התחלת ביאור אהבה מסותרת. ישתדל להיות מרכבה לה' כפי יכולתו.

Catalog entry: ספר התניא א' י"ז no. ⁨38⁩ Pocket Guide p. 44 Yiddish 43 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 43 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

Opening Tanya chapter 17, the Mashgiach explains how 'the matter is very near to you' holds for every Jew: the mind rules the heart by nature, so service from understanding is always within reach, unless sin has taken away that control, and then teshuvah with a broken heart must come first.

Starting a new zman with chapter 17, the Mashgiach explains that the whole Tanya is built on the passuk 'ki karov eilecha hadavar me'od'. He reviews the earlier chapters: the Jewish soul naturally loves Hashem, as in the mutual love of Shir HaShirim, illustrated by the Avnei Nezer's reason about a bas Levi and by the Lechovitcher, who felt the moment his rebbe passed away. Hisbonenus in the morning brachos should bring forth love and fear, and where it does not burn Hashem counts the cold understanding as the deed. Chapter 17 asks how the Torah can call love of Hashem near when love of Hashem and love of this world cannot live together and only tzaddikim rule their hearts. The answer: the mind rules the heart by nature, so understanding-driven service of mitzvos is near to all, except a rasha who lost control, like Pharaoh. Such a person must first do teshuvah with a broken heart, raising the lower heh of Hashem's Name, which the Mashgiach illustrates with the lulav and esrog and with Yerushalayim and Rome.

Topics: Tzaddik, Beinoni and Rasha (Tanya ch. 9-17) · Ahavas Hashem and Dveikus · Teshuvah

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 A new zman: Tanya and 'ki karov'

    The Mashgiach explains why he starts the new zman at chapter 17, where the part on avodah begins, and asks newcomers to catch up on the earlier groundwork. He shows from the title page that the whole Tanya is built on the passuk 'ki karov eilecha hadavar me'od', explained at length and in brief for each person's level.

  2. 3:58 The natural love of a Jew for Hashem

    Reviewing the earlier chapters, the Mashgiach explains that the soul, a part of G-d above, loves Hashem by instinct, the mutual love of Shir HaShirim, which some say only on Pesach as the Minchas Elazar wrote. He brings the Avnei Nezer's reason why a bas Levi who remarried on false testimony is penalized: the tribe that stayed bound to Hashem at the Egel should have felt that her husband was alive.

  3. 8:31 The Lechovitcher feels his rebbe's passing Story

    Great tzaddikim felt their bond to Hashem, and even talmidim felt their bond to their rebbe. The Mashgiach tells how the Lechovitcher cried out that he was cut off from his rebbe at the moment Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin was killed, and calmed down once he was told, since a known reason is natural.

  4. 11:42 Hisbonenus in the brachos, and the cold intellect

    The Mashgiach reviews how the mitzvah to love Hashem works: hisbonenus in the brachos of Krias Shema on the angels and on Hashem's love brings forth fear and love, the two wings of every mitzvah, before kabbalas ol malchus Shamayim. Where the flame does not catch, the earlier chapters taught that Hashem counts the cold understanding as if it were felt.

  5. 15:06 Chapter 17: is love of Hashem truly near?

    The Mashgiach opens chapter 17 and asks how the eternal Torah can say love of Hashem is near, when it does not always burn even in great people. Love of Hashem and love of this world cannot share one heart, and he brings the Kotzker's reading of the Targum on 'do not come near a woman' at Matan Torah: one cannot stand on both sides of the fence.

  6. 19:21 Only tzaddikim rule their hearts: the answer

    The Mashgiach strengthens the question from the Gemara that yirah is 'small' only for Moshe Rabbeinu and from Chazal that only tzaddikim have their hearts in their control. The Tanya answers that 'ki karov' means a love of the intellect that brings one to do the mitzvos: everyone with a mind can understand that he must keep the Torah, and this is accepted according to his level.

  7. 24:16 The mind rules the heart, unless sin removed it

    The Mashgiach explains that the mind rules the heart by nature, over the left chamber where the animal soul nests, and can make a person do or refrain from anything if he stops to think. Only a rasha who never used that control loses it as a punishment; the 'reshaim birshus libam'. He brings Pharaoh, whose loss of bechirah at the plagues was the punishment for his earlier sins.

  8. 29:59 Teshuvah first: raising the lower heh

    The Mashgiach explains that 'ki karov' speaks to ordinary people who have not lost their bechirah, while a rasha cannot begin a lasting avodah without teshuvah with a bitter, broken heart that breaks the kelipos. This is teshuvah tata'ah, raising the last heh of Hashem's Name from its exile; he connects it to the four species as the letters of the Name and tells the Rokeach's story of a dream about a separated heh, explained by a man holding the lulav and esrog apart.

  9. 38:33 Yerushalayim and Rome, and the separated heh

    When the soul's sparks are in exile within the kelipah, teshuvah breaks it and separates its forces. The Mashgiach brings Rashi that when one of Yerushalayim and Rome is full the other is ruined, and a remez from a Blazhever tzaddik on Yerushalayim written without a yud in Tanach; as long as the heh is apart the sitra achra is joined, and teshuvah reverses this.

The shiur, written up

A new zman: Tanya and 'ki karov'

1:01

Opening a new zman, the Mashgiach begins at chapter 17, where the Tanya's part on avodah starts; the groundwork was laid over the past two years, and newcomers are asked to catch up from friends or from him. As the title page states, the whole sefer is built on the passuk 'ki karov eilecha hadavar me'od, b'ficha uvilvavcha la'asoso', to explain how near it is, at length or in brief according to each reader's level. a,b

The natural love of a Jew for Hashem

4:28

The earlier chapters explained that the Jewish soul is 'a part of G-d above', and so it should burn by instinct with longing for Hashem, the mutual love Shlomo HaMelech describes in Shir HaShirim. Not everyone is on the level to say it every Erev Shabbos; the Minchas Elazar wrote that he says it only on Pesach. c,d,e

7:09

The Mashgiach brings the Avnei Nezer: a bas Levi who remarried on false testimony is penalized, because her tribe kept its bond with Hashem at the Egel and she should have felt that her husband was alive. f

The Lechovitcher feels his rebbe's passing

8:31

Tzaddikim felt their bond with Hashem, and even talmidim felt their bond with their rebbe. When Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin was killed, the Lechovitcher cried out at home that he felt cut off from his rebbe; once told, he grew calm, since a known cause is natural. A talmid truly bound to his rebbe feels the bond, and so does a Jew bound to Hashem.

Hisbonenus in the brachos

12:16

Each morning, hisbonenus in the brachos of Krias Shema, on the angels and on Hashem's great love, brings forth fear and love, the two wings of every mitzvah, before accepting Hashem's kingship. For souls in whom it does not burn, the earlier chapters taught that Hashem counts their cold understanding as if it were felt.

Is love of Hashem truly near?

15:08

Chapter 17 opens with the passuk. It does not always work, even for great people, yet the Torah is eternal and must hold today too; the Mashgiach says one should daven Pesukei DeZimra and the brachos so that at least a great longing is kindled. a

17:21

Love of Hashem and love of this world cannot share one heart. The Kotzker explained the Targum's 'to the side of' a woman at Matan Torah: one cannot stand on both sides of a fence. g

Only tzaddikim rule their hearts

19:34

The question grows: the Gemara calls yirah small only for Moshe Rabbeinu, and Chazal say only tzaddikim have their hearts in their control. How then can every Jew be told love is near? h,i,j

21:25

The Tanya answers that it means a love of the intellect leading to mitzvos. Anyone with a mind can understand he must learn and avoid sin, which Hashem accepts according to his level. k

The mind rules the heart

24:25

As the Tanya explained, the mind rules the heart by nature. Of the heart's two chambers, the good inclination dwells in the right, 'a wise man's heart is to his right', and the animal soul in the left. If a person stopped to think who the Ribono shel Olam is and learned musar daily, his mind could keep him from sin. l,m

26:58

Only a true rasha loses this control as a punishment for never using it: the wicked are in their heart's control, while Dovid 'said to his heart'. So Pharaoh's loss of choice at the plagues punished his earlier cruelty to the Jews. j,n

Teshuvah first: raising the lower heh

30:14

The passuk speaks to ordinary people who have not lost their choice. A rasha cannot begin a lasting avodah without first doing teshuvah, breaking the kelipos with a bitter, broken heart; people who are good one moment and bad the next lack this, mostly from certain sins that dull the heart. k

32:49

On 'the offerings of G-d are a broken spirit', the Mashgiach explains that real regret breaks the spirit of impurity. This is teshuvah tata'ah, raising the last heh of Hashem's Name from its fall; the Gemara likens the world to a heh open for teshuvah. p,q

35:09

The four species are the Name's letters, the esrog its last heh. The Magen Avraham brings the Rokeach: a tzaddik dreamed of writing the Name with the last heh apart, then saw a man holding lulav and esrog apart. Teshuvah rejoins that heh. r

Yerushalayim and Rome

39:02

While the soul's sparks are in exile under the kelipah, teshuvah breaks it and scatters its forces. As Rashi says, when Yerushalayim is ruined Rome is full; the Mashgiach adds a Blazhever tzaddik's remez that Yerushalayim lacks a yud in Tanach until its rebuilding. t

42:07

As long as the heh stands apart, the sitra achra stays joined; teshuvah reunites the Name and scatters it.

Sources

Torah

  1. a Devarim 30:14 text index In the write-up: 1:01, 15:08
  2. g apparently Shemos 19:15 with Targum Onkelos index In the write-up: 17:21
  3. h Devarim 10:12 text index In the write-up: 19:34
  4. o apparently Shemos 10:1 29:15 index

Nevi'im

  1. n apparently Shmuel I 27:1 index In the write-up: 26:58

Kesuvim

  1. d Shir HaShirim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 4:28
  2. m Koheles 10:2 text index In the write-up: 24:25
  3. p Tehillim 51:19 text index In the write-up: 32:49

Talmud Bavli

  1. i Berachos 33b text index In the write-up: 19:34
  2. q apparently Menachos 29b index In the write-up: 32:49
  3. s apparently Megillah 29a 37:52 index

Midrash

  1. j apparently Bereishis Rabbah 34:10 index In the write-up: 19:34, 26:58

Rishonim

  1. t apparently Rashi on Bereishis 25:23 index In the write-up: 39:02

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. b apparently Tanya, title page index In the write-up: 1:01
  2. c apparently Tanya ch. 2 index In the write-up: 4:28
  3. e Minchas Elazar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 4:28
  4. f Avnei Nezer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 7:09
  5. k apparently Tanya ch. 17 index In the write-up: 21:25, 30:14
  6. l apparently Tanya ch. 12 index In the write-up: 24:25
  7. r Magen Avraham (place not identified) index In the write-up: 35:09

Key points

  1. 2:24 The whole Tanya is built on the passuk 'ki karov eilecha hadavar me'od, b'ficha uvilvavcha la'asoso', to explain how serving Hashem is near to every Jew.
  2. 4:40 Because the soul is bound to Hashem, a Jew loves Him by nature and instinct, the mutual love Shlomo HaMelech describes in Shir HaShirim.
  3. 17:10 Love of Hashem and love of this world's desires cannot live in the heart together; one who is attached to this world only imagines that he loves Hashem.
  4. 21:25 The mind rules the heart by nature, so a love born of understanding that leads to doing the mitzvos is within reach of every person.
  5. 26:54 A rasha who sinned until his heart is no longer in his control cannot begin serving Hashem without first doing teshuvah with a broken heart.
  6. 33:33 Such teshuvah is the lower teshuvah, which raises the last heh of Hashem's Name from its fall and rejoins it to the other three letters.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 7:18 Why is a bas Levi who remarried on testimony that her husband died penalized when he returns, more than another woman?

    Answer: 7:36 The Avnei Nezer explains that the tribe of Levi kept its bond with Hashem at the Egel, so a bas Levi is more sensitive and should have felt that her husband was alive.

  2. Question: 18:34 Why does the Targum render 'do not come near a woman' as 'to the side of' a woman?

    Answer: 18:42 The Kotzker explains that there are two sides of a fence; one sunk in the desires of this world cannot be on the side of receiving the Torah with love.

  3. Question: 19:39 How can the Torah say love of Hashem is very near to every Jew, when the Gemara calls even yirah small only for Moshe Rabbeinu and only tzaddikim have their hearts in their control?

    Answer: 21:25 The Tanya answers that it means a love of the intellect that brings one to do the mitzvos: the mind is in every person's control and rules the heart by nature.

  4. Question: 29:11 Why was Pharaoh punished with the plagues if Hashem hardened his heart and he had no choice?

    Answer: 29:31 He brought it on himself: losing his choice at the plagues was the punishment for the sins he committed against the Jews while he still had bechirah.

Stories

  1. 9:03 The Lechovitcher at the moment of his rebbe's passing

    Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch was a talmid of Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin, of whom it was said that he had the soul of Moshiach ben Yosef and who was shot by a Russian Cossack. At the moment Rabbi Shlomo died in Karlin, the Lechovitcher, at home, began running about and crying out that he felt cut off from his rebbe, and his household did not know what to do. They already knew of the passing but had not wanted to tell him; when they told him, he went to the window, said there was darkness over the world, and became calm, since a cause that is known is no reason for alarm.

    In the story: Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch, Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin, Rabbi Mordechai (Mottel) of Slonim, Rabbi Asher of Stolin, Rabbi Uri of Strelisk (the Strelisker)

    told in 1 other shiur →

  2. 36:01 The Rokeach's dream of the separated heh

    The Magen Avraham brings the Rokeach, one of the mekubalim, who told of a tzaddik who dreamed on the first night of Sukkos that he wrote Hashem's Name and moved the last heh apart, making the Name invalid. He did not understand the dream until the morning, when he saw in shul a man holding the lulav in one hand and the esrog in the other without bringing them together. He then understood it and told the man that the three species, the first three letters of the Name, must be joined to the esrog, the last heh.

    In the story: the Rokeach, the Magen Avraham

Insights

  1. 7:36 Through the Avnei Nezer, the Mashgiach reads the penalty of a bas Levi who remarried on false testimony as a demand of sensitivity: her tribe stayed bound to Hashem at the Egel, so she should have felt that her husband was alive.
  2. 11:02 From the Lechovitcher the Mashgiach shows that a talmid truly bound to his rebbe feels the bond, and his distress comes from not knowing why it is gone; once the reason is known, the feeling is natural and there is nothing to lament.
  3. 18:37 Following the Kotzker, the Targum's 'to the side of' a woman shows that love of this world and love of Torah are two sides of one fence: a person can stand on either, never on both.
  4. 27:46 Losing one's bechirah is itself a punishment for not using it earlier, which the Mashgiach applies to Pharaoh: his hardened heart at the plagues was the penalty for oppressing the Jews while he still had choice.
  5. 35:09 The Mashgiach connects teshuvah tata'ah with the four species as the letters of Hashem's Name: the esrog is the last heh, and holding it apart from the lulav, as in the Rokeach's dream, is a separated heh that teshuvah reunites.
  6. 39:42 As long as the heh is apart from the Name, the forces of the sitra achra stay joined, like Rome that is full while Yerushalayim is ruined; teshuvah reverses it, so the sitra achra splits apart.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 16:36 The Mashgiach says one should sit down and daven with Pesukei DeZimra and the brachos of Krias Shema so that love of Hashem, or at least a great longing for Him, is kindled.
  2. 26:00 The Mashgiach says that if a person stopped for a while to think who the Ribono shel Olam is and what his purpose is, and learned a musar sefer every day, his mind could keep him from sin.
  3. 32:32 The Mashgiach says one who has sinned must first do sincere teshuvah with a broken heart and real regret, and only then begin serving Hashem.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Dovid HaMelech, Moshe Rabbeinu, Pharaoh, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch, Rabbi Shlomo of Karlin, Rashi, Shlomo HaMelech, the Avnei Nezer of Sochatchov, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Kotzker Rebbe (Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk), the Magen Avraham, the Minchas Elazar of Munkatch, the Rokeach

Terms אהבה מסותרת, בחירה, גלות השכינה, חלל השמאלי, חלק אלוק ממעל, כי קרוב אליך הדבר מאד, מוח שליט על הלב, סטרא אחרא, קבלת עול מלכות שמים, קליפה, רבונו של עולם, שם הוי"ה

Report an error on this page