טעם על מה שמדליקין במנורה יחידה ולא בנרות נפרדות
Catalog entry: זמנים סעודת זאת חנוכה no. 5 Pocket Guide p. 20 תשנ"ב (1991–92) Yiddish 1 hr 1 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains why the Chanukah menorah is one piece with eight lamps: its lit and empty lamps hold both sides of the miracle, salvation for the Jews and downfall for the nations, until on Zos Chanukah all eight are full.
The Mashgiach opens with the passuk in Beha'aloscha about Aharon lighting the Menorah and its being 'mikshah', and asks why the Torah repeats this. He then asks why the minhag is one menorah of eight lamps rather than a separate lamp each night. From the Gemara's two versions of the Chanukah brachah he draws two sides of the miracle: salvation for Klal Yisrael and downfall of the nations, matching Beis Hillel's increasing and Beis Shammai's decreasing lights. Through the Arizal on the eight kings of Edom and the Bnei Yissaschar, he explains that the oil lasted because the 'long days' of Moshiach shone, so all eight lamps stand from the first night. The full lamps are the Jews and the empty ones the nations. A bracha cannot be made over empty vessels, so the menorah must be one piece. On Zos Chanukah, like Shemini Atzeres, all eight are full. He closes with a story about emunah and a brachah.
Topics: The Chanukah Lights · Zos Chanukah · Moshiach and the Days of Moshiach · Yisroel and the Nations
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Opening
-
20:56 Why one menorah and why mikshah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads the passuk about Aharon lighting the Menorah and asks why the Torah repeats that it is mikshah. He asks why the minhag is a single menorah of eight lamps, and discusses the Arizal's arrangement of the lights toward the door against the Gemara's requirement to light near the door, noting that the Shulchan Aruch HaRav differs here.
-
24:48 Two sides of the miracle listed in the guide
From the Gemara in Megillah on the two versions of the brachah, the Mashgiach shows that the miracle was both vengeance on the enemies and salvation for Israel, like the plagues in Egypt that were healing for the Jews. He ties the two sides to Beis Shammai's decreasing and Beis Hillel's increasing lights, then recalls Megillas Taanis on the twenty-fifth of Kislev.
-
28:25 Long days of Moshiach in eight lamps listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Arizal on the eight kings of Edom: after the long exile of Edom will come days of Moshiach that are long days. Following the Bnei Yissaschar, Chanukah prepares for Moshiach, and the oil lasted because a day of 'orech yamim' came. This is why a menorah of eight branches stands from the first night.
-
34:14 Aharon prepared the Chanukah menorah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why eight separate lamps would not suffice, and brings the Ramban that Aharon's Menorah alludes to Chanukah. Through his unchanging avodah Aharon drew down the light of Moshiach and prepared the Chashmonaim's menorah and ours, so 'ken asah' refers to the Chanukah menorah. He links this to Nachshon ben Aminadav, root of Moshiach.
-
37:24 Chanukah as a continuation of Sukkos listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Sfas Emes that Chanukah continues Sukkos, whose decreasing bulls were offered for the nations. So the Chanukah lights, too, give the nations some share, and this is Beis Shammai's decreasing order. Both views are correct, and the two versions of the brachah match them.
-
41:11 Full lamps and empty lamps listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the menorah is made of lit, full lamps and dark, empty ones: the full are Klal Yisrael, growing each night, and the empty are the nations, growing fewer. Like Egypt's darkness while the Jews had light, both are in the menorah. The seven dark lamps correspond to the seven kings of Edom of whom the Torah says 'vayamos'.
-
47:23 Zos Chanukah and why mikshah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach compares Zos Chanukah to Shemini Atzeres, which comes after seven days, when all eight strings of Moshiach's harp play. He then answers why the menorah must be mikshah: a brachah is not made over an empty vessel, and as one piece with a lit lamp the empty lamps are not an empty vessel. The empty lamps are as much a mitzvah as the full ones.
-
51:48 Tonight all eight lamps are full listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says that today, Zos Chanukah, the twenty-fifth of Kislev reaches completion: all eight lamps are full, none empty, and the nations have no part, like Shemini Atzeres. Aharon's avodah gave Jews a menorah holding darkness and light, and 'ken asah' speaks of every Jew's menorah. Tonight all eight lights are holy, a good sign.
-
56:30 Believing in the light of Moshiach
The Mashgiach says Jews look at the menorah and believe the light of Moshiach shines from it, and tells of a tzaddik who saw the ushpizin and the Kotzker who answered that believing they come is greater. He closes with a brachah for the geulah.
The shiur, written up
Why one menorah and why mikshah
The Mashgiach reads the passuk in Beha'aloscha about Aharon lighting the Menorah and asks why the Torah describes its making again, when Parshas Terumah already did, adding only that it is mikshah, beaten from one piece. He then asks why the minhag is one menorah of eight lamps rather than a new lamp each night, which might be more practical. a,b
Two sides of the miracle
The Gemara in Megillah gives two versions of the brachah: one praises Hashem for choosing Israel from all its enemies, the other as the G-d who saves. The Mashgiach explains that the miracle held both, vengeance on the enemies and salvation for Israel, as the Zohar says the plagues of Egypt were healing for the Jews. Beis Hillel's increasing lights reflect the salvation and Beis Shammai's decreasing lights the downfall of the nations; both are needed, and the question is only which leads. e,f,g
Long days of Moshiach in eight lamps
Recalling Megillas Taanis on the twenty-fifth of Kislev, the Mashgiach brings the Arizal on the eight kings of Edom: after the long exile of Edom, Hashem will repay Klal Yisrael, 'samcheinu kimos inisanu', and the days of Moshiach will be long days. h,i
Bnei Yissaschar writes that Chanukah prepares for the days of Moshiach, and lighting fulfills 'arachti ner limshichi'. The Mashgiach explains that the oil lasted because a day of 'orech yamim', long days, came then. So even on the first night a menorah of eight branches is set out, publicizing that one day stretched into eight. k,l
Aharon prepared the Chanukah menorah
Why not set out eight separate lamps? The Mashgiach brings the Ramban that Aharon's Menorah alludes to Chanukah. Praised for not changing, Aharon brought times without change and drew down the light of Moshiach, preparing the Chashmonaim's menorah and ours. 'Ken asah es hamenorah' therefore speaks of the Chanukah menorah. He adds that Nachshon ben Aminadav, root of Moshiach, accompanies all eight days. m,n
Chanukah as a continuation of Sukkos
The Sfas Emes says Chanukah continues Sukkos, whose decreasing bulls were offered for the nations. The Mashgiach concludes that the Chanukah lights also give the nations some share, and this is Beis Shammai's decreasing order. Both views are correct; the Biur Halacha notes there is no real psak, and the minhag follows Beis Hillel. The version 'who chose Israel' matches the decreasing side, 'the G-d who saves' the increasing side, and both are in the menorah. o,p
Full lamps and empty lamps
The menorah is one piece: on the first night one lamp burns and seven stay empty. It holds lit and dark lamps, as in Egypt the plague of darkness came with light for the Jews, which the Zohar calls healing for them. f
The full lamps are Klal Yisrael, growing like 'ohr zarua latzaddik'; the empty lamps are the nations, whose light is withheld. Each night the Jews grow brighter and the nations darker. The seven dark lamps match the seven kings of Edom of whom the Torah says 'and he died'; of the eighth it does not say so. q,r,s
Zos Chanukah and why mikshah
The Mashgiach reads 'zos chanukas hamizbe'ach' as the eighth day, Zos Chanukah. Following the Sfas Emes, as Shemini Atzeres follows seven days of Sukkos, Zos Chanukah follows seven days of Chanukah, when all eight strings of Moshiach's harp play. t,u,o
This answers mikshah: a brachah is not made over an empty vessel, as Jews clear empty vessels before bentching. Eight separate lamps would leave seven empty, but in one piece with a lit lamp they are not an empty vessel. The empty lamps are as much a mitzvah as the full: they publicize 'who chose Israel', and the full ones 'the G-d who saves'.
Tonight all eight lamps are full
Today, Zos Chanukah, the twenty-fifth of Kislev reaches completion: all eight lamps are full and the nations have no part, like Shemini Atzeres. Aharon's avodah gave every Jew a menorah holding darkness and light.
Believing in the light of Moshiach
The Mashgiach says Jews look at the menorah and believe the light of Moshiach shines from it, and that this belief is great. A tzaddik in dispute with the Kotzker sent word that he saw the ushpizin with his own eyes. The Kotzker answered that when Sukkos comes he believes they come, and believing, the Mashgiach says, is the greater level. He closes with a brachah for the geulah.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 21:34 The Mashgiach asks why the Torah repeats the making of the Menorah in Beha'aloscha, mentioning only that it is mikshah, one piece, and why Jews use one menorah of eight lamps instead of separate lamps.
- 25:21 The miracle has two sides, the downfall of the enemies and the salvation of Israel, reflected in the two versions of the brachah and in Beis Shammai's and Beis Hillel's ways of lighting.
- 31:58 The oil burned eight days because the 'long days' of Moshiach shone at that time, so a menorah of eight branches stands even on the first night to show that one day stretched into eight.
- 43:08 The lit lamps represent Klal Yisrael, growing brighter each night, and the dark empty lamps the nations, growing fewer.
- 49:25 The menorah must be one piece because a brachah is not made over empty vessels; as one piece with a lit lamp, its empty lamps are not an empty vessel.
- 48:13 Zos Chanukah is like Shemini Atzeres: all eight lamps are full, none empty, and the light of Moshiach is fully revealed.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 21:15 Why does the Torah repeat the making of the Menorah in Beha'aloscha, mentioning only that it is mikshah?
Answer: 36:01 Because the passuk speaks of the Chanukah menorah Aharon prepared, which must be one piece.
-
Question: 22:04 Why do Jews light one menorah of eight lamps rather than a separate lamp each night?
Answer: 32:34 To show from the first night that one day stretched to eight, the long days of Moshiach.
-
Question: 34:14 Would it not be enough to set out eight separate lamps and light one?
Answer: 49:25 No: a brachah is not made over empty vessels, and only as one piece are the empty lamps not an empty vessel.
Stories
-
57:13 Seeing the ushpizin or believing
A tzaddik who had a dispute with the Kotzker Rebbe sent him a message asking how he could dispute with him, when the seven ushpizin came to his sukkah and he saw them with his own eyes. The Kotzker answered through the same messenger that when Sukkos comes he believes the ushpizin come. The Mashgiach says believing is a greater level.
In the story: the Kotzker Rebbe (Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk), Rabbi Meir of Apta (the Ohr LaShamayim), the Apter Rav (the Ohev Yisrael)
Insights
- 35:40 The Mashgiach reads 'ken asah es hamenorah' in Beha'aloscha as speaking of the Chanukah menorah: Aharon's lighting prepared the Chashmonaim's menorah and every Jew's menorah, which is why the only detail repeated there is mikshah.
- 43:32 The menorah's unlit lamps are not idle: they stand for the nations and the 'decreasing' side of the miracle, so lighting with empty lamps is as much a mitzvah and pirsumei nisa as the full ones.
- 29:15 The Mashgiach explains the oil miracle as the 'long days' of Moshiach shining then: one day stretched to eight, like the long days that will follow the exile of Edom.
- 46:12 The seven dark lamps left on the first night correspond to the seven kings of Edom of whom the Torah says 'and he died'; of the eighth it does not say so.
- 49:26 The halachic requirement that a brachah not be made over empty vessels explains why the menorah must be one piece: joined to a lit lamp, the empty lamps are not an empty vessel.
- 48:07 Following the Sfas Emes that Chanukah continues Sukkos, Zos Chanukah is its Shemini Atzeres: the nations, who shared in the seven days, have no part, and all eight lamps are full and holy.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 56:54 The Mashgiach says Jews look at the menorah and believe that the light of Moshiach shines from it, and that such belief is a great thing.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Aharon HaKohen, Beis Hillel, Beis Shammai, Nachshon ben Aminadav, Rashi, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Kotzker Rebbe (Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Kotzk), the Ramban, the Sfas Emes
Terms אושפיזין, זאת חנוכה, מוסיף והולך, פרסומי ניסא, שמיני עצרת