בינוני מוח שליט על הלב' היצה"ר אינו מתלבש בלבוש מחשבה דיבור או מעשה אבל הוא במציאות אצלו.

Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' י"ב no. ⁨28⁩ Pocket Guide p. 43 Yiddish 37 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 37 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

Learning Tanya chapter 12, the Mashgiach explains that in the beinoni the evil inclination is still present but can never clothe itself in thought, speech or deed, because the mind rules over the heart.

The Mashgiach recalls the question from chapter one, how Rabbah could call himself a beinoni, and how the earlier chapters defined the tzaddik; the beinoni never sins yet still desires evil, so in essence he is not called a tzaddik. Chapter 12 explains that his evil never gains enough strength to clothe itself in his body; he may even have once been wicked and done teshuvah. Using the Tanya's parable of two kings fighting over a small city, the Mashgiach explains the exception of Shema and tefillah, and expands on davening as passage through the heavenly chambers, where foreign thoughts mean being pushed out, and on preparing with teshuvah and joining oneself to all Jews. The evil inclination stays a mere passer-by, never a guest or master, because the mind rules the heart. He adds that rare situations can exist where a person truly cannot help himself, but one must always suspect that he can. A bad thought is driven out by holy thoughts, as light drives away darkness. Finally, even after davening the yetzer suggests things, and the impression of davening and the hidden love keep the beinoni in control.

Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Rabbah's question and the tzaddik defined

    The Mashgiach recalls the question from chapter one, how Rabbah, who served Hashem every moment, could call himself a beinoni, and reviews the complete tzaddik who has killed his evil inclination. He explains that the beinoni never sins, yet since he still desires evil he is a tzaddik only in judgment, not in essence.

  2. 3:18 The evil cannot clothe itself in the body listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach reads the opening of Tanya chapter 12: in the beinoni the evil never gains enough strength to clothe itself in thought, speech or deed. He adds that one may become a beinoni after teshuvah, and recalls the parable of two kings fighting over a small city, where the good king holds his position, except during Shema and tefillah.

  3. 7:55 Davening as passage through the heichalos

    The Mashgiach explains, in the name of the Ba'al Shem Tov and the Chasam Sofer, that every word of Torah and tefillah is a heavenly chamber, and davening ascends through the worlds. Foreign thoughts during davening mean the keruvim are pushing a person out, so before davening one does teshuvah and includes oneself with the tzaddikim and all Jews; davening, especially Shacharis, is a war, with tallis and tefillin as its weapons.

  4. 14:06 The beinoni during and after davening listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that the beinoni is always armed for the war, so during Shema and tefillah the other king has no permission to enter; the Tanya describes this as the time of greatness of mind, contemplating Hashem's greatness in the blessings before Shema. After davening the evil reawakens, but since it is only one of two judges and the good also sits, it cannot bring its desire into action.

  5. 18:24 Passer-by, guest, master; the mind rules the heart listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that the yetzer has three names, a passer-by, a guest and a master of the house, and says that in the beinoni it always remains a passer-by who is turned away at the door. The reason, from the Ra'aya Mehemna, is that the mind by nature rules over the heart, so no one can say his yetzer overpowered him.

  6. 22:49 Rare cases where one cannot help himself listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach adds, noting that this is not in the Tanya, that occasionally Hashem places a person in a situation where he truly cannot control himself and is not responsible; but this is rare, and a person must always suspect that he can help himself. In general the mind rules the heart, and the beinoni says no to every suggestion and pushes the thought away.

  7. 26:41 Light drives away darkness listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that a bad thought is driven away more easily by thinking of holy matters, bringing the passuk in Koheles about the advantage of wisdom over folly like light over darkness. Darkness, he says, is a real creation, as the passuk in Yeshayahu says, yet a little light pushes away much darkness; so the folly of the kelipah is pushed away by the holy thought, and even so the beinoni is not called a tzaddik.

  8. 30:58 The yetzer still present; three daily failings listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that the yetzer still sits on its bench, and after davening the love of Hashem is only hidden, so the yetzer can make suggestions, even of forbidden things, which the beinoni rejects. He brings the Gemara that no one escapes hirhur aveirah and iyun tefillah daily, with Tosafos' reading of iyun tefillah as feeling one has davened well, and concludes that the impression of davening and the hidden love keep the yetzer from ruling.

The shiur, written up

Rabbah's question and the tzaddik defined

0:48

The Mashgiach recalls the question from chapter one: how could Rabbah, who served Hashem every moment, think he was a beinoni? The complete tzaddik has killed his yetzer, as David HaMelech said his heart was hollow within him. The beinoni never sins but still desires evil, so he is a tzaddik in judgment, not in essence. b,c

The evil cannot clothe itself in the body

3:22

Chapter 12 explains that in the beinoni the evil never grows strong enough to clothe itself in thought, speech or deed. He need not always have been a beinoni; he may once have been wicked and done teshuvah. a

6:22

The Mashgiach recalls the earlier parable of two kings fighting over a small city: the good king holds his position and never lets the other cause a sin, except at the times of Shema and tefillah. d

Davening as passage through the heichalos

8:37

Citing the Ba'al Shem Tov, as the Chasam Sofer also writes, the Mashgiach explains that every word of Torah and tefillah is a heavenly chamber, and davening passes from chamber to chamber through the worlds. As the keruvim guard the way to the tree of life, angels keep out one who is unworthy; the soul feels thrown out, and the body feels it as stray thoughts mid-davening. e

11:56

Therefore before davening one does teshuvah and includes oneself with the tzaddikim and all Jews. Davening, above all Shacharis, is a war, fought with tallis and tefillin.

The beinoni during and after davening

14:20

The beinoni, always armed for this war, is let in, and the other king has no permission to enter and suggest sin. The Tanya calls Shema and tefillah a time of greatness of mind, when the blessings before Shema describe the angels singing to Hashem. After davening the evil reawakens, but since good also sits as a judge, it cannot carry its desire into action. a

Passer-by, guest, master

18:52

The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that the yetzer is first a passer-by, then a guest, then master of the house. For the beinoni it stays a passer-by, refused at the door, never sitting down to draw his thoughts from Torah and emunah. f

21:01

Why? Because, as the Ra'aya Mehemna says, the mind rules the heart by nature. No one can say his yetzer got the better of him. g

Rare cases

23:21

The Mashgiach adds, noting it is not in the Tanya, that Hashem occasionally places a person where he truly cannot control himself, and then he is not responsible. But this is rare, so one must always suspect that he can help himself. Generally the mind rules, and the beinoni answers every suggestion with no.

Light drives away darkness

26:47

A bad thought can be driven out by thinking of other things, and more easily by thinking of holiness. Wisdom surpasses folly as light surpasses darkness. Darkness, says the Mashgiach, is a creation, as Yeshayahu says, yet a little light drives much darkness away. So the folly of the kelipah flees before holy thought; still, the beinoni is not called a tzaddik. h,i

The yetzer still present

31:19

The yetzer still sits on its bench, and after davening the love of Hashem is only hidden, so it can suggest even forbidden things, which the beinoni refuses.

34:28

The Gemara says no one escapes daily hirhur aveirah and iyun tefillah, which Tosafos explains as thinking one davened well and deserves something; that thought alone can make the davening rejected. Unable to cause sin, the yetzer tries pride, which one must push away at once. The impression of davening and the hidden love keep the yetzer from ruling. j,k

Sources

Torah

  1. e Bereishis 3:24 text index In the write-up: 8:37

Nevi'im

  1. i Yeshayahu 45:7 text index In the write-up: 26:47

Kesuvim

  1. c Tehillim 109:22 text index In the write-up: 0:48
  2. h Koheles 2:13 text index In the write-up: 26:47

Talmud Bavli

  1. b Berachos 61b text index In the write-up: 0:48
  2. f Sukkah 52b text index In the write-up: 18:52
  3. j Bava Basra 164b text index In the write-up: 34:28

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. g apparently Ra'aya Mehemna, Parshas Pinchas index In the write-up: 21:01

Rishonim

  1. k apparently Tosafos, Bava Basra 164b index In the write-up: 34:28

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a apparently Tanya ch. 12 index In the write-up: 3:22, 14:20
  2. d apparently Tanya ch. 9 index In the write-up: 6:22

Key points

  1. 2:00 The beinoni never sins, but because he still has a desire for evil he is not called a tzaddik in essence, only in judgment.
  2. 3:28 In the beinoni the evil never becomes strong enough to clothe itself in the body through thought, speech or deed.
  3. 7:14 During Shema and tefillah, when the mind is in a state of greatness, the evil in the beinoni has no dominion at all; afterwards it reawakens.
  4. 21:07 The mind rules over the heart by the nature of man's creation, so a person can always overcome his yetzer and cannot claim he was unable to help it.
  5. 27:03 A bad thought is best driven away by thinking of holy matters, just as a little light drives away much darkness.
  6. 31:19 Even after davening the yetzer still sits in its place and makes suggestions; the impression of the davening and the hidden love keep the beinoni in control.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 0:48 How could Rabbah, who served Hashem every moment, consider himself a beinoni?

    Answer: 1:55 Because a beinoni is not defined by deeds; he never sins, but as long as he still has a desire for evil he is not a tzaddik.

  2. Question: 11:01 Why do foreign thoughts come to a person in the middle of davening?

    Answer: 10:54 Because he is not worthy to enter the heavenly chambers, and the keruvim who guard them push him out.

  3. Question: 21:01 If the beinoni still has a yetzer hara, why can it never get him to act?

    Answer: 21:07 Because the mind by nature rules over the heart, and a person who wants to can always restrain himself.

  4. Question: 28:34 If darkness is a real creation, why does bringing in a light not simply leave a half-dark light?

    Answer: 28:47 Because light has an advantage and dominion over darkness: where light enters, darkness flees.

Insights

  1. 2:31 The Mashgiach distinguishes between being judged a tzaddik and being a tzaddik as a title: on the day of judgment the beinoni will be called a tzaddik because he never sinned, but by definition he is not one, since the desire for evil remains.
  2. 10:30 Foreign thoughts during davening are explained as the keruvim and the flaming sword at the gates of the heavenly chambers pushing out one who is not worthy to enter; the soul feels being thrown out, and the body feels it as stray thoughts.
  3. 19:06 The Gemara's three names of the yetzer, passer-by, guest and master, describe the stages of letting it in; the beinoni keeps it a passer-by at the door and never lets it sit down in his house.
  4. 27:51 Against those who say darkness is only an absence, the Mashgiach holds that spiritually darkness is a creation; that a little light nevertheless drives away much darkness shows the inherent dominion of light, and likewise of holy thought over the folly of the kelipah.
  5. 34:42 When the yetzer sees it cannot get a servant of Hashem to sin, it tries to make him feel important after a good davening, and that thought alone can cause the davening to be rejected.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 11:56 The Mashgiach says that before davening one should do teshuvah, include oneself with the tzaddikim and with all Jews of the generation, and ask Hashem to be allowed into the chambers of tefillah.
  2. 24:17 The Mashgiach says a person must always suspect himself and assume that he can in fact help himself, rather than claim the yetzer was stronger.
  3. 26:41 The Mashgiach says that when a bad thought comes, one can drive it out by turning to think of other matters, and even more easily by thinking of holy matters.
  4. 34:58 The Mashgiach says that when the thought comes after davening that one has davened well, one can push it away immediately.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Dovid HaMelech, Rabbah (bar Nachmani), the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Chasam Sofer, the Haflaah (Rabbi Pinchas Horowitz), the Maggid of Mezritch

Terms אהבה מסותרת, בינוני, היכל, חלל השמאלי, יצר הרע, כרובים, מוח שליט על הלב, מוחין, מחשבה דיבור ומעשה, מחשבות זרות

Report an error on this page