בינוני - זה וזה שופטן וה' מכריע. תשובה על הקושיא על המילים - תהא בעיניך כרשע.

Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' י"ב no. ⁨29⁩ Pocket Guide p. 43 Yiddish 39 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 39 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Mashgiach explains why the beinoni is judged by two 'judges', the good and evil inclinations, with Hashem as the deciding voice, and how this answers why even a tzaddik should regard himself as a rasha.

Finishing Tanya chapter 12, the Mashgiach explains that the beinoni cannot stop thoughts of envy, hatred or resentment from arising, but has the choice not to accept them. Emunah that everything comes from Hashem removes resentment, as David said of Shimi ben Gera and as Yosef repaid his brothers with good; a tzaddik told a shopkeeper to thank Hashem for every customer who went to his competitor. Moving to chapter 13, he explains the Gemara's 'zeh v'zeh shoftan': the yetzer hara is a judge giving an opinion, not a ruler, and Hashem is the decider who helps the good side. The world is balanced between good and evil, but the Creator stands above it, as light drives out darkness. Hashem helps only one who struggles himself. This answers 'be in your eyes like a rasha': without Hashem's help the yetzer would win. Finally, the beinoni's evil is only asleep during prayer, which explains Rabbah's error in calling himself a beinoni.

Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 The beinoni's choice over passing thoughts

    The Mashgiach explains from Tanya chapter 12 that thoughts of envy, hatred and resentment come to the beinoni on their own, but he can refuse to accept them and push them away. He adds that resentment toward another Jew goes against emunah, since whatever happens is decreed from Heaven.

  2. 3:57 Shimi, Yosef and the competing shop

    The Mashgiach brings David HaMelech's response to Shimi ben Gera, the mashal of the dog that bites the stick, and Yosef repaying his brothers with good. He then tells of a tzaddik who told a man to thank Hashem each time a customer entered his competitor's shop, until the thanks became true in his heart.

  3. 10:01 Two judges and the One who decides listed in the guide

    Starting chapter 13, the Mashgiach explains the Gemara's 'zeh v'zeh shoftan' from the plural 'shoftei nafsho': the yetzer hara is like a judge voicing an opinion from the heart, not a ruler, and the yetzer tov argues against it. The halachah follows the decider, Hashem, as the Gemara says that without His help one could not overcome the yetzer.

  4. 15:16 A balanced world and the light that drives out darkness listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings a teaching of the Maggid Meisharim that Hashem is the decider who helps the tzaddik, who still receives full credit at the judgment. He explains that the world's good and evil are balanced, as the Gemara shows from Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya, but the Creator stands above the balance, just as light does not mix with darkness but drives it out.

  5. 23:02 Then how can anyone sin? listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach asks: if Hashem always sides with the good, how can a person ever sin? He answers from the mitzvah of 'azov ta'azov imo', which applies only when the owner works along: Hashem helps only one who struggles against the yetzer hara himself, and so the beinoni who fights never sins.

  6. 26:44 Answering 'be in your eyes like a rasha' listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that Hashem's help is the light of Hashem in the G-dly soul, which pushes away the darkness, as Yosef was helped when he could no longer resist. With this he answers the question from Tanya's first chapter: the tzaddik should see himself like a rasha because the yetzer in him is just as strong, and only Hashem's help keeps him from sinning.

  7. 30:07 The yetzer hara is not gone, only quiet

    The Mashgiach explains that the beinoni's evil keeps its full strength, and every physical act strengthens it further. Only during Krias Shema and tefillah, or for one who learns Torah lishmah all day, does the yetzer have no voice, yet even then it is not driven out but only asleep.

  8. 34:05 Subdued, not transformed: Rabbah's error

    The Mashgiach explains that even in prayer the G-dly soul only rules over the animal soul like a wrestler on top, which is iskafya rather than transformation; only a tzaddik like David HaMelech, whose heart was 'chalal', has killed the evil. This answers Tanya's question of how Rabbah could call himself a beinoni: his whole day of learning was like the time of Krias Shema.

The shiur, written up

The beinoni's choice over passing thoughts

0:50

Continuing Tanya chapter 12, the Mashgiach explains that thoughts of envy, hatred and resentment come to the beinoni on their own; that he cannot prevent. His choice is not to accept them willingly: the moment such a thought arises, he remembers that it is forbidden and pushes it out of his mind. a

3:31

Resentment toward another Jew, the Mashgiach adds, simply contradicts emunah. Whatever unpleasant thing happens to a person is decreed from Heaven, and if this man had not done it, someone else would have.

Shimi, Yosef and the competing shop

3:57

He brings David HaMelech, who stopped his men from killing Shimi ben Gera for cursing him, saying that Hashem had told Shimi to curse. Only a dog bites the stick instead of the one who threw it. Yosef too, as the Zohar teaches, repaid his brothers with good: knowing that the suffering came from Hashem, he preferred that it come through holy tzaddikim, and even owed them thanks for the atonement it brought. b,c,d

7:35

The Mashgiach tells of a man who complained to a tzaddik that a competitor had opened the same business next door. The tzaddik told him to thank Hashem each time a customer entered the other store, even if his heart disagreed, since everything is decided from Heaven; with time the thanks would become true. So, the Mashgiach says, should erliche Yidden conduct themselves.

Two judges and the One who decides

10:22

Turning to chapter 13, the Mashgiach explains the Gemara in Berachos that the beinoni is judged by both inclinations. The passuk says Hashem stands at the right of the poor man to save him 'mishoftei nafsho', in the plural, so the beinoni has two judges. The yetzer hara is not a ruler who must be obeyed but a judge stating his opinion from the heart, and the yetzer tov argues back. e,f

13:21

When judges disagree, the halachah follows the decider, and here the decider is Hashem, who helps the yetzer tov. As the Gemara in Kiddushin says, without His help a person could not overcome his yetzer, and the passuk says Hashem will not leave him in its hand. g,h

A balanced world and the light that drives out darkness

15:18

The Mashgiach brings a teaching of the Maggid Meisharim, the angel who learned with the Beis Yosef: Hashem helps the tzaddik against the yetzer hara as the deciding voice, yet at the judgment the tzaddik still receives full credit, because he had the choice to be bad and chose good. i

16:32

The world, he explains, is balanced between good and evil. The Gemara in Chagigah tells that when Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya was dying, his students worried who would now stand against the heretics; the answer was that evil has only as much strength as the good opposite it. Yet this balance holds only among creations; the Creator stands above it and decides for the good. l

20:57

It is like light brought into a dark room. One might expect it to mix with the darkness, like wine with ink, but the darkness flees entirely. Spiritual darkness is a real thing, the Mashgiach stresses, but light is Hashem's life-giving power, which nothing can neutralize. j

Then how can anyone sin?

23:05

The Mashgiach then asks: if Hashem always decides for the good, how can anyone sin? He answers from 'azov ta'azov imo': the Gemara learns from 'imo' that one must help unload an animal only when its owner works along, not when he sits back. So too Hashem helps only one who struggles against the yetzer hara himself, and the beinoni who fights is always helped and never sins. m,n

Answering 'be in your eyes like a rasha'

27:06

Hashem's help, the Mashgiach explains, is the light of Hashem in the G-dly soul, which drives away the darkness, as Yosef was helped when he could no longer resist. This answers the question from Tanya's first chapter about 'be in your eyes like a rasha': not that his deeds resemble a rasha's, but that the yetzer in him is just as strong, and only Hashem's help keeps him from falling. o,r,q

The yetzer hara is not gone, only quiet

30:47

The beinoni's evil, the Mashgiach explains, keeps its full strength, and every physical act strengthens it further. Only during Krias Shema and tefillah, when the hidden love is aroused, does the yetzer have no power. One who learns Torah lishmah all day is constantly in that state, yet his yetzer has not been driven out; it is only asleep and can wake again.

Subdued, not transformed: Rabbah's error

34:21

Even in prayer, the G-dly soul only rules over the animal soul like a wrestler on top, who can still be overturned. This is iskafya, subduing, not is'hapcha, transformation. Only a tzaddik like David HaMelech, who said his heart was 'chalal', had truly killed the evil in him. s

37:17

This answers how Rabbah, who never sinned, could call himself a beinoni: he held that his whole day of learning was like the time of Krias Shema, and that if he stopped, the yetzer could awaken. t

Sources

Torah

  1. d apparently Bereishis 50:20-21 index In the write-up: 3:57
  2. m Shemos 23:5 text index In the write-up: 23:05

Nevi'im

  1. b apparently II Shmuel 16:10 index In the write-up: 3:57

Kesuvim

  1. f Tehillim 109:31 text index In the write-up: 10:22
  2. h Tehillim 37:33 text index In the write-up: 13:21
  3. j apparently Koheles 2:13 index In the write-up: 20:57
  4. k apparently Koheles 7:14 16:36 index
  5. s Tehillim 109:22 text index In the write-up: 34:21

Talmud Bavli

  1. e Berachos 61b text index In the write-up: 10:22
  2. g Kiddushin 30b text index In the write-up: 13:21
  3. l apparently Chagigah 5b index In the write-up: 16:32
  4. n apparently Bava Metzia 32a index In the write-up: 23:05
  5. p apparently Sotah 36b 27:18 index
  6. q apparently Niddah 30b index In the write-up: 27:06
  7. t apparently Berachos 61b index In the write-up: 37:17

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. c Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 3:57

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a apparently Tanya ch. 12 index In the write-up: 0:50
  2. o apparently Tanya ch. 13 index In the write-up: 27:06
  3. r apparently Tanya ch. 1 index In the write-up: 27:06

Other

  1. i Maggid Meisharim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 15:18

Key points

  1. 0:50 The beinoni cannot prevent bad thoughts from arising, but he has the choice not to accept them willingly and to push them out at once.
  2. 3:37 Resentment toward someone who caused harm contradicts emunah, since everything that happens to a person is decreed from Heaven and the other person is only the stick.
  3. 11:27 The yetzer hara in the beinoni is a judge who states his opinion, not a ruler who must be obeyed, and the halachah follows the decider, Hashem, who helps the yetzer tov.
  4. 23:55 Hashem's help comes only to one who struggles against the yetzer hara himself, like the mitzvah to help unload an animal only together with its owner.
  5. 28:36 'Be in your eyes like a rasha' means that even one who does no sin should know that the yetzer in him is as strong as in a rasha, and only Hashem's help keeps him from falling.
  6. 32:28 During Krias Shema and tefillah the beinoni's evil is only asleep, subdued but not transformed, and it can wake up again afterwards.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 10:22 Why does the Gemara say the beinoni is judged by both inclinations?

    Answer: 10:26 Because the passuk says 'mishoftei nafsho' in the plural: the beinoni has two judges, the yetzer tov and the yetzer hara, and neither rules over him.

  2. Question: 18:19 If the world's good and evil are balanced, how does the good side win?

    Answer: 18:24 The balance holds only among created things; the Creator is above creation and is the decider who joins the good.

  3. Question: 21:13 When light enters darkness, why does it not mix with the darkness and become half-dark?

    Answer: 21:26 Because light is Hashem's life-giving power, which cannot be neutralized, so the darkness flees from it entirely.

  4. Question: 23:02 If Hashem always decides in favor of the good, how can anyone ever sin?

    Answer: 23:55 Hashem helps only one who struggles himself, just as the mitzvah of 'azov ta'azov imo' applies only when the owner works along; one who leaves it all to Hashem is not helped.

  5. Question: 28:28 How can a person who sees he is a tzaddik regard himself as a rasha?

    Answer: 28:40 Not that his deeds are like a rasha's, but that the yetzer in him is as strong as in a rasha, and without Hashem's help he would fall.

  6. Question: 37:35 How could Rabbah, who never sinned, think he was only a beinoni?

    Answer: 37:46 Because he held that his whole day of learning was like the time of Krias Shema and tefillah, when the yetzer is only asleep and could wake if he stopped.

Stories

  1. 7:35 The tzaddik and the competing store

    A man came to a tzaddik in distress because someone had opened the same kind of business right next to his, and he watched customers go to his competitor instead of to him. The tzaddik told him that every time he saw a customer enter the other store he should thank Hashem for the other man's livelihood. If the thanks did not feel true in his heart, he should say it anyway, since the customer would not have come to him in any case and everything is decided by Heaven. With time, the tzaddik said, the thanks would become true.

    In the story: Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch

    told in 1 other shiur →

Insights

  1. 6:02 The Mashgiach reads Yosef's kindness to his brothers as emunah: since the suffering had to come from somewhere, Yosef preferred that it come through holy tzaddikim, and he even owed them thanks for the atonement it brought.
  2. 18:24 Among created forces good and evil are always in balance, but the Creator of both light and darkness stands above that balance and joins the side of good, so the one on the side of good must win.
  3. 21:32 Spiritual darkness is a real entity, not merely the absence of light, yet it flees completely from light because light is Hashem's life-giving power, which nothing can neutralize.
  4. 19:29 Following the Maggid Meisharim, the tzaddik receives full credit at the judgment even though Hashem helped him, because he had the choice to be bad and chose good.
  5. 32:47 One who learns Torah lishmah all day is in a constant state like Krias Shema and tefillah, so he may never feel a desire for sin, yet his yetzer is only asleep; this is how Rabbah could think he was a beinoni.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 4:38 The Mashgiach says that when someone harms a person, he should remember that it comes from Hashem and not hate the other or bear resentment toward him.
  2. 8:58 The Mashgiach says this is how erliche Yidden should conduct themselves: thank Hashem for another's success even when the heart does not yet agree, until with time it does.
  3. 24:57 The Mashgiach says one must struggle against the yetzer hara oneself, and then Hashem helps; one who leaves the job to Hashem is not helped.
  4. 28:40 The Mashgiach says a tzaddik should always know that his righteousness is not by his own strength, since without Hashem's help he would fall.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Dovid HaMelech, Rabbah (bar Nachmani), Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya, Rabbi Yosef Karo (the Beis Yosef), Shimi ben Gera, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), Yosef HaTzaddik

Terms אהבה מסותרת, אתכפיא, בינוני, חלל השמאלי, יצר הרע, יצר טוב, נפש האלקית, נפש הבהמית

Report an error on this page