for one who takes Him along.

  2. 4:33 The Satan's share, Esav and the great sorcerers

    The Mashgiach brings a Midrash that the Satan demanded a share at the births of the Avos, and that Esav, the admoni, was born with Yaakov; David too was admoni, but with fine eyes. He then explains that when there were great tzaddikim there were also great sorcerers like Bilaam and Amalek, while today both sides are small, and that a union exists in impurity as in kedushah.

  3. 10:26 Ten sefiros of the soul and ten of impurity listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach reads the opening of Tanya chapter six: as the G-dly soul consists of ten sefiros clothed in three garments, the soul of the sitra achra from kelipas noga has ten powers of impurity, seven bad middos with a mind that gives birth to them. He mentions that in the days of sefirah one asks to refine each middah through the mitzvah of counting.

  4. 14:24 Kelipas noga: the walnut, orlah and periah

    The Mashgiach explains that a Jew's animal soul is from kelipas noga, which can be elevated, and illustrates the four kelipos with the four shells of a walnut. He shows the same pattern in 'kedoshim tihyu' as the Ramban explains it, in orlah and its fourth year, and in milah and periah, and notes that the Masorah's siman for the 64 pesukim of Parshas Kedoshim is 'noga'.

  5. 22:15 Bnei Keturah: milah without periah

    The Mashgiach brings the Rambam that the Bnei Keturah are obligated in milah, and the Acharonim who say only milah and not periah, since periah was given only in the days of Yehoshua. The inner reason is that a gentile's soul comes from the three impure kelipos and cannot elevate noga, which is also why only a Jew brings shelamim, as the Midrash on 'uri tzafon' shows.

  6. 26:11 Why impurity is called 'crowns' listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach rereads the Tanya and asks why the ten powers of impurity are called crowns and not sefiros. A sefirah, like 'livnas hasapir', is transparent and lets the light of kedushah through, which is bittul; impurity says 'I am something' and 'I will reign'. He links the ten powers of impurity to the ten sons of Haman.

  7. 30:37 The mind behind the middos; garments of impurity

    The Mashgiach explains the Tanya's point that the middos follow the intellect: a child and an adult have the same middah of love, but a small mind directs it to toys and a large one to property. He then explains the three garments of impurity, thought, speech and action not for Hashem, and 'all that is done under the sun', which is futility and a broken spirit.

  8. 36:30 No neutral reshus: the 'other side'

    The Mashgiach explains that there is no middle between mitzvah and aveirah: eating or business done for Heaven's sake raises noga to kedushah, and otherwise it joins impurity. He brings the Kotzker Rebbe on the Targum's 'l'tzad' in 'al tigshu el ishah', that there are two sides of a fence, and concludes with the Tanya that kedushah rests only on what is nullified to Hashem.

The shiur, written up

Zeh l'umas zeh: kedushah and impurity in balance

0:17

The Mashgiach recalls that the previous perek explained the wondrous union with Hashem that comes through Torah and, in another way, through mitzvos. The Tanya's chapter six then opens with 'zeh l'umas zeh asah ha'Elokim' (Koheles 7:14): Hashem made kedushah and impurity opposite each other. a,h

2:11

He brings the Gemara in Chagigah: when Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya, who always defeated the minim, was dying, his students asked who would now stand against them. He answered with 'v'eilchah l'negdecha' (Bereishis 33:12): as wisdom leaves the world, its opponents lose their power too. Hashem keeps the sides balanced, and only one who takes Him along tips the scale. b,c

The Satan's share, Esav and the great sorcerers

4:36

The Mashgiach brings a Midrash that at the births of the Avos the Satan cried out for a share: against Avraham he was given Yishmael, and Esav came out together with Yaakov. Esav was admoni, ruddy, and the Satan thought Moshiach would be in his portion, since David too is called admoni (Shmuel I 16:12). But, as another Midrash explains, Esav's redness was for shedding blood, while David was admoni 'with fine eyes', judging with the Sanhedrin. d,e,f

7:29

Likewise, when there were great kedoshim there were great sorcerers such as Bilaam and Amalek; a Midrash says Shaul erred because Amalek's sorcery turned his soldiers into animals. Today, the Mashgiach says, neither side has such greatness. The rule stands: as one who does mitzvos unites with Hashem, one who does aveiros becomes clothed in impurity. g

Ten sefiros of the soul and ten of impurity

10:30

Reading Tanya chapter six, the Mashgiach explains that as the G-dly soul consists of ten holy sefiros clothed in thought, speech and action, the soul of the sitra achra from kelipas noga has ten powers of impurity: seven bad middos born of a mind of impurity. He adds that in the days of sefirah one asks Hashem, in the merit of counting, to refine each middah, so that these powers serve kedushah. h

Kelipas noga: the walnut, orlah and periah

14:24

A Jew's animal soul, the Mashgiach explains, is from kelipas noga, which can be turned to kedushah; the three wholly impure kelipos, source of the gentiles' animal soul, cannot. He compares this to a walnut: the green husk, the hard shell and the thin membrane dividing its four chambers are removed, but the thin brown skin over the nut is eaten with it and becomes food. That is noga; the nut itself parallels the four letters of Hashem's name.

19:22

So too eating and drinking are elevated when a Jew does them for kedushah. This is 'kedoshim tihyu' as the Ramban explains: to eat and sleep in order to have strength to learn and daven. In the same parsha, orlah's three years parallel the three kelipos and the fourth is 'kodesh hillulim' (Vayikra 19:23-24); in milah three layers are cut away while periah is raised up. The Masorah's siman for Kedoshim's 64 pesukim is 'noga'. i,j,k

Bnei Keturah: milah without periah

22:32

The Mashgiach brings the Rambam that the Bnei Keturah are obligated in milah, and the Shaagas Aryeh and Minchas Chinuch, who say only milah and not periah, since periah was given in Yehoshua's time. The inner reason is that a gentile's soul is from the three impure kelipos and cannot elevate noga. Therefore shelamim, eaten as part of the service, are not accepted from gentiles, who bring only olos burned whole, as the Midrash Shir HaShirim Rabbah on 'uri tzafon' shows. l,p

Why impurity is called 'crowns'

26:38

Rereading the Tanya, the Mashgiach notes that it speaks of a Jew, whose animal soul is noga, and asks why its ten powers are called crowns rather than sefiros. A sefirah is luminous, like 'livnas hasapir' (Shemos 24:10): like a window, it lets the light of kedushah through, and that is bittul. Impurity says 'ani v'afsi od' (Yeshayahu 47:8), 'I am something', and each power declares 'ana emloch' (Melachim I 1:5), 'I will reign'; so they are crowns. He links them to the ten sons of Haman. h,q,r,s,t

The mind behind the middos; garments of impurity

30:46

The Tanya says the middos of impurity also have an intellect. The Mashgiach illustrates: a child loves blocks and toy soldiers, an adult loves real estate and bank accounts. It is the same middah of chesed, but a small mind directs it to small things. So a child grows angry when someone grabs his marble, and boasts of a button an adult would be ashamed to wear.

34:14

Thoughts, speech and actions not for Hashem become garments of impurity: 'the deeds done under the sun'. The Gemara says there is nothing new under the sun, but above it, in Torah, there is (Shabbos 30b). They are 'hevel ur'us ruach' (Koheles 1:14), a broken spirit; the Mashgiach stresses this means not only real aveiros but plain nonsense and entertainment. u,v

No neutral reshus: the 'other side'

37:09

The Mashgiach explains that there is no middle between mitzvah and aveirah. Eating matzah is a mitzvah and eating treif an aveirah, and a sandwich seems neutral; but eaten for Heaven's sake it raises noga to kedushah, and otherwise noga joins the three impure kelipos. Business too should be for Heaven's sake, to have money for tzedakah. What decides is whether one is nullified to Hashem.

40:46

Why is impurity called sitra achra? The Mashgiach brings the Kotzker Rebbe's question why the Targum on 'al tigshu el ishah' (Shemos 19:15) adds 'l'tzad'. A fence has two sides, as at a wedding one is on the groom's side or the bride's; one who wants to stand at Sinai must be wholly on the other side from desire. The Ba'al HaTanya says the same: kedushah rests only on what is nullified to Hashem, and all else is the other side. y,z,h

Sources

Torah

  1. c Bereishis 33:12 text index In the write-up: 2:11
  2. j Vayikra 19:23-24 text index In the write-up: 19:22
  3. q Shemos 24:10 text index In the write-up: 26:38
  4. y Shemos 19:15 text index In the write-up: 40:46

Nevi'im

  1. e Shmuel I 16:12 text index In the write-up: 4:36
  2. n Yehoshua 5:2 23:26 text index
  3. r Yeshayahu 47:8 text index In the write-up: 26:38
  4. s Melachim I 1:5 text index In the write-up: 26:38

Kesuvim

  1. a Koheles 7:14 text index In the write-up: 0:17
  2. t apparently Esther 9:7-10 index In the write-up: 26:38
  3. v Koheles 1:14 text index In the write-up: 34:14

Targum

  1. z apparently Onkelos on Shemos 19:15 index In the write-up: 40:46

Talmud Bavli

  1. b apparently Chagigah 5b index In the write-up: 2:11
  2. m apparently Yevamos 71b 23:12 index
  3. o Gemara (place not identified) 24:26 index
  4. u apparently Shabbos 30b index In the write-up: 34:14

Midrash

  1. d Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 4:36
  2. f Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 4:36
  3. g Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 7:29
  4. p apparently Shir HaShirim Rabbah on 4:16 index In the write-up: 22:32

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. w Zohar (place not identified) 35:48 index
  2. x apparently Zohar, Terumah (Kegavna) 40:27 index

Rishonim

  1. i Ramban on Vayikra 19:2 text index In the write-up: 19:22
  2. l apparently Rambam, Hilchos Melachim 10:8 index In the write-up: 22:32

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. h apparently Tanya ch. 6 index In the write-up: 0:17, 10:30, 26:38, 40:46

Other

  1. k apparently Masorah, end of Parshas Kedoshim In the write-up: 19:22

Key points

  1. 1:42 Hashem made kedushah and impurity in balance, 'zeh l'umas zeh'; only by taking Hashem along does a person tip the balance toward kedushah.
  2. 10:30 Just as the G-dly soul has ten holy sefiros clothed in thought, speech and action, the animal soul from kelipas noga has ten powers of impurity: seven bad middos and an intellect divided into three.
  3. 14:24 A Jew's animal soul is from kelipas noga, which can be turned to kedushah when he eats and does physical things for the sake of Heaven; a gentile's comes from the three wholly impure kelipos, which cannot.
  4. 27:59 Impurity is called 'crowns' and not sefiros because a sefirah is transparent and nullified to Hashem, while each power of impurity declares 'I will reign'.
  5. 37:09 There is no neutral middle: a permitted act not done for Heaven's sake joins the side of impurity, which is why it is called sitra achra, the 'other side'.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 27:53 Why are the ten powers of impurity called 'crowns' and not sefiros?

    Answer: 28:04 A sefirah is transparent and nullified, letting kedushah shine through; each power of impurity says 'I will reign' and refuses to be nullified, like a crown.

  2. Question: 22:56 Why are the Bnei Keturah obligated in milah but not in periah?

    Answer: 23:12 In the plain halachah, periah was given only in Yehoshua's time; inwardly, periah corresponds to kelipas noga, which only a Jew can elevate.

  3. Question: 32:03 Why does a child use his love on small things and an adult on large ones?

    Answer: 32:10 The middos are born of the intellect; a small mind directs the same middah to small things, a large mind to large ones.

  4. Question: 36:58 Is there a neutral category of permitted acts between mitzvah and aveirah?

    Answer: 37:29 No. A permitted act done for Heaven's sake becomes a mitzvah; otherwise noga joins the three impure kelipos and it becomes an aveirah.

  5. Question: 40:57 Why does the Targum add the word 'l'tzad' to 'al tigshu el ishah'?

    Answer: 41:18 The Kotzker Rebbe explained that there are two sides of a fence, and one who wishes to receive the Torah must be wholly on the other side from desire.

  6. Question: 40:16 Why is impurity called sitra achra?

    Answer: 42:43 It is the other side, not the side of kedushah, because kedushah rests only on what is nullified to Hashem.

Stories

  1. 2:11 Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya's last words

    Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya used to debate the minim and always defeat them. When he was about to pass away, his students asked who would now stand up to the minim. He answered with the passuk 'nis'ah v'neleichah v'eilchah l'negdecha', and the Gemara explains that as the wisdom of Israel diminishes, the minim's power diminishes too.

    In the story: Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya

    told in 3 other shiurim →

Insights

  1. 4:03 Because kedushah and impurity are evenly balanced, a person cannot tip the scale by himself; when he takes Hashem along, Hashem becomes the deciding weight.
  2. 17:32 Kelipas noga is like the thin brown skin of a walnut: removed alone it is inedible, but eaten together with the nut it becomes food.
  3. 21:24 The Masorah's siman 'noga' for the 64 pesukim of Parshas Kedoshim shows that the parsha is about raising kelipas noga to kedushah.
  4. 23:54 The halachah that the Bnei Keturah have milah but not periah has an inner reason: periah corresponds to kelipas noga, which a gentile cannot elevate.
  5. 28:04 A sefirah is named for transparency, like a window that lets light through, and so expresses bittul; impurity's powers are 'crowns' because each one claims to be king.
  6. 31:42 A child and an adult have the same middah of chesed; what differs is the intellect that gives birth to it, which directs the love to small or to large things.
  7. 41:18 The Kotzker Rebbe read the Targum's 'l'tzad' as two sides of a fence: one who wishes to stand at Sinai must be entirely on the other side from desire, and this is the meaning of sitra achra.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 19:40 The Mashgiach says one should eat and sleep for the sake of Heaven, to have strength to learn, daven and serve Hashem, and this turns the physical to kedushah.
  2. 38:28 The Mashgiach says business too should be for Heaven's sake, to have money for one's mitzvah needs and to give tzedakah.
  3. 13:15 The Mashgiach says that in the days of sefirah one asks Hashem, in the merit of counting, to refine the middah of that day and repair what was damaged in it.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham Avinu, Bilaam, Dovid HaMelech, Esav, Haman, Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya, Shaul HaMelech, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Kotzker Rebbe (Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk), the Minchas Chinuch, the Rambam, the Ramban, the Shaagas Aryeh, Yaakov Avinu, Yehoshua bin Nun, Yishmael

Terms ביטול, טומאה, נפש האלקית, נפש הבהמית, סטרא אחרא, ערלה, עשר כתרין דמסאבותא, פריעה, קליפת נוגה

Report an error on this page