"בחור שא נא עיניך" - להעלות הגשמיות (קליפות נוגה)
Catalog entry: זמנים ט"ו באב no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 33 תשל"ח (1977–78) Yiddish 54 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that the Three Weeks are a 'milah' that cuts away the three impure kelipos, while the week ending on the fifteenth of Av is the 'periah' that elevates kelipas nogah, the body, so that from then on a Jew must raise his eyes and serve Hashem even with his physical life.
The Mashgiach opens with the Mishnah that the fifteenth of Av was a great Yom Tov, when the girls said 'bachur, sa na einecha', and the Gemara's reasons for it. He then brings the four kelipos of Yechezkel's vision and the Bnei Yissaschar's explanation of milah: three layers are cut off, like the three wholly impure kelipos, while the fourth, periah, is kelipas nogah, which can be turned to good, and the Tanya says a Jewish body comes from nogah. A goy can serve Hashem only by renouncing, like an olah; a Jew can elevate his eating, like a shelamim. The same pattern appears in orlah and neta revai. The Three Weeks are the milah of the season, and the week up to the fifteenth of Av is the periah, so it is a day of joy and the start of preparing for Rosh Hashanah. A ben Torah must refine his eating and conduct, make brachos with feeling, and love his friends, which repairs the sinas chinam behind the Churban.
Topics: Tu B'Av and the Weeks of Nechamah · Serving Hashem in Physical Life · Kedushah and Kelipah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The Mishnah and the Gemara's reasons for the fifteenth of Av
The Mashgiach opens with the Mishnah that the fifteenth of Av and Yom Kippur were the greatest days of joy, and goes through the Gemara's reasons: the tribes were allowed to intermarry, the tribe of Binyamin was permitted again, and wood-cutting for the altar ended. He adds that from then the nights grow longer, so one must add learning at night.
-
3:30 Kelipas nogah and the layers of milah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the four kelipos of Yechezkel's vision, the last being nogah, and the Bnei Yissaschar's teaching that milah cuts three layers while periah turns the fourth to good. With the Tanya, that a Jewish body is from nogah, he explains why the descendants of Keturah have milah but not periah.
-
8:04 Olah and shelamim, Noach's bris and Avraham's listed in the guide
Through the Midrash on 'uri tzafon u'vo'i teiman' the Mashgiach contrasts the olah, burnt entirely, with the shelamim, which is eaten: a goy can serve only by renouncing, a Jew can elevate his eating. He shows the same pattern in the four words of the brachah against the slanderers, in the bris with Noach versus the bris with Avraham, and in orlah and neta revai.
-
12:20 The Three Weeks as milah, the fourth week as periah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that from Shiva Asar b'Tammuz there are really four weeks: the three until Tisha b'Av are the milah, cutting off with fasts and restrictions, and the week ending on the fifteenth of Av is the periah. Then, as at a bris, malchus shamayim is revealed, the preparation for Rosh Hashanah begins, and like metzitzah from the distant places, even the bodily powers are drawn close to Hashem.
-
18:14 From arur to baruch: the two halves of Av listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads 'tze'enah ur'enah' as the revelation of the crown on the fifteenth of Av, and brings the Kedushas Levi that Av stands for arur and baruch, the first half belonging to Esav and the second to Yaakov. He reconciles this with the milah of Tisha b'Av as two steps, and contrasts the fasts and restrictions of the Three Weeks with the wine, meat and shidduchim of the fifteenth of Av.
-
21:25 'Bachur, sa na einecha': lifting the eyes listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that a bachur who wants to learn normally guards his eyes, but on the fifteenth of Av he is told to lift them: even bodily matters must be done with elevation. Doing only what is permitted is not enough; a ben Torah must eat, dress and walk with refinement, as the Shulchan Aruch and the Rambam describe, until the body becomes like a window that lets the light through, which is what nogah means.
-
25:01 Neta revai: eating the Yerushalayim way listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that the fruit of the fourth year is not simply permitted; it must be brought to Yerushalayim and eaten there, which brings to yiras shamayim. Eating must be a 'Yerushalayim eating', with the refinement fitting a talmid chacham, and Torah and holy conduct each strengthen the other; the light of 'day' is the work of tzaddikim.
-
28:30 Brachos and eating as avodah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says that from the fifteenth of Av one must bring kedushah into the night and the body as well. Brachos on food are learned from neta revai eaten in Yerushalayim; the Rambam says brachos are to remember Hashem, so a brachah must not be swallowed, and every bite can be a thanks. Chassidim eat dressed with a jacket and hat because eating is an avodah, and in this way malchus shamayim is revealed even in physical things.
-
34:35 Ahavas chaverim repairs the Churban
The Mashgiach explains that the fifteenth of Av, after the Three Weeks, repairs the sinas chinam that destroyed the Beis HaMikdash. He reads the permission for the tribes to intermarry and the return of Binyamin as ahavas chaverim, brings Rebbe Reb Elimelech's tefillah to see only a friend's good, and explains tov v'hameitiv as a brachah said only with another. Success in Torah and tefillah comes from being together, as in the letter about Rebbe Reb Elimelech's circle.
-
41:58 Kedushah above depends on kedushah below
The Mashgiach praises the yeshiva as a place of growth and urges going beyond the letter of the law. He brings the Nefesh HaChaim that everything above follows what Jews do below: the angels can say kedushah only when Jews say it together. So every bachur must come to davening on time and begin together with everyone, receiving from and giving to one another, as the angels do.
-
47:59 The taste of a refined body and Shabbos Nachamu
The Mashgiach says that one who refines his body and holds together with friends tastes Gemara, Shabbos and tefillah, and tells of a tzaddik who said that a poritz's lavish pleasure cannot compare to what he feels saying Nishmas. Such a person can feel the consolation of 'nachamu nachamu ami' on Shabbos Nachamu; the Mashgiach closes with advice to learn before davening and a tefillah to pass, with the days of Av, from arur to baruch.
The shiur, written up
The Mishnah and the Gemara's reasons for the fifteenth of Av
The Mashgiach opens with the Mishnah in Taanis that Yisrael had no days of joy like the fifteenth of Av and Yom Kippur, when the girls would say 'bachur, sa na einecha'. He goes through the Gemara's reasons: the tribes were permitted to marry one another, Binyamin was permitted again, and the cutting of wood for the altar came to an end. a,c
Kelipas nogah and the layers of milah
The Mashgiach brings the four kelipos of Yechezkel's vision, the last being nogah, a shell that light shines through. The Bnei Yissaschar explains that milah cuts off three layers, like the three wholly impure kelipos, while periah, the fourth layer, is nogah and is turned to good. Since the Tanya says a Jewish body comes from nogah, the Mashgiach explains why the descendants of Keturah have milah but no periah. f,g,h
Olah and shelamim
Through the Midrash on 'uri tzafon u'vo'i teiman', the Mashgiach contrasts the olah, burnt entirely, with the shelamim, which is eaten: a goy can serve Hashem only by renouncing, while a Jew makes his table an altar. The same pattern appears in the bris with Noach compared with the bris with Avraham, and in orlah: three years of fruit are cut off, and the fourth year's fruit is holy. k,l,o,p,q
The Three Weeks as milah, the fourth week as periah
The Mashgiach explains that from Shiva Asar b'Tammuz there are really four weeks. The three weeks until Tisha b'Av are the milah of the season, cutting off through fasts and abstentions, and the week ending on the fifteenth of Av is the periah. Its joy is like the joy at a bris when the mohel finishes.
From arur to baruch
The Mashgiach brings the Kedushas Levi that Av stands for arur and baruch: the first half of the month belongs to Esav, the second to Yaakov. This fits the milah in two steps, finished on Tisha b'Av and completed on the fifteenth. Until then one fasts and holds back from meat and weddings; from the fifteenth one drinks wine, eats meat and makes shidduchim. t
'Bachur, sa na einecha'
A bachur who wants to learn normally guards his eyes, but on the fifteenth of Av he is told 'sa na einecha', lift your eyes: even bodily matters must be done with elevation. The Mashgiach says doing only what is permitted is not enough; a ben Torah must eat, dress and walk with refinement, until his body, like nogah, lets the light shine through. a
Neta revai: eating the Yerushalayim way
The fruit of the fourth year is not simply permitted; it must be brought to Yerushalayim and eaten there, which leads to yiras shamayim. So too, the Mashgiach says, eating must be a 'Yerushalayim eating', with the refinement of a talmid chacham as the Rambam describes, and Torah and holy conduct each strengthen the other. w
Brachos and eating as avodah
From the fifteenth of Av one must bring kedushah into the night and into the body as well. The Gemara learns brachos on food from neta revai eaten in Yerushalayim. The Rambam says the hundred brachos are so that one remembers Hashem, so a brachah must not be swallowed; one stops for a moment and thanks Him, and then every bite becomes a thanks. aa,ab
Ahavas chaverim repairs the Churban
After the Three Weeks, the Mashgiach says, comes a time of ahavas chaverim, to repair the sinas chinam that destroyed the Beis HaMikdash. The tribes had kept their inheritances apart, and on the fifteenth of Av they saw that this applied only to that generation. After pilegesh b'Givah they had cut off Binyamin, and on that day they sought ways to bring it close. Rebbe Reb Elimelech's tefillah asks to see only a friend's good. ae,d,e,af
Kedushah above depends on kedushah below
The Mashgiach calls the yeshiva a place where one grows and must go beyond the letter of the law. He brings the Nefesh HaChaim that everything above comes from what Jews do below: the angels say kedushah together only when Jews say it together. Like the angels, who receive permission from one another, every bachur must come to davening on time and begin with everyone, since each is part of the whole body, and then each kindles the other. aj,ai
The taste of a refined body
One who refines his body and holds together with friends, the Mashgiach says, tastes a blatt Gemara, Shabbos and tefillah. He tells of a poritz who spread thousands of sacks of costly sugar over a field to ride a sleigh in summer; a tzaddik said this pleasure has no relation to what he feels saying Nishmas. Such a person feels the comfort of 'nachamu nachamu ami' this Shabbos. The Mashgiach closes with advice to learn before davening, and a tefillah to pass from arur to baruch. am,t
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Targum
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
- g Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 3:36
- h Tanya (place not identified) index In the write-up: 3:36
- t Kedushas Levi (place not identified) index In the write-up: 19:35, 48:37
- u apparently Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 551 20:41 index
- v Shulchan Aruch (place not identified) 23:54 index
- ah Noam Elimelech (place not identified) index In the write-up: 39:02
- aj Nefesh HaChaim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 42:27
Tefillah and Piyut
- n Siddur (Shemoneh Esrei, V'lamalshinim) (place not identified) 9:20 index
- r Rosh Hashanah liturgy (V'ye'esayu) (place not identified) 16:13 index
- af Tefillah Kodem HaTefillah (Rebbe Reb Elimelech) (place not identified) index In the write-up: 34:49
- ai Siddur (Birchos Krias Shema) (place not identified) index In the write-up: 42:27
Key points
- 4:28 Following the Bnei Yissaschar, milah cuts off three layers that correspond to the three wholly impure kelipos, while periah elevates the fourth layer, which corresponds to kelipas nogah.
- 5:37 A Jew's body is from kelipas nogah and can be turned to good, so a Jew can serve Hashem with his bodily powers, which a goy cannot do.
- 13:12 The Three Weeks are the milah of the season, cutting off through fasts and restrictions, and the week up to the fifteenth of Av is its periah; the fifteenth of Av is the joy of a completed bris.
- 22:23 'Bachur, sa na einecha' teaches that from the fifteenth of Av one must lift one's eyes: it is not enough to avoid the forbidden, a ben Torah must bring refinement into his eating and conduct.
- 34:45 The fifteenth of Av repairs the sinas chinam that caused the Churban; it is a time of love among friends, seeing only another's good.
- 43:18 When Jews say kedushah and daven together below, the angels can say kedushah above, so each person must come on time and start together with the minyan.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 0:53 Why is the fifteenth of Av so great a Yom Tov?
Answer: 0:56 The Gemara gives several reasons: the tribes were permitted to intermarry, Binyamin was permitted again, and the cutting of wood for the altar was completed.
-
Question: 6:21 Why do the descendants of Keturah have milah but not periah?
Answer: 7:11 Because their bodies come from the three impure kelipos, which can only be cut off; periah elevates kelipas nogah, which only a Jewish body has.
-
Question: 19:33 How does the Kedushas Levi's division of Av at the fifteenth fit with the milah ending on Tisha b'Av?
Answer: 19:53 Both are true: the milah is finished on Tisha b'Av, which is one level, and the completion, the periah, comes on the fifteenth of Av; it goes level by level.
-
Question: 29:14 From where does the Gemara learn that one must make a brachah before eating?
Answer: 29:17 From neta revai, the fruit eaten in Yerushalayim with praise to Hashem, so brachos come from a 'Yerushalayim eating'.
-
Question: 31:49 Why do Chassidim eat dressed in a jacket and hat?
Answer: 32:03 Because eating is an avodah, a table before Hashem like an altar, and just as a kohen lacking his garments cannot serve, one eats with proper dress.
Stories
-
49:11 The poritz who sledded on sugar
The Mashgiach tells of a poritz who, on a hot summer day, wanted to ride a sleigh. At a time when sugar was very expensive, he had thousands of sacks of sugar spread over the field so that it looked like snow, and rode over it in his sleigh. People came to a tzaddik and spoke of the great pleasure a poritz can allow himself. The tzaddik answered: what connection does his pleasure have with the pleasure I feel when I say Nishmas kol chai?
In the story: the Beis Aharon (Rabbi Aharon II of Karlin-Stolin), Reb Eliyahu Shalom (the Mashgiach's father), Rabbi Moshe Leib of Sassov
-
41:01 Rebbe Reb Elimelech's circle as one family
The Mashgiach cites the letter printed at the end of Noam Elimelech, written by Reb Mendel, describing the love among Rebbe Reb Elimelech's circle. It was so great that one could not tell whose children were whose; they were like one large family. Each one accepted the other's children like his own, and felt his friend to be a brother.
In the story: Rebbe Elimelech of Lizhensk (the Noam Elimelech)
Insights
- 13:12 The season itself has a bris: the Three Weeks cut off like milah, and the week from Tisha b'Av to the fifteenth of Av is its periah, so the joy of the fifteenth of Av is like the celebration when the mohel finishes.
- 6:21 The descendants of Keturah have milah but not periah because their bodies come from the three impure kelipos and have no part in nogah; periah, which elevates, belongs only to Yisrael.
- 8:14 The olah, burnt entirely, is the service of the nations, which can only renounce; the shelamim, whose meat is eaten as if on the altar, is the service of Yisrael, who can turn eating itself into avodah.
- 11:28 Orlah and neta revai follow the same pattern as milah and periah: three years of fruit are cut off entirely, and the fourth year's fruit is elevated in Yerushalayim, which is also where the Gemara learns brachos on food.
- 15:26 Metzitzah draws blood from the distant places of the body; so too after the fifteenth of Av even the bodily powers, far from Hashem, are drawn close to Him, as a preparation for crowning Him on Rosh Hashanah.
- 38:46 Tov v'hameitiv may only be said when another shares the good; this is why the reason of tov v'hameitiv belongs to the fifteenth of Av, the day that repairs sinas chinam.
- 43:18 A bachur who comes late to davening affects the angels above, since their kedushah in unison depends on Jews below saying it together.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 22:42 The Mashgiach says it is not enough to avoid what is forbidden; a ben Torah must eat, dress and conduct himself with refinement and modesty.
- 29:39 He says a brachah must not be swallowed; one should stop for a moment, make it with kavanah and real gratitude, and keep thanking Hashem with each bite.
- 37:43 He urges seeing only a friend's good and not his faults, and not letting the yetzer hara divide friends.
- 45:32 He asks that everyone come to davening on time and begin together with the minyan, since each one is part of the whole body.
- 52:21 He advises learning Gemara before davening, as the sefarim of tzaddikim say, to refine the mind and the heart.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Esav, Moshe Rabbeinu, Noach, Rabbi Chaim of Volozhin, Rebbe Elimelech of Lizhensk (the Noam Elimelech), the daughters of Tzelofchad, the Rambam, Yaakov Avinu, Yechezkel HaNavi, Yehoshua bin Nun, Yeshayahu HaNavi
Terms אהבת חברים, חמשה עשר באב, ערלה, פריעה, קליפת נוגה, רבונו של עולם, שלש קליפות הטמאות, שנאת חנם