צד ב: אברהם אבינו ראש למאמינים
Catalog entry: זמנים מהר"ל גבורת ה' no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 26 תשמ"ב (1981–82) Yiddish 42 min
Listen
About this shiur
Following the Maharal's answer to the Ramban, the Mashgiach explains why Avraham Avinu's emunah was so great and why emunah, which frees a Jew from dependence on anyone but Hashem, is the foundation of Klal Yisrael.
The Mashgiach opens with the Ramban's question on 'vehe'emin baShem': what was so praiseworthy in Avraham believing Hashem? The Maharal answers that by nature Avraham could not have children, and he feared sin might cancel the promise, yet he believed. From here the Mashgiach shows that a Jew's bond with Hashem does not rest on merits: the Torah gives no reason for 'Lech lecha', and the Ramban's 'great sin' of going down to Egypt teaches that a Jew remains a Jew and his sins are only external. He then follows the Maharal's challenge to the Ramban: emunah is no small thing, as the Mechilta's praise of the emunah at the sea shows. Emunah means firmness; a believer is subjugated to no person, as the Maharal's explanation of the dog shows. A believer is always joyful and never angry; Moshe's anger at Mei Merivah was a lack of emunah. He ends with Yaakov's 'me'ayin yavo ezri'.
Topics: Avraham Avinu · Foundations of Emunah · Bitachon
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The Ramban's question on 'vehe'emin' listed in the guide
The Mashgiach ties Pesach to the bris bein habesarim and brings the Ramban's question of what was great in Avraham's believing. He gives the Maharal's answer: by nature Avraham could have no children and he feared sin might undo the promise, yet he believed because Hashem wanted it.
-
5:41 Why 'Lech lecha' gives no reason listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says Klal Yisrael began with Avraham and does not rest on merits. He asks why the Torah, unlike by Noach, gives no reason for choosing Avraham, and leaves his mesiras nefesh in Ur Kasdim to the Oral Torah: a Jew is a Jew because his soul is a part of Hashem, even when he sins.
-
11:58 The Ramban's 'great sin' of Avraham listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Ramban that Avraham sinned greatly by going down to Egypt and by Sarah being taken to Pharaoh, and asks how the Ramban could judge him so when even Korach and Zimri are judged favorably. He answers that the very first account after 'Lech lecha' shows a sin, to teach that a Jew remains a Jew and his sin is only external.
-
16:46 The Maharal: emunah is no small thing listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Maharal's challenge to the Ramban and the Mechilta that the Jews at the sea merited ruach hakodesh for their emunah, and that one who takes on one mitzvah with emunah merits the Shechinah. He applies it: each Jew should take on one mitzvah with mesiras nefesh, such as a fixed seder after davening, illustrated by a story of a man who was 'dead' during his shiur, and Avraham withstanding the Satan at the Akeidah with pure emunah.
-
23:43 Emunah as firmness and foundation listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says emunah is great even if it came easily, as a segulah, like the Midrash on oneg Shabbos. Emunah means firmness, like a peg in a firm place; Avraham is the rock from which Klal Yisrael was hewn, the foundation, and as he became the first Jew through emunah, the nation left Egypt through emunah.
-
27:04 A believer is subjugated to no one listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains the Maharal: one who believes depends on Hashem alone and cannot be subjugated, since subjugation is the opposite of existence; so the Jews, believing, became free and left Egypt. He brings the Maharal's explanation of why 'dog' is an insult in every language: the dog is wholly dependent on its master, a repulsive trait, while a person should depend only on Hashem.
-
32:02 Rooted in Hashem, always in simcha listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that a believer is rooted in Hashem like a tree planted by water, and answers the Ramban that emunah is a great feat, for even Moshe Rabbeinu fell short in it. He teaches that a believer is always in simcha, and tells the story of Reb Shimon of Yaroslav and his 'two cows'.
-
37:21 A believer never becomes angry listed in the guide
The Mashgiach teaches that a believer does not become angry, since everything is from Heaven, as Dovid said of Shimi. Following the Maharal, Moshe's anger and striking the rock was the lack of emunah for which he was punished. He ends with the Midrash on Yaakov leaving Be'er Sheva saying 'me'ayin yavo ezri', a support for Jews in golus.
The shiur, written up
The Ramban's question on 'vehe'emin'
At the bris bein habesarim the Torah says Avraham 'believed in Hashem', and the Ramban asks what is so great in that: after all the miracles Hashem did for him, should he not believe? a,b
The Maharal answers that by nature Avraham could have no children, and only his merits would break nature. He could fear that a sin might cancel the promise, as Chazal say, yet he believed because he saw Hashem wanted it. That, the Mashgiach says, is emunah: believing where one does not understand. c,d
Why 'Lech lecha' gives no reason
Klal Yisrael began with Avraham, and the Mashgiach says it does not rest on merits. This answers why Hashem tells Avraham 'Lech lecha' with no reason given, whereas by Noach the Torah first says he was a tzaddik. e,f
Avraham's mesiras nefesh in Ur Kasdim, his breaking the idols and his proclaiming Hashem to a world that mocked him, as the Midrash and the Rambam tell, is left to the Oral Torah. The Mashgiach explains that this is so no one thinks a Jew's bond with Hashem was earned. A Jew remains a Jew even when he sins, because his soul is a part of Hashem, without any reason. g,h
The Ramban's 'great sin' of Avraham
The Maharal: emunah is no small thing
The Maharal argues with the Ramban: is emunah a small thing? He brings the Mechilta that the Jews merited ruach hakodesh at the sea in reward for their emunah, and Rabbi Nechemiah's teaching that one who takes on one mitzvah with emunah merits the Shechinah. c,l,m
From here the Mashgiach says each Jew should take on one mitzvah with mesiras nefesh, such as a fixed seder after davening that is never cancelled. He brings, from the Chofetz Chaim, a man who made a big merchant wait and said that during his shiur he is dead, as Chazal say the Torah endures in one who kills himself over it. n,o
Emunah as firmness and foundation
Even if believing came easily, emunah is great as a segulah, as oneg Shabbos equals a thousand fasts in Midrash Tanchuma. Emunah means firmness, like 'a peg in a firm place'. Avraham is the rock from which Klal Yisrael was hewn, its foundation, and just as he became the first Jew through emunah, the nation left Egypt through emunah. q,r,s
A believer is subjugated to no one
The Maharal explains that one who believes depends on Hashem alone, so no person can do him good or bad and he cannot be subjugated. Subjugation is the opposite of existence; when the Jews believed in Egypt they became independent and were redeemed. ag
Elsewhere the Maharal asks why 'dog' is an insult in every language. Every animal has some independence, but the dog depends wholly on its master. That is a repulsive trait: a person should depend only on Hashem.
Rooted in Hashem, always in simcha
Sources
Torah
- a Bereishis 15:6 text index In the write-up: 0:26
- e Bereishis 12:1 text index In the write-up: 5:45
- f Bereishis 6:9 text index In the write-up: 5:45
- m Shemos 14:31 text index In the write-up: 17:07
- aa Bamidbar 20:12 text index In the write-up: 32:14
- ad Bamidbar 20:10 text index In the write-up: 37:26
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- g apparently Bereishis Rabbah 42:8 index In the write-up: 7:19
- l apparently Mechilta, Beshalach (on Shemos 14:31) index In the write-up: 17:07, 22:29
- p Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 22:29
- q Midrash Tanchuma (place not identified) index In the write-up: 24:33
- ae Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 40:48
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 1:51 According to the Maharal, Avraham's emunah was great because by nature he could not have children and he feared sin might cancel the promise, yet he believed because he saw that Hashem wanted it.
- 6:08 The Mashgiach teaches that a Jew's bond with Hashem does not depend on merits; this is why the Torah says 'Lech lecha' without first praising Avraham.
- 12:23 The first thing the Torah tells after 'Lech lecha' is what the Ramban calls Avraham's great sin, to show that a Jew remains a Jew even when he sins.
- 17:07 The Maharal argues against the Ramban that emunah is a great thing in itself, and Chazal say the Jews merited ruach hakodesh at the sea in reward for their emunah.
- 25:38 Emunah means firmness: a believer depends only on Hashem and is subjugated to no person, and the Jews left Egypt through emunah because it made them free.
- 33:47 One who believes in Hashem is always in simcha and does not become angry, and Moshe's anger at the rock was a lack of emunah.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 0:39 What was so great in Avraham believing Hashem's promise?
Answer: 1:51 The Maharal: by nature he could not have children and he feared sin might cancel the promise, yet he believed because he saw Hashem wanted it.
-
Question: 6:35 Why does the Torah command 'Lech lecha' without stating Avraham's merits, unlike by Noach?
Answer: 10:31 Because a Jew's bond with Hashem does not rest on merit; a Jew is a Jew because his soul is a part of Hashem.
-
Question: 12:58 How could the Ramban call Avraham's going down to Egypt a great sin, when we judge even Korach and Zimri favorably?
Answer: 15:48 The first account of the first Jew shows a sin to teach that a Jew remains a Jew and his sin is only external.
-
Question: 23:50 Why is emunah great even if it came easily to Avraham?
Answer: 24:33 Emunah is great as a segulah, just as the Midrash Tanchuma equates oneg Shabbos with a thousand fasts though it is easier.
-
Question: 29:10 Why is 'dog' an insult in every language?
Answer: 30:13 Because the dog is entirely dependent on its master, a repulsive trait; a person must be dependent only on Hashem.
-
Question: 33:18 What was Moshe Rabbeinu's failing at Mei Merivah, that he is told 'you did not believe in Me'?
Answer: 38:41 He became angry, and one with full emunah does not become angry.
Stories
-
20:50 The man who was 'dead' during his shiur
The Mashgiach tells, in the name of the Chofetz Chaim, of a man whose practice was to learn his fixed shiur right after davening, before going to business. Once a big merchant came to do business with him, and he made him wait. His wife came shouting, and he told her that while he learns his shiur he is dead and nothing else exists for him. The Mashgiach connects this to Chazal's words that the Torah endures in one who kills himself over it.
In the story: the Chofetz Chaim
-
34:30 Reb Shimon of Yaroslav and his two cows
When Reb Shimon of Yaroslav was a young man, before he was known as a tzaddik, he was very poor. A man from his town who saw him sitting in the beis medrash day and night realized he was a great tzaddik, and would leave the rebbetzin some money, fish and potatoes. Once he asked Reb Shimon what he lived from, and he answered that he had two cows. When the man asked the rebbetzin why she then needed his money, she said they had no cows and the children had not tasted milk that day. The Mashgiach brings the story to show that one who believes in Hashem is always in simcha.
In the story: Rabbi Shimon of Yaroslav
Insights
- 3:34 The greatness of Avraham's emunah, per the Maharal, was not believing in miracles but believing against his own reasonable fear that sin might cancel the promise, simply because he saw Hashem wanted it; the Mashgiach calls this the meaning of emunah, believing where one does not understand.
- 8:57 The Written Torah deliberately hides Avraham's mesiras nefesh and gives no reason for 'Lech lecha', so that no one should think a Jew's chosenness was earned; a Jew is a Jew 'without any reason'.
- 15:42 The Ramban's harsh 'great sin' is itself a praise of Avraham: precisely in the first account of the first Jew the Torah shows a sin, to teach that a Jew's sin is external and never touches his inner self.
- 27:53 Emunah is the opposite of subjugation: one who depends on Hashem alone cannot be enslaved, which is why the Exodus came through emunah.
- 29:00 Following the Maharal, the dog is the universal insult because it is entirely dependent on its master, whereas a person should be independent of people and dependent only on Hashem.
- 38:41 According to the Maharal, Moshe's sin at Mei Merivah was the anger itself: full emunah leaves no room for anger, since no one can do a person harm or good except Hashem.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 18:47 The Mashgiach says every Jew should take on one mitzvah to which he devotes himself with mesiras nefesh.
- 20:15 The Mashgiach says one should have a fixed seder of learning after davening and never cancel it, even when one could earn a lot.
- 21:40 The Mashgiach mentions guarding the eyes in the street as such a mitzvah, not being curious to look.
- 41:27 The Mashgiach says that when trouble comes a Jew should hold on to 'me'ayin yavo ezri, ezri me'im Hashem'.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Korach, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nimrod, Noach, Pharaoh, Rabbeinu Yonah, Rabbi Nechemiah, Rabbi Shimon of Yaroslav, Sarah Imeinu, Shimi ben Gera, the Baal Shem Tov, the Chofetz Chaim, the Maharal of Prague, the Rambam, the Ramban, Yaakov Avinu, Zimri ben Salu
Terms אמונה, ברית בין הבתרים, דן לכף זכות, כעס, מסירות נפש, רוח הקודש, שמחה, תורה שבעל פה