חילוקים בבינונים - עובד ה' ואשר לא עבדו.
Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' י"ד no. 31 Pocket Guide p. 44 Yiddish 36 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains the Tanya's distinction between the beinoni who serves Hashem by constant battle and the beinoni who 'does not serve Him' because his learning comes easily, and shows that real avodah means going beyond one's nature and habit.
The Mashgiach opens by stressing that every beinoni is sent a battle suited to his nature, health, family and surroundings, as Avraham Avinu, born to Terach, had to fight against everything he came from. He then reads the Tanya on the passuk in Malachi that distinguishes between tzaddik and rasha, and between one who serves G-d and one who does not. 'Oved' is present tense: the beinoni is in an ongoing war, while the tzaddik bears the name as a title. The one who 'does not serve' is also a beinoni and never sins, yet wages no war, because he is a masmid by nature or because hidden love inherited from the Avos suffices for him. A masmid by habit was an oved while he worked, but becomes one who does not serve once it is easy. Using the Gemara's 100 versus 101 reviews and the donkey-drivers' mashal, the Mashgiach defines avodah as going beyond habit, through contemplating Hashem's greatness or awakening the hidden love.
Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · Torah Lishmah and Hasmadah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Every beinoni has his own battle
Continuing from the previous chapter, the Mashgiach says the beinoni's war never ends and each one is sent a battle suited to his nature, health, family and surroundings. He brings Avraham Avinu, born to Terach, who had to fight everything he came from, and says one should not envy another's soul.
-
4:14 Tzaddik and oved Elokim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads the Tanya on the passuk in Malachi and asks how 'tzaddik' and 'oved Elokim' differ. 'Oved' is present tense: the beinoni is still fighting, and with the mashal of a swimmer he shows that toil can feel like pleasure; for the tzaddik, 'oved' is a settled title, since he has already driven out his yetzer hara.
-
9:26 The beinoni who 'does not serve' listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the beinoni has two levels, and the one 'who does not serve' is not a rasha, since he never sins, not even bittul Torah. He is called so because he wages no war: learning and davening come easily to him, perhaps because he was born and raised in holiness, while one who struggles with every sugya earns far more reward.
-
13:30 The natural masmid and hidden love listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains why the 'lo avado' needs no battle: he is a masmid by nature, with a calm temperament that does not crave the world's excitements, so he need not contemplate Hashem's greatness to overcome his yetzer hara. The hidden love that every Jew has suffices for him, but he makes no effort to become better than he is.
-
18:26 Avraham Avinu, a new creation listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the hidden love is an inheritance from Avraham Avinu, whose toil on himself made him a new creation. He brings 'behibaram' read as 'be-Avraham' and the verses said daily in davening, and explains that Avraham is the source of every Jew's love of Hashem and Yitzchak of his fear.
-
21:46 The masmid by habit; 100 and 101 listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that one who trained himself to be a masmid, with fines and other means, was an oved Hashem while he struggled, but once it became second nature he is 'lo avado'. Such a person can become an oved by learning more than his habit, with more depth, as the Gemara contrasts reviewing 100 times with 101.
-
25:12 The donkey drivers and the limit listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the Gemara's mashal of the donkey drivers, who charge double for going past their regular limit, compares it to taxi fares, and concludes that the hardest thing is to act against one's habit. He cites Rabbi Yisrael that a masmid is one who holds on past the point where it is hard, and explains that forgetting comes from the sitra achra, whose name Samech-Mem equals 100.
-
30:00 Going beyond habit: two ways listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that a masmid by nature keeps his fixed schedule but will not learn a minute past mealtime; the oved does more than his habit. Reviewing a 101st time brings one into the realm of Michael, whose name equals 101, and the Mashgiach concludes that nature is broken either by contemplating Hashem's greatness or by fanning the hidden love inherited from Avraham Avinu.
The shiur, written up
Every beinoni has his own battle
The Mashgiach recalls that the beinoni wages a constant war with his yetzer hara that is never finished, and that Hashem sends each person the battle that fits his state: his nature, health, livelihood, family and surroundings. Avraham Avinu, born to Terach, had to fight everything he came from, as the command to leave his land, birthplace and father's house shows. Therefore, the Mashgiach says, one should not envy another's soul, but accept the battlefield Hashem has placed him on. c
Tzaddik and oved Elokim
The Mashgiach reads Tanya chapter 15 on the passuk in Malachi that in the future one will see the difference between tzaddik and rasha, between one who serves G-d and one who does not. He asks how 'tzaddik' differs from 'oved Elokim', and answers that 'oved' is present tense: the beinoni is still serving, still fighting, while 'eved' would already be a title. b,a
This war is great toil, the Mashgiach says, like the toil in Torah Rashi describes. Yet a swimmer on vacation does not call his exertion suffering, and one who feels the sweetness of avodah finds long nights of learning a pleasure; not everyone merits this at all times. The tzaddik is called oved Hashem as a name, since his yetzer hara has already left. d
The beinoni who 'does not serve'
The beinoni himself has two levels. The one 'who does not serve' is no rasha, since he never sins, not even through bittul Torah. He is called so because he feels no battle: learning and davening come easily to him, perhaps because he was born and raised in holiness. Someone who struggles with every sugya and does what he can, the Mashgiach says, receives far more reward.
The natural masmid and hidden love
Following the Tanya, the Mashgiach explains why this person needs no battle. He is a masmid by nature: his calm temperament does not crave the excitements the world offers, so he need not contemplate the greatness of Hashem to overcome his yetzer hara. The hidden love for Hashem found in all Jews is enough for him. But he makes no war to become better than he is, learning with more depth and effort, and so he is called one who does not serve. b
Avraham Avinu, a new creation
This hidden love, the Mashgiach explains, comes from Avraham Avinu, who worked on himself until he became a new creation. He brings the passuk 'behibaram', which Chazal read as 'be-Avraham': creation was completed only with him. In the verses said daily in davening, Hashem found Avraham's heart faithful. Avraham is the source of every Jew's love of Hashem, and Yitzchak of his fear. e,f
The masmid by habit; 100 and 101
One who is not a masmid by nature can train himself, for example by fining himself for each interruption, until it becomes second nature. While he struggled he was an oved Hashem; once it is habit he becomes 'lo avado', living off his earlier toil. How can such a person serve? By learning more than his habit, with more depth, as the Gemara in Chagigah contrasts reviewing a chapter 100 times with 101 times. g
The donkey drivers and the limit
The Mashgiach explains the Gemara's mashal: donkey drivers charge one zuz for ten parsaos but two for eleven, like taxi fares today, because the extra distance is beyond their regular limit. The hardest thing is to act against habit. He cites Rabbi Yisrael that a masmid is one who holds on when it becomes hard. h
In the Gemara's time everything was reviewed 100 times, since forgetting comes from the sitra achra, whose root Samech-Mem equals 100; 100 reviews break its power.
Going beyond habit: two ways
The natural masmid keeps his fixed schedule, but will not learn a minute past mealtime; the oved Hashem does more than his habit. Reviewing a 101st time is hard, since a person craves novelty, yet it brings him into the realm of holiness, of Michael, whose name equals 101.
Such a person had to break his nature, and the Mashgiach gives two ways: contemplating the greatness of Hashem, or awakening the hidden love in his heart, knowing that he truly loves Hashem. A strong love breaks through every obstacle. One who relies only on his habit, even without sin, is called 'lo avado'; the oved Hashem exerts himself.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 0:32 Each person is given his own battle according to his nature and circumstances, and he should not envy another's soul.
- 6:18 The beinoni is called 'oved Elokim' because he is constantly at war with his yetzer hara, while the tzaddik carries the name as a title.
- 10:04 The one who 'does not serve' is not a rasha; he is a beinoni who never sins, even through bittul Torah, but has no battle to fight.
- 15:06 Whether a person is a masmid by nature or became one through habit, as long as he only does what comes easily he is called 'lo avado'.
- 24:56 Avodah means doing more than one's habit, as the Gemara contrasts reviewing a chapter 100 times with 101 times.
- 33:30 There are two ways to break one's nature: contemplating the greatness of Hashem, or awakening the hidden love in the heart.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 5:16 What is the difference between the two terms 'tzaddik' and 'oved Elokim' in the passuk?
Answer: 5:44 'Oved' is present tense and describes the beinoni in an ongoing war; the tzaddik is called 'oved' as a title, having already defeated his yetzer hara.
-
Question: 10:50 If the 'lo avado' never sins and learns constantly, why is he called one who does not serve Hashem?
Answer: 12:30 Because he fights no battle with his yetzer hara: his good conduct comes from his nature and he makes no effort to go beyond it.
-
Question: 24:09 How can one who is a masmid by nature, or by habit, be an oved Hashem at all?
Answer: 24:21 By learning more than his habit, with more depth and effort, as the Gemara distinguishes between 100 and 101 reviews.
-
Question: 26:43 Why does one extra review, the 101st, make such a difference?
Answer: 27:00 Because, like the donkey drivers who charge double past their limit, it goes beyond the regular habit, and acting against habit is the hardest thing.
Insights
- 5:44 The Mashgiach reads 'oved' as present tense: the beinoni is called an oved because his service is an unfinished, ongoing war, whereas for the tzaddik 'oved Hashem' is a name, like the title 'chacham'.
- 7:17 Like a swimmer on vacation whose exertion is pleasure, one who feels the sweetness of avodah experiences long nights of learning as recreation, not toil; but not everyone merits this at all times.
- 18:59 Avraham Avinu's work on himself changed his very creation into a new kind of being, one who believes in Hashem; creation was completed only with him, and from him comes every Jew's hidden love.
- 23:12 One who made himself a masmid through effort was an oved during the struggle, but once it became second nature he is 'lo avado', living off the dividends of his earlier toil.
- 28:37 Forgetting comes from the sitra achra, whose root Samech-Mem equals 100; reviewing 100 times breaks its power, and the 101st time, beyond habit, brings one into the realm of Michael, whose name equals 101.
- 27:00 The donkey drivers charge double for going just past their limit because it is beyond their regular routine; so too, going even slightly beyond one's habit is the hardest and most valuable step.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 0:41 The Mashgiach says one should not envy another's soul or circumstances; each person must accept the task and battlefield Hashem placed him in.
- 24:21 The Mashgiach says one who learns easily should push to learn more than his habit, with more depth and effort, even sleeping less.
- 33:30 To go beyond one's nature, the Mashgiach gives two ways: contemplate the greatness of Hashem, or awaken the hidden love for Hashem in one's heart.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Rashi, Terach, the angel Michael, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), Yitzchak Avinu
Terms אהבה מסותרת, בינוני, טבע שני, יצר הרע, מרה שחורה