ביטול כח עמלק שבזמן הזה; הסבר יסודות האמונה וביטול דיעות האפיקורסים
Catalog entry: זמנים אדר no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 21 תשס"ח (2007–08) Yiddish 1 hr 1 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that Amalek's power is to explain everything as chance, and that the war against Amalek in Adar means seeing Hashem's hand in every event and knowing the foundations of emunah that no theory can shake.
The Mashgiach opens with the joy of Adar and the war against Amalek, whose essence is mikreh, chance: when all the chiefs of Edom trembled at the splitting of the sea, Amalek was not impressed. He recalls reading in Graetz's history that a freak wind split the sea, and brings the Ruzhiner's answer to a maskil that such a coincidence is an even greater miracle. The Megillah is a chain of such 'coincidences', and it teaches to see Hashem's hand in nature. He then explains why the Jewish emunah cannot be denied: an entire nation heard Hashem speak at Sinai, unlike religions founded on one individual, and he brings the Yismach Moshe on a mass event passed down from father to son. After explaining why one must speak about this today, he shows that evolution and the age-of-the-world theories are shifting speculation, and closes that the war against Amalek is knowing that every event comes from Hashem.
Topics: Doubts in Emunah and Amalek · Foundations of Emunah · Hashgacha Pratis · Chodesh Adar
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Adar, Amalek and chance listed in the guide
The Mashgiach opens with the joy of Adar and the war against Amalek, whose essence is chance, as Haman called his downfall 'a coincidence'. He asks why Amalek, alone among the chiefs of Edom, was not shaken by the splitting of the sea.
-
3:46 Graetz's wind and the Ruzhiner's answer listed in the guide
The Mashgiach recalls the apikorsus of the Yiddish papers in his youth and how he read in Graetz's history that a freak wind split the sea. He argues this is not more logical than a miracle, and brings the Ruzhiner's answer that such timing would be an even greater miracle.
-
8:14 The Megillah's chain of coincidences listed in the guide
The Mashgiach goes through the Megillah as a series of 'just then' events, from Vashti to Charvonah, and explains that it teaches to see Hashem's hand in nature, which is the destruction of Amalek. Amalek's attack before Matan Torah cooled the acceptance of the Torah until it was accepted anew in the days of Achashverosh.
-
12:41 An entire nation heard Hashem speak listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the Jewish emunah cannot be denied because six hundred thousand men with their families heard Hashem at Sinai, unlike Christianity, founded on one individual. He adds that milah is kept because of the command at Sinai, and that the people believe in Moshe Rabbeinu because they heard Hashem appoint him.
-
17:35 The Yismach Moshe on a mass event listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Yismach Moshe's answer to someone troubled by doubts in emunah: not to philosophize, but to rely on what a whole multitude saw, which cannot be denied, as no one denies Alexander the Great. The Torah was seen by millions, written and handed down from father to son, and even the other religions admit it, only claiming that Hashem changed His mind, which cannot be.
-
25:40 Why these matters must be spoken of today listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says he never spoke of these matters publicly, since it was not the custom, but today everyone comes into contact with these ideas, and the Skverer Rebbe says one must speak to children and bachurim. He mentions a doctor who began explaining evolution to him when he came for medical advice.
-
28:57 The folly of a world that made itself listed in the guide
The Mashgiach compares the claim that the world came about by itself to saying that a wise, beautifully written sefer was splashed onto its pages by a wind blowing over a bottle of ink, or that a computer evolved by itself. He notes that universities teach evolution only as a theory and that the more science learns, the less sense the theories make.
-
34:40 Scientific theories keep changing listed in the guide
The Mashgiach shows how theories change: the sun was held to circle the earth, Copernicus reversed it, and with Einstein's relativity both views are equally valid. He explains that scientists are driven by the wish for new discoveries and fame, and that belief in the Creator would bind them to the mitzvos, so their claims about billions of years are speculation.
-
40:56 Why their dating cannot be trusted listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains how a thermometer is built on a measured rate of expansion, and how water surprises by expanding again as it freezes, so no rate can be extrapolated back over a billion years. The same holds for the salt in the sea, rock layers and dinosaur bones: other conditions of pressure and temperature may have existed, and their proofs contradict each other.
-
47:28 The Mabul and the harmony of creation listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the boiling waters of the Mabul, covering even the highest mountains, could bring about in a short time changes they calculate as taking a billion years, like a potato that softens in minutes when cooked. He then points to the harmony of creation and compares the unseen life in a creature to electricity in a wire, known by its effects.
-
52:34 The war against Amalek today listed in the guide
The Mashgiach returns to Amalek, who called even the splitting of the sea a coincidence, and says today's devices bring Amalek's influence into the home. The war against Amalek is to know that every event is from Hashem, as the Megillah teaches and as the Ramban writes, and he closes with brachos for the coming year and for the geulah.
The shiur, written up
Adar, Amalek and chance
The Mashgiach opens with the joy of Adar, which is bound up with the war against Amalek, and Amalek's essence is mikreh, chance. Haman too, he notes, saw his downfall as a mere coincidence. Amalek met the Jews 'on the way', and when the sea split all the chiefs of Edom trembled, Amalek among them. Yet Amalek was not impressed, and the Mashgiach asks what his power was. a,b,c,d
Graetz's wind and the Ruzhiner's answer
The Mashgiach recalls that in his youth the Yiddish papers were full of apikorsus, and that he once opened Graetz's history exactly at the splitting of the sea. Graetz admits it happened but credits a freak wind, stronger than any in history. e
The Mashgiach argues, from logic alone, that this is no more reasonable than a miracle. He brings the Ruzhiner, who told a maskil that by his account it was an even greater miracle: the wind came exactly when the Jews fled and the Egyptians pursued.
The Megillah's chain of coincidences
The Megillah, the Mashgiach says, is full of such 'just then' events: Achashverosh's feast and Vashti's death, Esther becoming queen, Mordechai overhearing Bigsan and Teresh, and Charvonah appearing just as the king turned on Haman. Its lesson is to see Hashem's hand within nature, and that is the destruction of Amalek, who denies hashgacha pratis. f
An entire nation heard Hashem speak
The Mashgiach explains that Jewish emunah cannot be denied: six hundred thousand men with their wives, children and elders all heard Hashem. Christianity rests on one individual, though the Rambam in Hilchos Melachim credits it with drawing gentiles from idolatry; but Jews do not believe in an individual. h
The Yismach Moshe on a mass event
The Mashgiach notes that the Rambam in Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah explains these foundations at length. He then brings the Yismach Moshe, who was asked about a man troubled by doubts in emunah, and answered that one need not philosophize with him. Something an entire multitude saw cannot be denied. k,l
No one denies Alexander the Great, who conquered Europe two thousand years ago, because hundreds of thousands met him. So too millions saw the Torah given; had it not happened, the next generation would have asked why they never heard of it. Moshe wrote the Torah, gave each tribe a sefer Torah, and it passed on from father to son and teacher to student.
Even Christians and Muslims accept the Torah, claiming only that a later prophet said Hashem changed His mind. That cannot be, the Mashgiach says, for Hashem never changes.
Why these matters must be spoken of today
The Mashgiach says he never spoke of this publicly, as it was not the custom. Today everyone comes into contact with these ideas, and the Skverer Rebbe says one must speak to children and bachurim. A doctor once began teaching him about monkeys, and he replied that he had come for medical advice, not evolution.
The folly of a world that made itself
The Mashgiach calls it foolish to say the world came about by itself. If someone claimed that a wise, beautifully written sefer came from a wind tipping over a bottle of ink and splashing its pages, no one would accept it. The theories keep changing, from evolution to the Big Bang, and saying that a computer evolved by itself is no different.
Universities themselves teach evolution only as a theory, not as fact. The Mashgiach adds that the more science learns, the less sense the theories make.
Scientific theories keep changing
For centuries the sun was held to circle the earth, until Copernicus declared that the earth circles the sun. Then Einstein's theory of relativity came and said that either view is correct, depending on the observer. So the scientists come with a theory until someone overturns it.
Why do they hold such views? The Mashgiach explains that people crave new discoveries and fame, such as a Nobel prize, and that believing in the Creator would bind them to the six hundred thirteen mitzvos. Their claims of billions of years are speculation, and one should not be fooled.
Why their dating cannot be trusted
The Mashgiach explains that a thermometer is built on the measured expansion of mercury or water with heat. Yet water surprises: near freezing it expands again, and ice takes more space than water. One therefore cannot reckon backward a billion years from what is measured today, just as four quarters make one, but one has many other possible origins.
They likewise date the world from the salt in the sea, from rock layers and from dinosaur bones. But other conditions of pressure and temperature may have existed, and each of their proofs gives a different age.
The Mabul and the harmony of creation
Jews know from the Torah of the Mabul, whose waters were boiling and rose above the highest mountains. Such pressure could do in a month what they reckon as a billion years, just as a potato takes long to soften but softens in minutes when cooked. m
Looking at the harmony of creation, one sees that the Ribono shel Olam made the world. Life cannot be seen, like electricity in a wire, yet it is known from what it does.
The war against Amalek today
The Mashgiach returns to Amalek, for whom everything is chance, so that he could call even the splitting of the sea, which millions saw with their own eyes, a coincidence. Today Amalek comes through many devices and electronic tools in the home, and what one sees can leave its mark for years.
The war against Amalek is to know that all events come only from Hashem. As the Ramban writes, one who does not see that every natural occurrence is a miracle has no share in the Torah. n
The Megillah teaches this, for its events link one to the next and lead to the geulah. The Mashgiach closes with brachos for a year filled with that knowledge and for the coming of Moshiach.
Sources
Torah
- a Devarim 25:18 text index In the write-up: 0:36
- b Shemos 17:8 text index In the write-up: 0:36
- c Bereishis 36:16 text index In the write-up: 0:36
- d Shemos 15:15 text index In the write-up: 0:36
- i Devarim 5:4 text index In the write-up: 16:00
- j Devarim 4:32-33 text index In the write-up: 16:00
- m Bereishis 7:20 text index In the write-up: 47:45
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
Key points
- 0:45 Amalek's essence is mikreh: he attributes everything to chance and denies hashgacha pratis.
- 6:40 Explaining the splitting of the sea as a coincidental wind is no more logical than a miracle; such a coincidence would itself be a greater miracle.
- 10:45 The Megillah is a chain of apparent coincidences, and it teaches to see Hashem's hand within nature.
- 13:46 Jewish emunah rests on what an entire nation saw and heard at Sinai, not on the claim of one individual.
- 20:18 An event witnessed by a multitude and passed on from father to son cannot be denied, just as no one denies Alexander the Great.
- 32:14 Evolution and the calculations of the world's age are shifting theories built on extrapolations that cannot be relied on.
- 54:15 The war against Amalek today is to know that every occurrence, in the world and in one's own life, comes from Hashem.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 3:30 Why was Amalek alone not shaken by the splitting of the sea, when all the chiefs of Edom trembled?
Answer: 11:45 Because Amalek attributes everything to chance and does not believe in hashgacha pratis, so he could call even the splitting of the sea a coincidence.
-
Question: 6:31 Is it more logical to say a natural wind split the sea than that it was a miracle?
Answer: 7:47 No; such a wind arriving at precisely that moment would be an even greater miracle, as the Ruzhiner told the maskil.
-
Question: 12:55 Why can the Jewish emunah not be denied, when other faiths can?
Answer: 13:46 Because an entire nation, men, women, children and elders, heard Hashem speak at Sinai, while other faiths rest on one individual.
-
Question: 24:00 If the other religions accept the Torah, on what do they base their own?
Answer: 24:15 They claim a later prophet came and said Hashem changed His mind, which cannot be, since Hashem does not change.
-
Question: 25:51 Why does the Mashgiach now speak publicly about matters he never spoke of before?
Answer: 26:03 Because today everyone comes into contact with these ideas and cannot avoid them, so one must speak about them, as the Skverer Rebbe says.
-
Question: 40:10 How can scientists claim the world is billions of years old?
Answer: 43:55 They extrapolate rates measured today, but other conditions of pressure and temperature may have existed, as water's behavior near freezing and the Mabul show, so their calculations prove nothing.
Stories
-
4:49 The Mashgiach opens Graetz's history
The Mashgiach recalls that as a young man he once came upon Graetz's famous multi-volume history of the Jews. He opened it exactly at the account of the splitting of the sea. Graetz wrote that the event cannot be denied, since it is a historical fact, but that it happened to coincide with an exceptionally strong wind, stronger than any in history, which split the sea.
In the story: Heinrich Graetz
-
7:27 The Ruzhiner and the maskil
A maskil came to the Ruzhiner and claimed that the splitting of the sea was no miracle, only a strong wind that came at that moment. The Ruzhiner answered that he believes with complete emunah that it was a miracle. But by the maskil's own account it was an even greater miracle: that just when the Jews fled Egypt and the Egyptians pursued them, the sea split by a wind.
In the story: Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner)
-
27:48 The doctor who taught evolution
The Mashgiach mentions a visit to a prominent doctor who began explaining to him about monkeys as the ancestors of man. The Mashgiach answered that he had come for medical advice, not to learn evolution.
Insights
- 3:27 Amalek's ability to stay unmoved by the splitting of the sea came from his view of everything as chance; this is the root of the war against him.
- 7:47 Calling the splitting of the sea a natural wind does not escape the miracle: that it came exactly when the Jews fled and the Egyptians pursued is itself a greater miracle.
- 11:54 Amalek's attack before Matan Torah brought a coolness into the Jews' acceptance of the Torah, which was completed only when Amalek was destroyed in the days of Purim.
- 15:26 Unlike religions built on one individual, the Torah rests on testimony that millions passed on to their children; a fabricated mass event would have been questioned by the very next generation.
- 43:55 Rates measured in a laboratory cannot be extrapolated back over eons, as water shows by expanding again near freezing; the Mabul's boiling waters could do in a short time what they reckon as a billion years.
- 49:52 Like electricity in a wire, which is unseen but known from what it does, Hashem's presence in the world is known from life and from the harmony of creation.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 26:58 The Mashgiach says one must speak about these matters of emunah with children, bachurim and yungeleit, as the Skverer Rebbe says.
- 11:23 The Mashgiach says the Megillah teaches to look at every event in nature and see that it is not chance but Hashem's hand.
- 39:56 The Mashgiach says one should not be impressed by the scientists' theories, since all they say is speculation.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achashverosh, Albert Einstein, Alexander the Great, Avraham Avinu, Bigsan and Teresh, Charvonah, Copernicus, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Heinrich Graetz, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), the Rambam, the Ramban, the Skverer Rebbe, the Yismach Moshe, Vashti
Terms אפיקורס, השגחה פרטית, מבול, מחיית עמלק, מקרה, עמלק, קריעת ים סוף, רבונו של עולם