רשע וטוב לו' הטוב כפוף בו' רבבות מדריגות בו. רשע ורע לו. בינוני' הרע בו כמו הטוב אבל הוא אינו עושה רע. ובעיתות 'רצון' הרע הולך לו.

Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' י"א וי"ב no. ⁨27⁩ Pocket Guide p. 43 Yiddish 40 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 40 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

Learning Tanya chapters 11 and 12, the Mashgiach explains the levels of the rasha v'tov lo and the rasha v'ra lo, and defines the beinoni as one who never sins, whose evil is silenced during proper davening.

The Mashgiach opens chapter 11 of Tanya: opposite the tzaddik v'ra lo stands the rasha v'tov lo, whose good is bent under the evil in countless levels; the lightest stumbles only rarely, in a little lashon hara, levity or a sinful thought. He explains why hirhurei aveirah are easy to fall into yet graver than a deed, since thought reaches the world of Beriah. He discusses when thought alone is a sin, the rasha who regrets and the three kinds of atonement, and then the rasha v'ra lo, from whom the good has departed yet still surrounds him as a makif, so that he may complete a minyan. In chapter 12 he defines the beinoni as one who never sins though he still has free choice, notes that every Jew can become a beinoni, and explains that during krias shema and tefillah the evil in him is silenced, while afterward it may speak but he does not listen.

Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · Thought and the Power of Speech

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 The rasha v'tov lo and his levels listed in the guide

    Recalling the tzaddik v'ra lo of the previous chapter, the Mashgiach reads the opening of chapter 11: the rasha v'tov lo, whose good is bent under the evil in countless levels. The lightest of them falls rarely, in one of the three garments: a little lashon hara or levity in speech, or sinful thoughts.

  2. 3:58 Why sinful thoughts are light yet severe listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach describes the 'light' rasha who has not yet done teshuvah, and explains the two sides of hirhurei aveirah: they are easy to fall into, even for upright people, yet worse than a sin. He maps action, speech and thought onto the worlds of Asiyah, Yetzirah and Beriah, so a bad thought blemishes as high as the Throne of Glory.

  3. 9:41 When thought alone is a sin; regret and atonement listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that a bad thought is generally not joined to the deed, except in heresy and immorality, where the thought itself is the sin. Even an upright Jew who stumbles in such things is called a rasha at that moment, but afterward the good in him regrets and he seeks forgiveness; the Mashgiach lists the three kinds of atonement.

  4. 14:21 The rasha v'ra lo: the good surrounds him listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach moves to one who often falls into grave sins yet still has regrets, still a rasha v'tov lo, and then to the rasha v'ra lo, who never does teshuvah because the good has departed from within him. Even so he believes in the Ribono shel Olam and would give his life rather than serve idols, because the good stands around him as a makif, as if waiting at the door.

  5. 19:04 Counting him for a minyan listed in the guide

    As an example the Mashgiach explains that such a person may be counted for a minyan, and explains what a minyan is: ten souls join into one and draw down a holiness that nine tzaddikim cannot. He asks how one whose good has left can join, answers that the kedushah stays around him as a makif, and reads the closing lines of chapter 11 with the saying that wherever ten are gathered the Shechinah rests.

  6. 23:37 Who is a beinoni listed in the guide

    Opening chapter 12, the Mashgiach defines the beinoni as one who never sins yet still has free choice, which answers how Rabbah could think he was a beinoni. He notes the title 'Sefer shel Beinonim': the Ba'al HaTanya cannot make anyone a tzaddik, but every Jew can become a beinoni. 'Never sinned and never will' refers to his present state, as even great people like the meraglim and Korach fell.

  7. 29:42 Krias shema and tefillah as a time of gadlus listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that the ten powers of the beinoni's G-dly soul do not rule alone, yet at special times the evil has no say: during krias shema and tefillah, a time of gadlus hamochin when a Jew rises to higher worlds where there is no evil. Then he awakens the love of Hashem in the right chamber of his heart and fulfills the mitzvah of loving Hashem.

  8. 32:50 Preparing to daven; the two judges listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach walks through the preparation from waking up through pesukei dezimra, birchas yotzer, ahavah rabbah and shema, which brings a time when the yetzer hara is silenced. He compares the beinoni to a court with two judges who listens only to the good one, and stresses that this is only with proper davening, not a rushed one; after davening the evil may speak again, but the beinoni does not heed it.

The shiur, written up

The rasha v'tov lo and his levels

0:30

The Mashgiach recalls the tzaddik v'ra lo of the previous chapter, in whom the evil still sleeps. Opposite him, Tanya ch. 11 sets the rasha v'tov lo: not a complete rasha, since he has good within him, but that good is bent and suppressed under the evil, in countless levels. The lightest of them falls only rarely, in a little lashon hara or levity, or in sinful thoughts. a

Why sinful thoughts are light yet severe

4:53

Such a person, the Mashgiach says, is a 'light' rasha who has not yet done teshuvah. He then explains the two sides of a sinful thought. It is light because it is easy to fall into: a thought enters the mind and one does not push it out at once, and even people upright by our standards stumble in this.

7:28

Yet the Gemara in Yoma 29a calls sinful thoughts graver than the sin. The Mashgiach explains why: a deed illuminates or blemishes the world of Asiyah, speech the world of Yetzirah, and thought the world of Beriah, up to the Throne of Glory. b

When thought alone is a sin

10:04

As the Gemara in Kiddushin 40a teaches, a bad thought is not joined to the deed unless the deed follows. But for two matters, heresy and immorality, learned from the passuk in Bamidbar 15:39, the thought itself is the sin; immoral thoughts by day lead to impurity by night, as in Avodah Zarah 20b. c,d,e

12:22

One who lets his heart turn to idleness, as Avos 3:4 says, is called a rasha at that moment, because the evil rules him. Afterward the good overcomes, he regrets and asks forgiveness, and the Mashgiach outlines the three kinds of atonement from Yoma 86a. f,g

The rasha v'ra lo

14:31

The Mashgiach turns to one who often falls into grave sins but still feels regret; his teshuvah is not complete, yet he is still a rasha v'tov lo. This, he says, is our common situation: one falls and does teshuvah, falls and does teshuvah, because good and evil each prevail at times. a

15:32

The rasha v'ra lo never does teshuvah, for the good has left him. Still, he believes in the Ribono shel Olam and would give his life rather than serve idols, because the good stands around him, as if at the door waiting to be let in.

Counting him for a minyan

19:39

Such a man, the Mashgiach says, may complete a minyan. When ten Jews gather, their souls merge into one and draw down a holiness that nine tzaddikim cannot, which is why the Mashgiach urges always davening with a minyan.

21:33

He asks how one whose good has left can join, and answers that the good is around him as a makif; holiness never leaves a Jew. This is the end of the chapter, citing Sanhedrin 39a that the Shechinah rests wherever ten are gathered. h

Who is a beinoni

23:41

Tanya ch. 12 defines the beinoni as one who never sins. This answers how Rabbah, in Berachos 61b, could call himself a beinoni: unlike complete tzaddikim, the beinoni still has the choice to sin. k,i

24:38

The Mashgiach notes the title page, 'Sefer shel Beinonim': being a tzaddik cannot be taught; one must be born for it. But never obeying the yetzer hara is in every Jew's hands, so anyone can become a beinoni. j

27:41

'Never sinned and never will' reflects his present state, like a report card. One who did complete teshuvah can be a beinoni, and even great people, like the meraglim and Korach, later fell.

Krias shema and tefillah

30:05

The ten powers of the beinoni's G-dly soul do not rule alone, yet at special times the evil has no say: during krias shema and tefillah, a time of gadlus hamochin, when a Jew rises to higher worlds without evil and awakens his love of Hashem in the right chamber of the heart. k

Preparing to daven; the two judges

32:58

The Mashgiach traces the preparation from waking. Pesukei dezimra cut away the barriers to tefillah, 'zemer' meaning to cut, as in Vayikra 25:4-5. Birchas yotzer brings awe at the angels' praise, ahavah rabbah the love, and shema with 'v'ahavta' in Devarim 6:5 the readiness to give oneself over. Then the yetzer hara is silenced. l,m

37:21

The beinoni is like a court of two judges: the evil one may voice his opinion, but he listens only to the yetzer tov. This holds only for proper davening, not a rushed one. After davening the evil may speak again, but the beinoni does not heed it.

Sources

Torah

  1. d apparently Bamidbar 15:39 index In the write-up: 10:04
  2. l apparently Vayikra 25:4-5 index In the write-up: 32:58
  3. m Devarim 6:5 text index In the write-up: 32:58

Mishnah

  1. f Avos 3:4 text index In the write-up: 12:22

Talmud Bavli

  1. b Yoma 29a text index In the write-up: 7:28
  2. c Kiddushin 40a text index In the write-up: 10:04
  3. e apparently Avodah Zarah 20b index In the write-up: 10:04
  4. g apparently Yoma 86a index In the write-up: 12:22
  5. h Sanhedrin 39a text index In the write-up: 21:33
  6. i Berachos 61b text index In the write-up: 23:41

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a apparently Tanya ch. 11 index In the write-up: 0:30, 14:31
  2. j apparently Tanya, title page index In the write-up: 24:38
  3. k apparently Tanya ch. 12 index In the write-up: 23:41, 30:05

Key points

  1. 1:29 The rasha v'tov lo still has good within him, but it is bent and suppressed under the evil, and there are countless levels of how much it is suppressed.
  2. 5:41 Sinful thoughts are light in that even upright people easily stumble in them, but graver than a sin in their damage, since a bad thought blemishes the world of Beriah.
  3. 18:23 The rasha v'ra lo has driven the good out of himself and never does teshuvah, yet the good still surrounds him as a makif, so he remains a Jew who believes and can complete a minyan.
  4. 23:41 A beinoni never commits a sin, yet unlike the complete tzaddik he still has free choice; the Tanya, the 'Sefer shel Beinonim', teaches how to be a beinoni, which every Jew can become.
  5. 30:47 During krias shema and tefillah said properly, the evil in the beinoni is silenced and only the yetzer tov rules; after davening the evil may speak again, but the beinoni does not listen to it.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 5:37 How can sinful thoughts be called light, yet be graver than a sin?

    Answer: 5:49 They are light in how easily one stumbles in them, but grave in their damage, since a thought blemishes up to the world of Beriah.

  2. Question: 21:27 If the rasha v'ra lo has driven the good out of himself, how can he be counted for a minyan or give his life for Hashem?

    Answer: 21:55 The good is not within him but around him as a makif; the kedushah never lets go of a Jew.

  3. Question: 23:47 How could Rabbah err and say that he was a beinoni, when he knew he never sinned?

    Answer: 24:02 A beinoni too never sins; what separates him from the complete tzaddik is that he still has the choice to sin.

  4. Question: 27:41 What does it mean that the beinoni never sinned and never will?

    Answer: 28:24 Not literally; in his present state he has no connection to sin, and if he did sin he has already done complete teshuvah.

  5. Question: 38:00 Is the yetzer hara silenced during any davening?

    Answer: 38:24 No; a rushed davening does not silence it, and grave thoughts can come in the middle of shema. Only one who davens as a Jew should, as the Ba'al HaTanya explained, has the evil silenced.

Insights

  1. 5:41 The Mashgiach explains that a sinful thought is 'light' only in how easily one falls into it; in its damage it is graver than a deed, because a deed blemishes Asiyah while a thought reaches Beriah, up to the Throne of Glory.
  2. 7:19 He maps the three garments onto the worlds: a good deed illuminates the world of Asiyah, a good word the higher world of Yetzirah, corresponding to ruach, and a good thought the world of Beriah; their opposites blemish those same worlds.
  3. 18:44 Even the rasha v'ra lo is not cut off: the good he drove out stays around him as a makif, as if standing at the door asking to be let back in, which is why he would still give his life rather than serve idols.
  4. 20:26 When ten Jews gather, their souls merge into one and draw down a holiness that nine tzaddikim cannot, which is why the surrounding kedushah of even a rasha v'ra lo allows him to complete the ten.
  5. 24:55 The Ba'al HaTanya called his work a book for beinonim because becoming a tzaddik cannot be taught; one must be born for it. But refusing ever to obey the yetzer hara is in every Jew's hands, so every Jew can be a beinoni.
  6. 27:41 'Never sinned and never will' does not mean literally never; it is like a report card on his present state: one who sinned and did complete teshuvah can be a beinoni, and even great people who later fell were judged by the level they stood on.
  7. 37:21 The beinoni is like a court where two judges sit: the evil judge may voice his opinion, but the beinoni listens only to the judge seated in the right chamber of the heart; during proper davening the evil one may not even speak.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 21:02 The Mashgiach says one should make the effort always to daven with a minyan, because it brings a wondrous holiness upon a Jew.
  2. 32:50 The Mashgiach describes preparing for davening from the moment one wakes: how one gets up, washes negel vasser and readies oneself, before pesukei dezimra.
  3. 31:40 The Mashgiach stresses davening as a Jew should, with kavanah, and not rushing through it in a few minutes.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Korach, Rabbah (bar Nachmani), the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi)

Terms בינוני, חלל השמאלי, כסא הכבוד, לבושים, מוחין, מחשבות זרות, מקיף, נפש האלקית, עולם הבריאה, עולם היצירה, עולם העשיה, פסוקי דזמרה, צדיק ורע לו, קליפה, קריאת שמע

Report an error on this page