צד א: לימוד מארבע מינים שצריכים להיות "פריש" לעבודת ה'.
Catalog entry: זמנים סוכות no. 3 Pocket Guide p. 17 תשמ"ט (1988–89) Yiddish 39 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach teaches from the four species that a Jew must stay fresh and alive in serving Hashem precisely in Tishrei, when all of nature withers, and connects this to the halachos of the lulav's top leaf and to the Yerushalayim of the sukkah and Shemini Atzeres.
The Mashgiach asks why the Torah repeats that Sukkos falls in the seventh month. In Nissan nature blossoms; in Tishrei it withers. Precisely then the Torah tells a Jew not to grow old and dry with nature but to keep a freshness in avodas Hashem all year. The esrog, which stays on its tree from year to year, comes first, and the other species are invalid when dry, since 'the dead do not praise Hashem'. He then explains the dispute between the Mechaber and the Rema over a split middle leaf of the lulav: is it one leaf among many, or the continuation of the spine? The top of the lulav, like the head of the year, must be alive. He brings Moshe's undimmed freshness and the joy of Sukkos, and after a niggun turns to Yerushalayim: the sukkah is Yerushalayim, and Shemini Atzeres spreads its peace to the whole world.
Topics: Sukkos · Renewal in Avodas Hashem
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Staying fresh when nature withers listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why the Torah repeats that Sukkos is in the seventh month, and contrasts Nissan's blossoming with Tishrei's withering: the Torah demands that a Jew stay fresh against nature. The esrog, which lives on its tree from year to year, comes first, and the other species must not be dry.
-
7:30 The split middle leaf: Mechaber and Rema listed in the guide
The Mashgiach lays out the dispute over a lulav whose 'twin' leaves are split: the Mechaber, following the Rambam, requires most leaves to be split, while the Rema invalidates it when the middle leaf alone is split. He explains that they differ over whether the top leaf is one leaf among many or the continuation of the spine, which is why 'most of it is like all of it' cannot apply to it.
-
14:50 The head of the lulav must be alive listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Rema that a dried middle leaf invalidates the lulav, since it is the spine, and explains that the head of the lulav corresponds to the head of the year, from Rosh Hashanah through Shemini Atzeres. The four species sing to Hashem, and song must be sung with freshness.
-
18:04 Moshe's freshness and the joy of Sukkos listed in the guide
The Mashgiach links the middle day of Sukkos to the attribute of netzach and to Moshe, whose eye never dimmed, and explains the special joy of Sukkos as freshness and alertness. He returns to the esrog that never dies and prays that Jews serve Hashem with this freshness.
-
26:59 Stopping to see where one stands
The Mashgiach speaks of Simchas Beis Hashoeva and of Yerushalayim, where people go about their day without stopping to think who walked there. He tells of a dwelling from the time of the Second Beis Hamikdash found near where he stayed, and says the sukkah is Yerushalayim: one must stop at its door and think whom one is entering to.
-
30:50 Shemini Atzeres: asking for the peace of Yerushalayim
The Mashgiach explains that Shemini Atzeres is a day that is entirely Yerushalayim and shalom, the ushpizin of Shlomo Hamelech, breaking through the walls of the sukkah to the whole world. Citing the Zohar that one may then ask what one wishes, he says the Levites' song at Simchas Beis Hashoeva prepares for it: one must know to ask for the peace of Yerushalayim.
-
34:18 Closing singing (Singing)
The shiur, written up
Staying fresh when nature withers
The Mashgiach asks why the Torah, having already said that Sukkos falls on the fifteenth of the seventh month, repeats 'in the seventh month you shall celebrate it' (Vayikra 23:39-41). In Nissan nature renews itself and blossoms. When the season of Tishrei comes, leaves fall, the ground dries out and everything that grew for six months dies off. a,c
Precisely then, the Mashgiach explains, the Torah tells a Jew not to wither with nature but to stay fresh, as if each day were his first, like starting a new masechta or a Yom Tov. That is why the esrog comes first: it alone does not dry out in winter but dwells on its tree from year to year (Sukkah 35a). The other species are invalid when dry, since 'the dead do not praise Hashem' (Yerushalmi). He adds that at davening that morning he felt some liveliness was missing. b,e,g
The split middle leaf
The Mashgiach turns to the halachah that a lulav whose 'twin' leaves are split is invalid. The Mechaber, following the Rambam, explains this as most of the leaves being split; the Rema brings Rishonim who invalidate it when the middle leaf alone is split, and the Magen Avraham explains the Mechaber by 'most of it is like all of it'. The Shulchan Aruch HaRav is strict both ways. i,j,k,l
Why, he asks, does 'most of it is like all of it' not apply to the middle leaf? He suggests the dispute is about what the top leaf is. For the Mechaber it is one leaf among many; for the Rema it continues the spine, like the stem of a hadas or aravah. Then even a fully split leaf is only a minority of the spine, so the rule cannot apply.
The head of the lulav must be alive
The Rema rules that if the middle leaf is dried out the lulav is invalid, since it is the spine, while dried tips elsewhere can be cut off. The Mashgiach explains that this is the head of the lulav, which must have life, just as the period from Rosh Hashanah to Shemini Atzeres is the head of the year. The four species sing to Hashem, and song must be fresh. m
Moshe's freshness and the joy of Sukkos
The Mashgiach links the middle day of Sukkos to the attribute of netzach, eternity that does not wither, and to Moshe Rabbeinu, whose eye did not dim (Devarim 34:7): he stayed fresh to his last day. o
The joy of Sukkos that the Rambam singles out is, he explains, freshness: at Simchas Beis Hashoeva they did not taste sleep (Sukkah 53a), because one who is joyous does not tire. So too the esrog stays alive on its tree while other plants die, and he prays that Jews serve Hashem with such freshness. p,q
Stopping to see where one stands
After a niggun the Mashgiach speaks of Yerushalayim, where people go about their business without stopping to think. He tells that near where he stayed that summer a dwelling from the Second Beis Hamikdash was uncovered, and asks who walked there. Dovid Hamelech says 'our feet stood' (Tehillim 122:2): pilgrims stopped to think where they were, for Yerushalayim below is joined to the one above (122:3). s,t
The sukkah, he says, is Yerushalayim, where the ushpizin sit. One should stop at its door and think whom one is entering to.
Asking for the peace of Yerushalayim
Shemini Atzeres, the Mashgiach explains, is a day entirely Yerushalayim, the city of shalom; the sukkah holds Yerushalayim within its walls, but Shemini Atzeres breaks through to the whole world. The Zohar says one may then ask what one wishes, so the Levites at Simchas Beis Hashoeva sang 'ask for the peace of Yerushalayim' (Tehillim 122:6) to prepare for it. y,v
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Talmud Yerushalmi
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
- i apparently Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 645:3 index In the write-up: 7:37
- j Rema (place not identified) index In the write-up: 7:37
- k Magen Avraham (place not identified) index In the write-up: 7:37
- l Shulchan Aruch HaRav (place not identified) index In the write-up: 7:37
- m Rema (place not identified) index In the write-up: 15:10
Key points
- 1:29 The Torah places Sukkos in Tishrei, when nature withers, to teach that a Jew must not dry out with nature but stay fresh in avodas Hashem.
- 4:25 The esrog lives on its tree from year to year, and the other species are invalid when dry, because the dead cannot praise Hashem.
- 5:23 The freshness of the seven days of Sukkos is meant to be carried through the entire year.
- 9:53 The Mechaber and the Rema differ on whether the lulav's top leaf is one leaf among many or a continuation of its spine.
- 15:45 The top of the lulav, like the head of the year from Rosh Hashanah to Shemini Atzeres, must be alive and fresh.
- 29:43 The sukkah is Yerushalayim, and Shemini Atzeres is a day that is entirely Yerushalayim, whose peace spreads to the whole world.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 0:38 Why does the Torah repeat that Sukkos is to be kept in the seventh month, when it already said so?
Answer: 2:20 Because Tishrei is when all of nature withers, and the Torah teaches that precisely then a Jew must not dry out with nature but stay fresh and alive in serving Hashem.
-
Question: 4:22 Why is the esrog the first of the species?
Answer: 4:25 Because it is the one exception in nature that does not dry out when winter comes; it dwells on its tree from year to year.
-
Question: 9:31 Why, according to the Rema, does a split middle leaf invalidate the lulav, when for the other leaves one would say 'most of it is like all of it'?
Answer: 11:53 Because for the Rema the top leaf is a continuation of the spine, so even a fully split leaf is only a minority of the spine; it is therefore judged as the spine, like the cut top of a hadas or aravah stem.
-
Question: 15:29 Why does a dried middle leaf invalidate the lulav, when dried tips of other leaves can be cut off?
Answer: 15:45 Because the top part is the head of the lulav, and the head must have life.
Stories
-
27:43 A house from the Second Beis Hamikdash era
The Mashgiach tells that he was in Yerushalayim that summer, and digging near where he stayed uncovered a dwelling from the time of the Second Beis Hamikdash. He wonders who lived there, perhaps even a navi, and says he does not know. He uses it to say that one must picture who walked in those places.
Insights
- 4:06 The Torah's repetition of 'in the seventh month' is a demand to go against nature: exactly when everything withers, a Jew is to take living species and stay fresh.
- 4:22 The esrog is taken first because it is the one exception in nature that does not dry out in winter; it can pass through all the seasons and remain alive.
- 9:53 The dispute between the Mechaber and the Rema over a split middle leaf rests on whether the top leaf is a separate leaf or a seamless continuation of the spine; if it is the spine, even a fully split leaf is still only a minority of the spine, so 'most of it is like all of it' does not apply.
- 15:55 The leaves of the lulav are the parts of the year, and its head is the head of the year, the period from Rosh Hashanah to Shemini Atzeres; if the head is dried out, the whole year suffers.
- 19:08 The special joy of Sukkos is freshness itself, the opposite of drowsiness, as shown by those who did not sleep at Simchas Beis Hashoeva.
- 31:35 The sukkah is a measure of Yerushalayim confined within its walls, while Shemini Atzeres is higher: its Yerushalayim breaks through the walls and spreads to the whole world.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 3:01 The Mashgiach says one's avodas Hashem should always be as fresh as on the first day, like starting a new masechta or the start of a Yom Tov.
- 5:26 He says one should take the freshness of the seven days of Sukkos into the whole year: freshness in Torah, in tefillah and in simcha.
- 29:55 He says that before entering the sukkah one should stop for a moment at its door and think into whose presence one is entering.
- 32:46 He says that when Shemini Atzeres comes one must pay attention and know what to ask for: the peace of Yerushalayim.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Malki-Tzedek, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen of Lublin, Rabbi Yosef Karo (the Beis Yosef), Shlomo HaMelech, the Magen Avraham, the Rambam, the Rema, Yaakov Avinu, Yitzchak Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms אושפיזין, אתרוג, גמר חתימה, שמחת בית השואבה, שמיני עצרת