ביאור הפטורה - מלכות שאול וטעם שהפסיד אותו (התעוררות לפורים)
Catalog entry: זמנים זכור no. 2 Pocket Guide p. 23 תשל"ט (1978–79) Yiddish 1 hr 21 min
Listen
About this shiur
Through the haftarah of Parshas Zachor, the Mashgiach explains that Shaul held a true, hereditary kingship and a chance to be Moshiach on the eve of Pesach, and lost it through one critical failing: he did not subordinate his own halachic reasoning to Shmuel, the elder of the generation.
The Mashgiach opens with the Gemara that Shaul lost his kingship over one sin while David kept his despite two, and with the Midrash that Shaul's kingship was only 'borrowed'. He then builds the idea of hereditary office: one who holds authority over Jews cannot be removed and his son inherits it, because all authority is appointed by Heaven and true kingship mirrors Hashem's eternal kingship. Eisav has no 'king son of king', since its rule is service, not kingship, borrowed from Israel. Shaul's reign came when Edom's eight kings had ended, and before David's promise Moshiach could come from any tribe, so Shaul's war on Amalek on the eve of Pesach could have brought the redemption. Shaul reasoned halachically to spare Amalek's women and animals, but failed by not deferring to Shmuel. The Mashgiach contrasts Esther, who obeyed Mordechai even as queen, and closes on Purim: the reversal of Amalek, a festival for broken Jews, and this year's three-day Purim in Jerusalem.
Topics: The Neviim and Their Times · The Four Parshiyos · Hiskashrus to Tzaddikim and Emunas Chachamim
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Shaul lost his kingdom over one sin listed in the guide
The Mashgiach introduces the haftarah of Parshas Zachor, where Shmuel sends Shaul to war against Amalek, and notes that had Shaul obeyed fully, Haman would never have been born. He then asks, from the Gemara in Yoma, why Shaul lost his kingship over one sin while David, who stumbled twice, did not.
-
5:00 Yaakov's blessing and a borrowed kingship listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the blessing to Yaakov after his struggle with Eisav's angel, that kings would come from him, which Rashi explains as Shaul and Ish-Boshes, and asks what blessing lies in Ish-Boshes's brief, tragic reign. He adds the Midrash that Shaul was so named because the kingship was only borrowed, and asks what Shaul's sin then cost him.
-
11:36 Authority over Jews passes to the son listed in the guide
The Mashgiach lays out the halacha that one appointed to an office among Jews, a chazan, rav, gabbai or melamed, cannot be dismissed and a fitting son inherits it, as the Rambam rules for a king and a kohen gadol. He gives the reason that every such office is appointed by Heaven, and then asks how the Rema allows a condition that the appointment is only temporary.
-
19:00 Kingship belongs to Hashem alone listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara in Avodah Zarah on Ovadiah's prophecy that Eisav has no 'king son of king', and distinguishes kingship from mere service. He explains that kingship belongs only to Hashem, which is why Moshe honored Pharaoh and Eliyahu honored Achav, and that a human king is a vessel for Hashem's kingship, which is eternal and therefore passes from father to son.
-
26:29 Why Eisav has no king son of king listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Eisav's rulers are servants of the people, not kings, because Eisav has no real existence or inheritance of its own and lives only on what it takes from Yaakov, as Rashi says on 'one nation shall prevail over the other'. From this he answers the Rema: a chazan appointed on a temporary condition is a servant, not a holder of kingship, so the condition does not contradict the Torah.
-
32:34 The kings of Edom and Shaul's name listed in the guide
From the end of Parshas Vayishlach the Mashgiach shows that Edom had kings only before Israel had a king, and that none of its eight kings was the son of a king. He wonders why Kish named his son Shaul, a name found among Edom's kings, and compares the Chasam Sofer's comment on Korach's name.
-
36:44 Shaul's chance to be Moshiach on erev Pesach listed in the guide
Following the Chasam Sofer on 'the scepter shall not depart from Yehudah', the Mashgiach explains that before David received the promise Moshiach could come from any tribe, so Shaul, reigning once Edom's kings had ended, could himself have been Moshiach. He brings that the war against Amalek is destined for the eve of Pesach, and shows from the Targum that Shaul counted the people with Pesach lambs, so his war fell on that very day.
-
44:55 Why Shaul did not obey the navi listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks how a king could disobey a navi, and brings the Gemara that Shaul reasoned by kal vachomer from the eglah arufah not to kill Amalek's women, children and animals. He explains that Shmuel told him two things, a prophecy that now was the appointed time and a halacha from his own understanding, and Shaul disputed only the halacha, yet his whole kingship and the chance for redemption hung on it.
-
50:26 Bowing to the elder of the generation listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Amalek is the opposite of self-nullification, and tells how the Chasam Sofer explained to his son that in each generation one person is the decisor of Klal Yisrael. Shmuel was that elder in his day, and Shaul's error was not yielding to him; one mistake, but a critical one, whereas David's lapses did not touch his standing.
-
55:49 A flaw in outlook, Esther, and Ish-Boshes listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that David's faults came from the yetzer hara while his emunah stayed whole, but Shaul's flaw was in his outlook, and contrasts Esther, who kept obeying Mordechai even as queen. He describes the golden future Shaul lost by one day, as Agag's seed lived on that Pesach night, and answers why Ish-Boshes was a blessing: he showed that Shaul's kingship was a true, hereditary one.
-
1:02:30 Purim reverses Amalek's hold listed in the guide
The Mashgiach shows that on Purim the Jews took over Haman's house and wealth, and explains Purim as the reversal in which what Eisav took is returned to holiness: the Purim meal is held on a weekday to elevate kelipas nogah, which only a Jew can do. He brings the Chasam Sofer that 'mishteh vesimchah' turns the death of Moshe into the life of Moshe, and says Purim was made for Jews who feel broken.
-
1:09:43 Purim as revival and love listed in the guide
The Mashgiach describes Purim as a powerful remedy that revives Jews in whom the spark of Moshe seemed dead, a new light greater even than at Matan Torah because then the Torah was accepted out of love. He brings that on Purim a great light from above is revealed that reaches even the farthest Jew, like a father who reaches his most soiled child.
-
1:15:02 Shushan, Jerusalem and the three-day Purim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads the Megillah's count of the Jews in Shushan against the rest, explains that Shushan Purim today belongs to Jerusalem, whose Jews are the heart of the world, and notes that this year Purim in Jerusalem lasts three days. He calls Purim greater even than Yom Kippur, too bright to bear without drink, and closes by urging not to waste the opportunity, as preparation thirty days before Pesach.
The shiur, written up
Shaul lost his kingdom over one sin
The Mashgiach opens with the haftarah of Parshas Zachor, where Shmuel tells Shaul that Hashem sent him to anoint him king and therefore Shaul must listen. Following the Ramban, had Shaul obeyed fully he would have stayed king and his kingdom would have continued; because he let Agag live overnight, Haman descended from him. a,c
Yaakov's blessing and a borrowed kingship
The Mashgiach brings Hashem's blessing to Yaakov after his struggle with Eisav's angel: his name becomes Yisrael, a term of rulership, and kings will come from him. Rashi explains these as Shaul and Ish-Boshes, from Binyamin, not yet born. d,e
Shaul as a blessing is understandable, the king who saved Israel from its oppressors. But Ish-Boshes ruled two tragic years, led by Avner, with nothing recorded of him. What blessing is that? The Mashgiach adds the Midrash that Shaul is so named because the kingship was only borrowed, belonging to David. If so, he asks, what did Shaul's sin with Amalek cost him? f
Authority over Jews passes to the son
The Mashgiach turns to halacha. The Shulchan Aruch rules that one appointed to a post among Jews, a rav, chazan or shochet, cannot be dismissed unless he did something wrong, unlike an ordinary worker, and a fitting son inherits the post even if another is more capable. g
The Rambam rules so for a king from 'that he may prolong his reign, he and his sons', and for the kohen gadol from 'the anointed kohen in his place from his sons'. The Gemara in Horayos says a king's son needs no new anointing, and the Sifrei extends this to every post. The reason is 'He is exalted as head over all': even a minor appointment comes from Heaven, so no boss may remove one whom Hashem appointed. i,j,k,l,m,n,o,p
Kingship belongs to Hashem alone
The Mashgiach brings Ovadiah's prophecy to Eisav, 'small have I made you among the nations, greatly despised', which the Gemara in Avodah Zarah explains: Eisav has no 'king son of king'. He distinguishes two kinds of rule, kingship and service. q,r
Kingship exists even among the nations. Moshe was commanded to honor Pharaoh, as Rashi says on Va'eira, and Eliyahu ran before Achav. Kingship belongs to Hashem alone; where a mortal holds it he is a vessel for His kingship, which is why the Girgashi, as the Bnei Yissaschar explains, yielded without war. s,t,u
Why Eisav has no king son of king
Why then does Eisav have no king son of king? Eisav's ruler is a servant: the larger the people, the more masters he serves. Eisav itself has no true existence and lives on credit; as Rashi says, when one rises the other falls, and Rome was built only from Jerusalem's ruin. It has no inheritance, so no person there can be a vessel for kingship. w,x
The kings of Edom and Shaul's name
Shaul's chance to be Moshiach on erev Pesach
The Chasam Sofer reads 'the scepter shall not depart from Yehudah until Shiloh comes' as a promise only until Moshiach; Moshiach could come from any tribe until David was promised it. So in Shaul's day, with Edom's eight kings finished, Shaul himself could have been Moshiach, hinted in the gematria of Shiloh and Shaul. ab,ac
The Tikkunei Zohar says the war with Amalek will be on erev Pesach, read from 'ki yad al kes Kah'. Of the three mitzvos on entering the land, a king, wiping out Amalek and the Beis Hamikdash, the second is erev Pesach, when chametz, which is Amalek, is burned, and the third Pesach itself. af,ag,ah,ai
Why Shaul did not obey the navi
How could a king disobey a navi, something children know is forbidden? The Gemara says Shaul made a kal vachomer from the eglah arufah: if one calf is brought for one life, a whole people with women, children and animals surely should not be wiped out. He held so by halacha. al
The Mashgiach explains that Shmuel told him two things in two pesukim, which the Bnei Yissaschar says signals two matters: a prophecy that now is the appointed time, and a halacha from Shmuel's own understanding. Shaul did not dispute the prophecy, only the halacha, as he was entitled to. Yet his whole kingship hung on it, and a lost chance might not return. am
Bowing to the elder of the generation
Amalek is the opposite of self-nullification. The Mashgiach tells how the Ksav Sofer asked the Chasam Sofer how he answered a hard question so quickly; he replied that each generation has one Jew who decides for Klal Yisrael, and even if his proof is refuted the halacha stands.
Shmuel, whom the Alshich equates with Moshe and Aharon, was that elder. Shaul's reasoning might be valid, but Heaven rules like the elder of the generation, and the war on Amalek demanded yielding to him. Shaul made one mistake, a critical one, while David's lapses were those of a tzaddik, who can sin and remains a tzaddik. an,ao,ap
A flaw in outlook, Esther, and Ish-Boshes
David slipped through the yetzer hara, but his emunah stayed whole. Shaul's flaw was in outlook, where one does not simply slip; a foreign influence had crept in. Esther, by contrast, kept obeying Mordechai as queen as she had as a girl, and that self-nullification let her fight Haman. aq
The Mashgiach says this happens often with bochurim, who think they know better; they must ask their rebbe. Had Shaul yielded, he could have been Moshiach. By the next day it was Pesach night, and Agag's seed lived on toward Haman.
Now the question about Ish-Boshes is answered: his reign showed that Shaul's kingship passed from father to son, true kingship unlike Edom's.
Purim reverses Amalek's hold
On Purim Esther set Mordechai over Haman's house, and the Targum says Haman's wealth built the Beis Hamikdash. Purim is the reversal: Eisav loses its rule and Israel takes it back. ar,as
Of the four kelipos, the fourth, kelipas nogah, can be raised to holiness, which only a Jew can do. Therefore the Purim meal is on a weekday, even in Jerusalem when Purim falls on Shabbos, since kelipas nogah cannot be repaired on Shabbos.
Purim as revival and love
For Jews in whom the spark of Moshe seems dead, Purim is strong medicine, like reviving a stopped heart, a kind of resurrection. Its new light is greater than at Matan Torah, since on Purim the Torah was accepted out of love, and the love removes all inhibition.
Citing the Arizal, the Mashgiach says that on Purim a great light is revealed, a 'long father' whose reach extends even to the most soiled child at the edge of the heavens.
Shushan, Jerusalem and the three-day Purim
The Megillah counts three hundred killed in Shushan and seventy-five thousand elsewhere, calling the rest of the Jews the remainder. Shushan Purim today belongs to Jerusalem, the heart of the world; the Mashgiach cites that Jews of Eretz Yisrael have loftier souls. This year Purim in Jerusalem lasts three days, and those abroad share it, since Hashem's eyes and heart are there. au,av,aw
Sources
Torah
- d Genesis 35:10-11 text index In the write-up: 5:12
- j Deuteronomy 17:20 text index In the write-up: 14:03
- l Leviticus 6:15 text index In the write-up: 14:03
- y Genesis 36:31-39 text index In the write-up: 32:43
- ab Genesis 49:10 text index In the write-up: 37:10
- ag Exodus 17:16 text index In the write-up: 40:32
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
- p I Chronicles 29:11 text index In the write-up: 14:03
- ad apparently Psalms 89 38:14 index
- an Psalms 99:6 text index In the write-up: 51:24
- ap Ecclesiastes 7:20 text index In the write-up: 51:24
- aq Esther 2:20 text index In the write-up: 55:51
- ar Esther 8:2 text index In the write-up: 1:02:30
- au Esther 9:15-16 text index In the write-up: 1:15:10
Targum
Talmud Bavli
- b Yoma 22b text index In the write-up: 1:49
- m apparently Horayos 11b index In the write-up: 14:03
- o apparently Bava Basra 91b index In the write-up: 14:03
- r Avodah Zarah 10a text index In the write-up: 19:50
- v apparently Zevachim 102a index In the write-up: 25:09
- x apparently Megillah 6a index In the write-up: 26:53
- ah Sanhedrin 20b text index In the write-up: 40:32
- ai apparently Rosh Hashanah 30a; Sukkah 41a index In the write-up: 40:32
- al Yoma 22b text index In the write-up: 45:11
- ax apparently Megillah 18a index In the write-up: 1:17:46
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
- c apparently Ramban, Parshas Vayechi index In the write-up: 0:49
- e apparently Rashi on Genesis 35:11 index In the write-up: 5:12
- i apparently Rambam, Hilchos Melachim index In the write-up: 14:03
- k Rambam, Mishneh Torah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 14:03
- s apparently Rashi on Exodus 6:13 index In the write-up: 21:36
- w apparently Rashi on Genesis 25:23 index In the write-up: 26:53
- z apparently Rashi on Genesis 36:31 index In the write-up: 32:43
Acharonim and Chassidus
- g apparently Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 53 index In the write-up: 11:36
- h apparently Rema, Orach Chaim 53 index In the write-up: 17:46, 31:20
- u Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 21:36
- aa Chasam Sofer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 35:31
- ac apparently Chasam Sofer on Genesis 49:10 index In the write-up: 37:10
- am Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 46:53
- ao Alshich (place not identified) index In the write-up: 51:24
- at Chasam Sofer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:07:27
- av Chesed L'Avraham (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:15:10
Key points
- 4:10 The Mashgiach asks why Shaul lost his kingship over a single sin while David, who stumbled twice, kept his, especially since the Midrash says Shaul's kingship was only borrowed from the start.
- 13:12 Any office of authority among Jews, from king and kohen gadol down to chazan and melamed, passes to a fitting son, because every such authority is appointed by Heaven and true kingship reflects Hashem's eternal kingship.
- 26:53 Eisav has no 'king son of king' because its rulers are servants of the people rather than kings, and whatever rule it has is borrowed from Israel until Israel takes it back.
- 41:05 Shaul's war against Amalek fell on the eve of Pesach, the time destined for the destruction of Amalek, so Shaul could have become Moshiach had he fulfilled the command that very day.
- 48:52 Shaul's failing was not disobedience to prophecy but a refusal to subordinate his own halachic reasoning to Shmuel, the elder of the generation; since Amalek is the opposite of self-nullification, the war against it demands such subordination.
- 1:03:16 Purim, whose festive meal is held on a weekday, is the time of reversal when what Eisav took is returned to holiness, and it was made especially for Jews who feel broken and far.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 4:10 Why did Shaul lose his kingship over one sin while David, who stumbled twice, kept his?
Answer: 53:49 Shaul's one mistake came at the moment his whole kingship depended on it and was a flaw in outlook, not yielding to the elder of the generation, while David's lapses came from the yetzer hara and his emunah stayed whole.
-
Question: 11:09 If Shaul's kingship was only borrowed from the start, what did his sin cost him?
Answer: 38:49 Before David's promise Shaul could have become Moshiach himself; by failing in the war on the eve of Pesach he lost a golden future for himself and for Klal Yisrael.
-
Question: 17:46 How can the Rema allow a condition that an appointment is temporary, against the Torah's 'he and his sons shall prolong their reign'?
Answer: 31:20 One appointed on such a condition was never given kingship; he is a servant, so there is no condition against the Torah.
-
Question: 26:33 Why does Eisav have no 'king son of king'?
Answer: 26:53 Its rule is service rather than kingship: Eisav has no real existence or inheritance of its own, and its kingship is only taken from Israel until Israel takes it back.
-
Question: 44:57 How could Shaul, a king, disobey the navi Shmuel?
Answer: 45:41 He held by kal vachomer from the eglah arufah that Amalek's women, children and animals should be spared; Shmuel's prophecy concerned only the timing, and Shaul disputed the halacha, failing to yield to Shmuel as the elder of the generation.
-
Question: 8:31 What blessing was there for Yaakov in the brief, tragic reign of Ish-Boshes?
Answer: 1:01:30 Ish-Boshes showed that Shaul's kingship passed from father to son, a true kingship unlike the borrowed rule of Edom's kings it replaced.
Stories
-
50:38 The Chasam Sofer answers a hard question quickly
The Ksav Sofer once saw his father, the Chasam Sofer, answer a difficult halachic question in a few minutes, and asked how he could write so quickly on so hard a question. The Chasam Sofer answered that in every generation there is one Jew who decides the questions of Klal Yisrael, and in this generation that is he. Even if someone refutes his proof, the halacha will not change.
In the story: the Chasam Sofer, the Ksav Sofer
Insights
- 24:12 Hereditary office is not a social arrangement: because kingship is Hashem's alone and His kingship is 'in every generation', a king who is a vessel for it must pass it on to his son.
- 26:53 The Mashgiach distinguishes kingship from service: the bigger Eisav's nation, the more its ruler is their servant, and likewise a chazan appointed only temporarily is a servant, so the Rema's condition does not contradict the Torah's promise of inheritance.
- 38:40 Before David received the promise, Moshiach could come from any tribe; Shaul reigned exactly when Edom's eight kings had passed, so he could have been the one, which the Mashgiach sees hinted in a gematria linking Shiloh and Shaul.
- 43:02 From the Targum that Shaul counted the people by their Pesach lambs, the Mashgiach concludes that his war on Amalek fell on the eve of Pesach, the destined time, so delaying by even a day meant the chance was gone.
- 48:52 Shaul did not dispute Shmuel's prophecy, only his halachic ruling, and was entitled to his own reasoning; his failure was that the war against Amalek, the opposite of self-nullification, required him to yield to the elder of the generation.
- 56:47 Esther is the counterpart of Shaul: as queen she still obeyed Mordechai as she had as a girl, and that self-nullification is what let her prevail over Haman.
- 1:03:58 Purim's meal falls on a weekday because its task is to elevate kelipas nogah, which cannot be done on Shabbos and which only a Jew, not a gentile, can raise to holiness.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 57:23 The Mashgiach says that one who thinks he understands better must still ask his rebbe and yield to him, warning that bochurim often fail in a single matter on which their whole life depends.
- 1:08:23 The Mashgiach says that Jews who feel broken and unworthy should know that Purim was made precisely for them.
- 1:20:22 The Mashgiach urges not to be foolish but to use Purim's opportunity, as preparation thirty days before Pesach.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achav, Agag, Avner, Dovid HaMelech, Eliyahu HaNavi, Esav, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Ish-Boshes, Kish, Korach, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Pharaoh, Rashi, Shaul HaMelech, Shlomo HaMelech, the Alshich, the Arizal, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Chasam Sofer, the Ksav Sofer, the Rambam, the Ramban, the Rema, Yaakov Avinu
Terms ביטול, מחיית עמלק, משתה ושמחה, עד דלא ידע, פקידה, קל וחומר, קליפת נוגה