The Creation and Necessity of the Jewish Nation
Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) לך לך no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 54 תשמ"ט (1988–89) English 1 hr 14 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that with Avraham Avinu a new species came into the world, the Jew who believes in Hashem by inherited instinct, and that the Jewish nation exists because it must, not because of anyone's merit.
The Mashgiach opens by calling Avraham the purpose of creation and the start of a new species. He asks why emunah is written as a statement, not a command, and contrasts the Rambam with the Ramban. Knowledge, he explains, is acquired, but some knowledge is inherited, like the beaver's dam or the spider's web. Every human can see Hashem in the wonders of the body, but a Jew believes by instinct, as the Chasam Sofer's case of a father and son shows. Avraham, the first believer, was a new creation: hence the miracle of his children, his exemption from honoring his father, and his call to Eretz Yisrael, the first land. The Mashgiach then asks why the Ramban says Avraham sinned by going to Mitzrayim, and why the Torah never tells his merits. Using the Maharal and the Midrash Tanchuma, he answers that the Jewish nation had to exist, and that Avraham went down to prepare his children's purity there.
Topics: Avraham Avinu · Simple Emunah, Above Reason · The Greatness of Every Jew
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Avraham the new creation; emunah as a statement listed in the guide
The Mashgiach calls Avraham the purpose of creation and the beginning of a new Jewish species. He then notes that the mitzvah of emunah is written as a statement, not a command, and brings the Rambam who counts it and the Ramban who calls it the foundation before the mitzvos.
-
6:10 Acquired knowledge and inherited knowledge listed in the guide
The Mashgiach distinguishes knowledge acquired from outside from knowledge that is inherited, with the beaver's dam, the spider's web, the migrating bird and the nursing infant. He concludes that a Jew knows Hashem in the same inherited way, passed down from Avraham, the father of believers.
-
13:16 The wonders of the human body listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains why the nations are held to account for not believing in one G-d: a person can see Hashem in his own body. He describes an anatomy book he once read, and the wonders of the spine, the eye and the interdependent systems of the body, concluding that a Jew, besides this understanding, believes by instinct.
-
24:38 The Chasam Sofer: the instinct of belonging listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Chasam Sofer's case of a son whose thief father breaks in without knowing it is his son's house: the son may not kill him, since a father instinctively will not kill his son. He links this to the passuk that the ox knows its owner, and says Jews, as children of Hashem, know Him by instinct.
-
27:53 The first believer; spoiling and healing emunah listed in the guide
The Mashgiach notes that the word emunah first appears with Avraham, and calls the Jew a species that believes by heredity. Like a stomach ruined by bad food or a clogged heart, this spiritual organism can be spoiled by aveiros, above all forbidden food and immorality, and then needs treatment.
-
33:40 Avraham, a species of his own listed in the guide
The Mashgiach reads the morning passage that lists all of creation and then adds 'You chose Avram', as the item still missing. Because Avraham was a new species, not a link in the chain from Adam and Noach, he and Sarah needed a miracle to have children, and he was exempt from honoring his father. This is the third creation in Bereishis.
-
40:00 The first Jew in the first land listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains 'Lech lecha' as sending the first Jew to Eretz Yisrael, the first place created, from which the world developed. He shows that the Torah's first passuk and first word, and the first haftarah, point to Eretz Yisrael, and that Hashem's first words to Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov all concern the land, matching Avraham's chesed and Yitzchak's din.
-
46:49 The Ramban: Avraham's sin in going to Mitzrayim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Ramban that Avraham sinned by going down to Mitzrayim and exposing Sarah to Pharaoh, and that the exile in Mitzrayim was its punishment. Citing Rabbeinu Yonah that a tzaddik must be judged favorably even beyond reason, he asks why the Ramban did not find a merit for Avraham.
-
51:30 The Maharal: a Jew's sin is only on the surface listed in the guide
The Mashgiach introduces the Maharal, who taught that a Jew is fundamentally a tzaddik and his aveira is only on the surface, like soot on a chimney sweep that washes off. A gentile's sin comes from his nature and stays; therefore teshuvah is for a Jew.
-
54:41 Why the Torah does not introduce Avraham listed in the guide
The Mashgiach asks why the Torah opens Noach by calling him a tzaddik, but begins Lech Lecha with Hashem's call to Avraham without saying why he deserved it. He recounts from the Midrashim how Avraham defied Nimrod, was thrown into the fire and saved, and only then received his first prophecy.
-
59:18 The Maharal on Moshe's unnamed parents listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Maharal on why the Torah introduces Moshe's parents only as 'a man of the house of Levi': the redemption is absolute and does not depend on anyone's merit. He applies this to Avraham: the Torah does not give his merits because the world was created for the Jewish nation, which had to exist.
-
1:05:16 The Midrash Tanchuma: it had to be listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says Avraham, as a prophet, knew his children would go to Mitzrayim. He brings the Midrash Tanchuma in Vayeshev that Adam had to eat from the Etz HaDaas, that the Jews had to go to Mitzrayim, that Yosef had to be sold and that Moshe could not enter Eretz Yisrael, all as part of Hashem's plan.
-
1:08:56 Preparing purity in Mitzrayim; the Ramban's intent listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Avraham went down to prepare the ground: Sarah's purity in Pharaoh's house brought holiness to the Jewish women in Mitzrayim, as Yosef's did for the men. The Ramban knew the Zohar's merit for Avraham but wrote that he sinned to teach that Hashem's choice of the Jewish nation does not rest on merit: the nation must exist and is fundamentally pure.
The shiur, written up
Avraham the new creation; emunah as a statement
The Mashgiach opens with the arrival of Avraham Avinu in this week's sedra. After the Torah tells how the world was made, Chazal teach that heaven and earth were created for the sake of Avraham, whose name has the same letters. With Lech Lecha, he says, comes a new creation: the Jewish species. a
To explain this, he turns to the mitzvah of emunah, belief in Hashem. Every mitzvah is written as a command, yet 'I am Hashem your G-d' is a statement. The Rambam counts it among the mitzvos, while the Ramban holds it is not one of the 613 but the foundation before them, since there must first be a Commander. The wording of the passuk, the Mashgiach notes, seems to favor the Ramban. b,c,d
Acquired knowledge and inherited knowledge
The Mashgiach explains that most knowledge is acquired from outside, from a book or a teacher, and is not passed to one's children. Traits like eye color, however, are hereditary, and so, wondrously, is some knowledge.
A beaver raised apart from its parents still builds a dam, which a person cannot do without training in engineering. A spider weaves its mother's web without lessons, and a bird flies thousands of miles and returns to the same tree, not by memory. Even an infant knows how to nurse, an instinct it later forgets.
In the same way, the Mashgiach says, a Jew knows Hashem as an inherited trait. Avraham, the first and father of all believers, passed it down to us, and it is in our blood.
The wonders of the human body
Every person, the Mashgiach says, is expected to believe in one G-d, and the nations will be called to account on the Day of Judgment, because everything points to Him. One need not even look beyond one's own body.
He relates that he once found a beginners' anatomy book in an apartment whose owner studied anatomy, with twenty or thirty wonders on every page. From it he learned why the spine is S-shaped: to absorb the shock when a person jumps. The eye surpasses any camera: it repairs itself, is shielded by brows and lashes, shuts by reflex, adjusts its pupil to the light and washes out dust with tears, and two eyes together give depth.
The eye depends on the blood, the blood on the lungs, the lungs on the digestive system, each a wonder dependent on the others. The medical student learns to ask not only what something is but why, since the body has a plan; the passuk declares there is no artist like our G-d. A Jew, the Mashgiach concludes, has this understanding and besides it believes by instinct. j
The Chasam Sofer: the instinct of belonging
The Mashgiach brings the Chasam Sofer at the beginning of Pesachim. One may kill a burglar in self-defense, but not one's own father, who would not kill his child. If the father breaks in unaware that it is his son's house, the Chasam Sofer rules the son still may not kill him, because a father instinctively will not kill his son. e
The first believer; spoiling and healing emunah
The first to know Hashem by emunah, the Mashgiach says, was Avraham, where the word first appears: 'he believed in Hashem.' With him a new species arrived, believing by heredity as the beaver builds. This spiritual organism can be spoiled by abuse, as a stomach is by a diet of sawdust or a heart clogged by bad food, needing medicine or even a bypass. The Rambam compares illnesses of the soul to those of the body. g,h
Avraham, a species of his own
The Mashgiach cites the verses said every morning that list the heavens, the earth, the seas and all they contain. Creation seems complete, yet one item is missing: a Jew who believes in Hashem. So the passage continues, 'You chose Avram' and gave him a new name, as a new species. k
The sefarim explain that this is why Avraham and Sarah were infertile and needed a miracle: Avraham was not a link in the chain from Adam and Noach, so a new power of reproduction had to be created in him. Likewise Rashi says Hashem exempted Avraham from honoring his father, since as a new species that was not his father. This is the third creation in Bereishis, after the world and the world after the Flood. l
The first Jew in the first land
Lech Lecha sends the first Jew to Eretz Yisrael, the beginning of creation. The Gemara teaches that the place of the Beis HaMikdash was made first, the foundation stone from which the globe developed, then Yerushalayim, Eretz Yisrael and the rest of the world. Rashi says the Torah begins with creation to show the land belongs to the Jewish nation, and the Gemara in Sukkah reads Bereishis as referring to the place of the mizbeach. m,n,o,p
The haftarah of Bereishis also speaks of the land, which gives a soul to those on it, and the Gemara in Kesubos promises Olam HaBa to one who lives there. Hashem's first word to Avraham, chesed, was the command to go there; to Yitzchak, din, a prohibition against leaving; and to Yaakov in his dream, the land on which he lay. The man of Bereishis belongs in the land of Bereishis. q,r,s,t
The Ramban: Avraham's sin in going to Mitzrayim
The Maharal: a Jew's sin is only on the surface
The Mashgiach introduces the Maharal, known for the golem, whose greater feat was teaching Jewish thought. The Maharal explains that a Jew is fundamentally a tzaddik, and his aveira is only on the surface, like soot on a chimney sweep that a little soap and water removes. It is incidental and temporary.
A gentile's aveira, by contrast, comes from his nature and leaves a permanent stain. Therefore teshuvah belongs to a Jew.
Why the Torah does not introduce Avraham
The Maharal on Moshe's unnamed parents
To answer, the Mashgiach applies a Maharal on Yetzias Mitzrayim. The Torah introduces Moshe only through 'a man of the house of Levi' who married a daughter of Levi, though his parents Amram and Yocheved were great tzaddikim. The Maharal explains that the redemption is absolute: the Jews must be redeemed, whether they deserve it or not. y
Had the Torah stressed their righteousness, one might think the redemption depended on it. Moshe was born because he had to be. Likewise, the world was created for the Jewish nation, which had to exist regardless of Avraham's merit, so the Torah tells the first Jew to go to the land of the beginning without listing his virtues.
The Midrash Tanchuma: it had to be
Preparing purity in Mitzrayim; the Ramban's intent
Avraham had to prepare the ground. The Jews in Mitzrayim, millions of people, remained morally pure; the Torah singles out only Shlomis bas Divri. The Gemara attributes the women's purity to Sarah, who resisted Pharaoh's promises, and the men's to Yosef's stand with Potiphar's wife. aa,ab
The Ramban, who knew the Zohar that Avraham saw the Shechinah with Sarah, could have written that merit. He wrote of a sin to teach, at the very start of Avraham's story, that Hashem favors him not for his righteousness but because there must be a Jewish nation. That nation is fundamentally pure, and its aveiros wash off. u,ac
Sources
Torah
- c Shemos 20:2 text index In the write-up: 2:11
- g Bereishis 15:6 text index In the write-up: 28:08
- m Bereishis 12:1 text index In the write-up: 40:03, 54:53
- s apparently Bereishis 26:2 index In the write-up: 42:38
- t apparently Bereishis 28:13 index In the write-up: 42:38
- w apparently Bereishis 6:9 index In the write-up: 54:53
- y Shemos 2:1 text index In the write-up: 59:22
- aa apparently Vayikra 24:11 index In the write-up: 1:09:00
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
- b apparently Sefer HaMitzvos, positive commandment 1 index In the write-up: 2:11
- d apparently Ramban, glosses on Sefer HaMitzvos, positive commandment 1 index In the write-up: 2:11
- h apparently Rambam, Hilchos De'os 2:1 index In the write-up: 28:08
- l apparently Rashi on Bereishis 11:32 index In the write-up: 36:08
- o apparently Rashi on Bereishis 1:1 index In the write-up: 40:03
- u apparently Ramban on Bereishis 12:10 index In the write-up: 46:49, 1:12:03
- v Sha'arei Teshuvah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 48:46
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 1:10 With Avraham Avinu a new species was created: the Jew, for whom the purpose of all creation exists.
- 12:29 Belief in Hashem is for a Jew an inherited instinct, like the instinctive skills of animals, passed down from Avraham.
- 29:24 A Jew can spoil this inborn emunah through aveiros, especially forbidden food and immorality, just as a body is spoiled by abuse, and it can be healed.
- 40:14 Avraham, the man of the beginning, belongs in Eretz Yisrael, the land where creation began.
- 1:03:32 The Torah does not state Avraham's merits because the Jewish nation must exist regardless of anyone's deserving.
- 1:08:52 Avraham went down to Mitzrayim to prepare the ground for his children, whose purity there came from Sarah's and Yosef's steadfastness.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 25:56 May a son kill his father who breaks into his house as a thief, when the father does not know it is his son's house?
Answer: 26:30 The Chasam Sofer says no, since a father instinctively will not kill his son even without realizing who he is, so he is not a rodef.
-
Question: 36:00 Why did Avraham and Sarah need a miracle to have children?
Answer: 36:28 Avraham was a new species, not a link in the chain from Adam and Noach, so a new power of reproduction had to be created in him.
-
Question: 54:53 Why does the Torah describe Noach as a tzaddik but not tell why Avraham deserved Hashem's call?
Answer: 1:03:32 Because the world was created for the Jewish nation, which had to exist regardless of Avraham's merit, as the Maharal shows with Moshe's unnamed parents.
-
Question: 59:53 Why does the Torah name Moshe's parents only as 'a man of the house of Levi' and 'a daughter of Levi'?
Answer: 1:00:41 The Maharal explains that the redemption is absolute; had their righteousness been told, one would think it depended on their merit.
-
Question: 47:00 Why did Avraham go down to Mitzrayim and allow Sarah to be taken to Pharaoh?
Answer: 1:08:52 Knowing his children had to go to Mitzrayim, he went to prepare the ground: Sarah's purity there brought holiness to the Jewish women in Mitzrayim.
-
Question: 1:12:21 Why did the Ramban write that Avraham sinned, when he knew the Zohar's explanation that Avraham saw the Shechinah with Sarah?
Answer: 1:12:39 To teach at the very start that Hashem favors Avraham not because of his righteousness but because there has to be a Jewish nation.
Stories
-
15:27 The anatomy book
The Mashgiach relates that he once stayed in an apartment whose owner was a student of anatomy, and having nothing else to read he found a beginners' anatomy book. Every page held twenty or thirty wonders. He learned from it, for example, why the human spine is S-shaped: so that it can absorb the shock when a person jumps.
-
56:46 Avraham and Nimrod
From the Midrashim the Mashgiach recounts that Nimrod declared himself a god, and Avraham defied him, saying there is one G-d who created heaven and earth, and preached His existence at the risk of his life. Nimrod threw him into the fire, and Hashem made a miracle so that he came out unharmed. Then Hashem revealed Himself to him as the Maker of the world he had given his life for, and this was the first prophecy.
In the story: Avraham Avinu, Nimrod, Terach
Insights
- 9:35 The Mashgiach compares the Jew's belief in Hashem to the inherited knowledge of the beaver and the spider: it is not learned but part of his organism, and with Avraham a species carrying this trait began.
- 36:44 Since Avraham was not a continuation of mankind from Adam and Noach, he and Sarah needed a newly created power to have children, and he was told he need not honor his father, as he was not truly his father.
- 40:44 The man of Bereishis belongs in the land of Bereishis: Eretz Yisrael, the place from which the globe developed, is the natural home of the first Jew.
- 44:33 Hashem's first words to Avraham, the attribute of chesed, were a positive command to go to the land, while His first words to Yitzchak, the attribute of din, were a prohibition against leaving it.
- 1:00:51 Applying the Maharal on Moshe's parents, the Mashgiach explains that the Torah omits Avraham's merits because the Jewish nation's existence is a necessity, not a reward.
- 1:12:39 The Mashgiach reads the Ramban's harsh judgment of Avraham as deliberate: by showing at the outset that Avraham could sin and still be chosen, it teaches that the Jewish nation does not rest on anyone's righteousness.
- 1:09:00 Avraham's descent to Mitzrayim and Sarah's steadfastness in Pharaoh's house prepared the purity that kept the Jewish women holy in Mitzrayim.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 33:07 The Mashgiach says a Jew whose sense of Hashem has been dulled by aveiros, especially in forbidden food and kedushah, must come for treatment, and that there are remedies, though they may take time.
- 48:57 Citing Rabbeinu Yonah, the Mashgiach says one must judge a person favorably, and a known tzaddik even beyond what seems reasonable.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Amram, Avraham Avinu, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nimrod, Noach, Pharaoh, Rabbeinu Yonah, Rashi, Sarah Imeinu, Shlomis bas Divri, the Chasam Sofer, the Maharal of Prague, the Rambam, the Ramban, Yitzchak Avinu, Yocheved, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms אבן שתיה, אמונה, אנכי ה' אלקיך, דן לכף זכות, טמטום הלב, מאכלות אסורות, מדת הדין, מדת החסד, מי מריבה, עץ הדעת, עשרת הדברות, קדושת הברית, רבונו של עולם, רוח הקודש, שכינה