התחלת התשובה' על דרך עבודה' לתרץ הקושיות שבראש הספר. רשע ורע לו צדיק ורע לו (הרע כפוף בו) צדיק וטוב לו מהותם.
Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' ט-י no. 25 Pocket Guide p. 43 Yiddish 38 min
Listen
About this shiur
Opening Tanya chapter 10, the Mashgiach explains the tzaddik gamur, who has turned his evil into good and hates this world's pleasures out of love of Hashem, the tzaddik she'eino gamur, whose evil is only subdued, and the bnei aliyah who raise the evil up and serve Hashem for the sake of the Shechinah.
The Mashgiach explains that until chapter 10 the Tanya laid down foundations; now the path of avodah begins, and the questions of chapter one on tzaddik v'tov lo and tzaddik v'ra lo will be answered. The tzaddik gamur and the rasha gamur are two extremes that have lost their bechirah: one has turned his evil into good, the other, like Pharaoh, his good into evil. He tells of tzaddikim who remembered earlier gilgulim. The tzaddik gamur hates this world's pleasures because they come from the sitra achra and are the opposite of his love of Hashem with delight, illustrated by stories of the Beis Aharon and the Berditchever. The tzaddik she'eino gamur hates evil only according to his level; his evil is subdued and nullified, not transformed. Finally he explains the bnei aliyah, who raise the evil up to holiness and serve Hashem for a need on High, to do kindness with the Shechinah in exile.
Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · Ahavas Hashem and Dveikus
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 From foundations to the path of avodah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that until chapter 10 the Tanya laid down foundations, and from here the path of avodah begins and the questions of chapter one are answered. He reads the opening of the chapter and sets out the two extremes: the tzaddik gamur who has turned his yetzer hara into good, and the rasha who has turned his good into evil.
-
4:24 Pharaoh, and tzaddikim without bechirah listed in the guide
Using Pharaoh, whose heart was turned to evil, the Mashgiach shows that the two extremes have lost their bechirah. He tells of tzaddikim such as the Yismach Moshe and the Apter Rav who remembered their earlier gilgulim, and explains that Pharaoh let the Jews go not by free choice; until Matan Torah, he adds, non-Jews could still reach a high level, as the Ramchal discusses.
-
8:35 Tzaddik v'ra lo and tzaddik v'tov lo listed in the guide
After placing the beinoni between the extremes, the Mashgiach reads the Tanya: one who drives out evil but has not transformed it is a tzaddik she'eino gamur, tzaddik v'ra lo, whose evil is only bent and suppressed. The tzaddik gamur has turned it fully to good, has removed the soiled garments, and despises the pleasures of this world.
-
13:12 Love of Hashem with delight listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains why the tzaddik gamur hates this world's pleasures: they come from the kelipah, while he serves Hashem with a love full of delight. He brings the Beis Aharon on the word 'kamah', his reply about a nobleman who went sledding on sugar in summer, a tzaddik who could not tear himself away from Shemoneh Esrei, and the Berditchever who rushed to learn Gemara Sukkah after Yom Kippur; the measure of the love is the measure of the hatred of the sitra achra.
-
19:27 Why we must know what a tzaddik is listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why people who are not tzaddikim need to know this, and answers that one must love tzaddikim and know whose Torah one learns. The tzaddik she'eino gamur hates this world only according to his level, which he illustrates with the countless levels among people; one should not be shaken by still feeling an attraction to this world, since fighting it is our avodah. He returns to the tzaddikim who remembered earlier gilgulim and explains why others are not given that memory.
-
25:09 Evil nullified, and the levels of tzaddikim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that in the tzaddik she'eino gamur the evil is nullified by the strength of the good so that he never sins, yet it remains evil, and so he is tzaddik v'ra lo; one who does not hate evil completely does not love Hashem completely, except at high moments. This level divides into countless levels, from those whose evil is batel b'shishim, which he connects with the Gemara's numbers of 18,000, 36 and one tzaddik.
-
29:00 The bnei aliyah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains why the true tzaddikim gemurim are called bnei aliyah: they raise the evil up to holiness, as in the Zohar's story of R' Chiya at the heichal of R' Shimon bar Yochai, where darkness is turned to light. A second reason is that they serve Hashem for a need on High, not even to quench their own thirst for Him, but to do kindness with the Shechinah in exile, as the Tikkunim and the Ra'aya Mehemna describe.
The shiur, written up
From foundations to the path of avodah
Pharaoh, and tzaddikim without bechirah
The Mashgiach shows this from Pharaoh, whose heart, the verse says, was turned over, not merely bent. Such extremes no longer have bechirah. Tzaddikim like the Yismach Moshe and the Apter Rav told their students of their earlier gilgulim; the Apter remembered having been a kohen gadol. d
Pharaoh too let the Jews go not by choice but to save his life. He was a lofty soul, and until Matan Torah non-Jews could still be great, as the Ramchal discusses.
Tzaddik v'ra lo and tzaddik v'tov lo
Between the extremes stands the beinoni, who never sins. The Tanya then explains that one who drives out evil without transforming it is a tzaddik she'eino gamur: like the two angels of the previous chapter, the evil can return. He is tzaddik v'ra lo; his evil is bent and suppressed, not nullified. a
Love of Hashem with delight
Why must he hate them? Because they come from the kelipah, while he serves Hashem with a love full of delight. The Beis Aharon explained the word 'kamah' in the verse in Tehillim to mean that nothing in this world compares to the pleasure of a tzaddik serving Hashem. f,g
When told of a nobleman who spread sacks of sugar to go sledding in summer, the Beis Aharon asked what he knows of pleasure compared to saying Nishmas on Shabbos. The Berditchever, on motza'ei Yom Kippur, refused food and asked for a Gemara Sukkah, which he learned through.
Why we must know what a tzaddik is
Why do we need to know this? The Mashgiach answers that one must love tzaddikim, and when learning from the Tanna'im, Rashi, the Chasam Sofer or the Chofetz Chaim, one should know whose Torah one is learning.
The tzaddik she'eino gamur hates this world only by his level. Someone may find a filthy television show disgusting, yet not a slice of kosher pizza; every Jew stands on a different level. One should not be shaken by some attraction to this world, the Mashgiach says: fighting the yetzer hara is our avodah.
This explains the tzaddikim who remembered their gilgulim: they came down only to fix their generation, guaranteed to remain tzaddikim, so they had no bechirah to lose. Others would lose theirs by remembering.
Evil nullified, and the levels of tzaddikim
The bnei aliyah
True tzaddikim gemurim are few: R' Shimon bar Yochai said he saw bnei aliyah and they are few. They are so called because they turn evil over and raise it to holiness, like a korban's fragrance rising; in Heaven there can be no evil. i
In the Zohar, when R' Chiya wished to enter the heichal of R' Shimon bar Yochai, a voice asked who among them turns darkness to light and bitter to sweet; whoever has not reached that level may not enter. j
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 1:13 From chapter 10 the Tanya moves from foundations to the path of avodah and begins answering the questions of chapter one.
- 3:56 The tzaddik gamur has transformed his evil into good, while the rasha gamur has transformed his good into evil; both extremes no longer have real bechirah.
- 12:43 The tzaddik gamur hates the pleasures of this world because they come from the kelipah, the opposite of his love of Hashem with delight.
- 11:02 In the tzaddik she'eino gamur the evil is subdued and nullified by the good, but it remains evil, so he is called tzaddik v'ra lo.
- 18:49 Hatred of evil and love of Hashem go together: only one who hates evil completely can love Hashem completely.
- 29:23 The bnei aliyah raise the evil up to holiness, and they serve Hashem not to quench their own thirst for Him but to do kindness with the Shechinah in exile.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 13:12 Why must the tzaddik gamur hate the pleasures of this world?
Answer: 13:14 Because all the desires of this world come from the kelipos, the opposite of his great love of Hashem with delight.
-
Question: 19:27 Why do people who are not tzaddikim need to know what a tzaddik is?
Answer: 19:33 Because one must love tzaddikim and be humble before them, and when learning Torah one should know whose Torah one is learning.
-
Question: 23:44 Why did certain tzaddikim remember their earlier gilgulim while others do not?
Answer: 24:07 They were tzaddikim gemurim who came down only for the sake of their generation with a guarantee to remain tzaddikim, so they no longer had bechirah; someone who still has bechirah would lose it if he remembered.
-
Question: 29:18 Why are the true tzaddikim called bnei aliyah?
Answer: 29:23 Because they turn the evil over and raise it up to holiness; and further, because all their mitzvos are for a need on High.
Stories
-
14:33 The nobleman's summer sled ride
A nobleman wanted to go sledding in the middle of summer, so his servants spread hundreds of sacks of sugar on the road until it was covered with sugar, and he rode his sled on the sugar. People told the Beis Aharon of the pleasure such a man could have. The Beis Aharon answered: what does he know of pleasure, compared to the pleasure he himself has when he stands on Shabbos and says Nishmas kol chai.
In the story: the Beis Aharon (Rabbi Aharon II of Karlin-Stolin), Reb Eliyahu Shalom (the Mashgiach's father), Rabbi Moshe Leib of Sassov
-
17:09 The Berditchever's Gemara Sukkah after Yom Kippur
On motza'ei Yom Kippur Reb Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev cried out that he must hurry and catch up. When they brought him something to eat, he refused, and asked for a Gemara Sukkah, sat down and learned it through. Before Sukkos one should learn Maseches Sukkah, and on Yom Kippur there had been no time to learn; this was his pleasure.
In the story: Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev
Insights
- 5:12 The verse about Pharaoh says his heart was 'turned over', not merely bent: in the rasha gamur the good itself has become evil, the mirror image of the tzaddik gamur.
- 23:44 Tzaddikim gemurim could remember their earlier gilgulim because they have no bechirah left to lose; others are not given that memory, since remembering would take away their bechirah.
- 26:31 Love of Hashem and hatred of evil are measured against each other: whoever does not hate evil completely cannot love Hashem completely, except in elevated moments of davening.
- 29:34 Like the fragrance of a korban that rises up, the bnei aliyah take the evil itself and raise it to such a level that it ascends to Heaven, where no evil can exist.
- 33:33 The greatest tzaddikim serve Hashem not even to quench their own thirst for Him, but to do kindness with the Shechinah in exile, like a son toiling to redeem his parents.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 20:25 The Mashgiach says that when one sits down to learn, one should truly know whose Torah one is learning, the Tanna'im, Rashi, or tzaddikim like the Chasam Sofer and the Chofetz Chaim who learned lishmah.
- 23:14 The Mashgiach says one should not be shaken or feel bad on seeing that one still has some attraction to this world; we came into the world to fight the yetzer hara, and that is our avodah.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Pharaoh, Rabbi Chiya, Rabbi Elazar (ben Pedas), Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, the Apter Rav (the Ohev Yisrael), the Beis Aharon (Rabbi Aharon II of Karlin-Stolin), the Chasam Sofer, the Chofetz Chaim, the Ramchal (Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto), the Yismach Moshe, Yaakov Avinu
Terms אהבה בתענוגים, בטל בששים, בינוני, גלגול, סטרא אחרא, צדיק גמור, צדיק ורע לו, שכינה