19 Kislev - 12 - R Moshe Wolfson
Catalog entry: זמנים י"ט כסלו no. 17 תשע"ה (2014–15) Yiddish 19 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the folder and file name.
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach contrasts the light of Shabbos, which lifts souls upward, with the light of Chanukah, which descends to the lowest places, and sees in this the path of the Chabad Rebbes.
The Mashgiach opens with the pairs Hashem set in the world, holiness against its opposite, light against darkness, day against night, inside against outside, and notes that the Chanukah light belongs to night, darkness and the public domain. He brings the Midrash of Yaakov's ladder, where Yaakov saw the angels of the kingdoms rise and fall and Edom rise without end, and asks how the Midrash can say Yaakov did not believe. He contrasts the Shabbos light, which raises a Jew upward, with the Chanukah light, which can kindle even the 'disqualified oils'. Yaakov is the aspect of Shabbos, but some souls bound to him cannot hold on to it; for their sake Yaakov asked that the Shechinah come down below ten, and this became Chanukah. The Mashgiach applies this to the Alter Rebbe, who raised his chassidim, and to the later Chabad Rebbes, who went down to the lowest places.
Topics: Chodesh Kislev and Yud-Tes Kislev · The Chanukah Lights · Kedushas Shabbos · The Shechinah and Galus HaShechinah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Chanukah's light and Yaakov's ladder
The Mashgiach lists the pairs of holiness and its opposite and shows that the Chanukah light belongs to night, darkness and the outside. He brings the Midrash of Yaakov's ladder and the angels of the kingdoms, and asks how the Midrash can say that Yaakov, the root of bitachon, did not believe.
-
5:41 The Shabbos light and the Chanukah light
The Mashgiach contrasts the Shabbos candle, inside and above ten, with the Chanukah candle, outside and below ten, and brings the Me'or Einayim that the oils not lit on Shabbos are lit on Chanukah. He explains that Yaakov is the aspect of Shabbos, the trunk from which the twelve tribes branch out, and that some fallen souls cannot hold on to Shabbos to rise with it.
-
9:08 Yaakov's plea brings down the Shechinah
The Mashgiach explains that Yaakov saw the souls bound to him that had fallen to the side of Esav and could not believe, and that this is the meaning of the Midrash's 'he did not believe'. Yaakov refused to go up alone and asked that the Shechinah come down below ten; 'Hashem stood over him', and Hashem promised there would be a Chanukah.
-
13:07 The Alter Rebbe's Shabbos and Chabad's Chanukah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says the Alter Rebbe raised his chassidim to lofty levels, and tells of Reb Avraham Zuskin, whom he saw davening on Shabbos with tears for hours. He then says the later Chabad Rebbes did the opposite, going down with the Chanukah light through shluchim to Jews with no Jewish education, and closes with a tefillah that Jews spread chassidus and be redeemed.
The shiur, written up
Chanukah's light and Yaakov's ladder
The Mashgiach opens with the pairs Hashem set in the world: holiness and its opposite, light and darkness, inside and outside, day and night. Unlike most mitzvos, the Chanukah light belongs to night, darkness and the public domain, and he cites Toras Menachem on how it differs from the Menorah of the Beis HaMikdash. a
The Shabbos light and the Chanukah light
Yaakov's plea brings down the Shechinah
Yaakov saw that some of his own souls had fallen to Esav's side, souls of 'they did not believe'. This, the Mashgiach explains, is the Midrash's meaning; Yaakov himself certainly believed. Though the Gemara in Sukkah says the Shechinah never descended below ten, Yaakov refused to go up without them and asked that it come down to them. l
The Alter Rebbe's Shabbos and Chabad's Chanukah
The Alter Rebbe raised his chassidim to lofty levels found in Tanya, Likkutei Torah and Torah Or. The Mashgiach recalls Reb Avraham Zuskin in Williamsburg, who began davening on Shabbos at nine and was still davening, in tears, when people returned at four for Mincha. p
The later Chabad Rebbes did the opposite: with the Chanukah light they went down, sending shluchim to Jews who know nothing of Shabbos, to public school children and colleges, to lift them up to Shabbos, just as Chanukah candles are lit before Shabbos candles. He closes with a tefillah that Jews spread chassidus and be redeemed.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 1:46 The Chanukah light belongs to the side of night, darkness and the public domain, unlike the Menorah of the Beis HaMikdash.
- 7:13 Shabbos is the highest point in time and lifts a Jew upward, but some fallen souls cannot hold on to it.
- 6:21 What Shabbos cannot kindle, Chanukah can: the 'disqualified oils' not lit on Shabbos are lit on Chanukah.
- 11:49 For the sake of the souls who cannot rise with him, Yaakov asked that the Shechinah come down to them, below ten, and from this came Chanukah.
- 13:13 The Alter Rebbe lifted his chassidim upward, like Shabbos, while the later Chabad Rebbes went down with the Chanukah light to the lowest places to raise Jews.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 4:31 How can the Midrash say that Yaakov was afraid and did not believe, when Yaakov is the root of the bitachon of Jews?
Answer: 11:24 It refers to the souls included in Yaakov that do not believe; Yaakov himself certainly believed.
-
Question: 6:55 If Chanukah can kindle what Shabbos cannot, is Chanukah greater than Shabbos?
Answer: 7:12 No; Shabbos is the highest thing in time and lifts souls upward, but the fallen souls who cannot hold on to it are reached by the light of Chanukah.
Stories
-
14:14 Reb Avraham Zuskin's Shabbos davening
The Mashgiach recounts that as a young man he knew a Lubavitcher chossid in Williamsburg, Reb Avraham Zuskin, an oved Hashem. On Shabbos he davened in the Stoliner shul on Rodney Street, coming at about nine o'clock to start davening. When people came back at four on a short Shabbos for Mincha, he was still sitting and davening, with tears flowing from his eyes. The Mashgiach says he was in heaven, rising with the Shabbos of the Ba'al HaTanya.
In the story: Reb Avraham Zuskin, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Rebbe Rashab (Rabbi Sholom Dovber of Lubavitch)
Insights
- 5:06 The Mashgiach reads the Midrash that Yaakov 'did not believe' as referring not to Yaakov himself, the root of bitachon, but to the faithless souls included in him.
- 6:21 The Me'or Einayim's lesson that disqualified oils are lit on Chanukah is applied to fallen souls: a Jew whom Shabbos cannot kindle, Chanukah can.
- 7:24 Yaakov is the trunk of the tree and Shabbos, the middle blessing, while the twelve tribes correspond to the twelve middle blessings of the weekday prayer.
- 11:57 Chanukah is the answer to Yaakov's plea: instead of the souls rising with Shabbos, the Shechinah comes down below ten to the place of darkness.
- 13:40 The Alter Rebbe's path is that of Shabbos, raising chassidim upward, while the later Chabad Rebbes took the path of Chanukah, going down to the lowest to bring them up to Shabbos.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Esav, Rabbi Menachem Nachum of Chernobyl (the Me'or Einayim), Reb Avraham Zuskin, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), Yaakov Avinu
Terms למטה מעשרה, נר חנוכה, סמאל, פסולת, רשות היחיד, רשות הרבים, שליחות