גדול ה' ומהלל מאד
Catalog entry: תפילה no. 15 Pocket Guide p. 49 Yiddish 45 min
Listen
About this shiur
On the words of Ashrei, 'Gadol Hashem… v'ligdulaso ein cheker', the Mashgiach explains that Hashem cannot be grasped by investigation but is known through the neshamah, the mesorah of Sinai, the tzaddikim of every generation and the beauty of His world.
The Mashgiach opens with the verse 'Gadol Hashem u'mehulal me'od, v'ligdulaso ein cheker' and explains that each sense grasps its own kind of thing, and the intellect is not the faculty that grasps Hashem. Every Jew has a neshamah and a measure of ruach hakodesh, blocked only by sin; Klal Yisroel as a whole has it, which is why its minhagim are true, as the Binas Adam and Rav Moshe Feinstein show. The human mind was made for the physical world; Hashem is felt through Torah, mitzvos and kedushah. The Torah never proves the ikkarim by investigation: they rest on what an entire nation saw at Sinai, as the Yismach Moshe writes. On 'dor l'dor yeshabach ma'asecha' he explains that the tzaddikim of each generation reveal Hashem, with stories of Lechovitch, Belz and the Satmar Rav's megillah, and that later generations understand Hashem's ways. He ends with 'hadar kevod hodecha': the grace and beauty of creation.
Topics: Simple Emunah, Above Reason · Torah Min HaShamayim and the Mesorah · Pesukei DeZimra
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Gadol Hashem: no investigating His greatness listed in the guide
After a few words on the nusach of tefillah set by the Anshei Knesses Hagedolah, the Mashgiach takes up the verse 'Gadol Hashem… v'ligdulaso ein cheker'. He explains that each sense grasps its own kind of thing, a picture with the eyes and a symphony with the ears, and that the intellect is not the faculty for grasping Hashem.
-
3:45 The neshamah and the ruach hakodesh of Klal Yisroel listed in the guide
Citing the Kuzari, the Mashgiach explains that every Jew has a neshamah and a measure of ruach hakodesh, and only sin insulates him from it; the neshamah knows what lies beyond walls and time. Klal Yisroel as a whole has ruach hakodesh, which is why its minhagim are true, as he shows from the Binas Adam and a teshuvah of Rav Moshe Feinstein.
-
10:19 The mind cannot reach Hashem; emunah through Torah and mitzvos listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the human mind was made for the physical world and breaks down on questions of infinite time and space; Hashem is felt through Torah, mitzvos and kedushah. He discusses the old dispute over chakirah, says that today one should not engage in it, and stresses that the Torah never proves its ikkarim by investigation, unlike religions that believe 'because he said so'.
-
16:29 A whole nation saw: the mesorah of Sinai listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the pesukim in Devarim that no nation ever heard Hashem speak from the fire, and explains that something an entire people witnessed and handed down cannot be denied. He reads a teshuvah of the Yismach Moshe on doubts in emunah, compares denial of Sinai to denying the Holocaust or Julius Caesar, and explains that the nations too accept the Torah's miracles.
-
24:36 Dor l'dor: the tzaddikim as Hashem's handiwork listed in the guide
Returning to the verse, the Mashgiach explains that Hashem's greatness is known not through philosophy but through the mesorah, 'dor l'dor yeshabach ma'asecha', and warns that every Jew must guard his emunah. He brings the Zohar on Shavuos night that 'ma'asecha' and 'ma'aseh yadav' are the tzaddikim, and describes Jews whose avodah radiates onto others.
-
28:48 Lechovitch, Belz and the Satmar Rav's megillah Story listed in the guide
The Mashgiach tells how a poritz listening to the Lechovitcher daven said that his love for his wife was nothing next to the Jew's love for Hashem, and how the young R' Shalom of Belz told the megillah in Lublin. He describes hearing the Satmar Rav read the megillah for two hours, brings the Chasam Sofer and Kedushas Levi on the light of the megillah, and his shout at 'hakerovim v'harechokim'.
-
33:54 The falling generations, and what later generations understand listed in the guide
With the example of a falling stone that speeds up as it drops, the Mashgiach explains that the decline between generations grows ever greater, so earlier tzaddikim are beyond compare. Then, with other meforshim, he reads 'dor l'dor' as later generations understanding what Hashem did, bringing the Chazon Ish's mashal of the tailor cutting silk after the destruction in Europe.
-
39:21 Hadar kevod hodecha: the beauty of creation listed in the guide
On 'hadar kevod hodecha', the Mashgiach describes the beauty of the countryside that the city hides, and explains 'hazan es ha'olam… b'chen' : Hashem could have fed people like a car with fuel, but made food beautiful, varied and tasty, for which one must thank and praise Him. He ends with the ever-changing clouds and his love of speaking about Hashem's wonders.
The shiur, written up
Gadol Hashem: no investigating His greatness
The Mashgiach takes up the verse 'Gadol Hashem u'mehulal me'od, v'ligdulaso ein cheker' (Tehillim 145:3): Hashem's greatness cannot be calculated or investigated. He explains that each sense is suited to its own kind of thing. Someone who says he listened to a picture in a museum, or saw a symphony in a concert hall, is a fool; in the same way, the head and its investigation are not the faculty through which one understands the Ribono shel Olam. a
The neshamah and the ruach hakodesh of Klal Yisroel
What does grasp Him is the neshamah. Bringing the Kuzari, the Mashgiach says that every Jew has ruach hakodesh, since his neshamah is a part of G-d above. Only sin insulates a person from it, as the passuk says, 'avonoseichem hayu mavdilim' (Yeshayahu 59:2). The neshamah itself is not limited by walls or by time; a person cannot see beyond the wall or into tomorrow only because he has no contact with it. Those who purify the body until it is crystal clear have ruach hakodesh, and Yeshayahu saw Hashem (Yeshayahu 6:1). b,c,d
Klal Yisroel as a collective has ruach hakodesh even today, so its minhagim are aimed at the truth. The Binas Adam, the Mashgiach notes, proves a halachah from the fact that Jews are not stringent about it. Likewise Rav Moshe Feinstein, in the Igros Moshe, rejects the claim that a practice Klal Yisroel follows on the instruction of its leaders could be a mistake. e,f
The mind cannot reach Hashem
The human mind, the Mashgiach explains, was created only to deal with the physical world. When it tries to think what will be in a trillion years, or where space ends, it breaks down; such things are settled only with emunah. A Jew who learns Torah, keeps mitzvos, is honest and careful in kashrus and kedushah comes to feel the Ribono shel Olam in davening and learning, but not through calculation.
He recalls the great dispute between the Ba'alei Tosafos and the investigators of Spain such as the Rambam, who wrote sefarim of chakirah. Today, he says, all sefarim write that one should not engage in it, since it only twists the mind. The whole Torah never proves the ikkarim by investigation; they are an axiom received from the avos, not belief in one man 'because he said so' like the Christians and Muslims.
A whole nation saw
Jewish emunah rests on Yetzias Mitzrayim and Sinai, the experience of a whole people, all of whom heard Hashem speak 'face to face… from the fire' (Devarim 5:4). The Mashgiach brings the pesukim that no nation ever heard the voice of G-d from the fire and lived (Devarim 4:32-34). Millions handed this down to their children, and it cannot be denied: had someone invented it a generation later, everyone would have asked why their own father never told them. h,i
When the yetzer hara confuses a person with doubts, the Mashgiach reads the Yismach Moshe's answer to such a questioner: he does not answer in the way of the philosophers, where one easily slips, but in the way of the Torah, that a tradition received from a multitude who saw with their own eyes cannot be false. He compares denial of this to those who deny the Holocaust or Julius Caesar. Even the nations accept the miracles of the Torah; they only invented a new, watered-down Torah because they could not keep it. j
Dor l'dor: the tzaddikim as Hashem's handiwork
This, the Mashgiach says, is what Dovid Hamelech means: Hashem is great and praised not through philosophy, but 'dor l'dor yeshabach ma'asecha' (Tehillim 145:4), each generation handing down His praise to the next. Every Jew must guard his emunah from nonsense. He adds, from the Zohar on Shavuos night and the verse 'hashamayim mesaprim kevod Kel, u'ma'aseh yadav' (Tehillim 19:2), that Hashem's handiwork are the tzaddikim, and there are Jews whose avodah radiates onto others. l,m,n
Lechovitch, Belz and the Satmar Rav's megillah
The Mashgiach relates from the Slonimer Rebbe that a poritz and his wife once heard R' Mordechai of Lechovitch daven, and the poritz told her that his great love for her was nothing next to this Jew's love for the Ribono shel Olam. When a tzaddik davens, his words enter the heart. The young R' Shalom of Belz once told the megillah in Lublin so beautifully that it was said nobody had ever told it that way.
The Mashgiach merited hearing the Satmar Rav read the megillah over two hours. The Chasam Sofer, and also the Kedushas Levi, write of the great light of the megillah. At 'hakerovim v'harechokim' (Esther 9:20) the Satmar Rav gave a shout, and all understood that the megillah can bring even the furthest Jew close. o,p
The falling generations
A stone thrown from a roof falls faster with each stretch. So the generations fall, and the gap between ours and the previous one is greater than between Yehoshua and Moshe. 'Dor l'dor' means this falling from generation to generation, and each generation tells the gevuros of the earlier tzaddikim. l
Other meforshim read it differently: what one generation cannot understand, a later one does. After the churban in Europe the Chazon Ish answered a questioner with the mashal of a tailor who cuts fine silk; a fool must not judge half-done work. Already the unprecedented rebuilding of Torah is seen, and the middas hadin will be revealed as Klal Yisroel's tikkun.
Hadar kevod hodecha: the beauty of creation
On 'hadar kevod hodecha' (Tehillim 145:5), the Mashgiach says the buildings of the city hide the Ribono shel Olam, while in the countryside one sees the flowers, the sky, the harmony of colors and the birds. He explains 'hazan es ha'olam… b'chen' (Birkas Hamazon): a car needs fuel poured into its tank, and Hashem could have fed people a black nutrient fluid. Instead He made beautiful fruit, spices and ice cream, everything with grace, and for this one must thank and praise Him. Even the clouds keep changing their shapes with chen. q,r
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 2:13 Each sense grasps its own kind of thing, and the intellect with its investigation is not the faculty through which a person grasps Hashem.
- 4:12 Every Jew has a neshamah that is a part of G-d and a potential for ruach hakodesh; sin insulates him from it, and Klal Yisroel as a whole has ruach hakodesh, so its minhagim are true.
- 10:58 The human mind was made only for the physical world; Hashem is felt through Torah, mitzvos, honesty and kedushah, not through calculation.
- 15:28 The Torah never brings proofs from investigation for its foundations; Jewish belief rests on the experience of an entire nation at Yetzias Mitzrayim and Sinai, handed down from generation to generation.
- 25:05 'Dor l'dor yeshabach ma'asecha': the tzaddikim of each generation are Hashem's handiwork, through whom His praise is told.
- 36:31 What one generation cannot understand of Hashem's ways becomes clear to later generations, as with the rebuilding of Torah after the destruction in Europe.
- 39:21 'Hadar kevod hodecha': Hashem made the world with grace and beauty beyond what was needed, and for this one must thank and praise Him.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 5:11 If the neshamah is beyond space and time, why can a person not see beyond the wall or know what will happen tomorrow?
Answer: 5:45 The neshamah does know, but a person has no contact with it; those who purify their body so that nothing interposes have nevuah and ruach hakodesh.
-
Question: 15:28 If the Torah brings no proofs from investigation for the ikkarei emunah, from where do we know them?
Answer: 15:59 From the mesorah of the avos: an entire nation experienced Yetzias Mitzrayim and heard Hashem speak at Sinai, and passed it on from generation to generation.
-
Question: 18:07 Could someone in a later generation have invented the claim that the whole nation stood at Sinai?
Answer: 18:21 No: everyone would have asked why their own fathers never told them; something a whole people saw cannot be falsified, just as no one can deny Julius Caesar.
-
Question: 36:56 Why did Hashem bring the destruction in Europe?
Answer: 37:41 Through the Chazon Ish's mashal of the tailor: half-finished work cannot be judged; in later generations, and when Moshiach comes, it will be seen, and already one sees an unprecedented rebuilding of Torah.
Stories
-
28:48 The poritz who heard the Lechovitcher daven
The Mashgiach relates, in the name of the Slonimer Rebbe, that R' Mordechai of Lechovitch once stood davening when the local poritz and his wife passed by. They stopped to listen. The poritz turned to his wife and said that although he loves her very much, his love is nothing compared to how this Jew loves the Ribono shel Olam.
In the story: Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch, the Slonimer Rebbe
-
30:16 Young R' Shalom of Belz tells the megillah
When R' Shalom of Belz was young, he was once with the Lubliner and was asked to tell over the megillah. Afterwards it was said, the Mashgiach is not sure whether by R' Shalom or by the Lubliner, that the story had been heard many times but never told as beautifully as this young man told it. The Mashgiach adds that he put strength into it.
In the story: the Sar Shalom of Belz (Rabbi Shalom of Belz), the Chozeh of Lublin
-
30:57 Hearing the Satmar Rav read the megillah
The Mashgiach recalls that he merited hearing the Satmar Rav read the megillah, which took him two hours. Everyone who heard him did not know what was happening to himself, and new explanations of the megillah were revealed through his reading. Once, at the words 'hakerovim v'harechokim', he gave a shout, and everyone understood that each year Mordechai sends his letter to the most distant Jews, since the megillah can bring even the lowest Jew close to Hashem.
In the story: the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum), Mordechai HaTzaddik
-
36:49 The Chazon Ish and the tailor's silk
After the destruction in Europe someone asked the Chazon Ish why Hashem brought such a churban. He answered with a mashal: a man who knows nothing of tailoring walks into a tailor's shop and sees him cutting a gorgeous piece of silk into pieces, and asks why he ruins it. The tailor answers that one does not show half-finished work to a fool; once it is sewn, a magnificent garment will come out.
In the story: the Chazon Ish
Insights
- 2:50 Trying to grasp Hashem with the intellect is like trying to hear a painting or see a symphony: each faculty has its own object, and the intellect is not the one for Hashem.
- 4:47 The neshamah is not bound by space and time; a person cannot see beyond the wall or into tomorrow only because sin insulates him from his own neshamah, while tzaddikim who purify the body 'crystal clear' have ruach hakodesh.
- 7:56 The minhag of Klal Yisroel serves as a proof in halachah because Klal Yisroel as a collective has ruach hakodesh even today.
- 16:13 Unlike other faiths built on one man's word, Jewish emunah rests on an event an entire nation witnessed; a fabricated claim of national revelation would have been exposed at once, as Holocaust denial is absurd.
- 34:01 Like a falling stone that gathers speed, the spiritual decline between generations accelerates, so the gap between our generation and the one before it is greater than between Yehoshua and Moshe.
- 36:21 'Dor l'dor yeshabach ma'asecha' means that what Hashem's middas hadin did in one generation is understood in a later one, when it is revealed retroactively as part of Klal Yisroel's tikkun.
- 41:01 'B'chen' in Birkas Hamazon: Hashem could have sustained man with a plain nutrient fuel, like a car, but chose to feed him with beauty, taste and variety.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 13:07 The Mashgiach says that the more a Jew learns Torah, keeps mitzvos, acts with temimus, is honest in business and careful about kashrus and kedushah, the more he will feel the Ribono shel Olam in davening and learning.
- 14:52 The Mashgiach says that today one should not engage in philosophical investigation of emunah, since it can only confuse the mind; one must accept with temimus.
- 25:34 The Mashgiach says every Jew must guard his emunah so that it does not become sick with nonsense.
- 43:21 The Mashgiach says one must thank and praise the Ribono shel Olam for the grace and beauty with which He made all of creation.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Dovid HaMelech, Julius Caesar, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch, Rabbi Tzvi Hirsh of Rimanov, Rav Moshe Feinstein, Rebbe Elimelech of Lizhensk (the Noam Elimelech), the Chasam Sofer, the Chazon Ish, the Chozeh of Lublin, the Rambam, the Sar Shalom of Belz (Rabbi Shalom of Belz), the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum), the Slonimer Rebbe, the Yismach Moshe, Yehoshua bin Nun, Yeshayahu HaNavi
Terms חלק אלוק ממעל, חקירה, יציאת מצרים, מסורה, מעמד הר סיני, עיקרים, רבונו של עולם, רוח הקודש, תמימות, תקופה