משה רבינו - “ותרא אותו כי טוב” - אור הגנוז שנולד מהול

Catalog entry: זמנים מהר"ל גבורת ה' no. ⁨4⁩ Pocket Guide p. 27 תשל"ד (1973–74) Yiddish 1 hr 12 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 1 hr 12 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Mashgiach's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

Building on the Maharal, the Mashgiach explains that Moshe Rabbeinu was born circumcised and filled the house with light because he was a 'separate form' with no share in evil, and from there he develops why holiness and blessing must always stay hidden.

The Mashgiach opens with the Midrash's readings of 'she saw that he was good' and the Maharal: the orlah is the power of physicality and evil, and Moshe, who had no connection to evil and came only to repair others, was born without it. Milah shows that man can improve on nature, as wheat becomes bread and grapes wine, which is why Malki-tzedek, born circumcised, brought Avraham bread and wine. The light hidden for the righteous lies under the orlah and is reached through toil, the work of Shovavim, until in Adar one sees that Torah is light. The Mashgiach then explains Moshe's name, the astrologers' error about water, and why Moshe married Tzipporah, a convert tied to the heavens like a bird. From Yisro's recognition of Sarah's modesty he concludes that holiness and blessing are always covered.

Topics: Moshe Rabbeinu · The Hidden Light · Bris Milah · Tznius

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Why Moshe was born circumcised listed in the guide

    The Mashgiach brings the Midrash's readings of 'she saw that he was good', and the Maharal's explanation that Moshe was born circumcised because the orlah is the power of evil and physicality, while Moshe came only to repair others.

  2. 4:12 Souls that come for others; the Apter Rav listed in the guide

    Every Jew's life work is to remove the orlah, which begins with the bris. Tzaddikim who come only for others are spared the risk; the Mashgiach tells how the Apter Rav remembered being a king and a kohen gadol in earlier lives.

  3. 8:10 Milah, bread and wine: man perfects nature listed in the guide

    Milah shows that man can improve on nature, as in the Midrash's answer about wheat and bread. The Mashgiach explains why bread and wine get higher brachos, and why Malki-tzedek, born circumcised, brought Avraham bread and wine.

  4. 15:03 The hidden light under the orlah listed in the guide

    The house filling with light means the goodness of serving Hashem. That light, the 'light sown for the tzaddik', is hidden under darkness and obstacles, and is reached only through hard work and self-sacrifice, the meaning of milah.

  5. 19:35 Shovavim, Terumah and Adar: Torah is light listed in the guide

    The weeks of Shovavim are the time to remove the orlah, today through toil in Torah and tefillah. After them comes Terumah, where the aron (from 'or') shines, and Adar, when one discovers that Torah is light and milah is joy.

  6. 26:51 Moshe and water: form against formlessness

    Following the Maharal, the Mashgiach explains that Moshe is a 'separate form' while water has no form, so water is his opposite. The astrologers saw that Israel's savior would be struck through water but did not understand that only his sin at Mei Merivah gave water power over him.

  7. 31:29 Why Moshe married a convert

    The Mashgiach asks why Moshe married Tzipporah, a convert, from whom a descendant became an idol priest. He answers that Moshe, equal to all of Israel, was not part of the six hundred thousand, so his match had to be someone else outside them, a convert.

  8. 35:01 Form and matter; Tzipporah the seventh

    Man is to woman as form to matter, and Moshe stands as form to all Israel; this explains why he was suspected regarding married women. The Torah notes that Tzipporah was the seventh daughter, since all sevenths are beloved, raising her to be Moshe's match.

  9. 39:24 Tzipporah: a bird tied to the heavens

    The Mashgiach explains that Tzipporah's name shows her nature: like a bird, which belongs to the air and the heavens, her body was refined and fit for Moshe, who belonged to the heavens. The Midrash says she purified her father's house like a bird.

  10. 43:12 Yisro served every idol: the all-inclusive power

    Yisro served every idol in the world because his soul was tied to all powers and could rest only with the power that includes all, Hashem. This matches Moshe, who includes all Israel; like Moshe, Yisro had seven names.

  11. 47:07 'Where is he?': Yisro recognizes Sarah's modesty

    The Midrash says Yisro's word 've'ayo' hinted that Moshe came from Sarah, of whom it says 'ayeh'. The Mashgiach explains: blessing rests only on what is hidden, and when Moshe did not come home to be thanked for rescuing the daughters, Yisro saw the modesty of Sarah's children.

  12. 51:25 The world as the Artist's camouflage

    As the Ba'al Shem Tov's students teach, all holiness is hidden: the whole earth is full of His glory yet He is not seen. Through the Gemara's 'there is no artist like our G-d', the Mashgiach compares the world to a painting and to camouflage that hides Hashem's trademark.

  13. 57:11 The holier, the more covered: Mishkan, Adar, head covering

    This world is a place where one must dig for G-dliness. The holier a thing, the more hidden: Purim and Adar, the Mishkan's coverings, the aron in the Holy of Holies, uncovered drinks, and the Jewish custom of covering the head, which the Mashgiach says has been weakened.

  14. 1:05:57 Hidden deeds and covered blessing

    Through Rebbe Reb Bunim on Lavan and Sarah, who did not come out for compliments, the Mashgiach shows that a Jew hides his mitzvos. Blessing is covered, like the challos at kiddush, and Adar is a hidden month until the reward stored for the righteous is revealed.

The shiur, written up

Why Moshe was born circumcised

0:10

The Mashgiach opens with the Midrash's readings of 'she saw that he was good': that he was named Tov or Toviah, and that he was born circumcised. The Maharal explains that the orlah is the power of evil and of this world's physicality, and Moshe had no connection to evil, so he came into the world without it. a,b,c

3:15

He adds that some souls do not come to repair themselves but only to repair others, and Moshe was such a soul.

Souls that come for others

4:43

Every Jew's life is a constant labor to remove the orlah and reveal the holiness beneath, and it begins with the bris. Tzaddikim who come only for others are not put at risk of failing. The Mashgiach tells that the Apter Rav remembered being a king and a kohen gadol in earlier lives, and once complained that he had always been someone and now was nothing.

Milah, bread and wine

8:54

Milah, the Mashgiach continues, shows that man can improve on what Hashem created. He brings the Midrash in which the questioner asked whose works are finer, and was answered that wheat must be ground and baked before it is bread. Hashem made the world lacking so that man could perfect it, and this is the meaning of the image of G-d. e

11:38

Usually changing a food lowers its brachah, but bread and wine are raised by it; the Bnei Yissaschar sees in them a sign of teshuvah. This is why Malki-tzedek, whom the Midrash says was born circumcised, brought Avraham bread and wine: he could not show from milah that a person can repair himself, so he showed it from bread and wine. f,g,h

The hidden light under the orlah

15:06

The house filling with light at Moshe's birth refers to the goodness of serving Hashem. Not everyone merits to feel it; first one must break physicality, and there is no easy path, as the Gemara says one must bear Torah like an ox under a yoke. b,j

17:50

The 'light sown for the tzaddik' lies hidden under darkness and obstacles, and removing them costs blood and self-sacrifice, which is the meaning of milah. k

Shovavim, Terumah and Adar

19:35

Moshe needed no such breaking. For everyone else, the Mashgiach explains, the six weeks of Shovavim are the time to remove the orlah of the heart. In earlier generations this was done through fasts; today it is done through Torah, tefillah and toil for emunah.

23:33

After Mishpatim comes Terumah, where the aron is named from 'or', light, as the Maharal brings, and Adar begins. Then one discovers that Torah is light, as the Gemara reads 'light' as Torah and 'gladness' as milah. Once the toil is done, milah is no longer pain but a feast of joy. m

Moshe and water

26:53

Returning to the Maharal, the Mashgiach explains Moshe's name, given for being drawn from the water. Moshe is a separate form, unique and unlike anyone else, while water has no form of its own; it is his opposite. c,n

28:56

The astrologers saw that Israel's savior would be struck through water, but erred: Moshe is above water. Only his sin at Mei Merivah gave water power over him. o,q

Why Moshe married a convert

31:42

The Mashgiach asks why Moshe married Tzipporah, a convert, when the Gemara contrasts Aharon's marriage with Moshe's, from whose line came an idol priest. He answers that Moshe was equal to all of Israel and above the six hundred thousand, so his match had to be one who also stood outside them, a convert. r

Form and matter; Tzipporah the seventh

35:01

A man to a woman is like form to matter, and Moshe stood as the form of all Israel. This, the Mashgiach says, explains why Chazal say Moshe was suspected regarding married women: he was felt to belong to every Jew, though the truth is that he stood above them.

38:24

The Torah notes that the priest of Midian had seven daughters because all sevenths are beloved; being the seventh raised Tzipporah to be Moshe's match. s,t

Tzipporah, a bird of the heavens

39:45

The Maharal explains why the Torah gives her name. Moshe, a 'man of G-d', lived as it were in heaven, so his match had to be far from earthiness. A bird does not creep on the ground but belongs to the air and the heavens, and her refined body shared that bond. The Midrash adds that she purified her father's house like a bird. c,v,w,y

Yisro and the all-inclusive power

43:18

Rashi brings that Yisro served every idol in the world. The Mashgiach explains that Moshe includes all Israel, and so his father-in-law also had to hold every power. One who serves one idol limits himself to one force; Yisro's soul was tied to all of them and wandered until he reached the power that includes all. Like Moshe, he had seven names. z

'Where is he?'

47:23

The Midrash says that when the daughters told Yisro of their rescuer, his word 'where is he' hinted that he was of Sarah's children, of whom it says 'where is Sarah'. The Maharal explains that blessing rests only on what is hidden. c,u,aa,ab

50:07

A hero who saved seven girls would usually expect thanks, but Moshe did not come. Yisro understood that this was a modest man, from the seed of Sarah who was in the tent. aa

The world as camouflage

51:36

The Ba'al Shem Tov's students teach that all holiness is hidden: the whole earth is full of His glory, yet He is not seen. The Gemara reads 'there is no rock like our G-d' as 'no artist like our G-d'. ac,ad

53:26

A painter makes plain canvas look like a landscape. Hashem made a world covered with camouflage, the pleasures of this world, so people mistake it for the real thing and do not see His trademark. R' Aharon of Karlin asked what eyes these are, that a small thing can cover them.

The holier, the more covered

57:18

The holier a thing, the Mashgiach says, the more it is hidden; this world is a place where one must dig for G-dliness. So Purim's miracle came under disguise, and Adar is a covered month.

59:59

The Mishkan had four layers of coverings, and the aron stood in the Holy of Holies where only the kohen gadol entered. The Shelah explains that even if uncovered drinks are not dangerous today, an inward person should cover them. ae

1:02:03

Jews cover their heads to honor, and add a tallis at davening. The Gemara tells that Rav Nachman bar Yitzchak's mother kept his head covered so he would not steal. The Mashgiach laments the shrinking yarmulke as a reversal of Jewish custom. af

Hidden deeds and covered blessing

1:05:57

Rebbe Reb Bunim asks why Lavan told Yaakov of Hashem's warning, 'beware of speaking with Yaakov', and answers that a coarse man who reaches a vision cannot hold it in. An honest Jew covers his mitzvos. Sarah too hid her good deeds and did not come out to be complimented on her meal. ag,ah

1:09:49

Blessing must be covered, so the challos are covered at kiddush. Adar is a covered month, until the reward stored for the righteous is revealed.

Sources

Torah

  1. a Shemos 2:2 text index In the write-up: 0:10
  2. f Bereishis 14:18 text index In the write-up: 11:38
  3. l Bereishis 22:12 18:30 text index
  4. n Shemos 2:10 text index In the write-up: 26:53
  5. p Devarim 34:10 29:47 text index
  6. q apparently Bamidbar 20:13 index In the write-up: 28:56
  7. s Shemos 2:16 text index In the write-up: 38:24
  8. u Shemos 2:20 text index In the write-up: 47:23
  9. w Bereishis 1:20 text index In the write-up: 39:45
  10. aa Bereishis 18:9 text index In the write-up: 47:23, 50:07
  11. ah Bereishis 31:29 text index In the write-up: 1:05:57

Nevi'im

  1. ac Yeshayahu 6:3 text index In the write-up: 51:36

Kesuvim

  1. i Koheles 9:7 12:50 text index
  2. k Tehillim 97:11 text index In the write-up: 17:50
  3. x Tehillim 8:9 41:33 text index
  4. y Tehillim 90:1 text index In the write-up: 39:45
  5. ag Mishlei 29:11 text index In the write-up: 1:05:57

Talmud Bavli

  1. j Avodah Zarah 5b text index In the write-up: 15:06
  2. m Megillah 16b text index In the write-up: 23:33
  3. o apparently Sotah 12b index In the write-up: 28:56
  4. r apparently Bava Basra 109b index In the write-up: 31:42
  5. ad Berachos 10a text index In the write-up: 51:36
  6. af apparently Shabbos 156b index In the write-up: 1:02:03

Midrash

  1. b Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 0:10, 15:06
  2. e apparently Midrash Tanchuma, Tazria 5 index In the write-up: 8:54
  3. g apparently Bereishis Rabbah 43:6 index In the write-up: 11:38
  4. t apparently Vayikra Rabbah 29:11 index In the write-up: 38:24
  5. v apparently Shemos Rabbah 1:32 index In the write-up: 39:45
  6. ab Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 47:23

Rishonim

  1. d apparently Moreh Nevuchim 3:49 2:23 index
  2. z Rashi on Shemos 18:11 text index In the write-up: 43:18

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. c Gevuras Hashem (place not identified) index In the write-up: 0:10, 26:53, 39:45, 47:23
  2. h Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 11:38
  3. ae Shelah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 59:59

Key points

  1. 1:50 According to the Maharal, Moshe was born circumcised because the orlah is the power of evil and physicality, and Moshe had no connection to evil.
  2. 3:15 Some souls do not come into the world to repair themselves but only to repair others, and Moshe was such a soul.
  3. 8:54 Milah shows that man can improve on what Hashem created, like wheat that becomes bread and grapes that become wine.
  4. 18:19 The hidden light for the righteous lies under the orlah and darkness, and one reaches it only through toil and self-sacrifice.
  5. 32:23 Moshe, a 'separate form' equal to all of Israel, could not find his match within Klal Yisrael and married a convert.
  6. 49:30 The holier a thing is, the more it must be covered: the world hides Hashem, and blessing rests only on what is hidden.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 1:31 Why was Moshe born circumcised, unlike everyone else?

    Answer: 1:50 The orlah is the power of evil and physicality that each person must cut away; Moshe had no connection to evil and came only to repair others.

  2. Question: 13:34 Why did Malki-tzedek bring Avraham bread and wine?

    Answer: 14:02 To show the broken Avraham that a person can repair himself; being born circumcised, he could not prove it from milah, so he proved it from bread and wine, which improve when changed.

  3. Question: 29:20 How did the astrologers know Israel's savior would be struck through water, and where did they err?

    Answer: 30:20 They understood that water is the opposite of Moshe, but not that Moshe is above water; only his sin at Mei Merivah left him open to it.

  4. Question: 32:23 Why did Moshe marry a convert?

    Answer: 32:53 Being equal to all Israel and not included in the six hundred thousand, his match had to come from outside them, a convert.

  5. Question: 39:45 Why does the Torah tell us her name was Tzipporah?

    Answer: 40:56 A bird belongs to the air and the heavens, not the ground; her refined body was tied to the heavens, fitting her for Moshe.

  6. Question: 48:21 How did Yisro sense that Moshe descended from Sarah?

    Answer: 50:39 Moshe did not come to be thanked after his heroic rescue; such modesty marks Sarah's children, of whom it says she was in the tent.

Stories

  1. 6:25 The Apter Rav remembers his earlier lives

    The Mashgiach relates that the Apter Rav used to tell that he remembered his earlier lives. In one generation he had been a king and in another a kohen gadol, and when he said the Yom Kippur avodah he would say the words describing the kohen gadol as one who remembered. Once he sat and complained to his people that he had always been someone, and now he was nothing.

    In the story: the Apter Rav (the Ohev Yisrael)

    told in 1 other shiur →

  2. 1:02:38 The child whose mother kept his head covered

    The Mashgiach recalls the Gemara about Rav Nachman bar Yitzchak: astrologers said he would be a thief, so his mother kept his head covered. The Mashgiach adds that every Jew covers his head, and she covered it even more so that he would not steal.

    In the story: Rav Nachman bar Yitzchak

Insights

  1. 2:03 Being born circumcised is not a mere wonder but a sign: the orlah expresses a share in evil and nature, and only one who came to the world solely to repair others could be born without it.
  2. 14:02 Malki-tzedek, himself born circumcised, could not prove from milah that man can improve on nature, so he made the point to Avraham with bread and wine, the two foods whose brachah rises when they are changed.
  3. 23:33 The aron is so named from 'or', light, yet Torah's light is felt only after the weeks of Shovavim have removed the orlah; then milah itself becomes a feast of joy rather than pain.
  4. 28:10 Water, which has no form of its own, is the opposite of Moshe, the pure form; the astrologers saw this but erred, since water ruled him only through the sin at Mei Merivah.
  5. 33:35 Moshe's marriage to a convert reflects his greatness: being above the six hundred thousand, his match had to be someone who also stood outside them.
  6. 44:35 Yisro's wandering through every idol was itself a sign of an all-inclusive soul, fitting him to be father-in-law to Moshe, who includes all Israel.
  7. 50:39 Yisro recognized Sarah's descendant precisely in Moshe not coming to collect thanks: modesty is the 'trademark' of Sarah's children, the source of blessing.

What the Mashgiach says to take from it

  1. 20:40 The Mashgiach says that today the tikkun of Shovavim is not fasts but toiling in Torah and tefillah and working on emunah.
  2. 1:05:38 The Mashgiach says a Jew should keep his mitzvos hidden, not seeking credit or showing them off, so they remain a private matter between him and Hashem.
  3. 1:04:16 The Mashgiach says the Jewish custom is to keep the head well covered, especially at davening, and laments the shrinking yarmulke.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Aharon HaKohen, Avraham Avinu, Lavan, Malki-Tzedek, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Aharon of Karlin (Rabbi Aharon HaGadol), Rav Nachman bar Yitzchak, Rebbe Reb Bunim of Peshischa, Sarah Imeinu, Shem, the Apter Rav (the Ohev Yisrael), the Baal Shem Tov, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Maharal of Prague, the Rambam, the Shelah HaKadosh, Tzipporah, Yaakov Avinu, Yisro

Terms מזל, מילה, נולד מהול, עבודת מתנה, ערלה, צניעות, שובבים, ששים ריבוא

Report an error on this page