שיר המעלות ... לולי ה' שהיה לנו
Catalog entry: תפילה no. 32 Pocket Guide p. 50 Yiddish 40 min
Listen
About this shiur
Through Tehillim 124 and 125, the Mashgiach explains that the Jewish people survive their exile because they recognize Hashem's hand in everything and trust in Him, and that their holiness, like Yerushalayim's, comes from the Shechinah and can never be taken away.
The Mashgiach opens with a remez on why the first blessing of Shemoneh Esrei says 'Elokei Yaakov' and not Yisrael, then reads Tehillim 124. Only a Jew who sees Hashem's providence in everything can say 'Had Hashem not been with us'. He brings the Gemara that 'a man rose against us' means Haman, a man with free choice rather than a king, and explains the floods, Rashi on the splitting of all waters at the Yam Suf, and the trap that broke. The nations that fought the Jews were broken, while the Jews revived again and again; he describes the sinking of pre-war American Jewry like Pisom and Raamses, tells of a Jew who would not work on Shabbos, and the rebirth of Torah after the war. 'Our help is in Hashem's Name' means recognizing that He constantly renews creation. In Tehillim 125 he explains Har Tziyon and, with the Rambam, that Yerushalayim's and Klal Yisrael's holiness comes from the Shechinah and is never annulled.
Topics: Netzach Yisroel · Hashgacha Pratis · The Churban of Europe and Persecutions
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Who can say 'Had Hashem not been with us' listed in the guide
The Mashgiach opens with a remez from sefarim on why Shemoneh Esrei says 'Elokei Yaakov' rather than Yisrael, then reads the start of Tehillim 124. He asks who it is that says 'Had Hashem not been with us' and answers: a Jew who sees Hashem's providence in everything, unlike the nations who speak of luck.
-
4:38 Haman, the floods and the broken trap listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara that 'a man rose against us' is Haman and explains why a man with free choice is more dangerous than a king. He explains the floods as forces of judgment that split before the Jews by the eternal power of the Yam Suf, and the bird escaping the broken trap, which the meforshim apply to the Beis HaMikdash; the nations that fought the Jews were all broken.
-
12:32 Pre-war America like Pisom and Raamses
The Mashgiach speaks of the unrecognized wonder of Torah's growth after the Nazi destruction, and contrasts pre-war America, which he likens to Pisom and Raamses built on sinking ground. He tells that of about forty boys in his yeshiva class only four remained Shabbos-observant, and describes the immigrants who had to work on Shabbos to keep a job.
-
17:12 Holding on to Shabbos in America Story
The Mashgiach tells of a Williamsburg Jew who would not work on Shabbos, and of an old Jew who, ready to give in for his family's sake, saw bread in a garbage can and resolved not to work on Shabbos as long as there was bread there; in the end Hashem helped him. He adds that those who could got a pushcart license, while millions sank and their children did not stay Jewish.
-
20:58 The rebirth after the war listed in the guide
The Mashgiach describes how the youth of his own shul sank, and how after the war refugees and great leaders like the Satmar Rav, the Klausenburger Rav, Rabbi Yonasan Steif and the Vizhnitzer Rebbe rebuilt Yiddishkeit here and in Eretz Yisrael. He calls it a techiyas hameisim of a people that is taken for granted, and explains that the trap broke and the Jews came out whole, not like a bird that escapes with a broken wing.
-
24:29 What sustains the Jews in exile
The Mashgiach asks what keeps the Jews alive in exile and answers from the opening and close of the kapitel: recognizing that Hashem is with us and runs the world, 'our help is in the Name of Hashem, Maker of heaven and earth'. 'Maker' in the present means He constantly renews creation, so that, as the talmidei haBa'al Shem Tov say, a decree can be absent from the new heavens. He then begins Tehillim 125: those who trust in Hashem are like Har Tziyon, built on rock, which never moves.
-
28:32 Tziyon as a mark of G-dliness
The Mashgiach explains that the mountains around Yerushalayim are a natural protection, and so Hashem surrounds His people. He brings Rav Samson Raphael Hirsch that Tziyon means a marker: from there the knowledge of one G-d went out into the world, and those who trust in Hashem take over that role in exile, firm and unmoving.
-
32:13 Holiness that comes from the Shechinah
The Mashgiach explains the Rambam's view that the holiness of Eretz Yisrael that came from Yehoshua's conquest was annulled when Nevuchadnetzar conquered it, but Yerushalayim's holiness comes from the Shechinah and remains. So too Klal Yisrael is holy because the Shechinah dwells among them, and no conquest by the nations can remove it. A Jew who knows this, that he is a part of G-d above, will not sin and drag the Shechinah into exile.
The shiur, written up
Who can say 'Had Hashem not been with us'
The Mashgiach opens with a remez from sefarim on why the first blessing of Shemoneh Esrei says 'Elokei Yaakov' and not Yisrael, connected to the count of its letters. He then reads the opening of the kapitel: 'Had Hashem not been with us, let Yisrael now say'. a,b
He asks who it is that says this, and answers: a Jew for whom Hashem's Name is constantly on his lips, who sees Hashem's providence in everything. The nations, when they succeed, speak of luck.
Haman, the floods and the broken trap
On 'when a man rose against us', the Mashgiach brings the Gemara that this is Haman, 'a man and not a king'. A king's heart is in Hashem's hand, but a man has free choice, and from someone with free choice it is very hard to be saved; he illustrates this with the reasoning that a pit is safer than a man. He notes that the kapitel fits the season, moving from Chamishah Asar b'Shvat toward Purim. c,d,e
He explains the floods that would have swept over us as forces of judgment, called 'mighty waters'. Rashi says that at the Yam Suf all the waters in the world split, and the Mashgiach explains that this power is eternal: every flood that threatens a Jew still splits before him. f,g,h
On the bird that escapes the trap, the meforshim apply it to the Beis HaMikdash, where Hashem poured His anger on wood and stones and the Jews were saved. The Mashgiach adds, citing Rav Hirsch, that whoever fights the Jews is broken in the end, like the Roman and Greek empires, while the Jews remain forever. j,k,l
Pre-war America like Pisom and Raamses
The Mashgiach speaks of the unrecognized wonder of how Torah grew after the Nazi destruction, in Eretz Yisrael and in America. Before the war, America was like Pisom and Raamses, which the Gemara says were built on ground where each layer sank and had to be rebuilt. m
So too the immigrants sank into the clay of America. Of about forty boys in his yeshiva class, he learned, only four remained Shabbos-observant, since immigrants without a job had to work on Shabbos.
Holding on to Shabbos in America
The Mashgiach tells of an old Jew who went from shop to shop and was told everywhere to work on Shabbos. Fearing his family would starve, he decided to give in at the next shop. On the way he saw bread in a garbage can, unheard of in Europe, and said that as long as there is bread in the garbage he would not work on Shabbos; in the end Hashem helped him.
The rebirth after the war
After the war came refugees and great leaders such as the Satmar Rav, the Klausenburger Rav, Rabbi Yonasan Steif and the Vizhnitzer Rebbe, and Yiddishkeit was rebuilt here and in Eretz Yisrael. The Mashgiach calls it a techiyas hameisim that people take for granted. A bird escapes a trap with a broken wing, but here the trap broke and the Jews came out whole. j
What sustains the Jews in exile
Tziyon as a mark of G-dliness
Those who trust in Hashem are like Har Tziyon, built on rock, which never moves, and as mountains protect Yerushalayim, Hashem surrounds His people even in exile. Rav Hirsch explains Tziyon as a marker: from there the world learned of one G-d. After its destruction the Jews take over that role among the nations. p,q,r
Holiness that comes from the Shechinah
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara's discussion of whether the first sanctification of the land lasted. The holiness that obligates mitzvos like terumos and maasros came from Yehoshua's conquest and was annulled by Nevuchadnetzar's. The Rambam holds that Yerushalayim's holiness comes from the Shechinah, which is never annulled, and so it remains today. s,t
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
- b Tehillim 124:1 text index In the write-up: 0:25
- d apparently Mishlei 21:1 index In the write-up: 4:38
- f Tehillim 124:3-5 text index In the write-up: 7:08
- g apparently Tehillim 93:4 index In the write-up: 7:08
- i Tehillim 124:6 9:03 text index
- j Tehillim 124:7 text index In the write-up: 10:07, 21:47
- n Tehillim 124:8 text index In the write-up: 24:29, 25:46
- p Tehillim 125:1 text index In the write-up: 28:55
- q Tehillim 125:2 text index In the write-up: 28:55
- w Tehillim 125:3 text index In the write-up: 36:29
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 3:24 Only a Jew for whom Hashem's Name is constantly on his lips, who sees Hashem's providence in everything, can say 'Had Hashem not been with us', unlike the nations who credit luck.
- 4:38 The Gemara reads 'a man rose against us' as Haman: a man has free choice and is harder to be saved from than a king, whose heart is in Hashem's hand.
- 11:02 The nations that attacked the Jews were all broken in the end, while the Jewish people survived and revived after every trouble, including after the Nazis.
- 24:29 Jews survive in exile through recognizing that Hashem is with them and runs the world; the more they know it, the more help they have.
- 27:34 Those who trust in Hashem are like Har Tziyon, which never moves; even in exile they are protected as the mountains surround Yerushalayim.
- 35:41 According to the Rambam, Yerushalayim's holiness comes from the Shechinah and was never annulled; Klal Yisrael's holiness likewise comes from the Shechinah dwelling among them and no conquest or sin can take it away.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 3:24 Who is it that says 'Had Hashem not been with us'?
Answer: 3:30 A Jew for whom Hashem's Name is constantly on his lips and who sees Hashem's providence in everything, not the nations who credit their success to luck.
-
Question: 4:38 Why does the Gemara stress that Haman was 'a man and not a king'?
Answer: 5:05 A man has free choice, while a king's heart is in Hashem's hand; from a man with free choice it is very hard to be saved.
-
Question: 24:29 What keeps the Jews alive in exile?
Answer: 24:54 Recognizing that Hashem is with them and runs the world with individual providence; that recognition is their help.
-
Question: 34:50 Why does the Rambam hold that Yerushalayim's holiness remains while the holiness of the land for mitzvos was annulled?
Answer: 35:06 The land's holiness for mitzvos came from Yehoshua's conquest, which Nevuchadnetzar's conquest annulled; Yerushalayim's holiness comes from the Shechinah, which is never annulled.
Stories
-
15:07 Four of forty classmates
The Mashgiach relates that he learned in the yeshiva on Wilson Street, in a class of about forty boys. Years later he received an invitation to a reunion of his class. He did not go, but he asked what took place there, and of the forty boys only four had remained Shabbos-observant.
-
17:12 The Williamsburg Jew who said 'Shabbos'
The Mashgiach tells of a Jew in Williamsburg whom people mocked as odd; he davened loudly and with fervor. He told how he made a living: he would start work in a shop on Monday and not come on Shabbos. When he returned the next Monday and the boss asked where he had been, he answered 'Shabbos'.
-
18:16 Bread in the garbage can
The Mashgiach heard in a mikveh from an old chassidishe Jew what another old Jew had told him: in America he went from shop to shop looking for a job, and every one demanded work on Shabbos. With a family to feed, he decided that in the next shop he would agree, since his family would otherwise starve. On the way he passed a garbage can with bread in it, something unheard of in Europe, and he said: 'Ribono shel Olam, as long as there is bread in the garbage can I will not work on Shabbos.' This strengthened him, and in the end Hashem helped him and he did not have to work on Shabbos.
Insights
- 5:05 A man with free choice is a greater danger than a king, whose heart is in Hashem's hand; this is why the Gemara stresses that Haman was 'a man and not a king', and the Mashgiach illustrates it with saving someone from a man versus from a pit.
- 8:06 The 'waters' in the kapitel are forces of judgment, and the power of the splitting of the Yam Suf, when all the world's waters split, is eternal: every flood that threatens the Jews still splits before them.
- 13:21 Pre-war America was like Pisom and Raamses: whatever was built sank into the ground and had to be built again, and so the immigrants' Yiddishkeit sank into the 'clay' of America.
- 23:44 A bird caught in a trap escapes only by breaking a leg or a wing, but here 'the trap broke and we escaped': the Jews came out whole, as seen in the rebirth after the war.
- 25:46 'Maker of heaven and earth' in the present tense means Hashem constantly creates new heavens and earth, and in the new heavens a decree that was written may no longer be written.
- 29:21 Har Tziyon was a marker that left the imprint of G-dliness on the world; after its destruction, the Jews who trust in Hashem take over its function among the nations.
- 37:32 Just as, according to the Rambam, Yerushalayim's holiness from the Shechinah outlasts every conquest, the holiness of a Jew from the Shechinah cannot be taken away by the nations or by sin.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 25:27 The Mashgiach says that the more Jews know that Hashem runs the world, the more help they have.
- 22:46 The Mashgiach says the rebirth of Torah and Jewish life after the Nazis should be recognized as a techiyas hameisim of a people, not taken for granted.
- 39:07 The Mashgiach says it is good for a Jew to know that he is holy because of the Shechinah, so that he will not sin and cause the Shechinah pain.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Haman, Nevuchadnetzar, Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch, Rabbi Yonasan Steif, Rashi, Reuven, the Baal Shem Tov, the Klausenburger Rebbe, the Rambam, the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum), the Vizhnitzer Rebbe, Yehoshua bin Nun, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms בחירה, גלות השכינה, השגחה פרטית, חלק אלוק ממעל, קריעת ים סוף, רבונו של עולם, שכינה, תחיית המתים