מלחמת יצה"ר ויצה"ט על העיר הקטנה. שניהם רוצים שהשני יהיה בטל אצלו.
Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' י no. 26 Pocket Guide p. 43 Yiddish 40 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains how the Godly soul and the animal soul fight like two kings over the 'small city' of the body, each wanting the other to be subdued to it, and what this war asks of an ordinary person.
Learning Tanya chapter 9, the Mashgiach explains that the animal soul of a Jew, from kelipas nogah, dwells in the blood-filled left chamber of the heart, while the Godly soul dwells in the brain and the right chamber. The heart's blood even drives the brain to scheme for the heart's desires; the liver, all blood, is lower still, and a Midrash reads Pharaoh's 'heavy heart' as a heart that was really a liver. Contemplation of Hashem's greatness gives birth to love, as Birchas Yotzer leads to Ahavah Rabbah. The body is a small city over which the yetzer tov and the yetzer hara wage constant war, each wanting the other subdued. The yetzer tov wants its love to overflow into the left chamber until even appetite serves Hashem, as with matzah eaten with appetite. Only a tzaddik gamur transforms his evil; for most people the avodah is to subdue it, and the Zohar's parable shows the yetzer hara itself serves the King.
Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos · The Two Souls (Tanya ch. 1-8)
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The animal soul in the left chamber of the heart
The Mashgiach reads the Tanya's words that the animal soul of a Jew, from kelipas nogah, dwells in the blood-filled left chamber of the heart. He explains the two chambers, the blood as the vehicle of the vital soul, and why a Jew's animal soul can be transformed to good.
-
3:40 Desires rise to the brain; the Godly soul's seat
The Mashgiach explains how the desires of the heart spread through the body and rise to the brain, which plans how to fulfil them because the heart's blood drives it. He then reads that the Godly soul dwells in the brain and in the right chamber, 'the heart of the wise is on his right'.
-
7:22 The liver, and Pharaoh's heart
The Mashgiach explains that the liver, lower than heart and brain, is full of blood, which is why the poskim say it cannot be salted but must be roasted. He tells the Midrash of the lion, the donkey that had 'no heart' and the fox, and the Midrash's reading of 'Pharaoh's heart is heavy' as a heart that was a liver.
-
11:17 The heart of the wise is on his right
The Mashgiach explains that good middos come from the right chamber and bad ones from the left, and that the wise man's contemplation of Hashem's greatness arouses love of Hashem in the right chamber. He shows this in the order of tefillah, where Birchas Yotzer's contemplation gives birth to the love of Ahavah Rabbah.
-
18:11 Two kings fighting over the small city listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings 'one nation shall overpower the other' about Yaakov and Esav as the constant war of the yetzer tov and the yetzer hara, and the Tanya's image of the body as a small city two kings fight over. He explains that the Godly soul wants to rule the body alone, with all its limbs, powers and garments subjugated to it.
-
22:26 Chabad gives birth to love that overflows listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains what the yetzer tov wants: chochmah, binah and daas of the Godly soul filling the mind, giving birth to fear and love like a father and mother give birth to children. The love is to fill the right chamber until it spills into the left and subdues the sitra achra there.
-
25:42 Matzah with appetite: serving with both inclinations listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why the Mishnah wants matzah eaten with appetite if a mitzvah should be done only for Hashem's will, and answers that the yetzer hara must serve the yetzer tov. The appetite gives the mitzvah its fire, and this is 'with all your heart, with both your inclinations'.
-
29:40 Love with delight and avodas matanah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the yetzer tov wants the 'evil waters', the drive for pleasure, transformed into love of Hashem, up to love with delight that even simple people taste at high moments such as Shabbos. He distinguishes 'avodas avodah', service by toil, from 'avodas matanah', service as a gift.
-
33:57 Not a tzaddik gamur; the Zohar's parable listed in the guide
Anticipating the next chapter, the Mashgiach explains that only a tzaddik gamur transforms his yetzer hara, while most people's avodah is to subdue it, so no one should despair. He finishes the chapter: the yetzer tov wants thought, speech and action for Hashem alone, the animal soul wants the opposite, yet it too serves man's good, as the Zohar's parable of the king's son and the harlot shows.
The shiur, written up
The animal soul in the left chamber of the heart
The Mashgiach reads the Tanya in chapter 9: the animal soul of a Jew dwells in the left chamber of the heart, which is full of blood. The heart has two chambers; the left sends blood to the whole body, and blood is the vehicle of the vital soul, as 'the blood is the soul'. A Jew's animal soul comes from kelipas nogah, which can be turned to good. a,b
Desires rise to the brain
From the heart, the Mashgiach explains, the desires spread through the body and rise to the brain, which schemes how to get, say, a certain food. Why does the brain serve the heart? Because the heart sends it blood, and that blood drives it to fulfil the heart's wishes. The Godly soul, by contrast, dwells in the brain and spreads to the right chamber, where there is hardly any blood: 'the heart of the wise is on his right'. a,c
The liver, and Pharaoh's heart
Lower still is the liver, all blood; therefore, the Mashgiach notes, the Shulchan Aruch says it cannot be salted but must be roasted. He brings the Midrash on 'Pharaoh's heart is heavy': a donkey demanded the toll from the lion, who tore it apart; the fox ate its heart and claimed it had none, for with a heart it would never have spoken so to the king. So too Pharaoh's heart was a liver; with a heart he could have feared Hashem. d,e,f
The heart of the wise is on his right
Good middos come from the right chamber, the Mashgiach explains, and bad ones from the left. 'The heart of the wise is on his right': the wise man understands why he came into the world and is not enchanted by the yetzer hara, so his thoughts reach the right chamber. Love itself is not intellect but desire; pure thought arouses the right chamber to love Hashem, a fellow Jew, Torah and mitzvos. c
Two kings fighting over the small city
'One nation shall overpower the other', said of Yaakov and Esav, is the constant war of the yetzer tov and the yetzer hara. The body, the Mashgiach explains from Koheles, is a 'small city', and the two souls are like two kings each fighting to conquer it. The Godly soul wants to rule alone, with every limb, its ten powers and its garments of thought, speech and action subjugated to it. h,i
Chabad gives birth to love that overflows
The yetzer tov wants chochmah and binah, contemplating Hashem's endless greatness, to give birth through daas to love and fear, as father and mother give birth to children. That love is to fill the right chamber until it spills into the left and subdues the sitra achra, so that even the bad inclinations serve the yetzer tov.
Matzah with appetite
The Mishnah says not to eat on Erev Pesach, so the matzah is eaten with appetite. The Mashgiach asks: is a mitzvah not better done purely for Hashem's will? He answers that the yetzer hara must serve the yetzer tov. Its drive pushes a person to eat, he takes that drive and eats with kavanah, and without it the mitzvah would lack fire. This is 'with all your heart', with both inclinations. j,k,l
Love with delight and avodas matanah
The craving for pleasure comes from the left chamber, and the yetzer tov wants it transformed into love of Hashem, up to love with delight. Great tzaddikim feel it, the Mashgiach says, and even simple people at moments, such as Shabbos at Nishmas or Kiddush. Beyond 'avodas avodah', service by toil, there is 'avodas matanah', a gift of delight nothing in the world compares to. n,o
Not a tzaddik gamur
Previewing the Tanya's answer to its question in chapter 1, the Mashgiach explains that a tzaddik gamur has transformed his yetzer hara, as David said 'my heart is void within me'. Most people, especially today, will never reach this; their avodah is to subdue the yetzer hara, like a king who imprisons the enemy king. He says this now because such learning can frighten a person, and the Ba'al HaTanya does not demand it. q,r
Sources
Torah
- b apparently Devarim 12:23 index In the write-up: 1:01
- e Shemos 7:14 text index In the write-up: 7:52
- h Bereishis 25:23 text index In the write-up: 18:20
- k Devarim 6:5 text index In the write-up: 25:42
- n apparently Bamidbar 18:7 index In the write-up: 30:01
- o apparently Bamidbar 4:24 index In the write-up: 30:01
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- f Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 7:52
Zohar and Kabbalah
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 1:01 The animal soul dwells in the blood-filled left chamber of the heart, and the Godly soul dwells in the brain and spreads to the right chamber, where there is hardly any blood.
- 4:00 The desires of the heart rise to the brain and drive it to scheme how to fulfil them, because the heart sends its blood to the brain.
- 19:05 The body is a small city over which the Godly soul and the animal soul wage a lifelong war, each wanting the whole body subjugated to it alone.
- 24:39 The yetzer tov wants the love born of contemplation to fill the right chamber and overflow into the left, so that even the bad inclinations are subdued and used for good.
- 34:36 Only a tzaddik gamur transforms his yetzer hara into good; for the vast majority of people the avodah is to subdue it, like a king who imprisons the enemy king.
- 39:14 The yetzer hara itself is there for a person's good: like the harlot in the Zohar's parable, its true wish is that the person withstand it.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 5:17 Why does the brain, seat of the Godly soul, plan how to fulfil the heart's physical desires?
Answer: 5:24 Because the heart sends its blood to the brain, and that blood activates the brain to think of ways to fulfil the heart's wishes.
-
Question: 7:59 Why can the liver not be koshered by salting like other organs?
Answer: 8:11 Because, as the poskim say, the liver is entirely blood, so it must be roasted.
-
Question: 25:54 If matzah is a mitzvah, why should it be eaten with appetite rather than purely for Hashem's will?
Answer: 26:08 Because the yetzer hara must serve the yetzer tov: its drive gives the mitzvah fire and completeness, which is serving 'with both your inclinations'.
-
Question: 36:41 Why does the Mashgiach speak now about the tzaddik gamur, before the Ba'al HaTanya explains it in later chapters?
Answer: 36:49 Because learning about such levels can frighten a person into thinking he will never reach them, and the Ba'al HaTanya does not demand this of us.
Stories
-
8:45 The lion, the donkey and the fox
In the Midrash the Mashgiach tells, the lion went traveling with his entourage of animals and came to a bridge over a stream where a donkey collected the toll. The donkey demanded that the lion pay too; the lion said the toll's income goes to him, but the donkey insisted that everyone who crosses must pay. The angry lion tore the donkey apart and told the fox to prepare it as a meal for their return, and meanwhile the fox ate the donkey's heart. When the king asked where the heart was, the fox answered that the donkey had none: had it had a heart, would it have dared speak with such chutzpah to the king?
In the story: Pharaoh
-
39:26 The king who tested his son
From the Zohar the Mashgiach tells of a king who wanted to test whether his son was upright, and instructed a harlot to try to seduce him. The son, being a prince, did not let himself be seduced. The Zohar says the harlot is the yetzer hara, and her real joy is that the son not be enticed, for that fulfils the king's will.
Insights
- 5:17 The brain, though the seat of the Godly soul, is driven by the heart: the blood the heart sends up activates the brain to devise ways of fulfilling the heart's wishes.
- 10:48 Following the Midrash, Pharaoh's 'heavy heart' means his heart was a liver, all blood: he could admit his sin but had no heart to fear Hashem and send the people out.
- 15:31 The order of the morning blessings embodies the Tanya's teaching: Birchas Yotzer's contemplation of the luminaries and the angels gives birth to the love of Ahavah Rabbah, as intellect gives birth to emotion.
- 27:58 Eating matzah with appetite is 'stealing' the yetzer hara's drive for the mitzvah; without it the mitzvah would lack its fire and completeness, which is the meaning of serving 'with both your inclinations'.
- 32:42 Beyond 'avodas avodah', service by toil, there is 'avodas matanah', a gifted delight in serving Hashem that even a simple person can be granted at high moments.
- 36:15 Subduing the yetzer hara is like a conquering king who has not made the defeated king his friend but holds him as a prisoner, and this every Jew can achieve.
- 39:58 The yetzer hara's own joy, like the harlot in the Zohar's parable, is that the person not be seduced, so that even the yetzer hara is subservient to Hashem.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 36:06 The Mashgiach says that for most people the avodah is to subdue the yetzer hara, not to destroy it, and this every Jew can achieve.
- 36:49 The Mashgiach says one should not be frightened or despair on learning of the tzaddik gamur, since the Ba'al HaTanya does not demand that level of us.
- 27:26 The Mashgiach says a person should take the physical drive, like the appetite for eating matzah, and use it with kavanah for Hashem.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Dovid HaMelech, Esav, Pharaoh, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), Yaakov Avinu
Terms אהבה בתענוגים, ארבע יסודות, חב"ד, חלל השמאלי, יצר טוב, מיכלא דמהימנותא, נפש האלקית, נפש הבהמית, סטרא אחרא, עבודת מתנה, עיר קטנה, צדיק גמור, קליפת נוגה