The Power of Man to Build or Destroy the World
Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) נח no. 2 Pocket Guide p. 54 תשס"ב (2001–02) English 48 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Mashgiach explains that man controls the whole world for good or for bad, and that Noach, damaged by Cham's sin in the Teva, was saved only out of mercy and in the merit of Avraham Avinu.
The Mashgiach opens with the Midrash that Noach found chein, undeserved favor, and was saved because Avraham Avinu would descend from him, and asks why the Zichronos of Rosh Hashanah praise Hashem for remembering Noach if his rescue was planned from the start. Through Rashi's account that the lion maimed Noach, the dispute over the lion's food, and Rashi's covenant that kept the food fresh, he builds his answer. Man controls the world by remote control: before Adam's sin the world was a peaceful utopia, and human sin corrupted even the animals. The Mabul was to restart the world with a society of tzaddikim, but Cham sinned in the Teva and affected Noach, so the lion needed meat and attacked him. Noach was saved only in Avraham's merit. The Mashgiach concludes that today Jews who learn and keep the Torah carry the fate of the world, and the real front of the war is in the beis medrash.
Topics: Noach and the Mabul · The Power and Greatness of Torah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Noach's undeserved favor and the Zichronos
The Mashgiach brings the Midrash that chein means undeserved favor and that Noach was saved because Avraham Avinu would descend from him. He then asks why the Zichronos of Rosh Hashanah single out Hashem's remembering Noach with kindness, if Noach's rescue was programmed from the start.
-
5:59 The lion that maimed Noach
The Mashgiach brings Rashi that Noach was maimed by the lion when he was late with its food, and asks why Hashem, who made so many miracles in the Teva, did not help him feed it on time. He brings the Ibn Ezra that the lion ate straw, against Chazal that each animal got its own diet, and Rashi that a covenant kept all the food from spoiling.
-
12:14 Man controls the world by remote control listed in the guide
The Mashgiach describes the world before the Mabul as a utopia and explains that Adam's sin contaminated it, because man controls the world for good or bad. Human corruption grew until even the animals sinned, and he brings Yeshayahu and the Ramban on Bechukosai that in the days of Moshiach animals will again not prey on each other.
-
20:54 Starting over with a society of tzaddikim listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Hashem decided to wipe out the world and start over from a nucleus of tzaddikim. Every person has a portion of the world that his deeds affect; Noach's portion, Eretz Yisrael, was not flooded, and the animals of his portion stayed pure and came to the Teva, where, as before the sin, the lions needed no meat.
-
25:51 Cham's sin and Noach's wine listed in the guide
The Mashgiach brings the Gemara in Sanhedrin that Cham, the dog and the raven broke the rules of the Teva, and explains that Cham's sin affected his father Noach, as a sin spreads to generations before and after. This is why Noach did not realize he could not drink wine as one will in the days of Moshiach, and he became drunk.
-
30:26 Saved only in the merit of Avraham
The Mashgiach explains that after Cham's sin the lion was no longer satisfied with straw, attacked Noach and maimed him, and Hashem made no miracle for a sinful society. By the condition of the Teva Noach should have perished, but he was saved out of mercy because Avraham Avinu would come from him; this answers the opening question and the Zichronos, and the parsha, which starts with Noach and ends with Avraham, is like a headline.
-
35:07 The war is fought in the beis medrash listed in the guide
The Mashgiach explains that Hashem put all of creation under man's control, and after giving the nations several chances He chose Avraham, so that today only Jews who know what Hashem wants are responsible for the world. The war of the day, he says, is fought in the batei medrash where Jews learn and daven, and he brings Rashi that the rain of the Mabul began as rain that could have been blessing, to show that even after Yom Kippur the decree can be changed.
-
40:57 A fateful year: Hoshana Rabbah, the moon and the soldiers listed in the guide
The Mashgiach says the fate of the Jewish people rests on the shoulders of those who learn, especially in this year. He brings the tradition that the final war will begin on Hoshana Rabbah, notes that the war in Afghanistan began then on a moonlit night, brings the Rema and Ramban on the moon and the shadow on Hoshana Rabbah and the stars that fought Sisera, and calls Yishmael a pere adam who can be fought only with Torah and mitzvos.
The shiur, written up
Noach's undeserved favor and the Zichronos
The lion that maimed Noach
Man controls the world by remote control
Following the Ramban and the Midrashim, the Mashgiach describes the world before the Mabul as a utopia: spring all year, abundance and peace. Adam's sin contaminated it because, as the Nefesh HaChaim explains the verse that man became a living soul, man is the soul of the world and controls it by remote control. i,j,k
His mitzvos bring bounty and peace, his sins war and hunger. When the Jews learned Torah in the desert, the fruit grew so large that eight men carried one cluster of grapes. Corruption spread until even animals, who have no free choice, mated with other species, and Rashi says the Mabul wiped out even the topsoil. m
Starting over with a society of tzaddikim
Hashem therefore decided to wipe out the world and start again from a nucleus of tzaddikim. Every person has a portion of creation that his deeds affect; Noach's portion stayed pure, and its animals, which had not sinned, came to the Teva.
Cham's sin and Noach's wine
Saved only in the merit of Avraham
The war is fought in the beis medrash
Hashem put all creation under man's control, as Tehillim says. After giving the nations several chances He chose Avraham, and when Esav refused the Torah, the Jews alone came to control the world. y
The responsibility, the Mashgiach says, lies with those who learn and know what Hashem wants. The present war is fought in the batei medrash: learning brings peace and bounty everywhere, and sins bring destruction, car bombs and anthrax.
A fateful year: Hoshana Rabbah, the moon and the soldiers
The destiny of the Jewish people, the Mashgiach says, rests on the slender shoulders of those who learn, especially in this fateful year. He brings the tradition, cited by the Gra and the Imrei Noam, that the war before Moshiach begins on Hoshana Rabbah, and the war in Afghanistan began then, on a moonlit night. ab
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- b Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 0:06
Rishonim
- d Rashi on Bereishis 7:23 text index In the write-up: 6:07
- e apparently Ramban on Bereishis 6:19 index In the write-up: 6:07
- f apparently Ibn Ezra on Bereishis 6:21 index In the write-up: 8:48
- h Rashi on Bereishis 6:18 text index In the write-up: 8:48
- i Ramban (place not identified) index In the write-up: 12:20
- m apparently Rashi on Bereishis 6:13 index In the write-up: 14:17
- p Ramban on Vayikra 26:6 text index In the write-up: 18:41
- t apparently Rashi on Bereishis 49:6 27:52 index
- u Rashi on Bereishis 9:20 text index In the write-up: 28:38
- w apparently Rashi on Vayikra 26:5 31:12 index
- z Rashi on Bereishis 7:12 text index In the write-up: 40:25
- ad Ramban on Bamidbar 14:9 text index In the write-up: 43:14
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 1:04 Chein means undeserved favor: according to the Midrash Noach was saved not by his own merit but because Avraham Avinu would descend from him.
- 13:39 Man controls the entire world by remote control: his mitzvos bring peace and bounty, and his sins bring war, hunger and corruption, even among the animals.
- 21:19 The Mabul was meant to start the world anew from a society of tzaddikim, people and animals alike, in the state of the world before Adam's sin.
- 26:51 Cham's sin in the Teva affected Noach and spoiled the plan, so the lion needed meat, attacked Noach, and no miracle protected him.
- 36:23 Since Avraham Avinu, only Jews control the world, and Jews who learn Torah and do mitzvos decide whether it has peace or war.
- 40:38 Teshuvah can still change the decree after Yom Kippur, as the rain at the start of the Mabul could have turned into rain of blessing.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 5:08 If Noach's rescue was programmed from the start, why do the Zichronos praise Hashem for remembering Noach with special kindness?
Answer: 32:55 Because after Cham's sin the condition of the Teva was broken and Noach deserved to perish; he was saved only out of mercy, for Avraham Avinu who would descend from him.
-
Question: 8:20 With so many miracles in the Teva, why did Hashem not help Noach feed the lion on time?
Answer: 31:48 Hashem makes miracles for tzaddikim, not for a society that has sinned, and after Cham's sin the Teva was no longer a society of tzaddikim.
-
Question: 9:02 How could meat for the lions stay fresh for a whole year in the Teva?
Answer: 11:17 Rashi says Noach needed a covenant that the food he brought would not rot; that covenant covered the meat as well as the fruits.
-
Question: 17:36 Animals have no free choice; how could they sin before the Mabul?
Answer: 17:45 The corruption of mankind spread to the beasts as a direct result of what man does, since man controls the world.
-
Question: 40:57 After Yom Kippur, how can teshuvah still change the decree?
Answer: 40:38 Rashi shows that the rain of the Mabul came first as potential rain of blessing had the people repented, so teshuvah can still help.
Insights
- 6:07 The 'ach' of 'only Noach remained' carries a double message: Rashi reads it as Noach's injury from the lion, and the Mashgiach adds that the verse no longer calls him tzaddik, because Cham's sin had affected him.
- 22:44 The animals that came to the Teva were the 'tzaddikim' of the animal world: they belonged to Noach's portion of creation, which his righteousness kept from corruption.
- 25:16 The Mashgiach reconciles the Ibn Ezra and Chazal on the lion's food: in the Teva's pure society the lion could live on straw, as before Adam's sin and in the days of Moshiach, and only after Cham's sin did it need meat.
- 30:45 The more physical a being is, the more concentrated food it needs; a lion's one meal of meat equals a week of a cow's grazing, so a world fallen from its purity needs meat.
- 28:52 Noach's drinking is read as a mistake about the times: he thought the era of Moshiach had come, when one can drink a great cup of wine without becoming drunk, like the cup of Eliyahu at the Seder.
- 34:15 The parsha is built like a headline: its opening verses already say that Noach was saved only by grace, and it moves from Noach to Avraham Avinu, in whose merit the world survived.
What the Mashgiach says to take from it
- 38:20 The Mashgiach says the front of the war is not in Afghanistan but in every beis medrash, Jewish home and Jewish heart: learning Torah brings peace and bounty to the whole world.
- 46:51 He says the only way to fight the pere adam is with Torah and mitzvos, not with flags and bombers.
- 47:28 He asks his listeners to take this seriously and be good soldiers, since the fate of the Jewish people is in their hands.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Avraham Avinu, Cham, Eliyahu HaNavi, Kalev ben Yefuneh, Korach, Noach, Rashi, Shem, Sisera, the Chofetz Chaim, the Ibn Ezra, the Ramban, the Rema, the Vilna Gaon, Yaakov Avinu, Yeshayahu HaNavi, Yishmael
Terms אליהו הנביא, בחירה, בעל מום, גוג ומגוג, הושענא רבה, זכרונות, חן, טומאה, מבול, נס, סייעתא דשמיא, פרא אדם, רבונו של עולם, תיבה