אם אתם תמחו עמלק מלבכם' אני אמחה אותו מעולם (התעוררות לפורים)
Catalog entry: זמנים זכור no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 22 תשל"ז (1976–77) Yiddish 1 hr 11 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that Amalek's true root is the yetzer hara in the Jewish heart, which attacks both kedushas habris and emunah, and that Purim, the day of milah and tefillin, is the time to erase it with an emunah above the intellect.
The Mashgiach opens with the mitzvah of erasing Amalek and asks how it can be fulfilled when nobody knows who Amalek is. Following the Alshich, he explains that every nation has a heavenly prince, but Amalek's prince is the yetzer hara itself, living in Jewish hearts; only the Jews can defeat it through teshuvah, and then physical Amalek falls on its own. Amalek attacks both kedushas habris and emunah, which are one, since emunah is Avraham's inheritance through the bris. Purim, a weekday Yom Tov of hidden miracles, is the time of clear emunah. Through the Gemara's teaching that sasson is milah and yikar is tefillin, he explains tefillin as emunah above the intellect, black in galus. After a hesped for a tzaddik who passed away that week, he calls our era the low point of time and Purim the preparation for the final Shabbos.
Topics: Doubts in Emunah and Amalek · The Yetzer Hara and Nisyonos · Shmiras HaBris · Purim
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 A mitzvah no one seems able to fulfill listed in the guide
The Mashgiach opens with Parshas Zachor and asks why the Torah gave the mitzvah of erasing Amalek, when Shaul did not fulfill it and since Sancheiriv mixed up the nations nobody knows who Amalek is. He reviews the pesukim about Amalek: how he cooled the Jews on the way, his attack on milah, and the war against him in every generation.
-
4:07 The Alshich: Amalek's prince is the yetzer hara listed in the guide
Bringing the Alshich, the Mashgiach explains that every nation falls when Hashem topples its heavenly prince, but Amalek's prince is the yetzer hara inside Jewish hearts, which Hashem leaves to the Jews because of free choice. When they erase it through teshuvah, physical Amalek falls, which answers his opening question and the two pesukim of 'I will erase' and 'you shall erase'.
-
12:01 Amalek: blemish of the bris and doubt in emunah
From the pesukim the Mashgiach shows that Amalek concentrates on two things, impure thoughts and attacking milah, and doubt in emunah, as Amalek equals safek in gematria. He explains that both are one, since the clear emunah of Jews is Avraham Avinu's inheritance through the bris, and guarding the bris keeps that emunah clear.
-
17:22 Purim: emunah in hiddenness, like Yom Kippur
The Mashgiach explains that Adar is the month for strengthening emunah: the Megillah has no open miracles and no Name of Hashem, yet one makes a brachah on its miracles, an emunah greater than that of Yetzias Mitzrayim. Purim was deliberately kept a weekday Yom Tov, and Yom Kippur, the day Avraham had his bris, is only 'like Purim'; he then brings the Gemara's 'orah, simchah, sasson and yikar'.
-
23:54 Why milah and tefillin, and where kefirah comes from
The Mashgiach asks why the joy of Purim is milah and its glory is tefillin, and why intelligent people deny Hashem when the world shows Him so clearly. From Chazal's 'acharei levavchem, this is minus' he explains that heresy comes from the heart: a person who wants to justify a weakness or a desire invents a world-view that permits it, and so a blemish of the bris leads to kefirah.
-
29:57 Tefillin as the keser above the body
Through Pesach Eliyahu the Mashgiach explains that the ten maamaros correspond to parts of the body, but keser is the tefillin, worn on the body yet not part of it, because Elokus is beyond even the mind and is reached only through emunah and kabbalas ol malchus Shamayim. Black tefillin and covered eyes at Shema express this; on Shabbos the clarity shines in and Shabbos itself is the tefillin, and Purim joins milah with tefillin.
-
38:05 Yikar in Targum: the glory of emunah in galus
The Mashgiach asks why 'yikar' is an Aramaic, Targum word, and explains that Targum stands for galus and darkness, as the Chasam Sofer says about shnayim mikra v'echad targum. The tefillin of Purim are black Targum-tefillin, and the glory of Jews who believe and say Shema in the darkness of galus is a nachas ruach to Hashem greater than in the time of the Beis HaMikdash, as Hashem's own tefillin praise Klal Yisrael.
-
44:29 The heretic's demand for proof and the orlah
The Mashgiach describes the heretic who refuses to accept anything his mind cannot grasp, and says the true reason is that he is not careful with milah. From the Ibn Ezra and Rambam on the orlah, an extra part on the body that must be removed, he answers that just as the body has something not belonging to it, it can carry something above it; this is the bond between sasson and yikar, and on Purim one surrenders one's daas to Hashem.
-
50:23 Hesped: a tzaddik of yesod Story
The Mashgiach speaks of a tzaddik who passed away that week, the Gerer Rebbe, whose avodah was kedushah beyond the letter of the law, and tells how as a ten-year-old he leapt from a window rather than be alone with a disguised woman. Against those who mock such care as excessive, he brings Rashi that Avraham Avinu did not know how Sarah looked, because as the root of milah he had to pass on that guarding to his children.
-
56:05 The tzaddik's life left to the living
The Mashgiach says earlier tzaddikim felt the darkness when a great tzaddik passed away, while today we do not. He brings the letter in Tanya on the passing of Rabbi Mendel of Vitebsk, that a tzaddik 'leaves life to all the living', and the Midrash that Yosef died but his Elokus remained, and connects it to Zayin Adar, when Moshe both died and was born.
-
59:37 Mitzrayim of time: the era before Moshiach
The Mashgiach asks why Avraham's episode with Sarah happened precisely in Mitzrayim, and explains that Mitzrayim is the 'ervas ha'aretz' where Amalek's klipah is strongest. Since place, time and soul parallel each other, there is also an 'ervas hazman', the era before Moshiach of heresy and immorality, in which we live; the last pasuk of Shema and Purim, the last month of the year, give strength for it, and the Megillah is spread out to spread emunah.
-
1:05:53 Purim as tefillin and preparation for Shabbos listed in the guide
The Mashgiach concludes that Purim is the day of black tefillin, emunah above daas in the drunkenness of galus, until the Shabbos of Moshiach when the grasp will be white. Like the sixth day that prepares for Shabbos, Purim prepares for it, and on Shabbos the Kedushah of Keser replaces tefillin; Parshas Zachor begins the preparation with teshuvah and not forgetting Hashem.
The shiur, written up
A mitzvah no one seems able to fulfill
The Alshich: Amalek's prince is the yetzer hara
The Mashgiach brings the Alshich on the end of Ki Seitzei. On the passuk that Hashem will punish the host of heaven and then the kings of the earth, the Alshich explains that every nation has a prince in heaven, and when that prince falls the nation below falls with it, as when the Jews saw the prince of Mitzrayim and knew the Egyptians would follow. e,f,g
Amalek's prince is different: he is the Satan, the yetzer hara, who enters Jewish hearts. Since the Torah gave man free choice between life and death, Hashem does not abolish him; the Jews must fight him themselves, with yiras Shamayim, which is why Amalek attacked those who 'did not fear G-d'. When they defeat him, Amalek's prince is nullified. c,h
This explains why Beshalach says 'I will erase' while Ki Seitzei says 'you shall erase'. The Jews erase Amalek from their hearts through teshuvah, and then Hashem makes the physical Amalek fall, the reverse of other nations. So the mitzvah is fulfilled without knowing who Amalek is, answering his opening question. i
Amalek: blemish of the bris and doubt in emunah
From the parsha the Mashgiach shows that Amalek concentrates on two things: bringing impure thoughts and attacking milah, and casting doubt in emunah. Amalek came right after the Jews asked whether Hashem is among them, and the sefarim note that Amalek equals 'safek', doubt, in gematria. The hands of Moshe that fought him were 'emunah'. j,k
Both are one thing. Avraham Avinu, the first of believers, left emunah as an inheritance through his bris; one who guards kedushas habris keeps his emunah clear, and each person's doubts match how far he is careful.
Purim: emunah in hiddenness
The decisive war against Amalek came in Adar, so Adar is the month to strengthen emunah. The Megillah shows no open miracles and no Name of Hashem, yet one makes a brachah on its miracles; believing that everything is a miracle even when it comes naturally is greater emunah than that of Yetzias Mitzrayim.
Purim was not accepted as a Yom Tov with forbidden labor; it stays a weekday so that clarity of emunah shines into the hiddenness. The Tikkunim call Yom Kippurim 'like Purim'. Yom Kippur repairs milah, since Avraham had his bris on that very day, and Purim draws Avraham's kedushah through Mordechai and Esther. Then he brings the Gemara: orah is Torah, simchah Yom Tov, sasson milah, yikar tefillin. l,m,n,o
Why milah and tefillin, and where kefirah comes from
Orah and simchah are understood, since on Purim the Torah was accepted willingly. But why should Purim's joy be milah and its glory tefillin? And the world shows Hashem so clearly, as the Rambam says one comes to know Him by contemplating creation; how can people with a high IQ deny Him? q
Chazal teach that 'after your hearts' means heresy. Heresy comes from the heart, because a person wants to be right; he blames his weakness on the hammer or the yeshivah. So too the Jews served idols only to permit forbidden relations: one who stumbles builds a philosophy that excuses him, and a blemish of the bris brings kefirah. r,s
Tefillin as the keser above the body
The Mashgiach turns to Pesach Eliyahu, said before davening: Hashem created the world with ten maamaros, which match parts of the body, chessed the right arm, gevurah the left, chochmah and binah the brain. Keser is the tefillin, which are on the body but not part of it. t
The reason is that the middos and even the mind belong to the body, but Elokus is beyond the mind; it is grasped only through emunah, Shema and kabbalas ol malchus Shamayim. So one covers the eyes and wears black tefillin, black meaning no grasp, and accepts Hashem's kingship.
On Shabbos the clarity shines in and Shabbos itself is the tefillin. Milah and tefillin are connected: one who guards the bris and is free of Amalek's doubt merits pure emunah, and Purim is the time for it.
Yikar in Targum: the glory of emunah in galus
The Mashgiach asks why the verse uses 'yikar', a Targum word, among Hebrew words. Targum is galus, the language of the nations, where one does not see clearly. The Chasam Sofer explains that one reads the parsha with Targum before Shabbos to feel the Torah's light even through galus darkness. p,u
Weekday tefillin are pure emunah without grasp, so they are black, and the yikar of Purim is these Targum tefillin. Jews who cry out Shema in deepest darkness give Hashem a nachas ruach He lacked even in the Beis HaMikdash, as His own tefillin praise Klal Yisrael. In this today's generations are greater than earlier ones, despite Amalek's might in their day. v
The heretic's demand for proof and the orlah
The Mashgiach describes heretics who demand logical proof and refuse to accept what their brains cannot grasp. The real cause, he says, is that they are not careful with milah. Their real complaint is that tefillin are above the mind and not part of the body.
Hesped: a tzaddik of yesod
Without giving a hesped, the Mashgiach notes that a Jew passed away that week, the Gerer Rebbe, the 'Yosef HaTzaddik' of his generation, whose avodah was kedushah beyond the letter of the law; at his birth the Sfas Emes said the middah of yesod was born. As a ten-year-old, when his disguised sister entered his room on Purim, he jumped from a window two floors down.
The tzaddik's life left to the living
Earlier tzaddikim felt darkness descend when a great tzaddik passed away; we no longer feel it. The Mashgiach brings the Ba'al HaTanya's letter on Rabbi Mendel of Vitebsk: a tzaddik 'leaves life to all the living', and his disciples can still cleave to him. The Midrash says that Yosef died but the Elokus he planted remained. On Zayin Adar Moshe died and was born, which Haman did not know, and a tzaddik's kedushah stays in the air for whoever exerts himself. ab,ac,ad
Mitzrayim of time: the era before Moshiach
Why did Avraham's episode happen in Mitzrayim? The world, like man, has limbs, and Mitzrayim is the 'ervas ha'aretz', as Yosef told his brothers, where Amalek's klipah is strongest. Since place, time and soul correspond, there is also an 'ervas hazman', the era before Moshiach, when heresy and immorality spread together; we live in that Mitzrayim of time. af,ag
Purim as tefillin and preparation for Shabbos
The Mashgiach concludes that Purim is the day of black tefillin, kabbalas ol even in the hiddenness, the 'drunkenness' of galus, above daas. From Purim one draws emunah for the whole time of darkness, until the Shabbos of Moshiach, when the grasp will be white. aj
As the sixth day prepares for Shabbos, Purim prepares for it; on Shabbos one says Shema with the crown of Kedushas Keser instead of tefillin. Thirty days before Pesach the preparation for emunah begins, and Parshas Zachor brings teshuvah, removing what covers the bris and the emunah, and not forgetting Hashem. ak
Sources
Torah
- a Devarim 25:17-19 text index In the write-up: 1:05
- c Devarim 25:18 text index In the write-up: 2:41, 5:22
- d Shemos 17:16 text index In the write-up: 2:41
- h apparently Devarim 30:15 index In the write-up: 5:22
- i Shemos 17:14 text index In the write-up: 9:41
- j Shemos 17:7-8 text index In the write-up: 12:09
- k Shemos 17:12 text index In the write-up: 12:09
- n Bereishis 17:26 text index In the write-up: 19:41
- af Bereishis 42:9 text index In the write-up: 59:41
- ah Bamidbar 15:41 text index In the write-up: 1:03:48
- ak Shemos 16:5 text index In the write-up: 1:08:35
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
- b apparently Berachos 28a index In the write-up: 1:05
- l apparently Megillah 5b index In the write-up: 19:41
- o Megillah 16b text index In the write-up: 19:41
- r apparently Berachos 12b index In the write-up: 25:54
- s apparently Sanhedrin 63b index In the write-up: 25:54
- v Berachos 6a text index In the write-up: 40:34
- y apparently Megillah 7b index In the write-up: 48:26
- ad apparently Megillah 13b index In the write-up: 56:23
- ae apparently Chullin 7b 58:59 index
- ag apparently Sotah 49b index In the write-up: 59:41
Midrash
- ac Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 56:23
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
- g apparently Rashi on Shemos 14:10 index In the write-up: 4:07
- q apparently Rambam, Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah 2:2 index In the write-up: 23:56
- w Ibn Ezra (place not identified) index In the write-up: 46:35
- x apparently Moreh Nevuchim 3:49 index In the write-up: 46:35
- z Rashi on Bereishis 12:11 text index In the write-up: 53:18
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 5:22 Amalek's heavenly prince is the yetzer hara in the Jewish heart, so the war against Amalek must be fought by the Jews themselves, with yiras Shamayim and teshuvah.
- 9:59 When the Jews erase Amalek from their hearts, Hashem erases the physical Amalek, which answers how the mitzvah can be fulfilled without knowing who Amalek is.
- 14:22 Amalek attacks kedushas habris and emunah, and the two are one, since emunah is Avraham Avinu's inheritance that comes through the bris.
- 17:45 Purim, a weekday Yom Tov whose miracles are hidden, is the month and day for strengthening clear emunah.
- 34:20 Tefillin, the 'yikar' of Purim, stand for emunah above the intellect, black because in galus there is no grasp, and this emunah in darkness is the glory of Klal Yisrael.
- 1:01:56 Our generation lives in the 'ervas hazman', the lowest point of time, and Purim gives the strength to hold on to emunah until the Shabbos of Moshiach.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:37 How could the Torah give a mitzvah to erase Amalek that Shaul did not fulfill and that cannot be fulfilled today, since nobody knows who Amalek is?
Answer: 10:58 The mitzvah is to erase Amalek from one's own heart, the yetzer hara that is Amalek's prince; when the Jews do teshuvah, Hashem makes physical Amalek fall without anyone needing to know who he is.
-
Question: 24:21 Why do Chazal say the joy of Purim was milah and its glory was tefillin?
Answer: 37:01 Both are tied to emunah: guarding milah keeps emunah clear, and tefillin are emunah above the intellect; Purim is the time for that clear emunah and for erasing Amalek.
-
Question: 25:30 How can intelligent people deny Hashem when creation shows Him so clearly?
Answer: 26:21 Heresy comes from the heart: a person who will not admit a weakness or desire finds a world-view that permits it, rationalizing instead of admitting.
-
Question: 32:41 Why is keser, the tefillin, worn on the body but not part of it?
Answer: 33:40 Because Elokus cannot be grasped by the body or even the mind; it is reached only through emunah and kabbalas ol malchus Shamayim.
-
Question: 38:30 Why is 'yikar', the word for the tefillin of Purim, written in the language of Targum?
Answer: 39:07 Targum stands for galus and darkness; the tefillin of Purim are black, emunah without grasp, and that emunah in galus is the glory of the Jews.
-
Question: 59:41 Why did Avraham Avinu's episode with Sarah happen precisely when he went down to Mitzrayim?
Answer: 59:50 Mitzrayim is the 'ervas ha'aretz', where Amalek's klipah is strongest, and that place caused it.
Stories
-
52:45 The ten-year-old who leapt from the window
The Mashgiach tells that when the tzaddik who had just passed away was ten years old, on Purim his sister came into his room in disguise. He did not realize it was his sister, and rather than remain with her he jumped out of the window, two floors down. The Mashgiach brings it as an example of his extreme care in kedushah.
In the story: the Gerrer Rebbe
Insights
- 5:01 Unlike every other nation, which falls when Hashem topples its heavenly prince, Amalek's prince is the yetzer hara in the Jewish heart; Hashem leaves this war to the Jews, and only when they win it does physical Amalek fall, the reverse of the usual order.
- 14:32 The two faces of Amalek, attacking milah and casting doubt in emunah, are one thing: the clear emunah of the Jews is Avraham's inheritance through the bris, so a blemish of the bris clouds the emunah.
- 26:21 Heresy comes from the heart, not the head: a person who will not admit a weakness invents a philosophy that justifies it, so the demand for logical proof is really a cover for a lack of shmiras habris.
- 32:11 Tefillin are the keser, worn on the body but not part of it, because Elokus lies beyond even the mind; they are black because emunah in galus has no grasp, and this is the 'yikar' written in the Targum-language of galus.
- 46:47 The orlah, an extra part on the body that belongs to no other creature, answers the heretic: if the body can hold something that does not belong to it, it can also carry tefillin, something above it.
- 1:00:34 Just as Mitzrayim is the 'ervas ha'aretz' of place, the era before Moshiach is the 'ervas hazman' of time, when heresy and immorality spread together; Purim, the last month of the year, is given as strength for it.
- 42:15 The emunah of today's Jews in the deepest darkness of galus gives Hashem a nachas ruach He did not have even in the time of the Beis HaMikdash, and in this the present generations are greater than earlier ones.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 10:08 The Mashgiach says the Jews themselves must wage the war against Amalek, by erasing the yetzer hara from their hearts through teshuvah.
- 49:49 The Mashgiach says that on Purim one gives one's daas over to Hashem, not insisting on understanding everything, because Purim is above daas.
- 53:07 The Mashgiach says one must be careful in kedushah even when others mock it as too much.
- 1:04:36 The Mashgiach says that in our difficult era one must strengthen oneself and connect to Purim, drawing emunah from it for the whole time of darkness.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Menachem Mendel of Vitebsk, Rashi, Sancheiriv, Sarah Imeinu, Shaul HaMelech, the Alshich, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Chasam Sofer, the Chiddushei HaRim, the Gerrer Rebbe, the Ibn Ezra, the Rambam, the Sfas Emes, the Tiferes Shlomo (Rabbi Shlomo of Radomsk), Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms אמונה, יום הכפורים, יצר הרע, למעלה מן הדעת, מחיית עמלק, מילה, ספק, עמלק, עקבתא דמשיחא, ערות הארץ, ערלה, פגם הברית, פורים, תפילין, תרגום