הפך שאין בו שמן - יהודי בזמן הזה
Catalog entry: זמנים סעודת זאת חנוכה no. 3 Pocket Guide p. 20 תשמ"ח (1987–88) Yiddish 1 hr
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that every generation's new answer to how the first night of Chanukah was a miracle draws down a new salvation, and that for our empty, fallen generation the miracle is lit even from an empty flask with only a trace of oil left on its walls.
The Mashgiach opens with the repetition, in Parshas Beha'aloscha, of how the menorah was made as one beaten piece, and turns to the well-known question of what the miracle of the first night was. He brings the Tzvi LaTzaddik and the Yismach Yisroel, who answer that the flask found was empty, holding only drops left on its walls. Asking how a new answer can differ from all the Rishonim, he explains through the Mishnah in Niddah and the Arizal that each Torah view reflects its own heavenly heichal, and that each chacham's chiddush on the Chanukah miracle draws down a new salvation. Chanukah, he says, is above all for the lowly later generations, which are like empty ears of grain. Leaders shrink, yet Hashem can be served in every situation, and today a sigh of teshuvah counts as much as great fasts did once. In our generation there is no flask, only a trace of oil, and that suffices. On Zos Chanukah he explains the menorah as one piece, joining even its base, the souls of the end of days, to its lights.
Topics: The Miracle of Chanukah and the Greeks · Avodah of the Last Generation · Signs of the Generation Before Moshiach · Zos Chanukah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The menorah as one beaten piece, and the first-night question
The Mashgiach asks why Parshas Beha'aloscha repeats how the menorah was made, stressing that it is one beaten piece, unlike Terumah where broken pieces could be refined and reused. He then raises the question of what the miracle of the first night was and introduces the Tzvi LaTzaddik's new answer, which he says he would not have given had it not been the truth.
-
4:18 The empty flask: Tzvi LaTzaddik and Yismach Yisroel listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Tzvi LaTzaddik's answer: the flask with the Kohen Gadol's seal was empty, a flask once used for oil, and from the few drops left on it the light burned even on the first night. He notes the same answer in the Yismach Yisroel and asks why it is called a path the Rishonim did not take.
-
8:07 Many true answers: the heichalos above
The Mashgiach asks how many conflicting answers can all be true, and brings the Mishnah in Niddah where Rashi, Tosafos and the Rambam explain differently and the Chasam Sofer writes that reality matches only the Rambam. He answers with the Arizal and the Beis Yosef on the shape of the letters, and with the teaching that in Heaven there are many heichalos, each learning Torah according to its own middos.
-
13:15 Psak shapes reality; each answer brings a new salvation listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Rashi and Tosafos each spoke from their own root, while the Rambam as a posek matched this world, and that reality follows the psak. So every chacham who answers the Beis Yosef's question draws down a new kind of miracle in his generation. He adds that Chanukah is mainly for the later generations and for those too low to rise to Shabbos.
-
18:47 Falling generations and the empty ears of grain
The Mashgiach says that the lower the generation falls, the nearer Moshiach comes, citing 'nafla velo sosif' and the Chessed l'Avraham. Today's generations are like Pharaoh's empty ears of grain, and as Yosef brought plenty into the years of famine, Chanukah sweetens the season of Teves. He describes the emptiness of the individual compared with the avodah of earlier generations.
-
22:34 Shrinking leaders; serving Hashem in every situation
The Mashgiach explains that the navi was once called ro'eh because a look from the tzaddik was enough, later speech was needed, and today even speech does not help. He brings the Beis Aharon's Yiddish teaching that no creature can raise itself to serve G-d except as He wills, and the Ba'al Shem Tov's lesson that one serves Hashem in every circumstance, even with confusion during davening.
-
26:07 Stories: locked in, and a teaching that lasted three years Story
The Mashgiach tells of a man locked in a place where one may not think words of Torah, who knocked on the walls for hours so as not to think Torah, as his way of serving Hashem there. He then tells of a chassid who came to the Beis Aharon after three years because one short teaching had sustained him until then, and the Rebbe wrote it down.
-
29:34 Then and now: a sigh of teshuvah suffices
The Mashgiach tells, as heard from the Skverer Rebbe, of a boy who rested from learning by learning complex Mishnayos and Hilchos Kiddush HaChodesh, and did not know what playing meant; such children no longer grow today. He brings the Beis Aharon on 'dor ledor yeshabach' and the Arizal's answer about Rabbi Elazar ben Azaryah's fast: in small generations a sigh to Hashem counts as much.
-
35:14 No flask today, only a trace of oil listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that earlier generations still had a pure flask, often a tzaddik of the generation, but today there is not even that, only a little oil clinging to the walls. In our generation, he says, the chachamim revealed a new Chanukah miracle from an empty flask, and the seal that remains is the point of emunah of Avraham Avinu, whom the Midrash calls a Kohen Gadol, which no Greek can defile.
-
41:18 Zos Chanukah and the empty eighth light
The Mashgiach brings the Ba'al HaTanya that the lights reach even the 'feet', those who still long for Hashem. He explains that the eighth light stood empty all of Chanukah and is lit only now, that each night corresponds to one of the thirteen middos of mercy, and that the gathering in shul allows lighting even later.
-
44:59 The menorah as all of Klal Yisroel, one piece listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that on the eighth day Beha'aloscha is read because the menorah includes all of Klal Yisroel and the whole Torah. The seven shepherds shine at its top, and its base is the souls of the end of days, yet all is one beaten piece. He says this parsha speaks of the Chanukah menorah and so repeats that even the base is mikshah.
-
48:59 Gam yachad: gathering as one, and a prayer for the end
The Mashgiach explains the psalm said before lighting, 'Hinei mah tov… gam yachad': the Chanukah gathering is itself mikshah, and the good oil flows from the head to the beard, the thirteen middos. He closes with a prayer that the empty souls of the end of days be helped and the whole menorah be complete.
The shiur, written up
The menorah as one beaten piece, and the first-night question
The Mashgiach opens with the reading of Beha'aloscha, which repeats that the menorah was beaten from one piece of gold, down to its base and its flowers. In Terumah one could read that pieces broken off may be refined and joined again; here the Torah rules that out, and he asks why this must be said again in a parsha connected to Chanukah. a,b
The empty flask
The Tzvi LaTzaddik reads the Gemara's 'a flask of oil' precisely: it was an empty flask, once used for oil, which the Kohen Gadol had sealed so it would be known as his. Only a few drops clung to it, so even the first night's light was a miracle, and Chanukah is eight days because the miracle lasted all eight. d,e
Many true answers: the heichalos above
Yet the Rishonim themselves gave several answers; the Beis Yosef alone gives three, and only one can be the fact. The Mashgiach sharpens this with the Mishnah in Niddah on the form of the body: Rashi, Tosafos and the Rambam each explain it differently, and the Chasam Sofer writes that physicians see only the Rambam's reading fits reality. Did Rashi and Tosafos then err? c,g,h
He answers with the Arizal, whose form of a letter differs from the Beis Yosef's: the Arizal wrote with ruach hakodesh how it appears in higher worlds, while for mitzvos here one writes as the Beis Yosef does. In Heaven there are many heichalos, each learning Torah its own way, and each scholar draws his Torah from the heichal of his soul's root, as in 'elu va'elu'. c,i
Psak shapes reality; each answer brings a new salvation
So when Rashi and Tosafos dispute the Mishnah, each speaks from his root. The Rambam, as a posek, matched this physical world, and because the halachah was fixed like him, reality here follows him; had it been decided otherwise, the body's form would be otherwise. In other heichalos the psak differs, and there reality differs too. g
Likewise every Rishon and Acharon who answers the Beis Yosef's question answers according to his own reality, and his chiddush on the miracle draws down a new salvation in his generation. The Mashgiach adds that Chanukah is above all for the later generations and for those too low to rise to the holiness of Shabbos; it comes down to them. c
Falling generations and the empty ears of grain
Shrinking leaders; serving Hashem in every situation
The leaders also grow smaller. A navi was once called ro'eh, the Mashgiach explains, because the tzaddik needed only to look at a person for him to do teshuvah; later speech was needed, and today even speaking does not help. m
He brings a teaching the Beis Aharon wrote in Yiddish himself: which creature can raise itself to serve G-d? Only as He wills, when He wills and with what He wills. The Ba'al Shem Tov taught that Hashem must be served in every way: if two gentiles stand talking during one's davening, that too is from Heaven, and that is the avodah now. n
Two stories
The Mashgiach tells of a man locked for eight hours where one may not think Torah, who knocked on the walls to keep Torah out of his mind. Being placed there, he explains, was itself his service. One may think raising oneself means retreating to a forest with fine tzitzis; the Beis Aharon taught otherwise. n
Then and now: a sigh of teshuvah suffices
Today one word no longer lasts three years. The Mashgiach heard from the Skverer Rebbe of a boy, a gifted reckoner, called in when found playing, who said that from six he rested from learning with a complex Mishnah of measurements with the Tosfos Yom Tov, and at eleven with the Rambam's Hilchos Kiddush HaChodesh; he did not know what playing meant. Such children no longer grow. u
Yet the Beis Aharon read 'dor ledor yeshabach' to mean the world grows better, since avodah now is dearer to Hashem. The Arizal's students asked: if Rabbi Elazar ben Azaryah fasted until his teeth blackened over his cow, as the Yerushalmi relates, how can we repair ourselves? He answered that in small generations a groan to Hashem is just as good. Today a resolution to improve is great avodah; because it grows worse, it grows better. n,o,p
No flask today, only a trace of oil
Earlier generations still had inner purity, a flask not defiled; often the tzaddik of the generation was its flask of oil, given strength from Heaven to bring it back. Today there is not even that, among the many or among the great ones. What remains is an empty flask with a little oil clinging to its walls, a trace, and with that one can be helped.
In each generation the chachamim answered the Beis Yosef's question and a salvation was renewed. In our generation, after the war that began the true ikvesa d'meshicha, two chachamim revealed a new Chanukah miracle: no flask is needed, only a trace, so that even the empty ears not starve in the famine before Moshiach. c,d,f
Zos Chanukah and the empty eighth light
The Mashgiach brings the Ba'al HaTanya that the lights are lit until the 'feet' leave the market, so that even those on the level of feet, who long for Hashem, are reached. The eighth light stood empty all Chanukah and is lit only now.
The menorah as all of Klal Yisroel, one piece
On the eighth day Beha'aloscha is read, because the menorah includes all of Klal Yisroel and the whole Torah. At its top shine the seven shepherds, Avraham, Yitzchak, Yaakov, Moshe, Aharon, Yosef and David; its base, resting on the ground, is the souls of ikvesa d'meshicha, farthest from the lights. Yet they too are part of the menorah. a
Gam yachad, and a prayer for the end
The psalm said before lighting, 'Hinei mah tov… gam yachad', explains the Chanukah gathering: when Jews sit together it too works mikshah, binding low levels to high ones. 'Like the good oil on the head, flowing down to the beard': the good oil is the root of Chanukah, and the beard is the thirteen middos of mercy, matching the thirteen middos by which the Torah is expounded. t
The Mashgiach closes by noting that tonight the eighth light, empty seven nights, was lit too. He prays that the empty souls of the end of days, the base of the menorah, be helped, and that the whole menorah be complete with the redemption.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Talmud Yerushalmi
Midrash
- q Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 40:01
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
- c apparently Beis Yosef, Orach Chaim 670 index In the write-up: 8:07, 10:11, 15:14, 37:22
- d Tzvi LaTzaddik (place not identified) index In the write-up: 3:10, 5:02, 37:22
- h Chasam Sofer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 8:07
- k Chessed l'Avraham (place not identified) index In the write-up: 18:50
- n Beis Aharon (place not identified) index In the write-up: 24:23, 26:34, 28:05, 32:50
Other
Key points
- 5:16 The Tzvi LaTzaddik and the Yismach Yisroel answer that the flask the Chashmona'im found was empty, used before for oil, and the few drops left on it made even the first night a miracle.
- 12:06 Each Torah view comes from its own heichal in Heaven according to the root of the scholar's soul, and the psak decided below shapes reality in this world.
- 16:32 Every chacham's new answer to how the Chanukah miracle happened draws down a new salvation in his generation.
- 17:28 Chanukah is mainly for the later, lower generations, who are like empty ears of grain, and its light comes down to them.
- 24:35 Following the Beis Aharon and the Ba'al Shem Tov, Hashem can and must be served in every situation, with whatever one has.
- 34:32 In today's small generations a sigh of teshuvah or a resolution to improve is as great before Hashem as the hard avodah of earlier times.
- 45:03 The menorah, made as one beaten piece down to its base, shows that all of Klal Yisroel, even the souls of the end of days, are one with its shining lights.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 0:50 Why does Parshas Beha'aloscha repeat how the menorah was made, when Terumah already describes it?
Answer: 47:47 Because Beha'aloscha speaks of the Chanukah menorah, it must stress that everything down to the base is one beaten piece, so that even the lowest souls are one with the lights.
-
Question: 3:10 If there was oil for one night, what was the miracle of the first night?
Answer: 5:16 According to the Tzvi LaTzaddik and the Yismach Yisroel, the flask was empty, holding only a few drops on its walls, so even the first night was a miracle.
-
Question: 8:07 How can conflicting answers and explanations, such as Rashi, Tosafos and the Rambam on the Mishnah in Niddah, all be true?
Answer: 12:06 Each learns from his own heichal in Heaven according to his soul's root, and the psak decides which becomes the reality of this world.
-
Question: 34:10 If Rabbi Elazar ben Azaryah had to fast until his teeth blackened for so small a matter, how can we ever repair ourselves?
Answer: 34:30 The Arizal answered that in such small generations a sigh and cry to Hashem is just as good.
Stories
-
26:28 Locked in for eight hours
The Mashgiach tells of a man who was locked into a place where one may not think words of Torah and could not get out. To keep Torah thoughts out of his head he knocked and drummed on the walls, and he sat there eight hours. The Mashgiach asks how one serves Hashem in such a situation, and answers that being placed there is itself the avodah.
-
28:05 The chassid sustained three years by one teaching
A chassid came to the Beis Aharon after three years away, and the Rebbe asked why he had not come until now. He answered that three years earlier he had heard a short teaching from the Rebbe, and it had served him until now; only now did he feel he needed something new. The teaching was that no creature can raise itself to serve G-d except as He wills. The Rebbe said he had not said it quite so, but since it had sustained a chassid for three years it was important, and he wrote it down.
-
30:03 The boy who did not know what playing meant
The Mashgiach heard from the Skverer Rebbe about a child, a great reckoner, who was called in by his father when he was found playing. The child recounted that from the age of six, when he grew tired of learning, he rested by learning a complicated Mishnah of measurements with the Tosfos Yom Tov, and at eleven by going through the Rambam's Hilchos Kiddush HaChodesh. He said he did not know what playing meant. The Mashgiach adds that today such children no longer grow.
In the story: the Skverer Rebbe
Insights
- 3:48 The Mashgiach reads the Tzvi LaTzaddik's caution, that he would not have said an answer unknown to the Rishonim were it not the truth, as a sign that a new answer on Chanukah is itself a new revelation.
- 14:12 Because reality in this world follows the psak, as with the Rambam on the Mishnah in Niddah, each chacham's answer about the first night does not merely explain the past but brings a new kind of miracle into his own generation.
- 38:31 The answer of an empty flask with only a trace of oil was revealed specifically to our generation, because only such a miracle fits a generation that is itself an empty vessel.
- 40:01 The seal of the Kohen Gadol on the flask is the point of emunah inherited from Avraham Avinu, called a Kohen Gadol in the Midrash, which no Greek influence can defile even when the flask is empty.
- 32:50 The Mashgiach reads 'dor ledor yeshabach' with the Beis Aharon: precisely because generations grow worse, their small avodah is more precious, so the world grows better.
- 42:26 The eighth light, which stood empty all of Chanukah, is a picture of the empty souls of the end of days, and its lighting on Zos Chanukah shows that they too are lit.
- 47:26 Beha'aloscha repeats that the menorah is mikshah down to its base because it speaks of the Chanukah menorah, teaching that the lowest souls are not attached pieces but one piece with the lights above.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Rabbi Elazar ben Azaryah, Rabbi Yosef Karo (the Beis Yosef), Rashi, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Beis Aharon (Rabbi Aharon II of Karlin-Stolin), the Chasam Sofer, the Rambam, the Skverer Rebbe, the Tzvi LaTzaddik (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Bluzhov), the Yismach Yisrael of Alexander, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms היכל, זאת חנוכה, י"ג מדות הרחמים, עקבתא דמשיחא, פך השמן, שורש הנשמה