כל אחד זוכה להאור שבתורה לפי קדושתו ומדרגתו.
Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' ה no. 16 Pocket Guide p. 42 Yiddish 45 min
Listen
About this shiur
Building on the Derech Hashem and Tanya chapter 5, the Mashgiach explains that Torah draws down G-dliness only when learned with awe and by an upright Jew, each according to his level, and that understanding a halacha unites a person with Hashem's wisdom more deeply than any other mitzvah.
The Mashgiach recalls from chapter 4 that Torah and mitzvos are vessels for Hashem's light, and brings the Derech Hashem: every person, through Torah and mitzvos, draws holy influence into himself and into all creation, but on two conditions. The first is learning with seriousness and derech eretz, not lightheadedly; here he discusses dress while learning, tells of the Arugas Habosem, and warns against copying a rebbe's faults, citing the four kinds of students in Avos. The second is being an upright Jew, though even a rasha's Torah keeps a trace of holiness. After the parable of the esrog, he learns Tanya chapter 5: the intellect grasps what it understands and is enclothed in it, so understanding a halacha grasps Hashem's will, a unity greater than any mitzvah. He compares sod and pshat, explains Torah as the soul's bread, and closes with a story from R' Yitzchak Chayes.
Topics: The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8) · The Power and Greatness of Torah · Yiras Shamayim
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Torah and mitzvos draw light into all creation
The Mashgiach recalls chapter 4, that Torah and mitzvos are vessels for Hashem's holiness, and brings the Derech Hashem: through them each person draws holy influence into himself and into all creation, some tzaddikim to the point of bringing a city, a country or the world to teshuvah.
-
3:54 First condition: learning with awe; the Arugas Habosem
The Mashgiach brings the Derech Hashem's first condition, that Torah be learned with seriousness and awe, not sprawled out lightheadedly, and discusses how people dress while learning. He tells how a fellow student found the Arugas Habosem learning on a hot day fully dressed, and the Arugas Habosem answered that he had learned other things from their Rebbe.
-
7:43 Learning the good from a rebbe, not the faults
Using the four kinds of students in Avos, the Mashgiach warns against picking out a rebbe's apparent faults, such as the Ohev Yisroel's eating or R' Baruch's anger, which had hidden reasons. He explains that chassidim in Eretz Yisroel learn in shirtsleeves because of the hot climate of their origins, while the common rule is derech eretz for Torah.
-
13:35 Respect for seforim; the lamp and the current
The Mashgiach brings the Derech Hashem that one must honor the seforim and speak respectfully of the Rishonim; learning without derech eretz draws nothing. Torah words are vessels in which Hashem contracts Himself, and like a lamp not plugged in, they give no light when learned without awe.
-
16:44 Second condition; each according to his level; the esrog listed in the guide
The second condition is that the learner not be a rasha, yet even a rasha's Torah has a trace of holiness that brings him back, like a body that keeps a trace of its soul; each person draws according to his level. The Mashgiach then explains why an esrog worth twenty cents costs a hundred and fifty dollars: G-dliness is enclothed in it, so holding it one holds G-dliness.
-
23:08 Tanya ch. 5: intellect, knower and known
The Mashgiach begins Tanya chapter 5 on the term 'grasping', and explains the three terms sechel, maskil and muskal. The intellect grasps and surrounds what it understands, and at the same time is enclothed in it, as one absorbed in a Tosfos does not hear when called: a two-way unity.
-
28:26 Halacha as Hashem's will; a wondrous unity
The Mashgiach explains that every halacha, even about cases that may never occur, is Hashem's wisdom and will; when one understands it clearly, he grasps what no thought can grasp, like embracing the king through his garments. This is a unity with nothing like it in the physical world, greater than that of mitzvos, which enclothe a person only from outside.
-
35:51 Mitzvos with kavanah; sod versus pshat listed in the guide
The Mashgiach notes that a mitzvah done with kavanah also includes Torah, but the Tanya speaks of the bare act. He then explains that each grasps Torah according to his intellect in pshat, remez, drash and sod: sod is higher because it has fewer garments, yet a clearly understood Gemara gives a stronger unity, since no one fully grasps the secrets of the Torah.
-
40:44 Torah as bread; mitzvos as garments
The Mashgiach explains why Torah is called bread that nourishes the soul when learned in depth, and brings the Zohar that in the world of souls Torah is food and mitzvos are garments. He brings R' Pinchas of Koretz on why mitzvos cost money and Torah is free, tells of R' Yitzchak Chayes who appeared to his son in fine garments but without shoes, and closes urging both collecting for Jews and learning Torah lishmah.
The shiur, written up
Torah and mitzvos draw light into all creation
The Mashgiach recalls from the previous chapter that through Torah and mitzvos a person's soul is enclothed in Hashem's holiness. He brings the Derech Hashem: Torah and mitzvos are vessels that draw Hashem's influence into the person and into all creation. Everyone has some power over creation, but some tzaddikim, as among the students of the Ba'al Shem Tov, could bring a city, a country or the whole world to teshuvah. b,a
First condition: learning with awe
The greatest influence comes from words of Torah, but the Derech Hashem sets a condition: Torah must be learned with seriousness and yiras shamayim, not sprawled out lightheadedly. Customs of dress while learning differ, the Mashgiach says, and what counts is the intention for Heaven. A fellow student of the Ksav Sofer once found the Arugas Habosem learning under a tree on a hot day in a velvet hat and gartel, and asked whether he had seen this from their Rebbe. He answered that he had learned other things from the Rebbe. a
Learning the good from a rebbe
From here the Mashgiach explains that every person has good to learn from and things not to copy, as the Mishnah in Avos lists the kinds of students who sit before the sages. Some visit all the rebbes and pick out exactly the wrong things: the Ohev Yisroel's eating, as when snow kept the chassidim away and he finished a whole pot of cholent; a tzaddik's long sleep; R' Baruch's anger, which was for Heaven's sake. Such conduct had hidden aspects. d
Chassidim in Eretz Yisroel, even rebbes, learn in shirtsleeves because they come from places like Tveria, where a jacket in summer heat is impossible, while others come from cool northern lands. Each follows how his rebbe behaved in his place; the shared principle is derech eretz while learning.
Respect for seforim; the lamp
The Derech Hashem also requires honoring seforim. One who treats them carelessly, or speaks lightly of Rishonim such as Rashi and Tosfos, lacks derech eretz for Torah, and his learning draws nothing. Words of Torah are vessels in which Hashem contracts Himself; like a lamp not plugged in, they give no light when learned without awe. a
Second condition; the esrog
The second condition is that the learner not be a rasha, as the passuk in Tehillim says to the rasha, what is it to you to tell My laws; his Torah is like idle stories. Yet the Derech Hashem reveals that even a rasha who learns much is brought back to good by the Torah's light. Torah properly learned is a body with a soul; otherwise it is a body without one, which still keeps a trace of the soul, as at the graves of tzaddikim. Each draws according to his level. e,a
A lemon costs cents, yet before Sukkos one pays a hundred and fifty dollars for an esrog, because G-dliness is drawn into it. No thought can grasp Hashem, but holding the four species one holds G-dliness, and shaking them spreads it to all sides of the world.
Tanya ch. 5: intellect, knower and known
The Mashgiach begins Tanya chapter 5 on the term 'grasping', since, as the Tikkunei Zohar says, no thought can grasp Hashem. He explains sechel, the power to think; maskil, the intellect thinking; and muskal, the thing understood, such as a Tosfos. The intellect grasps and surrounds what it understands, yet is also enclothed in it: one absorbed in a Tosfos does not hear when called. It is a unity from both sides. c,h
Halacha as Hashem's will
The halacha, the Mashgiach explains, is Hashem's own wisdom and will, as learned earlier from the Rambam that He is the knower and the knowledge. When Reuven claims from Shimon, the psak is Hashem's will, even in cases that may never occur. One who understands it clearly, not in a fog, grasps what no thought could grasp were it not enclothed in halacha, like embracing the king through his garments. i
This is a wondrous unity with nothing like it in the physical world. A mitzvah enclothes a person from head to foot, but only from outside; in Torah the intellect also takes G-dliness inside.
Kavanah; sod and pshat
A mitzvah done with kavanah includes Torah too, the Mashgiach notes, but the Tanya speaks of the bare act. Each grasps Torah by his intellect in pshat, remez, drash and sod. Sod is higher, having fewer garments; yet a clearly understood Gemara, even a physical halacha about tefillin or money, is a stronger unity, since no one, not even angels, fully grasps sod. Each has its virtue.
Torah as bread; mitzvos as garments
Torah learned in depth is bread that nourishes the soul; the Zohar says that among the souls Torah is food and mitzvos are garments. So, R' Pinchas of Koretz explains, mitzvos cost money while Torah, like bread, is free. R' Yitzchak Chayes appeared to his son in fine garments but without shoes, since he had not collected for the poor. The Mashgiach concludes that one must both collect for Jews and learn Torah lishmah. j,m
Sources
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
Key points
- 2:12 Through Torah and mitzvos every Jew draws holy influence into himself and into all of creation, each according to the reach of his soul.
- 4:16 According to the Derech Hashem, Torah draws down holiness only when learned with awe, seriousness and derech eretz, and by a person who is not a rasha.
- 14:42 Words of Torah are vessels for G-dliness, like a lamp that gives light only when connected to the current.
- 17:58 Even Torah learned without the proper way keeps some holiness of its own, like a body that keeps a trace of the soul.
- 26:41 Tanya chapter 5 teaches that when one understands a halacha, his intellect grasps Hashem's will and is enclothed in it, a two-way unity found in no physical thing.
- 34:43 The unity of Torah study surpasses that of mitzvos: a mitzvah enclothes a person from outside, while Torah is taken inside, like bread that becomes part of the body.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 17:01 If a rasha's Torah draws no holiness, how can the light of Torah bring him back to good?
Answer: 17:53 Torah as a vessel draws nothing in such a case, but in itself it keeps a little holiness, like a body that keeps a trace of the soul, so much Torah will in the end improve him.
-
Question: 21:19 Why does one pay a hundred and fifty dollars for an esrog whose market value is twenty cents?
Answer: 21:44 Because there is spirituality in it: G-dliness is drawn into the esrog, making it a body with a soul.
-
Question: 23:16 If no thought can grasp Hashem, how can a person grasp Him at all?
Answer: 23:35 His will and wisdom are enclothed in the halachos of the Torah, so one who understands a halacha grasps them, like one who embraces the king through his garments.
-
Question: 29:34 Why study the Gemara's laws about cases that have never happened and may never happen?
Answer: 30:30 Because every psak is Hashem's will and wisdom: had the case occurred, this is how it would be decided, and understanding it grasps His will.
-
Question: 37:55 Is learning the secrets of the Torah a greater unity than learning a Gemara?
Answer: 39:06 Sod is higher, having fewer garments, but a Gemara understood clearly is a stronger unity, since no one can fully grasp sod; each has its own virtue.
-
Question: 42:34 Why do mitzvos cost a lot of money while Torah study is free?
Answer: 42:48 R' Pinchas of Koretz explains that Torah is bread, a necessity whose price is cheap, while mitzvos are garments, which are expensive.
Stories
-
6:27 The Arugas Habosem learning fully dressed
The Arugas Habosem, a student of the Ksav Sofer in Pressburg who later became a chassid, was visited on a hot summer day by a former fellow student. He found him learning under a tree in his velvet hat and gartel. The visitor was annoyed and asked whether he had ever seen their Rebbe learn so dressed on a hot day. The Arugas Habosem answered that he had learned other things from the Rebbe.
In the story: the Arugas HaBosem (Rabbi Moshe Greenwald), the Ksav Sofer
-
8:38 The Ohev Yisroel and the pot of cholent
The Ohev Yisroel was known to eat a great deal. Once a large pot of cholent was prepared for Shabbos, but a heavy snow fell and the chassidim could not come. He stood by the big pot and ate until he finished all of it. The Mashgiach says there were many such hidden aspects in the conduct of tzaddikim.
In the story: the Apter Rav (the Ohev Yisrael)
-
43:43 R' Yitzchak Chayes without shoes
R' Yitzchak Chayes wrote a commentary on the Mishnah, and in its introduction his son writes that his father came to him after his passing dressed in unusually beautiful garments but without shoes. The father explained that he had done all the mitzvos and so received fine garments, but he had not gone around collecting money for poor people, and therefore he had no shoes.
In the story: Rabbi Yitzchak Chayes
Insights
- 8:00 The Mashgiach reads the Mishnah of the four kinds of students as a warning to those who visit many rebbes and pick out precisely what is not to be imitated, such as a tzaddik's eating, sleeping or anger, whose hidden reasons they do not see.
- 11:54 Different customs about dress while learning come from the climate where each group's rebbes lived; each follows how his rebbe behaved in his place, while the shared principle is derech eretz for Torah.
- 17:53 Torah has two aspects: as a vessel it draws G-dliness only when learned properly, but in itself it always keeps some holiness, like a dead body that still bears a trace of the soul, which is why people pray at the graves of tzaddikim.
- 21:26 The price of an esrog shows that G-dliness is clothed in it: no thought can grasp Hashem, yet one holding the lulav and esrog holds G-dliness in his hand and spreads it to all sides of the world when he shakes them.
- 38:07 Although the secrets of the Torah are higher because they have fewer garments, a Gemara or halacha understood clearly gives a stronger unity, since even angels cannot fully grasp sod, while a physical halacha can be truly understood.
- 42:28 R' Pinchas of Koretz explains that mitzvos cost money and Torah is free because Torah is bread, a basic necessity whose price is low, while mitzvos are garments, which are expensive.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 4:37 The Mashgiach says one must learn Torah with seriousness, yiras shamayim and derech eretz, not lightheadedly.
- 7:29 The Mashgiach says one should learn the good from every person and every rebbe, and not copy what is not meant to be learned from him.
- 13:35 The Mashgiach says one must honor seforim and speak with respect of the Rishonim and the sages.
- 38:38 The Mashgiach says a Gemara should be learned in depth until it is clear, understanding even why a difficulty is difficult.
- 44:35 The Mashgiach says one must both go collecting money for Jews in need and learn Torah lishmah.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Dovid HaMelech, Rabbi Pinchas of Koretz, Rabbi Yitzchak Chayes, Rebbe Reb Baruch'l of Mezhibuzh, the Apter Rav (the Ohev Yisrael), the Arugas HaBosem (Rabbi Moshe Greenwald), the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Ksav Sofer, the Ramchal (Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto)
Terms ארבעה מינים, אתרוג, דרך ארץ קדמה לתורה, השפעה, יחוד, יראת שמים, לית מחשבה תפיסא ביה, סודות התורה, פרד"ס, קלות ראש