צד א: במה אדע - עצמיות של כנ"י טוב; מדריגת אבות' שבטים' ושבעים נפש' גאולה עצם הגלות.

Catalog entry: זמנים מהר"ל גבורת ה' no. ⁨2⁩ Pocket Guide p. 26 תשמ"ב (1981–82) Yiddish 42 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 42 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

Following the Maharal, the Mashgiach explains that a Jew's sin, and so his exile, is only incidental while his goodness is his essence, which is why Avraham was promised that korbanos would bring his children back to Eretz Yisrael and why the start of every galus already holds the geulah.

The Mashgiach opens with Avraham's question 'bameh eda', 'how will I know that I will inherit the land', and asks how Avraham could seem to lack faith. Hashem answered: in the merit of korbanos. Bringing the Gemara in Megillah and the Midrash, the Mashgiach sets out the Maharal's rule: in a Jew sin is incidental, while in a gentile it is essential, illustrated by a man splashed with mud as opposed to one whose skin is dark. That is why a korban can wipe away a Jew's sin and draw him close to Hashem. Eretz Yisrael, a 'Jew in geography', spits out sin, yet it must return to the Jews, and this was Avraham's real question. The Mashgiach then distinguishes the avos, the shevatim and the seventy souls in their bond to Mitzrayim, and shows through the atbash calendar, Yocheved and Serach bas Asher that galus begins with the geulah already inside it.

Topics: The Greatness of Every Jew · Kedushas Eretz Yisroel · Galus as Preparation for Geulah · Korbanos and Avodas HaMikdash

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Avraham's question: 'bameh eda' listed in the guide

    Recalling that Avraham was the foundation of Jewish emunah, the Mashgiach asks how he could ask 'bameh eda'. He brings the Midrash that Hashem answered 'in the merit of korbanos', the objection of meforshim, and the Gemara in Megillah that korbanos would protect Avraham's children from the fate of the generations of the Flood and the Dispersion.

  2. 4:37 The Maharal's rule: sin by accident, not by essence listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach sets out the Maharal's rule that a Jew's sin is incidental while a gentile's is essential, with the mashal of a man splashed with black mud as opposed to a man whose skin is black. That is why a korban, which means closeness, can wipe away a Jew's sin, while a gentile may bring only an olah.

  3. 8:59 Korbanos and Torah as a shield in galus listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach explains that a korban accepted for a Jew proves his goodness is essential, while a gentile's good deeds bring no closeness. In galus, Torah, and especially the Torah of korbanos and the daily saying of korbanos, draws a Jew close to Hashem; he laments that yeshiva students treat saying korbanos lightly.

  4. 12:44 Eretz Yisrael, a Jew in geography listed in the guide

    Every Jew must in the end become good, through whatever cleansing is needed, while gentiles cannot be cleansed. Just as the Jewish people accept no filth, Eretz Yisrael, the 'separated land', spits out sinners; the Mashgiach calls it a Jew by place rather than by soul, and touches on exile to the cities of refuge.

  5. 16:31 Every nation's land, and Avraham's answer listed in the guide

    Every nation has a land fitted to its nature, and Eretz Yisrael is the land of Klal Yisrael. The Mashgiach returns to the Maharal: Avraham asked whether his children would come back after being exiled for their sins, and the answer, korbanos, shows their sin is incidental, so they must return.

  6. 19:53 Avos, shevatim and the seventy souls listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach describes three levels in Klal Yisrael: Yaakov, who belonged wholly to Eretz Yisrael and was brought back there in full; the shevatim, branches of the tree, whose bones alone went up; and the seventy souls, Jews of galus who stayed in Mitzrayim. He brings a hint from sefarim in the word 'gevia', Yosef's goblet.

  7. 25:09 Who completed the seventy: Yocheved or Serach listed in the guide

    The Gemara notes that only sixty-nine are counted, and answers that Yocheved, born 'between the walls' at the border of Mitzrayim, completed the seventy. The Midrash says Serach bas Asher completed it; the Mashgiach asks how, since she is already counted, and explains she is counted as two. He then brings the Midrash linking the first day of Pesach with Tisha b'Av.

  8. 28:51 Pesach sets Tisha b'Av: churban rooted in geulah listed in the guide

    By the atbash rule the first day of Pesach falls on the same weekday as Tisha b'Av. The Mashgiach explains that Pesach, the day of geulah, determines the day of churban because a Jewish churban must be rooted in geulah; galus is incidental and geulah essential. So Yocheved, mother of Moshe Rabbeinu, was born at the very step into the first galus.

  9. 34:59 Serach bas Asher and Eliyahu, bearer of good news listed in the guide

    Every matter has an angel appointed over it, and Eliyahu Hanavi is appointed over good news. Serach, who told Yaakov 'od Yosef chai', took on Eliyahu's quality, so she lived on, entered Gan Eden alive and counts as two. She later confirmed Moshe as redeemer by 'pakod pakadti', and the Mashgiach concludes that the seventy souls entering galus already hint at the geulah.

The shiur, written up

Avraham's question: 'bameh eda'

0:34

Continuing from the last shiur, that Avraham was the foundation of Jewish emunah, the Mashgiach asks how he could say 'bameh eda', 'how will I know that I will inherit it' (Bereishis 15:8), words some meforshim read as a flaw in his faith. The Midrash says Hashem answered: in the merit of korbanos. The Gemara in Megillah explains that korbanos, and later the reciting of korbanos, would save Avraham's children from the fate of the generations of the Flood and the Dispersion. a,b,d

The Maharal's rule: sin by accident, not by essence

4:37

The Maharal sets down a rule: something can belong to a person by accident or by essence. A Jew, a child of Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov, has no real connection to sin; in a gentile sin is essential. A Jew who falls into black mud only looks black and washes clean with soap and water, while a man with dark skin stays dark however he scrubs. This is why a korban, a word meaning closeness, can wipe away a Jew's sin. e

Korbanos and Torah as a shield in galus

9:50

A korban that is accepted, the Mashgiach continues, shows that a Jew's goodness is essential, while a gentile's good deeds bring him no closeness to Hashem. In galus, Torah, and especially the Torah of korbanos, draws a Jew close. He laments that yeshiva students take saying korbanos lightly, though the Shulchan Aruch counts it an obligation, and says this is the shield promised to Avraham. l

Eretz Yisrael, a Jew in geography

13:06

Every Jew must in the end become good: what plain soap does not remove is scrubbed off through other tikkunim or a gilgul, but gentiles cannot be cleansed, since sin is their essence. Like the Jewish people, Eretz Yisrael, the 'separated land', accepts no filth and spits out sinners. It is, the Mashgiach says, a Jew by place rather than by soul.

Every nation's land, and Avraham's answer

16:53

Every nation has a land fitted to its nature, and Eretz Yisrael belongs to Klal Yisrael. Here the Mashgiach returns to the Maharal: Avraham asked whether his children would come back after being exiled for their sins. Korbanos prove their sin is incidental, so they must return. e

Avos, shevatim and the seventy souls

20:36

The Mashgiach then describes three levels. Yaakov belonged wholly to Eretz Yisrael and went down only as part of the seventy souls, so after his passing he was brought back in full. The shevatim, branches of the tree, had a lesser bond to Mitzrayim, and only their bones went up. The seventy souls, their children, were Jews of galus and remained there. The Mashgiach cites sefarim that hint at this in Yosef's goblet, 'gevia': gimmel for the avos, beis-yud for the shevatim, ayin for the seventy.

Who completed the seventy

25:30

The Gemara counts only sixty-nine and answers that Yocheved, born 'between the walls' as they entered Mitzrayim, completed the seventy. The Midrash says Serach bas Asher completed it, and the meforshim ask how, since she is already counted. One answer: she, who told Yaakov that Yosef lived and entered Gan Eden alive, counts as two. The Mashgiach also brings the Midrash linking the first night of Pesach with Tisha b'Av. q,s,t

Pesach sets Tisha b'Av

28:54

By the atbash rule, the first day of Pesach falls on the weekday of Tisha b'Av. Why should Pesach, the day of geulah, set the day of churban? Because a Jewish churban must be rooted in geulah, and one day Tisha b'Av will be a bright Yom Tov. As the Maharal taught, galus is incidental and geulah essential. So at the very first step into galus, at the border of Mitzrayim, Yocheved was born, mother of Moshe Rabbeinu, the root of the geulah. e

Serach bas Asher and Eliyahu, bearer of good news

35:19

Every matter has an angel appointed over it, and Eliyahu Hanavi is appointed over good news; whoever brings good news takes on something of him, fully when it concerns all of Klal Yisrael, as in 'mah navu… raglei mevaser'. Yaakov was all of Klal Yisrael, so Serach, who told him 'od Yosef chai', received Eliyahu's full quality. That is why she lived on, entered Gan Eden alive and counts as two. v,w

39:06

The Gemara and Midrash therefore agree: Yocheved is the root of Moshe the redeemer, Serach the herald of the geulah, and according to the Midrash she confirmed Moshe through 'pakod pakadti'. The seventy souls who begin the galus already hint at its end. z

Sources

Torah

  1. a Bereishis 15:8 text index In the write-up: 0:34
  2. c Bereishis 15:9 1:24 text index
  3. f Shemos 13:17 8:05 text index
  4. m Vayikra 18:28 14:05 text index
  5. n Devarim 32:8 17:09 text index
  6. o Bereishis 46:27 20:45 text index
  7. p Shemos 13:19 23:18 text index
  8. w Bereishis 45:26-27 text index In the write-up: 35:19

Nevi'im

  1. v Yeshayahu 52:7 text index In the write-up: 35:19
  2. x apparently Melachim II 2:11 36:57 index

Kesuvim

  1. g Tehillim 148:14 8:02 text index
  2. u Eichah 3:15 28:14 text index

Talmud Bavli

  1. d Megillah 31b text index In the write-up: 0:34
  2. h apparently Menachos 73b 8:29 index
  3. j apparently Bava Basra 10b 10:03 index
  4. k apparently Menachos 110a 10:47 index
  5. q apparently Bava Basra 123b index In the write-up: 25:30

Midrash

  1. b apparently Bereishis Rabbah 44:14 index In the write-up: 0:34
  2. i Midrash (place not identified) 8:34
  3. s Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 25:30
  4. t Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 25:30
  5. z apparently Shemos Rabbah 5:13 index In the write-up: 39:06

Rishonim

  1. r apparently Rashi on Bereishis 46:15 25:52 index

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. e Gevuros Hashem (place not identified) index In the write-up: 4:37, 16:53, 28:54
  2. l Shulchan Aruch (place not identified) index In the write-up: 9:50
  3. y Ohr HaChaim (place not identified) 39:17 index

Key points

  1. 18:01 According to the Maharal, Avraham's question 'bameh eda' was not a lack of faith but whether his children would return to Eretz Yisrael after being exiled for their sins.
  2. 4:50 A Jew's sin is incidental (b'mikreh) and does not cling to him, while a gentile's sin becomes part of his essence (b'etzem).
  3. 7:36 Korbanos, and today the saying and learning of korbanos, show that a Jew is close to Hashem and can be cleansed, and they protect the Jews in galus.
  4. 14:02 Eretz Yisrael is the 'separated land' that, like the Jewish soul, does not tolerate sin, and every nation has a land fitted to its nature.
  5. 20:36 The avos, the shevatim and the seventy souls are three levels in their bond to Eretz Yisrael and to Mitzrayim.
  6. 31:49 Galus for Jews is only temporary while the geulah is essential, so the geulah is rooted in the very start of every galus.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 0:34 How could Avraham, the foundation of emunah, ask 'bameh eda', as if he lacked faith?

    Answer: 18:19 According to the Maharal he did not doubt the promise; he asked whether his children would return to the land after being exiled for their sins.

  2. Question: 1:52 What connection do korbanos have with inheriting Eretz Yisrael?

    Answer: 18:41 Korbanos show that a Jew's sin is incidental and can be wiped away, so even if exiled the Jews must return to the land that tolerates no sin.

  3. Question: 7:28 Why should a korban wipe away sins at all?

    Answer: 7:36 Because a Jew has no essential connection to sin, and a korban, from the word for closeness, reveals his closeness to Hashem.

  4. Question: 25:30 The Gemara counts only sixty-nine who went down to Mitzrayim, yet the passuk says seventy.

    Answer: 26:01 Yocheved, born 'between the walls' as they entered Mitzrayim, completed the seventy.

  5. Question: 26:42 How can the Midrash say Serach completed the seventy, when she is already counted among them?

    Answer: 27:31 Because she carries the quality of Eliyahu Hanavi as well as her own, she is counted as two.

  6. Question: 30:04 Why was Pesach given the role of determining the day of Tisha b'Av?

    Answer: 30:10 Because a Jewish churban can only be rooted in geulah; galus is incidental and the geulah essential, so the geulah is master over the churban.

Insights

  1. 18:37 The Mashgiach reads Hashem's answer to Avraham, 'in the merit of korbanos', as a proof about the Jewish essence: if a korban can wipe away a Jew's sin, his sin is only incidental, so his children must return to Eretz Yisrael.
  2. 6:21 A Jew who sins is like a man who fell into black mud: soap and water restore him, whereas for a man with dark skin no scrubbing helps, for the color is his essence.
  3. 14:29 Eretz Yisrael is 'a Jew in geography': everything that belongs to a Jewish soul belongs to the Jewish place, which is why it spits out sinners just as the Jewish soul spits out evil.
  4. 24:05 Yosef's goblet, 'gevia', hints at the three levels: gimmel for the three avos, beis-yud for the twelve shevatim, ayin for the seventy souls; once the seventy existed, the family could go down to Mitzrayim.
  5. 30:10 Pesach determines the weekday of Tisha b'Av because a Jewish churban is always rooted in geulah; the Mashgiach says a time will come when Tisha b'Av will be perhaps the most beautiful Yom Tov of the year.
  6. 36:43 Serach, who brought Yaakov the news that Yosef lived, took on the quality of Eliyahu, who is appointed over good news; she is thus 'two' and completes the seventy, hinting that redemption already walks with the Jews into galus.
  7. 39:00 The Gemara (Yocheved) and the Midrash (Serach) do not argue: Yocheved is the root of the redeemer Moshe, Serach carries Eliyahu who announces the geulah, and both say that galus begins with geulah.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 11:20 The Mashgiach laments that saying korbanos has become a light matter among yeshiva students, noting that the Shulchan Aruch treats the daily saying of the parshah of the tamid as an obligation and that it draws a Jew close to Hashem.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham Avinu, Binyamin, Eliyahu HaNavi, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Chama bar Chanina, Rashi, Serach bas Asher, the Maharal of Prague, Yaakov Avinu, Yocheved, Yosef HaTzaddik

Terms את"ב"ש, בשורה טובה, גאולה, גלות, מקרה, עצמות, פקידה, קרבנות, שבעים נפש

Report an error on this page